Files
nexus/sreweekly/articles/172/01-how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer-ieee-spe.html
2026-09-12 17:23:01 +08:00

2115 lines
500 KiB
HTML
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
<!DOCTYPE html><!-- Powered by RebelMouse. https://www.rebelmouse.com --><html lang="en"><head prefix="og: https://ogp.me/ns# article: https://ogp.me/ns/article#"><script type="application/ld+json">{"@context":"https://schema.org","@type":"NewsArticle","articleSection":"Aerospace","author":{"@type":"Person","description":"Gregory Travis is a writer, a software executive, a pilot, and an aircraft owner. In 1977, at the age of 13, he wrote Note, one of the first social media platforms, and he has logged more than 2,000 hours of flying time, ranging from gliders to a Boeing 757 (as a full-motion simulator).","identifier":"21081394","image":{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjY0NTkxNC9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTYyODI0MzE3M30.NwS_cVTzuyCiLxaAml2FFbcCzSQcEEQvx8aDC_ELg_M/image.png?width=980"},"name":"Gregory Travis","url":"https://spectrum.ieee.org/u/gregory-travis"},"dateModified":"2024-02-03T22:03:05Z","datePublished":"2019-04-18T19:49:00Z","description":"Design shortcuts meant to make a new plane seem like an old, familiar one are to blame","headline":"How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Developer","image":[{"@type":"ImageObject","height":600,"url":"https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/image.jpg?id=25588396&width=1200&height=600&coordinates=0%2C155%2C0%2C155","width":1200},{"@type":"ImageObject","height":1200,"url":"https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&width=1200&height=1200&coordinates=155%2C0%2C155%2C0","width":1200},{"@type":"ImageObject","height":1500,"url":"https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&width=2000&height=1500&coordinates=0%2C0%2C0%2C0","width":2000},{"@type":"ImageObject","height":700,"url":"https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&width=1245&height=700&coordinates=0%2C116%2C0%2C117","width":1245}],"keywords":["aviation","software","airbus","boeing","737-max"],"mainEntityOfPage":{"@id":"https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer","@type":"WebPage"},"publisher":{"@type":"Organization","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","url":"https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjg4NDUyMC9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTgyNjE0MzQzOX0.N7fHdky-KEYicEarB5Y-YGrry7baoW61oxUszI23GV4/image.png?width=210"},"name":"IEEE Spectrum"},"thumbnailUrl":"https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&amp;width=210","url":"https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer"}</script><meta charset="utf-8"/><link rel="preload" as="font" href="" type="font/woff2" crossorigin=""/><script>
window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer ||[];
function gtag(){dataLayer.push(arguments);}
gtag('consent','default',{
'ad_storage':'denied',
'analytics_storage':'denied',
'ad_user_data':'denied',
'ad_personalization':'denied',
'personalization_storage':'denied',
'functionality_storage':'granted',
'security_storage':'granted',
'wait_for_update': 500
});
gtag("set", "ads_data_redaction", true);
</script><!-- v ieee cookie banner v --><script src="https://cmp.osano.com/AzyzptTmRlqVd2LRf/04dfdd03-699a-4224-a9f1-d3ca23cdf4e9/osano.js"></script><!--<link rel="stylesheet" href="https://cookie-consent.ieee.org/ieee-cookie-banner.css" type="text/css" />--><!-- ^ ieee cookie banner ^ --><link rel="preload" as="font" href="https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/FavoritMono/ABCFavoritMono-Light.woff2" type="font/woff2" crossorigin=""/><link rel="preload" as="font" href="https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/FavoritMono/ABCFavoritMono-Regular.woff2" type="font/woff2" crossorigin=""/><link rel="preload" as="font" href="https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/ABCFavoritProFullWeb/ABCFavoritPro-Light.woff2" type="font/woff2" crossorigin=""/><link rel="preload" as="font" href="https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/ABCFavoritProFullWeb/ABCFavoritPro-Bold.woff2" type="font/woff2" crossorigin=""/><link rel="preload" as="font" href="https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/IvarCompleteWeb/IvarHeadline-Regular.woff2" type="font/woff2" crossorigin=""/><link rel="preload" as="font" href="https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/ABCFavoritProFullWeb/ABCFavoritPro-Regular.woff2" type="font/woff2" crossorigin=""/><link rel="preload" as="font" href="https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/IvarCompleteWeb/IvarHeadline-Bold.woff2" type="font/woff2" crossorigin=""/><link rel="preload" imagesrcset="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&width=3600&height=2700 3x, https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&width=2400&height=1800 2x, https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&width=1200&height=900 1x" as="image" fetchpriority="high"/><link rel="canonical" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer"/><meta property="fb:app_id" content="200167090048537"/><meta name="twitter:site" content="@"/><meta name="twitter:site:id" content=""/><meta property="og:type" content="article"/><meta property="article:section" content="Aerospace"/><meta property="og:url" content="https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer"/><meta property="og:site_name" content="IEEE Spectrum"/><meta property="og:image" content="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/image.jpg?id=25588396&width=1200&height=600&coordinates=0%2C155%2C0%2C155"/><meta property="og:image:width" content="1200"/><meta property="og:image:height" content="600"/><meta property="og:title" content="How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Developer"/><meta property="og:description" content="Design shortcuts meant to make a new plane seem like an old, familiar one are to blame"/><meta name="description" content="Design shortcuts meant to make a new plane seem like an old, familiar one are to blame"/><meta name="keywords" content="aviation, software, airbus, boeing, 737-max"/><meta name="referrer" content="always"/><meta name="robots" content="max-image-preview:large"/><meta name="twitter:card" content="summary_large_image"/><meta name="twitter:image" content="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/image.jpg?id=25588396&width=1200&height=600&coordinates=0%2C155%2C0%2C155"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://assets.rebelmouse.io/" crossorigin="anonymous"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://user-stats.rbl.ms/" crossorigin="anonymous"/><link rel="preconnect" href="https://pages-stats.rbl.ms/" crossorigin="anonymous"/><!--link rel="preload" href="https://static.rbl.ms/static/fonts/fontawesome/fontawesome-mini.woff" as="font" type="font/woff2" crossorigin--><script class="rm-i-script">window.REBELMOUSE_BOOTSTRAP_DATA = {"isUserLoggedIn": false, "site": {"id": 20265424, "isCommunitySite": false}, "runner": {"id": 20265424}, "post": {"id": 2650278376, "sections": [0, 497728257, 497728258, 544169516, 544169517, 2289600833, 2289599519, 2289605931, 2289600218, 2289615276], "shareUrl": "https%3A%2F%2Fspectrum.ieee.org%2Fhow-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer", "status": 0, "tags": ["aviation", "software", "airbus", "boeing", "737-max"]}, "path": "/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer", "pathParams": {"slug": "how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer"}, "resourceId": "pp_2650278376", "fbId": "200167090048537", "fbAppVersion": "v2.5", "clientGaId": "", "messageBusUri": "wss://messages.rebelmouse.io", "section": {"id": null}, "tag": {"slug": "aviation", "isSection": false}, "is_section_tag": false, "fullBootstrapUrl": "/res/bootstrap/data.js?site_id=20265424\u0026resource_id=pp_2650278376\u0026path_params=%7B%22slug%22%3A%22how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer%22%7D\u0026override_device=desktop\u0026post_id=2650278376", "whitelabel_menu": {}, "useRiver": true, "engine": {"recaptchaSiteKey": "6Lf7O5AsAAAAAF8DuJQDiMAZr4X1yLapkZpULPbO", "lazyLoadShortcodeImages": true, "backButtonGoToPage": true, "changeParticleUrlScroll": false, "countKeepReadingAsPageview": true, "defaultVideoPlayer": "", "theoPlayerLibraryLocation": "", "trackPageViewOnParticleUrlScroll": false, "webVitalsSampleRate": 100, "overrideDevicePixelRatio": null, "image_quality_level": 100, "sendEventsToCurrentDomain": false, "enableLoggedOutUserTracking": false, "useSmartLinks2": true, "enableRunnerCss": true}};
</script><script class="rm-i-script">window.REBELMOUSE_BASE_ASSETS_URL = "https://spectrum.ieee.org/static/dist/social-ux/";
window.REBELMOUSE_BASE_SSL_DOMAIN = "https://spectrum.ieee.org";
window.REBELMOUSE_TASKS_QUEUE = [];
window.REBELMOUSE_LOW_TASKS_QUEUE = [];
window.REBELMOUSE_LOWEST_TASKS_QUEUE = [];
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE = [];
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB = {};
window.RM_OVERRIDES = {};
window.RM_AD_LOADER = [];
</script><script src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/static/dist/social-ux/main.a30f292381a69501c3f0.bundle.mjs" class="rm-i-script" type="module" async="async" data-js-app="true" data-src-host="https://spectrum.ieee.org" data-src-file="main.mjs"></script><script src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/static/dist/social-ux/main.a8943d8b696069233e55.bundle.js" class="rm-i-script" nomodule="nomodule" defer="defer" data-js-app="true" data-src-host="https://spectrum.ieee.org" data-src-file="main.js"></script><script src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/static/dist/social-ux/runtime.696aaa0e5ce908bfa146.bundle.mjs" class="rm-i-script" type="module" async="async" data-js-app="true" data-src-host="https://spectrum.ieee.org" data-src-file="runtime.mjs"></script><script src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/static/dist/social-ux/runtime.4afd3d624b19a99eea15.bundle.js" class="rm-i-script" nomodule="nomodule" defer="defer" data-js-app="true" data-src-host="https://spectrum.ieee.org" data-src-file="runtime.js"></script><script src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/static/dist/social-ux/iabTracking.31cf81e3384788188e0d.bundle.mjs" class="rm-i-script" type="module" async="async" data-js-app="true" data-src-host="https://spectrum.ieee.org" data-src-file="iabTracking.mjs"></script><script src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/static/dist/social-ux/iabTracking.7f23064d1f64f976ca2f.bundle.js" class="rm-i-script" nomodule="nomodule" defer="defer" data-js-app="true" data-src-host="https://spectrum.ieee.org" data-src-file="iabTracking.js"></script><!-- we collected enough need to fix it first before turn in back on--><!--script src="//cdn.ravenjs.com/3.16.0/raven.min.js" crossorigin="anonymous"></script--><!--script type="text/javascript">
Raven.config('https://6b64f5cc8af542cbb920e0238864390a@sentry.io/147999').install();
</script--><link rel="manifest" href="/manifest.json"/><meta name="theme-color" content="#647187"/><script class="rm-i-script">
if ('serviceWorker' in navigator) {
window.addEventListener('load', function() {
navigator.serviceWorker.register('/sw.js').then(function(registration) {
console.log('ServiceWorker registration successful with scope: ', registration.scope);
}, function(err) {
console.log('ServiceWorker registration failed: ', err);
});
});
} else {
console.log('ServiceWorker not enabled');
}
</script><script class="rm-i-script">
// fallback error prone google tag setup
var googletag = googletag || {};
googletag.cmd = googletag.cmd || [];
</script><meta http-equiv="X-UA-Compatible" content="IE=edge"/><link rel="alternate" type="application/rss+xml" title="IEEE Spectrum" href="/feeds/topic/aerospace.rss"/><meta name="viewport" content="width=device-width,initial-scale=1,minimum-scale=1.0"/><!-- TODO: move the default value from here --><title>How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Developer - IEEE Spectrum</title><style class="rm-i-styles">
@layer tokens,themes,utilities,elements;.rm-embed-container{position:relative;}.rm-embed-container.rm-embed-instagram{max-width:540px;}.rm-embed-container.rm-embed-tiktok{max-width:572px;min-height:721px;}.rm-embed-container.rm-embed-tiktok blockquote,.rm-embed-twitter blockquote{all:revert;}.rm-embed-container.rm-embed-tiktok blockquote{margin-left:0;margin-right:0;position:relative;}.rm-embed-container.rm-embed-tiktok blockquote,.rm-embed-container.rm-embed-tiktok blockquote > iframe,.rm-embed-container.rm-embed-tiktok blockquote > section{width:100%;min-height:721px;display:block;}.rm-embed-container.rm-embed-tiktok blockquote > section{position:absolute;top:0;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;display:flex;align-items:center;justify-content:center;flex-direction:column;text-align:center;}.rm-embed-container.rm-embed-tiktok blockquote > section:before{content:"";display:block;width:100%;height:300px;border-radius:8px;}.rm-embed-container > .rm-embed,.rm-embed-container > .rm-embed-holder{position:absolute;top:0;left:0;}.rm-embed-holder{display:block;height:100%;width:100%;display:flex;align-items:center;}.rm-embed-container > .rm-embed-spacer{display:block;}.rm-embed-twitter{max-width:550px;margin-top:10px;margin-bottom:10px;}.rm-embed-twitter blockquote{position:relative;height:100%;width:100%;flex-direction:column;display:flex;align-items:center;justify-content:center;flex-direction:column;text-align:center;}.rm-embed-twitter:not(.rm-off) .twitter-tweet{margin:0 !important;}.logo__image,.image-element__img,.rm-lazyloadable-image{max-width:100%;height:auto;}.logo__image,.image-element__img{width:auto;}@media (max-width:768px){.rm-embed-spacer.rm-embed-spacer-desktop{display:none;}}@media (min-width:768px){.rm-embed-spacer.rm-embed-spacer-mobile{display:none;}}.rm-component,.rm-slot{display:contents !important;}.widget__head .rm-lazyloadable-image{width:100%;}.crop-16x9{padding-bottom:56.25%;}.crop-3x2{padding-bottom:66.6666%;}.crop-2x1{padding-bottom:50%;}.crop-1x2{padding-bottom:200%;}.crop-3x1{padding-bottom:33.3333%;}.crop-1x1{padding-bottom:100%;}.rm-crop-16x9 > .widget__img--tag,.rm-crop-16x9 > div:not(.rm-crop-spacer),.rm-crop-3x2 > .widget__img--tag,.rm-crop-3x2 > div:not(.rm-crop-spacer),.rm-crop-2x1 > .widget__img--tag,.rm-crop-2x1 > div:not(.rm-crop-spacer),.rm-crop-1x2 > .widget__img--tag,.rm-crop-1x2 > div:not(.rm-crop-spacer),.rm-crop-3x1 > .widget__img--tag,.rm-crop-3x1 > div:not(.rm-crop-spacer),.rm-crop-1x1 > .widget__img--tag,.rm-crop-1x1 > div:not(.rm-crop-spacer),.rm-crop-custom > .widget__img--tag,.rm-crop-custom > div:not(.rm-crop-spacer){position:absolute;top:0;left:0;bottom:0;right:0;height:100%;width:100%;object-fit:contain;}.rm-crop-16x9 > .rm-crop-spacer,.rm-crop-3x2 > .rm-crop-spacer,.rm-crop-2x1 > .rm-crop-spacer,.rm-crop-1x2 > .rm-crop-spacer,.rm-crop-3x1 > .rm-crop-spacer,.rm-crop-1x1 > .rm-crop-spacer,.rm-crop-custom > .rm-crop-spacer{display:block;}.rm-crop-16x9 > .rm-crop-spacer{padding-bottom:56.25%;}.rm-crop-3x2 > .rm-crop-spacer{padding-bottom:66.6666%;}.rm-crop-2x1 > .rm-crop-spacer{padding-bottom:50%;}.rm-crop-1x2 > .rm-crop-spacer{padding-bottom:200%;}.rm-crop-3x1 > .rm-crop-spacer{padding-bottom:33.3333%;}.rm-crop-1x1 > .rm-crop-spacer{padding-bottom:100%;}[data-image-share-headline] .share-tab-img .share{background-image:none !important;}[data-image-share-headline] .share{cursor:pointer;}.social-tab-i .share-fb:after,.social-tab-i .share-tw:after{content:none;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i a{margin-right:0;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i li{line-height:1px;float:left;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i ul{margin:0;padding:0;list-style:none;}.share-tab-img{max-width:100%;padding:0;margin:0;position:relative;overflow:hidden;display:inline-block;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i{position:absolute;bottom:0;right:0;margin:0;padding:0;z-index:1;list-style-type:none;}.close-share-mobile,.show-share-mobile{background-color:rgba(0,0,0,0.75);}.share-buttons .social-tab-i.show-mobile-share-bar .close-share-mobile,.share-buttons .social-tab-i .show-share-mobile,.share-buttons .social-tab-i .share{width:30px;height:30px;line-height:27px;padding:0;text-align:center;display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i.show-mobile-share-bar .show-share-mobile,.share-buttons .social-tab-i .close-share-mobile{display:none;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i .icons-share{vertical-align:middle;display:inline-block;font:normal normal normal 14px/1 FontAwesome;color:white;}.social-tab-i .icons-share.fb:before{content:"\f09a";}.social-tab-i .icons-share.tw:before{content:"\f099";}.social-tab-i .icons-share.pt:before{content:"\f231";}.social-tab-i .icons-share.tl:before{content:"\f173";}.social-tab-i .icons-share.em:before{content:"\f0e0";}.social-tab-i .icons-share.sprite-shares-close:before{content:"\f00d";}.social-tab-i .icons-share.sprite-shares-share:before{content:"\f1e0";}@media only screen and (max-width:768px){.share-tab-img .social-tab-i{display:block;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i .share{display:none;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i.show-mobile-share-bar .share{display:block;}.social-tab-i li{float:left;}}@media only screen and (min-width:769px){.social-tab-i .close-share-mobile,.social-tab-i .show-share-mobile{display:none !important;}.share-tab-img .social-tab-i{display:none;}.share-tab-img:hover .social-tab-i{display:block;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i .share{width:51px;height:51px;line-height:47px;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i{margin:5px 0 0 5px;top:0;left:0;bottom:auto;right:auto;display:none;}.share-buttons .social-tab-i .share{display:block;}}article,aside,details,figcaption,figure,footer,header,hgroup,nav,section{display:block;}audio,canvas,video{display:inline-block;}audio:not([controls]){display:none;}[hidden]{display:none;}html{font-size:100%;-webkit-text-size-adjust:100%;-ms-text-size-adjust:100%;}body{margin:0;font-size:1em;line-height:1.4;}body,button,input,select,textarea{font-family:Tahoma,sans-serif;color:#5A5858;}::-moz-selection{background:#145A7C;color:#fff;text-shadow:none;}::selection{background:#145A7C;color:#fff;text-shadow:none;}:focus{outline:5px auto #2684b1;}a:hover,a:active{outline:0;}abbr[title]{border-bottom:1px dotted;}b,strong{font-weight:bold;}blockquote{margin:1em 40px;}dfn{font-style:italic;}hr{display:block;height:1px;border:0;border-top:1px solid #ccc;margin:1em 0;padding:0;}ins{background:#ff9;color:#000;text-decoration:none;}mark{background:#ff0;color:#000;font-style:italic;font-weight:bold;}pre,code,kbd,samp{font-family:monospace,serif;_font-family:'courier new',monospace;font-size:1em;}pre{white-space:pre;white-space:pre-wrap;word-wrap:break-word;}q{quotes:none;}q:before,q:after{content:"";content:none;}small{font-size:85%;}sub,sup{font-size:75%;line-height:0;position:relative;vertical-align:baseline;}sup{top:-0.5em;}sub{bottom:-0.25em;}ul,ol{margin:1em 0;padding:0 0 0 40px;}dd{margin:0 0 0 40px;}nav ul,nav ol{list-style:none;list-style-image:none;margin:0;padding:0;}img{border:0;-ms-interpolation-mode:bicubic;vertical-align:middle;}svg:not(:root){overflow:hidden;}figure{margin:0;}form{margin:0;}fieldset{border:0;margin:0;padding:0;}label{cursor:pointer;}legend{border:0;padding:0;}button,input{line-height:normal;}button,input[type="button"],input[type="reset"],input[type="submit"]{cursor:pointer;-webkit-appearance:button;}input[type="checkbox"],input[type="radio"]{box-sizing:border-box;padding:0;}input[type="search"]{-webkit-appearance:textfield;box-sizing:content-box;}input[type="search"]::-webkit-search-decoration{-webkit-appearance:none;}button::-moz-focus-inner,input::-moz-focus-inner{border:0;padding:0;}textarea{overflow:auto;vertical-align:top;resize:vertical;}input:invalid,textarea:invalid{background-color:#fccfcc;}table{border-collapse:collapse;border-spacing:0;}td{vertical-align:top;}.ir{display:block;border:0;text-indent:-999em;overflow:hidden;background-color:transparent;background-repeat:no-repeat;text-align:left;direction:ltr;}.ir br{display:none;}.hidden{display:none !important;visibility:hidden;}.visuallyhidden{border:0;clip:rect(0 0 0 0);height:1px;margin:-1px;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute;width:1px;}.visuallyhidden.focusable:active,.visuallyhidden.focusable:focus{clip:auto;height:auto;margin:0;overflow:visible;position:static;width:auto;}.invisible{visibility:hidden;}.clearfix:before,.clearfix:after{content:"";display:table;}.clearfix:after{clear:both;}.clearfix{zoom:1;}.zindex20{z-index:20;}.zindex30{z-index:30;}.zindex40{z-index:40;}.zindex50{z-index:50;}html{font-size:11.25px;font-family:serif;line-height:1.66;color:#0D0D0D;font-weight:normal;}body,button,input,select,textarea{font-family:serif;color:#0D0D0D;}.col,body{font-size:1.6rem;line-height:1.66;}a{color:#FF4C00;text-decoration:none;}a:hover{color:#FF4C00;text-decoration:none;}.with-primary-color{color:#FF4C00;}.with-primary-color:hover{color:#FF4C00;}.js-tab,.js-keep-reading,.js-toggle{cursor:pointer;}.noselect{-webkit-touch-callout:none;-webkit-user-select:none;-khtml-user-select:none;-moz-user-select:none;-ms-user-select:none;user-select:none;}.tabs__tab{display:inline-block;padding:10px;}.tabs__tab-content{display:none;}.tabs__tab-content.active{display:block;}button:focus,input[type="text"],input[type="email"]{outline:0;}audio,canvas,iframe,img,svg,video{vertical-align:middle;max-width:100%;}textarea{resize:vertical;}.main{background-color:#bdbdbd;position:relative;overflow:hidden;}.valign-wrapper{display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-align-items:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;}.valign-wrapper .valign{display:block;}#notification{position:fixed;}.article-module__controls-placeholder{position:absolute;}.display-block{display:block;}.cover-all{position:absolute;width:100%;height:100%;}.full-width{width:100%;}.fa{font-family:FontAwesome,"fontawesome-mini" !important;}.fa.fa-instagram{font-size:1.15em;}.fa-googleplus:before{content:"\f0d5";}.post-partial,.overflow-visible{overflow:visible !important;}.attribute-data{margin:0 10px 10px 0;padding:5px 10px;background-color:#FF4C00;color:white;border-radius:3px;margin-bottom:10px;display:inline-block;}.attribute-data[value=""]{display:none;}.badge{display:inline-block;overflow:hidden;}.badge-image{border-radius:100%;}.js-expandable.expanded .js-expand,.js-expandable:not(.expanded) .js-contract{display:none;}.js-scroll-trigger{display:block;width:100%;}.sticky-target:not(.legacy){position:fixed;opacity:0;top:0;will-change:transform;transform:translate3d(0px,0px,0px);}.sticky-target.legacy{position:relative;}.sticky-target.legacy.sticky-active{position:fixed;}.color-inherit:hover,.color-inherit{color:inherit;}.js-appear-on-expand{transition:all 350ms;height:0;overflow:hidden;opacity:0;}.content-container{display:none;}.expanded .content-container{display:block;}.expanded .js-appear-on-expand{opacity:1;height:auto;}.logged-out-user .js-appear-on-expand{height:0;opacity:0;}.h1,.h2{margin:0;padding:0;font-size:1em;font-weight:normal;}.lazyload-placeholder{display:none;position:absolute;text-align:center;background:rgba(0,0,0,0.1);top:0;bottom:0;left:0;right:0;}div[runner-lazy-loading] .lazyload-placeholder,iframe[runner-lazy-loading] + .lazyload-placeholder{display:block;}.abs-pos-center{position:absolute;top:0;bottom:0;left:0;right:0;margin:auto;}.relative{position:relative;}.runner-spinner{position:absolute;top:0;bottom:0;left:0;right:0;margin:auto;width:50px;}.runner-spinner:before{content:"";display:block;padding-top:100%;}.rm-non-critical-loaded .runner-spinner-circular{animation:rotate 2s linear infinite;height:100%;transform-origin:center center;width:100%;position:absolute;top:0;bottom:0;left:0;right:0;margin:auto;}.position-relative{position:relative;}.collection-button{display:inline-block;}.rm-non-critical-loaded .runner-spinner-path{stroke-dasharray:1,200;stroke-dashoffset:0;animation:dash 1.5s ease-in-out infinite,color 6s ease-in-out infinite;stroke-linecap:round;}.pagination-container .pagination-wrapper{display:flex;align-items:center;}.pagination-container .pagination-wrapper a{color:rgba(59,141,242,1);margin:0 5px;}@keyframes rotate{100%{transform:rotate(360deg);}}@keyframes dash{0%{stroke-dasharray:1,200;stroke-dashoffset:0;}50%{stroke-dasharray:89,200;stroke-dashoffset:-35px;}100%{stroke-dasharray:89,200;stroke-dashoffset:-124px;}}@keyframes color{100%,0%{stroke:rgba(255,255,255,1);}40%{stroke:rgba(255,255,255,0.6);}66%{stroke:rgba(255,255,255,0.9);}80%,90%{stroke:rgba(255,255,255,0.7);}}.js-section-loader-feature-container > .slick-list > .slick-track > .slick-slide:not(.slick-active){height:0;visibility:hidden;}.rebellt-item-media-container .instagram-media{margin-left:auto !important;margin-right:auto !important;}.js-hidden-panel{position:fixed;top:0;left:0;right:0;transition:all 300ms;z-index:10;}.js-hidden-panel.active{transform:translate3d(0,-100%,0);}.content{margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;max-width:1100px;width:90%;}.ad-tag{text-align:center;}.ad-tag__inner{display:inline-block;}.content .ad-tag{margin-left:-5%;margin-right:-5%;}@media (min-width:768px){.content .ad-tag{margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;}}.no-mb:not(:last-child){margin-bottom:0;}.no-mt:not(:first-child){margin-top:0;}.sm-mt-0:not(:empty):before,.sm-mt-1:not(:empty):before,.sm-mt-2:not(:empty):before,.sm-mb-0:not(:empty):after,.sm-mb-1:not(:empty):after,.sm-mb-2:not(:empty):after,.md-mt-0:not(:empty):before,.md-mt-1:not(:empty):before,.md-mt-2:not(:empty):before,.md-mb-0:not(:empty):after,.md-mb-1:not(:empty):after,.md-mb-2:not(:empty):after,.lg-mt-0:not(:empty):before,.lg-mt-1:not(:empty):before,.lg-mt-2:not(:empty):before,.lg-mb-0:not(:empty):after,.lg-mb-1:not(:empty):after,.lg-mb-2:not(:empty):after{content:'';display:block;overflow:hidden;}.sm-mt-0:not(:empty):before{margin-bottom:0;}.sm-mt-0 > *{margin-top:0;}.sm-mt-1:not(:empty):before{margin-bottom:-10px;}.sm-mt-1 > *{margin-top:10px;}.sm-mt-2:not(:empty):before{margin-bottom:-20px;}.sm-mt-2 > *{margin-top:20px;}.sm-mb-0:not(:empty):after{margin-top:0;}.sm-mb-0 > *{margin-bottom:0;}.sm-mb-1:not(:empty):after{margin-top:-10px;}.sm-mb-1 > *{margin-bottom:10px;}.sm-mb-2:not(:empty):after{margin-top:-20px;}.sm-mb-2 > *{margin-bottom:20px;}@media (min-width:768px){.md-mt-0:not(:empty):before{margin-bottom:0;}.md-mt-0 > *{margin-top:0;}.md-mt-1:not(:empty):before{margin-bottom:-10px;}.md-mt-1 > *{margin-top:10px;}.md-mt-2:not(:empty):before{margin-bottom:-20px;}.md-mt-2 > *{margin-top:20px;}.md-mb-0:not(:empty):after{margin-top:0;}.md-mb-0 > *{margin-bottom:0;}.md-mb-1:not(:empty):after{margin-top:-10px;}.md-mb-1 > *{margin-bottom:10px;}.md-mb-2:not(:empty):after{margin-top:-20px;}.md-mb-2 > *{margin-bottom:20px;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.lg-mt-0:not(:empty):before{margin-bottom:0;}.lg-mt-0 > *{margin-top:0;}.lg-mt-1:not(:empty):before{margin-bottom:-10px;}.lg-mt-1 > *{margin-top:10px;}.lg-mt-2:not(:empty):before{margin-bottom:-20px;}.lg-mt-2 > *{margin-top:20px;}.lg-mb-0:not(:empty):after{margin-top:0;}.lg-mb-0 > *{margin-bottom:0;}.lg-mb-1:not(:empty):after{margin-top:-10px;}.lg-mb-1 > *{margin-bottom:10px;}.lg-mb-2:not(:empty):after{margin-top:-20px;}.lg-mb-2 > *{margin-bottom:20px;}}.sm-cp-0{padding:0;}.sm-cp-1{padding:10px;}.sm-cp-2{padding:20px;}@media (min-width:768px){.md-cp-0{padding:0;}.md-cp-1{padding:10px;}.md-cp-2{padding:20px;}}@media (min-width:1024px){.lg-cp-0{padding:0;}.lg-cp-1{padding:10px;}.lg-cp-2{padding:20px;}}.mb-2 > *{margin-bottom:20px;}.mb-2 > :last-child{margin-bottom:0;}.v-sep > *{margin-bottom:20px;}@media (min-width:768px){.v-sep > *{margin-bottom:40px;}}.v-sep > *:last-child{margin-bottom:0;}@media only screen and (max-width:767px){.hide-mobile{display:none !important;}}@media only screen and (max-width:1023px){.hide-tablet-and-mobile{display:none !important;}}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.hide-tablet-and-desktop{display:none !important;}}@media only screen and (min-width:768px) and (max-width:1023px){.hide-tablet{display:none !important;}}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.hide-desktop{display:none !important;}}.row.px10{margin-left:-10px;margin-right:-10px;}.row.px10 > .col{padding-left:10px;padding-right:10px;}.row.px20{margin-left:-20px;margin-right:-20px;}.row.px20 > .col{padding-left:20px;padding-right:20px;}.row{margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;overflow:hidden;}.row:after{content:'';display:table;clear:both;}.row:not(:empty){margin-bottom:-20px;}.col{margin-bottom:20px;}@media (min-width:768px){.col{margin-bottom:40px;}.row:not(:empty){margin-bottom:-40px;}}.row .col{float:left;box-sizing:border-box;}.row .col.pull-right{float:right;}.row .col.s1{width:8.3333333333%;}.row .col.s2{width:16.6666666667%;}.row .col.s3{width:25%;}.row .col.s4{width:33.3333333333%;}.row .col.s5{width:41.6666666667%;}.row .col.s6{width:50%;}.row .col.s7{width:58.3333333333%;}.row .col.s8{width:66.6666666667%;}.row .col.s9{width:75%;}.row .col.s10{width:83.3333333333%;}.row .col.s11{width:91.6666666667%;}.row .col.s12{width:100%;}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.row .col.m1{width:8.3333333333%;}.row .col.m2{width:16.6666666667%;}.row .col.m3{width:25%;}.row .col.m4{width:33.3333333333%;}.row .col.m5{width:41.6666666667%;}.row .col.m6{width:50%;}.row .col.m7{width:58.3333333333%;}.row .col.m8{width:66.6666666667%;}.row .col.m9{width:75%;}.row .col.m10{width:83.3333333333%;}.row .col.m11{width:91.6666666667%;}.row .col.m12{width:100%;}}@media only screen and (min-width:1024px){.row .col.l1{width:8.3333333333%;}.row .col.l2{width:16.6666666667%;}.row .col.l3{width:25%;}.row .col.l4{width:33.3333333333%;}.row .col.l5{width:41.6666666667%;}.row .col.l6{width:50%;}.row .col.l7{width:58.3333333333%;}.row .col.l8{width:66.6666666667%;}.row .col.l9{width:75%;}.row .col.l10{width:83.3333333333%;}.row .col.l11{width:91.6666666667%;}.row .col.l12{width:100%;}}.widget{position:relative;box-sizing:border-box;}.widget:hover .widget__headline a{color:#FF4C00;}.widget__headline{font-family:Theinhardt-Regular,Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif;color:#0D0D0D;cursor:pointer;}.widget__headline-text{font-family:inherit;color:inherit;word-break:break-word;}.widget__section-text{display:block;}.image,.widget__image{background-position:center;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:cover;display:block;z-index:0;}.widget__play{position:absolute;width:100%;height:100%;text-align:center;}.rm-widget-image-holder{position:relative;}.rm-video-holder{position:absolute;width:100%;height:100%;top:0;left:0;}.rm-zindex-hidden{display:none;z-index:-1;}.rm-widget-image-holder .widget__play{top:0;left:0;}.image.no-image{background-color:#e4e4e4;}.widget__video{position:relative;}.widget__video .rm-scrop-spacer{padding-bottom:56.25%;}.widget__video.rm-video-tiktok{max-width:605px;}.widget__video video,.widget__video iframe{position:absolute;top:0;left:0;height:100%;}.widget__product-vendor{font-size:1.5em;line-height:1.5;margin:25px 0;}.widget__product-buy-link{margin:15px 0;}.widget__product-buy-link-btn{background-color:#000;color:#fff;display:inline-block;font-size:1.6rem;line-height:1em;padding:1.25rem;font-weight:700;}.widget__product-buy-btn:hover{color:#fff;}.widget__product-price{font-size:1.5em;line-height:1.5;margin:25px 0;}.widget__product-compare-at-price{text-decoration:line-through;}.rebellt-item.is--mobile,.rebellt-item.is--tablet{margin-bottom:0.85em;}.rebellt-item.show_columns_on_mobile.col2,.rebellt-item.show_columns_on_mobile.col3{display:inline-block;vertical-align:top;}.rebellt-item.show_columns_on_mobile.col2{width:48%;}.rebellt-item.show_columns_on_mobile.col3{width:32%;}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.rebellt-item.col2:not(.show_columns_on_mobile),.rebellt-item.col3:not(.show_columns_on_mobile){display:inline-block;vertical-align:top;}.rebellt-item.col2:not(.show_columns_on_mobile){width:48%;}.rebellt-item.col3:not(.show_columns_on_mobile){width:32%;}}.rebellt-item.parallax{background-size:cover;background-attachment:fixed;position:relative;left:calc(-50vw + 50%);width:100vw;min-height:100vh;padding:0 20%;box-sizing:border-box;max-width:inherit;text-align:center;z-index:3;}.rebellt-item.parallax.is--mobile{background-position:center;margin-bottom:0;padding:0 15%;}.rebellt-item.parallax.has-description:before,.rebellt-item.parallax.has-description:after{content:"";display:block;padding-bottom:100%;}.rebellt-item.parallax.has-description.is--mobile:before,.rebellt-item.parallax.has-description.is--mobile:after{padding-bottom:90vh;}.rebellt-item.parallax h3,.rebellt-item.parallax p{color:white;text-shadow:1px 0 #000;}.rebellt-item.parallax.is--mobile p{font-size:18px;font-weight:400;}.rebellt-ecommerce h3{font-size:1.8em;margin-bottom:15px;}.rebellt-ecommerce--vendor{font-size:1.5em;line-height:1.5;margin:25px 0;}.rebellt-ecommerce--price{font-size:1.5em;line-height:1.5;margin:25px 0;}.rebellt-ecommerce--compare-at-price{text-decoration:line-through;}.rebellt-ecommerce--buy{margin:15px 0;}.rebellt-ecommerce--btn{background-color:#000;color:#fff;display:inline-block;font-size:1.6rem;line-height:1em;padding:1.25rem;font-weight:700;}.rebellt-ecommerce--btn:hover{color:#fff;}.rebelbar.skin-simple{height:50px;line-height:50px;color:#0D0D0D;font-size:1.2rem;border-left:none;border-right:none;background-color:#fff;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__inner{position:relative;height:100%;margin:0 auto;padding:0 20px;max-width:1300px;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .logo{float:left;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .logo__image{max-height:50px;max-width:190px;}.rebelbar--fake.skin-simple{position:relative;border-color:#fff;}.rebelbar--fixed.skin-simple{position:absolute;width:100%;z-index:3;}.with-fixed-header .rebelbar--fixed.skin-simple{position:fixed;top:0;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__menu-toggle{position:relative;cursor:pointer;float:left;text-align:center;font-size:0;width:50px;margin-left:-15px;height:100%;color:#0D0D0D;}.rebelbar.skin-simple i{vertical-align:middle;display:inline-block;font-size:20px;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__menu-toggle:hover{color:#FF4C00;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__section-links{display:none;padding:0 100px 0 40px;overflow:hidden;height:100%;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__section-list{margin:0 -15px;height:100%;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__section-links li{display:inline-block;padding:0 15px;text-align:left;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__section-link{color:#0D0D0D;display:block;font-size:1.8rem;font-weight:400;text-decoration:none;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__section-link:hover{color:#FF4C00;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__sharebar.sharebar{display:none;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__section-list.js--active .rebelbar__more-sections-button{visibility:visible;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__more-sections-button{cursor:pointer;visibility:hidden;}.rebelbar.skin-simple #rebelbar__more-sections{visibility:hidden;position:fixed;line-height:70px;left:0;width:100%;background-color:#1f1f1f;}.rebelbar.skin-simple #rebelbar__more-sections a{color:white;}.rebelbar.skin-simple #rebelbar__more-sections.opened{visibility:visible;}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__menu-toggle{margin-right:15px;}.rebelbar.skin-simple{height:100px;line-height:100px;font-weight:700;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .logo__image{max-width:350px;max-height:100px;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__inner{padding:0 40px;}.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__sharebar.sharebar{float:left;margin-top:20px;margin-bottom:20px;padding-left:40px;}}@media (min-width:960px){.rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__section-links{display:block;}.with-floating-shares .rebelbar.skin-simple .search-form{display:none;}.with-floating-shares .rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__sharebar.sharebar{display:block;}.with-floating-shares .rebelbar.skin-simple .rebelbar__section-links{display:none;}}.menu-global{display:none;width:100%;position:fixed;z-index:3;color:white;background-color:#1a1a1a;height:100%;font-size:1.8rem;overflow-y:auto;overflow-x:hidden;line-height:1.6em;}@media (min-width:768px){.menu-global{display:block;max-width:320px;top:0;-webkit-transform:translate(-320px,0);transform:translate(-320px,0);transform:translate3d(-320px,0,0);}.menu-global,.all-content-wrapper{transition:transform .2s cubic-bezier(.2,.3,.25,.9);}}.menu-overlay{position:fixed;top:-100%;left:0;height:0;width:100%;cursor:pointer;visibility:hidden;opacity:0;transition:opacity 200ms;}.menu-opened .menu-overlay{visibility:visible;height:100%;z-index:1;opacity:1;top:0;}@media only screen and (min-width:768px){.menu-opened .menu-overlay{z-index:10;background:rgba(255,255,255,.6);}}@media (min-width:960px){.logged-out-user .rebelbar.skin-simple .menu-overlay{display:none;}}@media (min-width:600px){.rm-resized-container-5{width:5%;}.rm-resized-container-10{width:10%;}.rm-resized-container-15{width:15%;}.rm-resized-container-20{width:20%;}.rm-resized-container-25{width:25%;}.rm-resized-container-30{width:30%;}.rm-resized-container-35{width:35%;}.rm-resized-container-40{width:40%;}.rm-resized-container-45{width:45%;}.rm-resized-container-50{width:50%;}.rm-resized-container-55{width:55%;}.rm-resized-container-60{width:60%;}.rm-resized-container-65{width:65%;}.rm-resized-container-70{width:70%;}.rm-resized-container-75{width:75%;}.rm-resized-container-80{width:80%;}.rm-resized-container-85{width:85%;}.rm-resized-container-90{width:90%;}.rm-resized-container-95{width:95%;}.rm-resized-container-100{width:100%;}}.sharebar{margin:0 -4px;padding:0;font-size:0;line-height:0;}.sharebar a{color:#fff;}.sharebar a:hover{text-decoration:none;color:#fff;}.sharebar .share,.sharebar .share-plus{display:inline-block;margin:0 4px;font-size:14px;font-weight:400;padding:0 10px;width:20px;min-width:20px;height:40px;line-height:38px;text-align:center;vertical-align:middle;border-radius:2px;}.sharebar .share-plus i,.sharebar .share i{display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;}.sharebar .hide-button{display:none;}.sharebar.enable-panel .hide-button{display:inline-block;}.sharebar.enable-panel .share-plus{display:none;}.sharebar.with-first-button-caption:not(.enable-panel) .share:first-child{width:68px;}.sharebar.with-first-button-caption:not(.enable-panel) .share:first-child:after{content:'Share';padding-left:5px;vertical-align:middle;}.sharebar--fixed{display:none;position:fixed;bottom:0;z-index:1;text-align:center;width:100%;left:0;margin:20px auto;}.with-floating-shares .sharebar--fixed{display:block;}.sharebar.fly_shared:not(.enable-panel) .share:nth-child(5){display:none;}.share-media-panel .share-media-panel-pinit{position:absolute;right:0;bottom:0;background-color:transparent;}.share-media-panel-pinit_share{background-image:url('/static/img/whitelabel/runner/spritesheets/pin-it-sprite.png');background-color:#BD081C;background-position:-1px -17px;border-radius:4px;float:right;height:34px;margin:7px;width:60px;background-size:194px auto;}.share-media-panel-pinit_share:hover{opacity:.9;}@media (min-width:768px){.sharebar .share-plus .fa,.sharebar .share .fa{font-size:22px;}.sharebar .share,.sharebar .share-plus{padding:0 15px;width:30px;min-width:30px;height:60px;line-height:60px;margin:0 4px;font-size:16px;}.sharebar.with-first-button-caption:not(.enable-panel) .share:first-child{width:180px;}.sharebar.with-first-button-caption:not(.enable-panel) .share:first-child:after{content:'Share this story';padding-left:10px;vertical-align:middle;text-transform:uppercase;}.share-media-panel-pinit_share{background-position:-60px -23px;height:45px;margin:10px;width:80px;}}.action-btn{display:block;font-size:1.6rem;color:#FF4C00;cursor:pointer;border:2px solid #FF4C00;border-color:#FF4C00;border-radius:2px;line-height:1em;padding:1.6rem;font-weight:700;text-align:center;}.action-btn:hover{color:#FF4C00;border:2px solid #FF4C00;border-color:#FF4C00;}.section-headline__text{font-size:3rem;font-weight:700;line-height:1;}.section-headline__text{color:#0D0D0D;}@media (min-width:768px){.section-headline__text{font-size:3.6rem;}.content__main .section-headline__text{margin-top:-.3rem;margin-bottom:2rem;}}.module-headline__text{font-size:3rem;font-weight:700;color:#262626;}@media (min-width:768px){.module-headline__text{font-size:3.6rem;}}.search-form{position:absolute;top:0;right:20px;z-index:1;}.search-form__text-input{display:none;height:42px;font-size:1.3rem;background-color:#f4f4f4;border:none;color:#8f8f8f;text-indent:10px;padding:0;width:220px;position:absolute;right:-10px;top:0;bottom:0;margin:auto;}.search-form .search-form__submit{display:none;position:relative;border:none;bottom:2px;background-color:transparent;}.search-form__text-input:focus,.search-form__submit:focus{border:0 none;-webkit-box-shadow:none;-moz-box-shadow:none;box-shadow:none;outline:0 none;}.show-search .search-form__close{position:absolute;display:block;top:0;bottom:0;margin:auto;height:1rem;right:-28px;}.search-form__open{vertical-align:middle;bottom:2px;display:inline-block;position:relative;color:#0D0D0D;font-size:1.9rem;}.show-search .search-form__text-input{display:block;}.show-search .search-form__submit{display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;padding:0;color:#0D0D0D;font-size:1.9rem;}.search-form__close,.show-search .search-form__open{display:none;}.quick-search{display:block;border-bottom:1px solid #d2d2d2;padding:24px 0 28px;margin-bottom:20px;position:relative;}.quick-search__submit{background-color:transparent;border:0;padding:0;margin:0;position:absolute;zoom:.75;color:#000;}.quick-search__input{background-color:transparent;border:0;padding:0;font-size:1.5rem;font-weight:700;line-height:3em;padding-left:40px;width:100%;box-sizing:border-box;}@media (min-width:768px){.search-form{right:40px;}.quick-search{margin-bottom:40px;padding:0 0 20px;}.quick-search__submit{zoom:1;}.quick-search__input{line-height:2.2em;padding-left:60px;}}.search-widget{position:relative;}.search-widget__input,.search-widget__submit{border:none;padding:0;margin:0;color:#0D0D0D;background:transparent;font-size:inherit;line-height:inherit;}.social-links__link{display:inline-block;padding:12px;line-height:0;width:25px;height:25px;border-radius:50%;margin:0 6px;font-size:1.5em;text-align:center;position:relative;vertical-align:middle;color:white;}.social-links__link:hover{color:white;}.social-links__link > span{position:absolute;top:0;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;margin:auto;height:1em;}.article__body{font-family:Theinhardt-Regular,Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif;}.body-description .horizontal-rule{border-top:2px solid #eee;}.article-content blockquote{border-left:5px solid #FF4C00;border-left-color:#FF4C00;color:#656565;padding:0 0 0 25px;margin:1em 0 1em 25px;}.article__splash-custom{position:relative;}.body hr{display:none;}.article-content .media-caption{color:#9a9a9a;font-size:1.4rem;line-height:2;}.giphy-image{margin-bottom:0;}.article-body a{word-wrap:break-word;}.article-content .giphy-image__credits-wrapper{margin:0;}.article-content .giphy-image__credits{color:#000;font-size:1rem;}.article-content .image-media,.article-content .giphy-image .media-photo-credit{display:block;}.tags{color:#FF4C00;margin:0 -5px;}.tags__item{margin:5px;display:inline-block;}.tags .tags__item{line-height:1;}.slideshow .carousel-control{overflow:hidden;}.shortcode-media .media-caption,.shortcode-media .media-photo-credit{display:block;}@media (min-width:768px){.tags{margin:0 -10px;}.tags__item{margin:10px;}.article-content__comments-wrapper{border-bottom:1px solid #d2d2d2;margin-bottom:20px;padding-bottom:40px;}}.subscription-widget{background:#FF4C00;padding:30px;}.subscription-widget .module-headline__text{text-align:center;font-size:2rem;font-weight:400;color:#fff;}.subscription-widget .social-links{margin-left:-10px;margin-right:-10px;text-align:center;font-size:0;}.subscription-widget .social-links__link{display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;width:39px;height:39px;color:#fff;box-sizing:border-box;border-radius:50%;font-size:20px;margin:0 5px;line-height:35px;background:transparent;border:2px solid #fff;border-color:#fff;}.subscription-widget .social-links__link:hover{color:#FF4C00;border-color:#FF4C00;background:transparent;}.subscription-widget .social-links__link .fa-instagram{margin:5px 0 0 1px;}.subscription-widget__site-links{margin:30px -5px;text-align:center;font-size:.8em;}.subscription-widget__site-link{padding:0 5px;color:inherit;}.newsletter-element__form{text-align:center;position:relative;max-width:500px;margin-left:auto;margin-right:auto;}.newsletter-element__submit,.newsletter-element__input{border:0;padding:10px;font-size:1.6rem;font-weight:500;height:40px;line-height:20px;margin:0;}.newsletter-element__submit{background:#262626;color:#fff;position:absolute;top:0;right:0;}.newsletter-element__submit:hover{opacity:.9;}.newsletter-element__input{background:#f4f4f4;width:100%;color:#8f8f8f;padding-right:96px;box-sizing:border-box;}.gdpr-cookie-wrapper{position:relative;left:0;right:0;padding:.5em;box-sizing:border-box;}.gdpr-cookie-controls{text-align:right;}.runner-authors-list{margin-top:0;margin-bottom:0;padding-left:0;list-style-type:none;}.runner-authors-author-wrapper{display:flex;flex-direction:row;flex-wrap:nowrap;justify-content:flex-start;align-items:stretch;align-content:stretch;}.runner-authors-avatar-thumb{display:inline-block;border-radius:100%;width:55px;height:55px;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-position:center;background-size:cover;overflow:hidden;}.runner-authors-avatar-thumb img{width:100%;height:100%;display:block;object-fit:cover;border-radius:100%;}.runner-authors-avatar-fallback{display:flex;align-items:center;justify-content:center;width:100%;height:100%;font-size:12px;line-height:1.1;text-align:center;padding:4px;background:#e0e0e0;color:#555;font-weight:600;text-transform:uppercase;border-radius:100%;overflow:hidden;}.runner-authors-author-info{width:calc(100% - 55px);}.runner-author-name-container{padding:0 6px;}.rm-breadcrumb__list{margin:0;padding:0;}.rm-breadcrumb__item{list-style-type:none;display:inline;}.rm-breadcrumb__item:last-child .rm-breadcrumb__separator{display:none;}.rm-breadcrumb__item:last-child .rm-breadcrumb__link,.rm-breadcrumb__link.disabled{pointer-events:none;color:inherit;}.accesibility-hidden{border:0;clip:rect(1px 1px 1px 1px);clip:rect(1px,1px,1px,1px);height:1px;margin:-1px;overflow:hidden;padding:0;position:absolute;width:1px;background:#000;color:#fff;}body:not(.rm-non-critical-loaded) .follow-button{display:none;}.posts-custom .posts-wrapper:after{content:"";display:block;margin-bottom:-20px;}.posts-custom .widget{margin-bottom:20px;width:100%;}.posts-custom .widget__headline,.posts-custom .social-date{display:block;}.posts-custom .social-date{color:#a4a2a0;font-size:1.4rem;}.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_headline] .widget{vertical-align:top;}.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_headline="top"] .widget{vertical-align:bottom;}.posts-custom .posts-wrapper{margin-left:0;margin-right:0;font-size:0;line-height:0;}.posts-custom .widget{display:inline-block;}.posts-custom article{margin:0;box-sizing:border-box;font-size:1.6rem;line-height:1.66;}.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_columns="2"] article,.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_columns="3"] article,.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_columns="4"] article{margin:0 10px;}.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_columns="2"] .posts-wrapper,.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_columns="3"] .posts-wrapper,.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_columns="4"] .posts-wrapper{margin-left:-10px;margin-right:-10px;}@media (min-width:768px){.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_columns="2"] .widget{width:50%;}.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_columns="3"] .widget{width:33.3333%;}.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_columns="4"] .widget{width:25%;}}.posts-custom .widget__headline{font-size:1em;font-weight:700;word-wrap:break-word;}.posts-custom .widget__section{display:block;}.posts-custom .widget__head{position:relative;}.posts-custom .widget__head .widget__body{position:absolute;padding:5%;bottom:0;left:0;box-sizing:border-box;width:100%;background:rgba(0,0,0,0.4);background:linear-gradient(transparent 5%,rgba(0,0,0,0.5));}.posts-custom .widget__head .social-author__name,.posts-custom .widget__head .main-author__name,.posts-custom .widget__head .social-author__social-name,.posts-custom .widget__head .main-author__social-name,.posts-custom .widget__head .widget__headline,.posts-custom .widget__head .widget__subheadline{color:white;}.posts-custom .widget__subheadline *{display:inline;}.posts-custom .main-author__avatar,.posts-custom .social-author__avatar{float:left;border-radius:50%;margin-right:8px;height:30px;width:30px;min-width:30px;overflow:hidden;position:relative;}.posts-custom .main-author__name,.posts-custom .social-author__name{color:#1f1f1f;font-size:1.4rem;font-weight:700;line-height:1.66;display:inline;overflow:hidden;text-overflow:ellipsis;white-space:nowrap;position:relative;}.posts-custom .main-author__social-name,.posts-custom .social-author__social-name{color:#757575;display:block;font-size:1.2rem;line-height:0.8em;}.posts-custom .main-author__name:hover,.posts-custom .social-author__name:hover,.posts-custom .main-author__social-name:hover,.posts-custom .social-author__social-name:hover{color:#FF4C00;}.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_carousel] .posts-wrapper:after{margin-bottom:0 !important;}.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_carousel] .widget{margin-bottom:0 !important;}.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_carousel][data-attr-layout_columns="1"] .posts-wrapper:not(.slick-initialized) .widget:not(:first-child),.posts-custom[data-attr-layout_carousel]:not([data-attr-layout_columns="1"]) .posts-wrapper:not(.slick-initialized){display:none !important;}.posts-custom .slick-arrow{position:absolute;top:0;bottom:0;width:7%;max-width:60px;min-width:45px;min-height:60px;height:15%;color:white;border:0;margin:auto 10px;background:#FF4C00;z-index:1;cursor:pointer;font-size:1.6rem;line-height:1;opacity:0.9;}.posts-custom .slick-prev{left:0;}.posts-custom .slick-next{right:0;}.posts-custom .slick-arrow:before{position:absolute;left:0;right:0;width:13px;bottom:0;top:0;margin:auto;height:16px;}.posts-custom .slick-arrow:hover{background:#FF4C00;opacity:1;}.posts-custom .slick-dots{display:block;padding:10px;box-sizing:border-box;text-align:center;margin:0 -5px;}.posts-custom .slick-dots li{display:inline-block;margin:0 5px;}.posts-custom .slick-dots button{font-size:0;width:10px;height:10px;display:inline-block;line-height:0;border:0;background:#FF4C00;border-radius:7px;padding:0;margin:0;vertical-align:middle;outline:none;}.posts-custom .slick-dots .slick-active button,.posts-custom .slick-dots button:hover{background:#FF4C00;}.posts-custom hr{display:none;}.posts-custom{font-family:Theinhardt-Regular,Helvetica,Arial,sans-serif;}.posts-custom blockquote{border-left:5px solid #FF4C00;border-left-color:#FF4C00;color:#656565;padding:0 0 0 25px;margin:1em 0 1em 25px;}.posts-custom .media-caption{color:#9a9a9a;font-size:1.4rem;line-height:2;}.posts-custom a{word-wrap:break-word;}.posts-custom .giphy-image__credits-wrapper{margin:0;}.posts-custom .giphy-image__credits{color:#000;font-size:1rem;}.posts-custom .body .image-media,.posts-custom .body .giphy-image .media-photo-credit{display:block;}.posts-custom .widget__shares.enable-panel .share-plus,.posts-custom .widget__shares:not(.enable-panel) .hide-button{display:none;}.posts-custom .widget__shares{margin-left:-10px;margin-right:-10px;font-size:0;}.posts-custom .widget__shares .share{display:inline-block;padding:5px;line-height:0;width:25px;height:25px;border-radius:50%;margin:0 10px;font-size:1.5rem;text-align:center;position:relative;vertical-align:middle;color:white;}.posts-custom .widget__shares .share:hover{color:white;}.posts-custom .widget__shares i{position:absolute;top:0;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;margin:auto;height:1em;}.infinite-scroll-wrapper:not(.rm-loading){width:1px;height:1px;}.infinite-scroll-wrapper.rm-loading{width:1px;}.rm-loadmore-placeholder.rm-loading{display:block;width:100%;}.widget__shares button.share,.social-tab-buttons button.share{box-sizing:content-box;}.social-tab-buttons button.share{border:none;}.post-splash-custom,.post-splash-custom .widget__head{position:relative;}.post-splash-custom .widget__head .widget__body{position:absolute;padding:5%;bottom:0;left:0;box-sizing:border-box;width:100%;background:rgba(0,0,0,0.4);background:-webkit-linear-gradient( transparent 5%,rgba(0,0,0,0.5) );background:-o-linear-gradient(transparent 5%,rgba(0,0,0,0.5));background:-moz-linear-gradient( transparent 5%,rgba(0,0,0,0.5) );background:linear-gradient(transparent 5%,rgba(0,0,0,0.5));}.post-splash-custom .headline{font-size:2rem;font-weight:700;position:relative;}.post-splash-custom .post-controls{position:absolute;top:0;left:0;z-index:2;}.post-splash-custom hr{display:none;}.post-splash-custom .widget__section{display:block;}.post-splash-custom .post-date{display:block;}.post-splash-custom .photo-credit p,.post-splash-custom .photo-credit a{font-size:1.1rem;margin:0;}.post-splash-custom .widget__subheadline *{display:inline;}.post-splash-custom .widget__image .headline,.post-splash-custom .widget__image .photo-credit,.post-splash-custom .widget__image .photo-credit p,.post-splash-custom .widget__image .photo-credit a,.post-splash-custom .widget__image .post-date{color:#fff;}@media (min-width:768px){.post-splash-custom .headline{font-size:3.6rem;}}.post-splash-custom .widget__shares.enable-panel .share-plus,.post-splash-custom .widget__shares:not(.enable-panel) .hide-button{display:none;}.post-splash-custom .widget__shares{margin-left:-10px;margin-right:-10px;font-size:0;}.post-splash-custom .widget__shares .share{display:inline-block;padding:5px;line-height:0;width:25px;height:25px;border-radius:50%;margin:0 10px;font-size:1.5rem;text-align:center;position:relative;vertical-align:middle;color:white;}.post-splash-custom .widget__shares .share:hover{color:white;}.post-splash-custom .widget__shares i{position:absolute;top:0;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;margin:auto;height:1em;}.post-authors{font-size:1.1em;line-height:1;padding-bottom:20px;margin-bottom:20px;color:#9a9a9a;border-bottom:1px solid #d2d2d2;}.post-authors__name,.post-authors__date{display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;}.post-authors__name{font-weight:600;}.post-authors__date{margin-left:7px;}.post-authors__fb-like{float:right;overflow:hidden;}.post-authors__fb-like[fb-xfbml-state='rendered']:before{content:'Like us on Facebook';line-height:20px;display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;margin-right:15px;}.post-authors__list{list-style:none;display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;margin:0;padding:0;}.post-author{display:inline;}.post-author__avatar{z-index:0;border-radius:100%;object-fit:cover;width:50px;height:50px;}.post-author__avatar,.post-author__name{display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;}.post-author__bio p{margin:0;}.post-pager{display:table;width:100%;}.post-pager__spacing{display:table-cell;padding:0;width:5px;}.post-pager__btn{display:table-cell;font-size:1.6rem;background:#FF4C00;color:white;cursor:pointer;line-height:1em;padding:1.6rem;font-weight:700;text-align:center;}.post-pager__btn:hover{background:#FF4C00;color:white;}.post-pager__btn .fa{transition:padding 200ms;}.post-pager__btn:hover .fa{padding:0 5px;}.post-pager__spacing:first-child,.post-pager__spacing:last-child{display:none;}.arrow-link{font-weight:600;font-size:1.5rem;color:#FF4C00;margin:0 -.5rem;text-align:right;position:relative;}.arrow-link__anchor span{vertical-align:middle;margin:0 .5rem;}.list{display:block;margin-left:-1em;margin-right:-1em;padding:0;}.list__item{display:inline-block;padding:1em;}.logo__anchor{display:block;font-size:0;}.logo__image.with-bounds{max-width:190px;max-height:100px;}@media (min-width:768px){.logo__image.with-bounds{max-width:350px;}}.share-plus{background-color:#afafaf;}.share-plus:hover{background-color:#aaaaaa;}.share-facebook,.share-fb{background-color:#1777f2;}.share-facebook:hover,.share-fb:hover{background-color:#318bff;}.share-twitter,.share-tw{background-color:#50abf1;}.share-twitter:hover,.share-tw:hover{background-color:#00a8e5;}.share-apple{background-color:#000000;}.share-apple:hover{background-color:#333333;}.share-linkedin{background-color:#0077b5;}.share-linkedin:hover{background:#006da8;}.share-pinterest{background-color:#ce1e1f;}.share-pinterest:hover{background:#bb2020;}.share-googleplus{background-color:#df4a32;}.share-googleplus:hover{background-color:#c73c26;}.share-reddit{background-color:#ff4300;}.share-email{background-color:#5e7286;}.share-email:hover{background:#48596b;}.share-tumblr{background-color:#2c4762;}.share-tumblr:hover{background-color:#243c53;}.share-sms{background-color:#ff922b;}.share-sms:hover{background-color:#fd7e14;}.share-whatsapp{background-color:#4dc247;}.share-instagram{background-color:#3f729b;}.share-instagram:hover{background-color:#4B88B9;}.share-youtube{background-color:#cd201f;}.share-youtube:hover{background-color:#EA2524;}.share-linkedin{background-color:#0077b5;}.share-linkedin:hover{background-color:#005d8e;}.share-slack{background-color:#36C5F0;}.share-slack:hover{background-color:#0077b5;}.share-openid{background-color:#F7931E;}.share-openid:hover{background-color:#E6881C;}.share-st{background-color:#eb4924;}.share-copy-link{background-color:#159397;}.listicle-slideshow__thumbnails{margin:0 -0.5%;overflow:hidden;white-space:nowrap;min-height:115px;}.listicle-slideshow__thumbnail{width:19%;margin:0.5%;display:inline-block;cursor:pointer;}.listicle-slideshow-pager{display:none;}.rm-non-critical-loaded .listicle-slideshow-pager{display:contents;}.rm-top-sticky-flexible{position:fixed;z-index:4;top:0;left:0;width:100%;transform:translate3d(0px,0px,0px);}.rm-top-sticky-stuck{position:relative;}.rm-top-sticky-stuck .rm-top-sticky-floater{position:fixed;z-index:4;top:0;left:0;width:100%;transform:translate3d(0px,-200px,0px);}.rm-top-sticky-stuck.rm-stuck .rm-top-sticky-floater{transform:translate3d(0px,0px,0px);}@layer tokens{:root{--small:4px;--black-500:#111}}@layer themes{:root,.default{--primary-color:var(--black-500)}}@layer utilities{.text-md{font-size:var(--size-10);line-height:var(--size-14);font-weight:var(--font-weight-bold)}}@layer elements{.button{background-color:var(--primary-color)}}@font-face{font-family:'My font';font-weight:200;font-style:normal;font-display:swap;src:url('') format('woff2')}.rblad-ieee_welcome_interstitial{margin-bottom:0;height:0}.rblad-ieee_welcome_interstitial .rbl-ad:before,[id^="google_ads_"]:before{content:none!important}.after_main_article_content{box-sizing:border-box}@media (max-width:727px){.top-leader-container.top-leader-container{min-height:147px}.rbl-ad{display:flex;flex-direction:column;align-items:center;justify-content:center}.rblad-ieee_in_content .rbl-ad,.rblad-ieee_in_content_new .rbl-ad,.rblad-ieee_infinite_new .rbl-ad,.rblad-ieee_infinite_leaderboard .rbl-ad,.rblad-ieee_infinite_leaderboard,.after_main_article_content{min-height:370px;min-width:350px}.feature_post_full + div{min-height:400px;box-sizing:border-box}.rblad-ieee_top_leaderboard .rbl-ad{min-height:180px;min-width:350px}}@media (min-width:1440px){.after_main_article_content,.rblad-ieee_infinite_new,.rblad-ieee_in_content,.feature_post_full + div,.article_column .rbl-ad,.rblad-ieee_infinite_leaderboard,.rblad-ieee_infinite_leaderboard .rbl-ad{box-sizing:border-box;display:flex;flex-direction:column;justify-content:center;align-items:center;min-width:790px}.after_main_article_content{min-height:320px}.rblad-ieee_infinite_new{min-height:125px}.rblad-ieee_in_content{min-height:384px}.feature_post_full + div{min-height:344px}.article_column .rbl-ad{min-height:320px}.rblad-ieee_infinite_leaderboard,.rblad-ieee_infinite_leaderboard .rbl-ad{min-height:280px;min-width:970px}.rblad-ieee_top_leaderboard .rbl-ad{min-height:120px}.top-leader-container.top-leader-container,.rblad-ieee_top_leaderboard.rblad-ieee_top_leaderboard{min-width:970px}}.sidebar_repeat_ad.sidebar_repeat_ad{margin-top:0}.sidebar_repeat_ad.sidebar_repeat_ad{justify-content:flex-start}.rbl-ad{width:100%}.sidebar_repeat_ad .rbl-ad-gpt>div{text-align:left!important}.rblad-ieee_in_content{padding-top:20px;padding-bottom:40px;border-top:1px solid lightgray;border-bottom:1px solid lightgray;display:flex;justify-content:center;clear:both}.ad-in-content.ad-in-content{border:0}.osano-cm-list__list-item.osano-cm-list__list-item{padding:0}.osano-cm-dialog.osano-cm-dialog{background-color:#1A1A1A;color:#BFBFBF;padding:44px 20px 24px 20px;font-size:18px;line-height:28px;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif}.osano-cm-info,.osano-cm-info-views{background:#1A1A1A;color:#BFBFBF;font-size:18px;line-height:28px;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;box-shadow:unset}.osano-cm-header,.osano-cm-info-dialog-header{background:#1A1A1A;font-size:20px;color:#fff}.osano-cm-link.osano-cm-link{color:#f2f2f2}.osano-cm-close.osano-cm-close{color:#efefef;stroke:#efefef}.osano-cm-close:hover,.osano-cm-close:focus{background-color:#1a1a1a;border-color:#1a1a1a;color:#fff;stroke:#fff;outline:none}.osano-cm-link:focus{color:unset}.osano-cm-buttons button.osano-cm-manage{border-radius:4px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;padding:8px 12px 5px;text-transform:uppercase;line-height:1.4;background-color:#ff4c00;color:white;border:none;margin-top:12px}.osano-cm-buttons button:hover,.osano-cm-buttons button:active{background-color:#A32700;color:#ffffff}.osano-cm-close{stroke-width:1px;border-radius:50%;border-style:solid;border-width:2px;box-sizing:initial;cursor:pointer;height:20px;line-height:normal;margin:16px;min-height:20px;min-width:20px;order:0;outline:none;overflow:hidden;padding:0;text-decoration:none;transition-timing-function:ease-out;width:20px;z-index:2}.osano-cm-link.osano-cm-link{cursor:pointer;text-decoration:none;transition-duration:0.2s;transition-property:color;transition-timing-function:ease-out}.osano-cm-link:hover,.osano-cm-link:active{cursor:pointer;text-decoration:none;color:#FF4C00}.osano-cm-close:focus,.osano-cm-close:hover{stroke-width:2px;transform:unset}.osano-cm-link:focus{font-weight:normal}.osano-cm-toggle__switch.osano-cm-toggle__switch{background-color:#b8b8b8}.osano-cm-toggle__input:checked + .osano-cm-toggle__switch{background-color:#ff4c00;border-color:#ff4c00}.osano-cm-toggle__input:checked:focus + .osano-cm-toggle__switch,.osano-cm-toggle__input:checked:hover + .osano-cm-toggle__switch{background-color:#ff4c00;border-color:#ff4c00}.osano-cm-toggle__input:disabled:checked + .osano-cm-toggle__switch,.osano-cm-toggle__input:disabled:checked:focus + .osano-cm-toggle__switch,.osano-cm-toggle__input:disabled:checked:hover + .osano-cm-toggle__switch{background-color:#ff4c00;border-color:#ff4c00;opacity:0.5}.osano-cm-button.osano-cm-button{background-color:#ff4b00;border:1px solid #ff4b00;color:#ffffff;border-radius:4px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;padding:8px 12px 5px;text-transform:uppercase;line-height:normal;margin-right:8px}.osano-cm-button:hover{background-color:#A32700;border:1px solid #A32700}.osano-cm-disclosure__toggle,.osano-cm-expansion-panel__toggle{color:#f2f2f2;cursor:pointer}.osano-cm-drawer-toggle .osano-cm-label{font-size:18px;line-height:1.375em;margin:0 auto 0 0;font-weight:normal;color:white;font-family:"Favorit-Pro"}.osano-cm-disclosure__toggle:focus,.osano-cm-expansion-panel__toggle:focus{color:#ff4b00}.osano-cm-disclosure__toggle:hover,.osano-cm-disclosure__toggle:active,.osano-cm-expansion-panel__toggle:hover,.osano-cm-expansion-panel__toggle:active{color:#ff4b00}.osano-cm-disclosure--collapse{border-bottom:1px solid #4a4a4a;padding-bottom:1em}.osano-cm-widget{display:none}.osano-cm-disclosure__toggle:focus,.osano-cm-disclosure__toggle:hover{text-decoration:none}.osano-cm-dialog--type_bar .osano-cm-button.osano-cm-button{flex:none;margin:0.125em auto;width:80%}@media screen and (min-width:768px){.osano-cm-dialog.osano-cm-dialog{padding:32px 32px 32px 32px}.osano-cm-dialog--type_bar .osano-cm-button.osano-cm-button{flex:0.3 0.5 70%;margin:0.25em 0.5em;width:auto}}.osano-cm-save{width:40%;float:right;margin:0 16px 24px 0}.osano-cm-powered-by{clear:both;margin-bottom:0}@font-face{font-family:'Favorit-Mono';font-weight:300;font-style:normal;font-display:swap;src:url('https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/FavoritMono/ABCFavoritMono-Light.woff2') format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'Favorit-Mono';font-weight:400;font-style:normal;font-display:swap;src:url('https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/FavoritMono/ABCFavoritMono-Regular.woff2') format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'Favorit-Pro-Light';font-weight:300;font-style:normal;font-display:swap;src:url('https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/ABCFavoritProFullWeb/ABCFavoritPro-Light.woff2') format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'Favorit-Pro';font-weight:700;font-style:normal;font-display:swap;src:url('https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/ABCFavoritProFullWeb/ABCFavoritPro-Bold.woff2') format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'Ivar-Headline';font-weight:400;font-style:normal;font-display:swap;src:url('https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/IvarCompleteWeb/IvarHeadline-Regular.woff2') format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'Favorit-Pro';font-weight:400;font-style:normal;font-display:swap;src:url('https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/ABCFavoritProFullWeb/ABCFavoritPro-Regular.woff2') format('woff2')}@font-face{font-family:'Ivar-Headline-Bold';font-weight:400;font-style:normal;font-display:swap;src:url('https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/IvarCompleteWeb/IvarHeadline-Bold.woff2') format('woff2')}:root{--terciary-color:#c33a00;--terciary-background-color:#d64000}.posts-custom .widget__headline{font-weight:unset}p.ieee-inbody-related{font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-weight:bold;text-align:center;text-transform:uppercase;padding:16px 0}p.ieee-inbody-related a{text-transform:none}.homepage-logo{display:inline;font-size:1.6rem}.lightbox--shown.lightbox--shown .image-media.media-caption,.lightbox--shown.lightbox--shown .image-media.media-photo-credit{display:none}.headline__h1{font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif;font-size:42px;line-height:44px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:-0.5px;padding:16px 16px 0px 16px;margin:0}body>#myframe{position:absolute}.widget.tag-type-webinar .widget__headline-text,.widget.tag-type-whitepaper .widget__headline-text{text-transform:capitalize}@media (min-width:1568px){.main{border-left:1px solid #bdbdbd;border-right:1px solid #bdbdbd}}[id^="google_ads_"]{margin:0 auto!important}[id^="google_ads_"]:before{content:"Advertisement";text-transform:uppercase;display:block;font-size:10px;color:#595959;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;padding-bottom:0px;letter-spacing:1px}.stick_in_parent{top:40px!important}.sidebar_repeat_ad{align-items:flex-start!important}.ad-in-content{padding-top:40px;padding-bottom:40px;border-top:1px solid lightgray;border-bottom:1px solid lightgray;display:flex;justify-content:center}.content{width:auto;max-width:none}.search__close{float:right;position:relative;right:30px;padding-top:3px}.search__close:before,.search__close:after{position:absolute;left:14px;content:" ";height:25px;border-left:2px solid}.search__close:before{transform:rotate(45deg)}.search__close:after{transform:rotate(-45deg)}.search-form{position:relative;right:0;margin-left:20px}.search-form__open{font-size:16px;line-height:53px;height:53px;width:53px;text-align:center;bottom:0}.search-form .search-form__submit{position:absolute;display:block;margin-left:3px;top:0;height:32px;z-index:1}.show-search .search-form__submit{color:#fff;position:absolute;right:0;padding:17px;top:0;display:initial}.topbar_sticky{margin:0}.topbar_sticky .sticky-target.sticky-active{z-index:2;width:100%;top:0}@media (max-width:767px){.menu-opened .menu-global{margin-top:53px}.menu-opened .rebelbar__menu-toggle .fa-bars:before{content:"\f00d"}.cta-member__right-column{margin-top:18px;margin-left:16px}}@media (min-width:768px){.container{box-sizing:border-box;padding:0 30px;margin:0 auto}.scrolled .rebelbar .container{padding:15px 30px 10px!important}.welcome-ad-cont{margin-bottom:32px}}#sidebar_1 div{padding:16px}.arrow-link,.custom-field-PodcastTime{display:none}.menu-global{display:none!important}.infinite-scroll-wrapper:not(.rm-loading){margin:0}.main,.all-content-wrapper{background-color:#ecece9;overflow:inherit}body:not(.section-podcast,.section-podcasts,.section-video,.section-chatbot,.section-fixing-the-future){background:#ecece9}.popup_links .list .list__item:nth-child(1){background:var(--terciary-color);border:1px solid var(--terciary-color)}.popup_links .list .list__item:nth-child(2){border:1px solid #595959!important;margin-left:15px}.popup_links .list .list__item:nth-child(1):hover{background:var(--terciary-background-color)}.popup_links .list .list__item:nth-child(2):hover{border:1px solid #bfbfbf!important}.articles-count{margin:0}.posts-custom .social-date,.posts-custom .time-to-read,.updated_post .social-date-modified,.posts-custom .custom-field-TimeofRead{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase;display:inline-block;padding-right:9px;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.5px;line-height:16px;margin:0;vertical-align:middle}.posts-custom .social-date,.posts-custom .time-to-read,.article_post.updated_post .social-date-modified,.posts-custom .custom-field-TimeofRead{color:#404040}.posts-custom .time-to-read,.posts-custom .custom-field-TimeofRead{border-left:1px solid #a6a6a6;padding-left:7px}.story_teaser .widget .row .col{margin:0}.story_teaser .widget{padding-bottom:20px}.story_teaser.infinite .widget{border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf;margin:0;padding:16px 6px}.story_teaser.not_infinite .widget:not(:last-child){border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf;margin-bottom:0px}.dark_layout .story_teaser.infinite .widget{border-bottom:1px solid #404040}.widget .widget__headline-text,.widget .widget__subheadline-text{text-decoration:underline;text-decoration-color:transparent;text-decoration-thickness:1px;text-underline-offset:3px;transition-duration:300ms;transition-property:text-decoration-color}.featured_post .widget .widget__headline-text,.featured_post .widget .widget__subheadline-text,.fullwidth_post .widget .widget__headline-text,.fullwidth_post .widget .widget__subheadline-text,.story_teaser .widget .widget__headline-text,.story_teaser .widget .widget__subheadline-text{text-underline-offset:5px}.widget .widget__subheadline-text{font-weight:normal}.widget .widget__headline:hover .widget__headline-text,.widget .widget__headline:hover + .widget__subheadline .widget__subheadline-text{text-decoration-color:var(--terciary-color);color:inherit}.widget:hover .widget__headline a{color:inherit}.current_post .widget .widget__headline-text,.current_post .widget .widget__subheadline-text,.feature_post_full .widget .widget__subheadline-text{text-decoration:none}.icon-close:before,.icon-close:after{position:absolute;left:14px;content:" ";height:29px;border-left:2px solid;color:#f2f2f2}.icon-close:before{transform:rotate(45deg)}.icon-close:after{transform:rotate(-45deg)}.footer{color:#8c8c8c}.dark_top_bar,.footer{background-color:#0d0d0d}.rebelbar-wrapper_static,.rebelbar-wrapper{background:#ecece9;border-bottom:1px solid #bdbdbd}.rebelbar-wrapper div .text-element:nth-child(2){color:#0d0d0d}.rebel-use-info-wrapper button{width:24px;height:24px;border-radius:40px;border:none;display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;background-size:105%}.rebel-user-info{display:inline-block}.menu-item__title{font-family:Favorit-Pro,sans-serif;font-size:18px;margin-right:16px;letter-spacing:-0.011111111111111112em;white-space:nowrap;line-height:32px;border:none;padding:0;background:transparent}.menu-item__title:before,.topbar-sticky .rebelbar__menu-toggle:before{content:"";display:inline-block;vertical-align:bottom;border-left:1px solid #d9d9d9;height:32px;margin-right:16px}.dark_layout .menu-item__title:before,.dark_layout .topbar-sticky .rebelbar__menu-toggle:before{border-left:1px solid #404040}.menu-item__title:after{content:"";margin-left:8px;vertical-align:middle;display:inline-block;width:13px;height:10px;transition:all 0.3s ease;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:100% auto}.menu-item:hover .menu-item__title:after{transform:rotate(180deg);position:relative;top:-2px}.menu-item{cursor:pointer}.menu-dropdown:before{content:"TOPICS";color:#737373;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;padding-top:19px;display:block}.menu-dropdown{padding:0 16px;background:#fff;box-sizing:border-box;position:absolute;z-index:2;box-shadow:0 5px 5px #00000017;min-width:231px;transition:all 0.2s ease-out;max-height:0;overflow:hidden}.menu-dropdown .list{padding-bottom:10px}.menu-dropdown .list__item{color:#0d0d0d}.menu-dropdown .list__item:before{content:"";background:var(--terciary-color);vertical-align:baseline;width:0;height:0;border-radius:50%;display:inline-block;transition:all 200ms ease}.menu-dropdown .list__item.active:before,.menu-dropdown .list__item:hover:before{transition:all 200ms ease;width:13px;height:13px;margin-right:5px}.menu-item:hover .menu-dropdown,.menu-item__title.keyboard-hover ~ .menu-dropdown{max-height:471px}.menu-item__title:focus{outline:5px auto #2684b1}.Top_hugeMenu .rebelbar__menu-toggle{border:none!important;position:relative;float:right;width:22px;height:48px;background:transparent;padding:0;display:flex;align-items:center}.notification-counter{background:#fa8;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;padding:0px 8px;border-radius:40px;font-size:12px;padding-top:3px;float:left;margin-top:3px;height:16px;line-height:16px}.user-info__dropdown-wrapper{display:none;right:32px;top:40px;width:224px;box-sizing:border-box;padding:24px 16px 12px;z-index:100;background:#fff;position:absolute;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-size:18px;letter-spacing:-0.011111111111111112em;line-height:22px;text-transform:capitalize}.user-menu-container:hover .user-info__dropdown-wrapper{display:block}.user-info__dropdown{padding:0;margin:0;display:none}.user-info__dropdown-wrapper .user-info__dropdown{display:block}.user-info__dropdown li,.member-link{padding-bottom:12px;list-style:none}.member-link{display:block}.user-info__dropdown li a,.member-link{color:#0d0d0d}.dark_layout .member-link{color:#d9d9d9}.user-info__dropdown .title strong{font-weight:400}.user-info__dropdown .title a:first-child{cursor:text}.river-notification{border-bottom:1px solid #e6e6e6;padding-bottom:16px;padding-top:2px}.river-notification .content-wrp .date,.river-notification .aside{display:none}.river-notification .content-wrp{font-size:14px;letter-spacing:-0.014285714285714287em;line-height:18px}.is_unread .title:before{content:"\f111";font-family:"FontAwesome";color:#ffaa88;padding-right:8px;font-size:11px;vertical-align:text-top}.river-notification .content-wrp a{font-weight:bold}.user-info__dropdown .profile_link:hover:before{content:"\f111";font-family:"FontAwesome";color:var(--terciary-color);padding-right:5px;float:left}#user_avatar{border-radius:50%;max-width:24px}#user_name{display:inline-block;color:white;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:initial;font-size:14px;color:#bfbfbf;padding:0 10px;margin-top:6px;vertical-align:middle}@media (max-width:767px){#user_name{margin-top:0}}.toggle-user-dropdown:after{content:"";box-sizing:border-box;height:8px;width:8px;border:1px solid #bfbfbf;border-bottom:0;border-right:0;transform:scaleX(-1) rotate(-135deg);margin-top:-4px;margin-left:9px;vertical-align:super;display:inline-block}.user-menu-container{display:inline-block;padding:2px 0px;vertical-align:middle}.toggle-user-dropdown{position:relative;top:6px}.user-info__dropdown .mark-all-as-read{text-align:right;font-size:9px;line-height:16px;cursor:pointer;border-top:1px solid #e6e6e6;margin-top:12px;padding:18px 0 21px;text-transform:lowercase;position:relative}.user-info__dropdown .mark-all-as-read:before{content:"NOTIFICATIONS";float:left;font-size:12px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:0.0625em;color:#737373;cursor:initial;position:absolute;left:0;top:18px}.user-info__dropdown-wrapper .notification-counter{float:right;position:relative;top:26px;cursor:text;z-index:1}.user-info__dropdown-wrapper .notification-counter:not(.hidden) + .user-info__dropdown .mark-all-as-read{padding-top:35px;padding-bottom:7px}.user-info__dropdown .title{margin:0}.user-menu-container:hover .toggle-user-dropdown:after{margin-top:0;transform:scaleX(1) rotate(45deg);position:relative;top:4px}.user-menu-container:hover>.rebel-use-info-wrapper .user-info__dropdown{display:block}.rebelbar__menu-toggle svg g g{fill:#0d0d0d}.dark_layout .rebelbar__menu-toggle svg g g{fill:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout .mobile_search_icon path{stroke:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout #mobile_search_icon svg g g,.dark_layout #search_modal svg g g{stroke:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout .search__close:before,.dark_layout .search__close:after{color:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout .user-info__dropdown-wrapper{background:#404040}.dark_layout .user-info__dropdown-wrapper a,.dark_layout .user-info__dropdown{color:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout .river-notification{border-bottom:1px solid #595959}.rebelbar__menu-toggle{min-width:32px;line-height:32px;white-space:nowrap;padding:0;border:none;background:#ecece8}.rebelbar__menu-toggle:focus{outline:5px auto #2684b1}.rebelbar__menu-toggle svg{margin-top:-4px}.dark_layout .site_logo svg g{fill:#f2f2f2}.dark_layout .site_logo .text-element{color:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout .search-form .search-form__submit svg g{stroke:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout,.dark_layout .rebelbar-wrapper,.dark_layout .rebelbar-wrapper_static{background:#1a1a1a;border-bottom:1px solid #404040}.dark_layout .dark_top_bar{background-color:#262626;border-bottom:1px solid #404040}.dark_layout .menu-dropdown{background:#404040}.dark_layout .rebelbar-wrapper div .text-element:nth-child(2),.dark_layout .list__item{color:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout .fa-search:before,.dark_layout .module-headline__text,.dark_layout .rebelbar-wrapper .text-element{color:#f2f2f2}.dark_layout .menu-item__title{color:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout .search-form__text-input{background:#404040;color:#f2f2f2}.bottom_menu_links .list__item:not(:last-child){border-right:1px solid #404040;padding:0px 7.5px}.bottom_menu_links .list__item:first-child{padding-left:0px;padding-right:15.5px}.js-hidden-panel.active + .featured_columns .sticky_column{top:0px!important}.js-hidden-panel:not(.active) ~ .featured_columns .sticky_column{top:135px!important}.js-hidden-panel:not(.active) ~ .featured_columns .sticky_column .container_head_sticky{top:115px!important}#mobile_search_icon.fa-search:before{padding-right:15px;vertical-align:sub}#search_modal{position:absolute;top:106px;left:0;width:100%;z-index:999;background:#ecece9;border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf;padding:16px;box-sizing:border-box}#search_modal.on-search-page{position:static;margin-bottom:0}.dark_layout #search_modal{border-bottom:1px solid #404040;background:#1a1a1a}#search_mobile{font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;height:30px;width:72%;border-radius:5px;border:0;padding:0 10px}.dark_layout #search_mobile{background:#404040}#search_form button{background:transparent;border:0;vertical-align:middle;padding-left:20px}.search-form__text-input{position:initial;background:white;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;color:#0d0d0d;height:32px;width:130px;border-radius:4px;display:inline-block;font-size:16px;padding:2px 20px 0 30px;box-sizing:border-box}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .search-form__text-input{position:static}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .video-row .story_teaser .widget__headline,_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .video-row .widget__subheadline,_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .video-row .popular_widget .widget__headline{color:rgba(255,76,0,1)!important}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .video-row .story_teaser .widget__headline a.widget__headline-text{text-decoration:none;color:white!important}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .video-row .story_teaser .widget__subheadline .widget__subheadline-text{text-decoration:none;color:#999999!important}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .video-row .popular_widget .widget__headline .widget__headline-text{text-decoration:none;color:white!important}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .video-row .story_teaser .widget__body:hover .widget__headline,_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .video-row .widget__body:hover .widget__subheadline,_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .video-row .popular_widget .widget__headline:hover{text-decoration:underline}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .story_teaser .widget__subheadline,_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .story_teaser .widget__headline{color:rgba(255,76,0,1)!important}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .story_teaser .widget__headline a.widget__headline-text{text-decoration:none;color:#0d0d0d!important}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .story_teaser .widget__subheadline .widget__subheadline-text{text-decoration:none;color:#595959!important}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .story_teaser .widget__body:hover .widget__headline,_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .story_teaser .widget__body:hover .widget__subheadline{text-decoration:underline}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .fullwidth_post .widget__headline.h1,_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .widget__subheadline{display:inline}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .featured_columns .bigger-teaser-headline .widget__headline.h1,_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .featured_columns .bigger-teaser-headline .widget__subheadline{display:inline}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .menu-opened .huge-menu{display:block}@media screen and (min-width:1024px){_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .section-the-next-pandemic .story_teaser .widget .widget__head{width:32.5%}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .section-the-next-pandemic .story_teaser .widget .widget__body{width:66.5%}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .section-the-institute .story_teaser .widget .col:first-child{width:34.7%!important}_:-ms-fullscreen,:root .section-the-institute .story_teaser .widget .col:last-child{width:63.3%!important}}.search-form__text-input:active,.search-form__text-input:focus{border:1px solid var(--terciary-color);color:#0d0d0d;caret-color:#0a7aff}.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:active,.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:focus{background:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:active + .search-form__submit svg g,.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:focus + .search-form__submit svg g{stroke:#0d0d0d}.search-form__text-input::placeholder,.search-form__text-input:-ms-input-placeholder,.search-form__text-input::-ms-input-placeholder,.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:active::placeholder,.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:focus::placeholder,.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:active:-ms-input-placeholder,.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:focus::-ms-input-placeholder,.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:active:-ms-input-placeholder,.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:focus::-ms-input-placeholder{color:#8c8c8c}.dark_layout .search-form__text-input::placeholder,.dark_layout .search-form__text-input:-ms-input-placeholder,.dark_layout .search-form__text-input::-ms-input-placeholder{color:#bfbfbf}.widget_column .sticky-target.legacy.sticky-active{top:0px;z-index:0}.featured_columns .row{overflow:inherit;margin:0!important}.featured_columns .row .home_column .story_teaser .widget{padding:24px 32px 24px 22px}.featured_columns .row .home_column,.featured_columns .row .sticky_column,.featured_columns .row .scroll_column,.featured_columns .row .widget_column{padding:0!important}.featured_columns .row .section_column{padding:0px 0px 20px!important}.widget_column .sticky-target.legacy.sticky-active{width:calc(100% - 75%);top:0px;z-index:0}.featured_columns .row .scroll_column{float:right}.featured_columns .widget .row .col{margin-bottom:0}.scroll_column .row .col{margin-bottom:20px}.scroll_column .widget .widget__headline-text{color:#0d0d0d;font-family:Favorit-Pro,sans-serif;font-size:24px;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:-0.2px;line-height:26px}.scroll_column .widget:hover .widget__headline a{color:#0d0d0d}@media (min-width:992px) and (max-width:1023px){.widget_column.col.l3{width:25%}.article_column.col.l9,.section_column.col.l9{width:75%}}.like-button{display:inline-block;margin:0;margin-top:-4px;line-height:normal;font-size:18px;vertical-align:middle}.like-label{display:none}.like-btn.like,.like-btn.unlike{color:#a6a6a6;border-left:1px solid;padding-left:4px;font-size:14px}.fa-heart:before,.fa-heart-o:before{visibility:hidden}.like-btn.like .heart{background-repeat:no-repeat;background-position:bottom;cursor:pointer;background-position:center 0.23em}.like-btn.unlike .heart,.like-btn.like .heart:active,.dark_layout .like-btn.like .heart:active,.widget.tag-type-podcast .like-btn.like .heart:active{background-repeat:no-repeat;background-position:center 0.23em}.dark_layout .like-btn.like .heart,.widget.tag-type-podcast .like-btn.like .heart{background-position:center 0.25em}.all-related-sections{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap}.all-related-sections a{display:none}.all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{display:inline;padding:1px 8px 5px 8px;margin-right:7px;border:1px solid transparent;border-left:1px solid #bfbfbf;border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;line-height:1;letter-spacing:0.0625em;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;margin-bottom:10px;transition-duration:200ms;transition-property:all;color:var(--terciary-color)}.social-author__bio a{color:var(--terciary-color)}.popular_widget .all-related-sections a,.trending_stories_carousel .all-related-sections a{color:#ff4c00}.all-related-sections a[href$="/topic/"],.all-related-sections a[href$="/type/"],.all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"]:not([href$="/topic/"]) ~ [href*="/topic/"]{display:none}.all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{color:#404040;order:1}.all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]:hover{background-color:#d9d9d9;border:1px solid #d9d9d9;box-shadow:0px -4px 0px #d9d9d9;color:#404040}.popular_widget .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{color:#bfbfbf;order:1}.popular_widget .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]:hover{background-color:#d9d9d9;border:1px solid #d9d9d9;box-shadow:0px -4px 0px #d9d9d9;color:#bfbfbf}.all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"]{order:2}.FillDark .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"],.dark_layout .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"],.trending_stories_carousel .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{color:#bfbfbf}.FillDark .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.FillDark .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"],.dark_layout .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.dark_layout .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"],.trending_stories_carousel .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.trending_stories_carousel .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border-left:1px solid #404040;border-bottom:1px solid #404040}.FillDark .time-to-read,.FillDark .like-btn.like,.FillDark .like-btn.unlike,.trending_stories_carousel .like-btn.like,.trending_stories_carousel .like-btn.unlike{border-left:1px solid #404040}.FillDark .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]:hover,.dark_layout .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]:hover,.trending_stories_carousel .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]:hover{background-color:#404040;border:1px solid #404040;box-shadow:0px -4px 0px #404040}.all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"]:hover{border:1px solid var(--terciary-color);background-color:var(--terciary-color);box-shadow:0px -4px 0px var(--terciary-color);color:white}.all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/the-institute"]{color:#005690}.all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/the-institute"]:hover{border:1px solid #005690;background-color:#005690;color:white!important;box-shadow:0 -4px 0 #005690}.widget.tag-type-ti .widget__headline:hover .widget__headline-text,.widget.tag-type-ti .widget__headline:hover + .widget__subheadline .widget__subheadline-text{text-decoration-color:#005690}@media (min-width:1024px){.all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{margin-bottom:10px}}.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline-text:before,.featured_post .widget__subheadline-text:before,.article_post .widget__subheadline-text:before,.story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text:before{content:"";display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-position:center;background-size:100% auto;margin-left:4px;margin-right:5px;height:1em;width:8px;width:0.25em;margin-top:-0.1em}.fullwidth_post{margin-bottom:0}.fullwidth_post .widget .row{margin:0}.fullwidth_post .widget .row .col{padding:0;margin-bottom:10px}.fullwidth_post .widget__body{max-width:50%;position:absolute;bottom:0;padding:32px;margin:32px 32px 20px 32px;height:fit-content;z-index:1}.fullwidth_post.TopLeft .widget__body{top:0;left:0}.fullwidth_post.TopRight .widget__body{top:0;right:0}.fullwidth_post.BottomLeft .widget__body{bottom:0;left:0}.fullwidth_post.BottomRight .widget__body{bottom:0;right:0}.fullwidth_post .widget__head .widget__body{max-width:100%;margin:0;height:auto;background:transparent!important;border:0!important}.fullwidth_post .widget__body{border:1px solid rgba(242,242,242,0.4)}.fullwidth_post .widget:after{content:"";position:absolute;top:25%;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;background:linear-gradient(180deg,rgba(13,13,13,0) 0%,#0d0d0d 100%)}.fullwidth_post .social-date,.fullwidth_post .time-to-read,.fullwidth_post .widget .widget__subheadline{color:#bfbfbf}.fullwidth_post:not(.FillDark,.FillLight) .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"],.fullwidth_post:not(.FillDark,.FillLight) .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"]{color:#bfbfbf;border:solid rgba(191,191,191,0.4);border-width:0 0 1px 1px}.fullwidth_post:not(.FillDark,.FillLight) .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]:hover,.fullwidth_post:not(.FillDark,.FillLight) .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"]:hover{border-color:#f2f2f2;background:transparent;box-shadow:none}.fullwidth_post .widget .widget__headline{color:#f2f2f2}.fullwidth_post:not(.FillDark,.FillLight) .widget__headline:hover .widget__headline-text,.fullwidth_post:not(.FillDark,.FillLight) .widget__headline:hover + .widget__subheadline .widget__subheadline-text{text-decoration-color:#f2f2f2}.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent{border-color:#bfbfbf}.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .social-date,.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .time-to-read,.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"],.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"]{color:#404040}.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .widget .widget__headline,.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .widget:hover .widget__headline{color:#0d0d0d}.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .widget__subheadline{color:#595959}.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"],.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"]{border-left:1px solid rgba(64,64,64,0.4);border-bottom:1px solid rgba(64,64,64,0.4)}.fullwidth_post.FillDark .widget__body{background:#1a1a1a;border:0}.fullwidth_post.FillDark .widget:after{background:none}.fullwidth_post.FillDark .social-date,.fullwidth_post.FillDark .time-to-read,.fullwidth_post.FillDark .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{color:#a6a6a6}.fullwidth_post.FillDark .widget .widget__headline,.fullwidth_post.FillDark .widget:hover .widget__headline{color:#f2f2f2}.fullwidth_post.FillDark .widget .widget__subheadline{color:#8c8c8c}.fullwidth_post.FillLight .widget__body{background:#ecece9;border:0}.fullwidth_post.FillLight .widget:after{background:none}.fullwidth_post.FillLight .social-date,.fullwidth_post.FillLight .time-to-read,.fullwidth_post.FillLight .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{color:#404040}.fullwidth_post.FillLight .widget .widget__headline,.fullwidth_post.FillLight .widget:hover .widget__headline{color:#0d0d0d}.fullwidth_post.FillLight .widget__subheadline{color:#595959}.fullwidth_post.Transparent .widget:after{background:none}.fullwidth_post.DarkBottom .widget:after{background:linear-gradient(180deg,rgba(13,13,13,0) 0%,#0d0d0d 100%)}.fullwidth_post.DarkTop .widget:after{background:linear-gradient(0deg,rgba(13,13,13,0) 0%,#0d0d0d 100%);top:0;bottom:25%}.fullwidth_post.DarkLeft .widget:after{background:linear-gradient(270deg,rgba(13,13,13,0) 0%,#0d0d0d 100%);top:0;right:25%}.fullwidth_post.DarkRight .widget:after{background:linear-gradient(90deg,rgba(13,13,13,0) 0%,#0d0d0d 100%);top:0;left:25%;right:0}.fullwidth_post.LightBottom .widget:after{background:linear-gradient(180deg,rgba(236,236,233,0) 0%,#ecece9 100%)}.fullwidth_post.LightTop .widget:after{background:linear-gradient(0deg,rgba(236,236,233,0) 0%,#ecece9 100%);top:0;bottom:25%}.fullwidth_post.LightLeft .widget:after{background:linear-gradient(270deg,rgba(236,236,233,0) 0%,#ecece9 100%);top:0;right:25%}.fullwidth_post.LightRight .widget:after{background:linear-gradient(90deg,rgba(236,236,233,0) 0%,#ecece9 100%);top:0;left:25%;right:0}@media (max-width:1023px){.fullwidth_post.mb-2:not(.Transparent,.FillLight,.FillDark) .widget:after{background:linear-gradient(180deg,rgba(13,13,13,0) 0%,#0d0d0d 100%);top:20%;bottom:0;left:0;right:0}.fullwidth_post.LightBottom .widget:after,.fullwidth_post.LightTop .widget:after,.fullwidth_post.LightLeft .widget:after,.fullwidth_post.LightRight .widget:after{background:linear-gradient(180deg,rgba(236,236,233,0) 0%,#ecece9 100%)}.fullwidth_post.mb-2:not(.Transparent,.FillLight,.FillDark){padding-bottom:20%;background:#0d0d0d}.fullwidth_post.LightBottom,.fullwidth_post.LightTop,.fullwidth_post.LightLeft,.fullwidth_post.LightRight{background:#ecece9}.fullwidth_post .widget__body{max-width:100%}.fullwidth_post .widget .widget__body{padding:16px;margin:16px;top:auto;left:0;right:0;bottom:0}.fullwidth_post:not(.Transparent,.FillLight,.FillDark) .widget .widget__body{bottom:-20vw}}.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline:before{content:""}.article_post .widget__headline-text,.article_post .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:24px;letter-spacing:-0.010416666666666666em;line-height:24px}.fullwidth_post .widget__headline,.featured_post .widget__headline-text,.article_post .widget__headline-text{font-family:Ivar-Headline-Bold,serif}.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline-text,.featured_post .widget__subheadline-text,.article_post .widget__subheadline-text{font-family:Ivar-Headline,serif}.fullwidth_post .widget__headline,.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline-text,.featured_post .widget__headline-text,.featured_post .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:32px;letter-spacing:-0.2px;line-height:32px}@media (min-width:768px){.article_post .widget__headline-text,.article_post .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:32px;letter-spacing:-0.0046875em;line-height:32px}.fullwidth_post .widget__headline,.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline-text,.featured_post .widget__headline-text,.featured_post .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:42px;line-height:42px}}@media (min-width:1024px){.fullwidth_post .widget__headline,.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline-text,.featured_post .widget__headline-text,.featured_post .widget__subheadline-text,.article_post .widget__headline-text,.article_post .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:48px;letter-spacing:-0.25px;line-height:48px}.dark_layout .article_post .widget__headline-text,.dark_layout .article_post .widget__subheadline-text{letter-spacing:-1.25px}.listicle-slideshow .rebellt-item-media-container>img.rm-shortcode,.rebellt-item-media-container .share-tab-img>img,.rebellt-item-media-container .product-image-container>img{width:auto}}.dark_layout .article_post .widget__headline-text{font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif}.dark_layout .article_post .widget__subheadline-text{font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif}.featured_post .widget__headline,.fullwidth_post .widget__headline,.article_post .widget__headline,.story_teaser .widget__headline{display:contents}.featured_post .widget__headline:before,.article_post .widget__headline:before,.fullwidth_post .widget__headline:before,.story_teaser .widget__headline:before{content:"";display:block;margin:8px}.featured_post .widget__subheadline:after,.article_post .widget__subheadline:after,.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline:after,.story_teaser .widget__subheadline:after{content:"";display:block;margin:5px}.individual_podcast .widget__subheadline:after{margin-bottom:16px}.fullwidth_post.BorderLight .widget:hover .widget__headline a,.fullwidth_post.FillDark .widget:hover .widget__headline a,.fullwidth_post.BorderLight .widget .widget__headline a,.fullwidth_post.FillDark .widget .widget__headline a{color:#f2f2f2}.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline,.featured_post .widget__subheadline,.article_post .widget__subheadline,.story_teaser .widget__subheadline{color:#595959;display:contents}.fullwidth_post.BorderLight .widget__subheadline,.fullwidth_post.BorderLight .widget__subheadline:before{color:#bdbdbd}.story_teaser .widget__body,.story_teaser .widget__headline-text,.story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:24px;letter-spacing:-0.15px;line-height:26px}.story_teaser .widget__headline-text{font-family:Ivar-Headline-Bold,serif}.story_teaser .widget__subheadline{font-family:Ivar-Headline,serif}@media (min-width:768px){.story_teaser .widget__body,.story_teaser .widget__headline-text,.story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:32px;line-height:32px}}@media (min-width:1024px) and (max-width:1151px){.story_teaser .widget__body,.story_teaser .widget__headline-text,.story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:42px;line-height:42px;letter-spacing:-0.2px}.section_column:not(.bigger-teaser-headline) .story_teaser .widget__body,.section_column:not(.bigger-teaser-headline) .story_teaser .widget__headline-text,.section_column:not(.bigger-teaser-headline) .story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:28px;line-height:28px}}@media (min-width:1151px){.story_teaser .widget__body,.story_teaser .widget__headline-text,.story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:42px;line-height:42px;letter-spacing:-0.2px}.section_column:not(.bigger-teaser-headline) .story_teaser .widget__body,.section_column:not(.bigger-teaser-headline) .story_teaser .widget__headline-text,.section_column:not(.bigger-teaser-headline) .story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:36px;line-height:36px;letter-spacing:-0.004722222222222222em}}.fullwidth_post.BorderDark .widget:hover .widget__headline a,.fullwidth_post.FillLight .widget:hover .widget__headline a,.post-custom .widget:hover .widget__headline a,.featured_post .widget:hover .widget__headline a,.featured_post .widget__body:hover .widget__headline a,.article_post .widget:hover .widget__headline a,.article_post .widget__body:hover .widget__headline a,.story_teaser .widget:hover .widget__headline a,.story_teaser .widget__body:hover .widget__headline a{color:#0d0d0d}.dark_layout .article_post .widget:hover .widget__headline a,.dark_layout .article_post .widget__body:hover .widget__headline a{color:#e6e6e6}a[rel="orange_button"],.mktoForm.mktoHasWidth.mktoLayoutLeft .mktoButtonRow .mktoButtonWrap.mktoSkip .mktoButton{border-radius:4px;background-color:var(--terciary-background-color);color:#ffffff!important;padding:8px 12px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;letter-spacing:0.0625em;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px}a[rel="orange_button"]:hover,.mktoButton:hover{color:white!important;background:var(--terciary-color);text-decoration:none}a[rel="gray_button"]{border-radius:4px;background-color:#404040;color:#f2f2f2;padding:8px 12px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;letter-spacing:0.75px;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px}a[rel="gray_button"]:hover{background:#595959}.widget__show-more{text-align:center;padding-bottom:45px}.show-less,.show-more{color:#0d0d0d;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-size:16px;letter-spacing:-0.1px;transition-duration:300ms;transition-property:all;background:transparent;border:none}.show-less:focus,.show-more:focus{outline:5px auto #2684b1}.show-less,.show-more:hover{color:var(--terciary-color)}.show-less{display:none}.dark_layout .widget__headline{color:#e6e6e6}.dark_layout .widget__subheadline{color:#999999}.dark_layout .article_post .social-author:before,.dark_layout .article_post .social-author__name,.dark_layout .article_post .social-date__text{color:#a6a6a6}.dark_layout .posts-custom .social-date{color:#a6a6a6;padding-left:0;padding-right:8px}.dark_layout .posts-custom .social-author + .social-date,.dark_layout .posts-custom .custom-field-PodcastEpisode + .social-date,.dark_layout .posts-custom .custom-field-PodcastVideoTime + .social-date{padding-left:8px}.dark_layout .like-btn.like,.dark_layout .like-btn.unlike{border-left:1px solid #404040}.dark_layout .like-btn.like .heart:before{color:#bfbfbf}.dark_layout .story_teaser .widget:hover .widget__headline a,.dark_layout .story_teaser .widget__headline:hover a{color:inherit}.custom-field-PodcastEpisode,.custom-field-PodcastVideoTime{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;color:#a6a6a6;text-transform:uppercase;display:inline-block;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;padding-right:7px;margin:0;vertical-align:middle}.custom-field-PodcastVideoTime{padding:0 10px;border-left:1px solid #404040;border-right:1px solid #404040}.custom-field-PodcastEpisode:before{content:"Episode "}.section-podcast,.section-podcasts,.section-video,.section-chatbot,.section-fixing-the-future{background:#1a1a1a}.section-video .story_teaser .widget__headline-text,.section-podcast .story_teaser .widget__headline-text,.section-podcasts .story_teaser .widget__headline-text{font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-weight:500}.section-video .story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text,.section-podcast .story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text,.section-podcasts .story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text{font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif;font-weight:300}.section-podcast .story_teaser .tag-fixing-the-future .widget__head>a,.section-podcasts .story_teaser .tag-fixing-the-future .widget__head>a,.widget.tag-fixing-the-future .widget__head>a{border-radius:5px;background-position:center;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:cover;display:block}.section-podcast .story_teaser .tag-chatbot-podcast .widget__head>a,.section-podcasts .story_teaser .tag-chatbot-podcast .widget__head>a,.widget.tag-chatbot-podcast .widget__head>a{border-radius:5px;background-position:center;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:cover;display:block}.section-podcast .story_teaser .widget__head img,.section-podcasts .story_teaser .widget__head img,.widget.tag-type-podcast .widget__head img{visibility:hidden}@media (max-width:992px){.top_menu_links .list .list__item:not(:nth-child(1)){display:none}}@media (max-width:767px){.widget.tag-type-podcast .widget__head,.section-podcast .posts-custom .widget__head,.section-podcasts .posts-custom .widget__head{width:20%;float:right;padding:0 0 0 8px}.topbar .search-form,.topbar .main-menu-el{display:none}.menu-opened .menu-global{margin-top:100px}.section_column{margin-bottom:20px!important}.widget.tag-type-podcast{padding-bottom:46px!important}.featured_post .widget__subheadline:after,.article_post .widget__subheadline:after,.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline:after,.story_teaser .widget__subheadline:after{margin:0px}.tag-type-podcast .widget__subheadline:after{margin:7px}.section-podcast .story_teaser .widget__headline-text,.section-podcasts .story_teaser .widget__headline-text,.section-podcast .story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text,.section-podcasts .story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text{letter-spacing:-0.03125em}.scroll_column .posts-custom .widget__headline{line-height:21px}.scroll_column .widget .widget__headline-text{font-size:18px;letter-spacing:-0.15px;line-height:21px}.section-podcast .story_teaser .widget .widget__image,.section-podcasts .story_teaser .widget .widget__image{border-radius:5px}.scroll_column .all-related-sections{display:none!important}.Top_hugeMenu .rebelbar__menu-toggle{padding:0}}@media (min-width:768px){.featured_columns .row .scroll_column{border-left:1px solid #bdbdbd}.section_column .story_teaser .widget{padding:16px 10px 16px 22px;margin:0}.section_column .story_teaser .all-related-sections{padding-top:8px}.page_headline_container .module-headline{padding:0px 0px 10px 32px}}@media (min-width:768px){#welcome_ad{min-width:640px;min-height:480px}.menu-opened .all-content-wrapper{-webkit-transform:translate(-320px,0);transform:translate(-320px,0);transform:translate3d(-320px,0,0)}.menu-global{right:0;-webkit-transform:translate(320px,0);transform:translate(320px,0);transform:translate3d(320px,0,0)}.search-form{padding:0 16px 0;margin:0}.user-menu-container{margin-right:16px}.featured_columns .story_teaser .widget .row .rm-col-center{padding:0 22px 0 10px}.footer .list a:last-child{padding-left:7.5px}.search-form__text-input{width:200px}}@media (min-width:1568px){.main,.rebelbar-wrapper,.dark_top_bar{max-width:1568px;margin:auto}.widget_column .sticky-target.legacy.sticky-active{max-width:392px}}.ftr-copy:first-letter {font-size:1.3em;margin:0 0 0 2px}.rebelbar-wrapper_static{padding:14px 16px 2px 16px;transition:all 300ms}.topbar-sticky.active .rebelbar-wrapper_static{position:fixed;width:100%;top:0;box-sizing:border-box;z-index:1}.topbar-sticky.active .js-hidden-panel.active + .rebelbar-wrapper_static{transform:translate3d(0,-100%,0)}.topbar__sticky-headline,.topbar__static-headline{display:none}.topbar__sticky-headline{max-width:calc(100% - 214px);box-sizing:border-box}.topbar__sticky-headline .text-element{width:100%;white-space:nowrap;text-overflow:ellipsis;box-sizing:border-box;overflow:hidden;height:100%}.topbar__sticky-headline--post{font-family:"Ivar-Headline-Bold",serif}@media (min-width:768px){.rebelbar-wrapper_static{padding:20px 32px 5px}.topbar-sticky.active .js-hidden-panel:not(.active) + .rebelbar-wrapper_static{padding-top:13px}.topbar-sticky.active .rebelbar-wrapper_static{max-width:1568px;margin:0 auto}.topbar-sticky.active .js-hidden-panel:not(.active) + .rebelbar-wrapper_static .topbar__sticky-headline + .topbar__static-headline{display:none}.topbar-sticky.active .js-hidden-panel:not(.active) + .rebelbar-wrapper_static .topbar__sticky-headline{display:inline-block;vertical-align:text-bottom;padding-left:16px}.topbar__static-headline{font:normal 12px/0.8 "Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;letter-spacing:0.0625em}.topbar__sticky-headline--post{letter-spacing:-0.010416666666666666em;font:bold 24px/24px "Ivar-Headline-Bold",serif;height:26px;position:relative;top:3px}_::-webkit-full-page-media,_:future,:root .topbar__sticky-headline--post{top:5px}.topbar__sticky-headline--section{font:normal 24px/1 "Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif;position:relative;top:4px;margin-left:8px}.topbar__sticky-headline--section:before{content:"";display:block;border-left:1px solid #d9d9d9;height:32px;transform:skewX(-15deg);position:absolute;top:-3px;left:6px}}@media (min-width:1024px){.search-form__text-input{width:282px}.topbar__sticky-headline--post{margin-left:8px}.topbar__sticky-headline--post:before{content:"";display:block;border-left:1px solid #d9d9d9;height:32px;transform:skewX(-15deg);position:absolute;top:-4px;left:6px}}@media (min-width:1366px){.topbar__static-headline{display:inline-block;vertical-align:text-bottom;padding-left:16px}}.hide-text.hide-text{font-size:0!important}[data-source-type="multi"] .freeze,[data-attr-source="filtered"] .freeze{display:none!important}article .ieee-summary{margin:16px 0 32px 0;padding:16px 16px 20px}article .body-description .ieee-summary h2{text-transform:uppercase;font-weight:600;padding-left:16px;font-size:20px;letter-spacing:0;line-height:16px}article .ieee-summary a::after{content:"\2193";padding:0 2px;text-decoration:none;display:inline-block}article .body-description .ieee-summary ul li{line-height:24px}.ieee-video-vertical video{max-height:70vh;width:auto;display:block;margin:0 auto}.tag_column .flourish-embed,.current_post_content .flourish-embed:not(.body-description .flourish-embed){display:none}#ieee-transcript-toggle{all:unset;cursor:pointer;color:#0d0d0d;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-size:16px;letter-spacing:-0.1px;line-height:20px;background:white;display:inline-flex;align-items:center;gap:6px}#ieee-transcript-toggle:hover{color:var(--terciary-color)}.ieee-transcript-icon{display:inline-block;width:13px;height:8px;background-image:url();background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;transition:transform 0.2s ease}.ieee-transcript-toggle[aria-expanded="true"] .ieee-transcript-icon{transform:rotate(180deg)}.rebellt-item.parallax>p.caption{text-transform:uppercase;margin-top:24px}@media screen and (max-width:1023px){.hide-on-mobile{display:none!important}}p.shortcode-media.shortcode-media-audio audio{width:100%}.rebellt-item div img{margin-bottom:8px}.rebellt-item small.image-media.media-photo-credit p{line-height:18px}p.shortcode-media.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image.rm-float-left.rm-resized-container.rm-resized-container-25 div{display:block}p.shortcode-media.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image.rm-float-left.rm-resized-container.rm-resized-container-25 div ul{display:none}p.shortcode-media.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image.rm-float-left.rm-resized-container.rm-resized-container-25 div img{padding-bottom:0}h2 strong,h3 strong,h4 strong,h5 strong{font-weight:normal}.body-description>p:first-child strong em,.body-description .widget__brief:first-child strong em{font-family:"Favorit-Pro"}.body-description .share-tab-img{overflow:visible}@media (max-width:767px){.feature_post_full.current_post .posts-custom .social-author__name{display:inline-flex}}.intro-text:first-letter ,.ieee-summary:first-letter {color:inherit;padding-top:16px;padding-bottom:16px}.intro-text{padding-top:16px;padding-bottom:16px}.pull-quote em,.ieee-pullquote em,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth em,.ieee-pullquote-left em{font-family:"Favorit-Pro"!important}.body-description .pull-quote a{text-decoration:unset}.body-description small.image-media.media-caption a{text-decoration:unset}.body-description .ieee-pullquote-fullwidth a{text-decoration:unset}.body-description small.image-media.media-photo-credit a{text-decoration:unset}.body-description h2 a,.body-description h3 a,.body-description h4 a{text-decoration:unset}.body-description h2 em,.body-description h3 em{font-family:"Favorit-Pro"}.body-description h4 em,.body-description h5 em{font-family:"Favorit-Mono"}p.shortcode-media.shortcode-media-youtube .rm-shortcode{margin-bottom:8px}p.shortcode-media.shortcode-media-youtube{line-height:18px}figure.xlrg{line-height:18px}.body-description strong em,.body-description em strong{font-family:IvarText}.pull-quote strong,.ieee-pullquote strong,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth strong,.ieee-pullquote-left strong,.pull-quote b,.ieee-pullquote b,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth b,.ieee-pullquote-left b{display:block;line-height:16px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;color:#0d0d0d;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;font-weight:400;text-transform:uppercase;padding-top:16px}@media (min-width:1586px){.rebellt-item.parallax p{width:80%;margin:0 auto}}.ieee-sidebar-small .rblad-ieee_in_content,.ieee-sidebar-medium .rblad-ieee_in_content,.ieee-sidebar-large .rblad-ieee_in_content{display:none}a.shortcode-media-lightbox__toggle.shortcode-media-controls__button.material-icons{display:none}small.image-media.media-caption em{font-family:inherit}.widget__body .photo-credit a{color:unset}.read_also_posts .rm-col-right.col{padding:0 0 0 16px}u{text-underline-offset:1px;text-decoration-thickness:1px;text-underline-position:from-font;color:inherit}@media (max-width:767px){u{text-underline-offset:0px}}.widget__body>.body,.widget__body.clearfix.sm-mt-1 .js-scroll-trigger,.widget__body.clearfix.sm-mt-1 #utm_campaign{margin-top:0}.social-author{font-size:0;margin-top:15px}.posts-custom .social-author:before{margin-right:5px}.tags .tags__item.tags__item,.dark_layout .tags .tags__item.tags__item{margin:0 5px 12px 0}.tags{font-size:0}.tag-type-webinar .photo-credit,.tag-type-webinar .photo-caption,.tag-type-whitepaper .photo-credit,.tag-type-whitepaper .photo-caption{display:none}.ad-in-content [id^="google_ads_"]{padding-bottom:12px}.dark_layout .ad-in-content{border-top:1px solid #404040;border-bottom:1px solid #404040}.feature_post_full .row.px10,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .row.px10{margin-left:0;margin-right:0}.feature_post_full .row.px10>.col,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .row.px10>.col{padding-left:0;padding-right:0}.custom-field-pdf-version{border-top:1px solid #bdbdbd;font-size:0;padding:16px 20px 16px;margin:0px -13px 0}.custom-field-pdf-version:before{content:"PDF VERSION";font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:12px;display:block;padding-bottom:24px;color:#404040;text-align:left}.rm-shortcode[href*=".pdf"]:before,.rm-shortcode[href*="javascript"]:before,.pdf-button:before{content:"Download PDF \2193";font-size:initial;color:#f2f2f2;font:400 12px/32px "Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;letter-spacing:0.0625em;height:32px;border-radius:4px;background-color:var(--terciary-color);text-transform:uppercase;display:inline-flex;justify-content:center;padding:0 16px;line-height:34px}.rm-shortcode[href*=".pdf"],.rm-shortcode[href*="javascript"]{font-size:0;text-decoration:none}.feature_post_full .custom-field-pdf-version{border:0;float:right;margin:0 32px 0 0;padding:0}.feature_post_full .custom-field-pdf-version:before{content:none}.feature_post_full .custom-field-pdf-version .rm-shortcode[href*=".pdf"]:before,.feature_post_full .custom-field-pdf-version .rm-shortcode[href*="javascript"]:before{background-color:transparent;border:1px solid;border-color:white;color:white}.feature_post_full.LightGreen .custom-field-pdf-version .rm-shortcode[href*=".pdf"]:before,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .custom-field-pdf-version .rm-shortcode[href*="javascript"]:before,.feature_post_full.Yellow .custom-field-pdf-version .rm-shortcode[href*=".pdf"]:before,.feature_post_full.Yellow .custom-field-pdf-version .rm-shortcode[href*="javascript"]:before{border-color:#0d0d0d;color:#0d0d0d}@media (min-width:375px) and (max-width:1120px){.feature_post_full .social-date-modified + .time-to-read{display:inline-block;width:fit-content;border-left:0;margin-left:24px}}@media (min-width:375px) and (max-width:425px){.social-date-modified{border-left:1px solid #a6a6a6;padding-left:8px}.updated_post .posts-custom .time-to-read{border-left:0;padding-left:0}.feature_post_full .social-date-modified + .time-to-read{margin-left:16px}}@media (min-width:992px) and (max-width:1024px){.feature_post_full .social-date-modified{width:48%}}@media (min-width:768px) and (max-width:1023px){.custom-field-pdf-version{padding:0;margin:0;position:absolute;right:32px;top:2px;border:0}.custom-field-pdf-version:before{position:absolute;left:-100px;top:12px}.feature_post_full .custom-field-pdf-version{top:unset;margin:0;transform:translateY(32px)}.feature_post_full.Vertical .widget__body:first-child{position:relative}.infinite_scroll.article_post .custom-field-pdf-version{position:relative;text-align:right;margin-top:-47px}.infinite_scroll.article_post .custom-field-pdf-version:before{position:absolute;top:12px;right:159px;left:initial}}@media (max-width:767px){.feature_post_full .custom-field-pdf-version{top:unset;margin:0 16px 0 0;transform:translateY(66px)}.infinite_scroll.article_post .custom-field-pdf-version{border-top:0;padding:16px 28px 16px}}@media (min-width:1024px){.posts-custom .social-author{margin-bottom:-2px!important}.custom-field-pdf-version{margin:0 -10px 24px;border:0;padding:0 0 24px;border-bottom:1px solid #bdbdbd}.infinite_scroll.article_post .custom-field-pdf-version{position:sticky;top:199px;height:0;width:calc(100% - 80%);margin:0;padding-bottom:92px}.infinite_scroll .custom-field-pdf-version + .tags{top:292px}.infinite_scroll .custom-field-pdf-version + .tags + .body{margin-top:-246px}.infinite_scroll .custom-field-pdf-version + .tags:before{padding-top:24px}}.post-partial .widget__headline-text{pointer-events:none}.share-media-panel{display:none}.photo-caption p{margin:0}p.caption{color:#262626;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:14px;letter-spacing:0.1px}.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image{line-height:0.6em!important}.media-caption,.posts-custom .media-caption,.photo-caption{color:#262626;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:14px;letter-spacing:0.1px;display:inline;line-height:18px;padding-right:5px}.media-photo-credit,.photo-credit{color:#404040;font-size:12px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:1px;margin-top:5px;line-height:18px}.photo-credit,.photo-caption p{display:inline}.feature_post_full .photo-credit{padding:8px 0}.feature_post_full .photo-caption{padding-right:0}@media screen and (min-width:768px){.feature_post_full .photo-caption{}}.sm-mt-1:not(:empty):before{margin-bottom:0px}.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image img{width:100%}.posts-custom .body .image-media,.posts-custom .body .image-media p,.posts-custom .body .media-photo-credit p{display:inline}.rm-float-left img{padding-bottom:8px;margin-top:-16px}.rebellt-item p.caption{line-height:20px}.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image img{display:block;margin-bottom:8px}.articles-count{margin:0}.body-description{color:#0d0d0d;font-family:"IvarText","Ivar-Headline",serif;font-size:24px;letter-spacing:0;line-height:36px;margin-bottom:44px}.rebellt-item em{font-family:"IvarText","Ivar-Headline",serif}.body-description>p:first-child strong{text-transform:uppercase;font-family:"Favorit-Pro"}.body-description a,.body-description a u{text-decoration:underline;text-underline-position:from-font;text-decoration-color:var(--terciary-color);color:inherit}.body-description .horizontal-rule{border-top:1px solid #bdbdbd}.body-description a:hover{color:var(--terciary-color)}.widget.tag-type-ti .body-description a{text-decoration-color:#005690}.widget.tag-type-ti .body-description a:hover{color:#005690}.body-description em{font-family:"IvarTextItalic"}.body-description h2{font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-size:32px;letter-spacing:-0.5px;line-height:36px;font-weight:400}.body-description h3,.body-description h1[data-role="headline"]{font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-size:24px;letter-spacing:-0.25px;line-height:28px;font-weight:400}.body-description h4{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:18px;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:1px;line-height:22px;text-transform:uppercase}.body-description h5{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:16px;letter-spacing:1px;line-height:20px;font-weight:bold;text-transform:uppercase}.rebellt-item{line-height:20px}.rebellt-item p,.rebellt-item blockquote{line-height:36px}.feature_post_full .rm-col-center{margin-bottom:0}.feature_post_full .posts-custom .social-author{margin:0;line-height:14px;vertical-align:middle}.posts-custom .social-author:before{content:"By ";font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;color:#404040;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;font-weight:normal;display:inline-block}.updated_post .social-date-modified:before{content:"Updated "}.updated_post .social-date:before{content:"Published "}.posts-custom .main-author__avatar,.posts-custom .social-author__avatar{display:none}.posts-custom .main-author__name,.posts-custom .social-author__name{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;color:#404040;text-transform:uppercase;padding-right:8px;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;font-weight:normal;text-decoration:underline}.around-the-web{margin-top:32px}.around-the-web__headline,.from-your-site__headline{font-size:0;line-height:0;padding:16px 0}.from-your-site__headline,.around-the-web__headline{border-top:1px solid #bfbfbf}.around-the-web__headline:before,.from-your-site__headline:before{font-size:12px;font-weight:400;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;color:#404040;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase}.around-the-web__headline:before{content:"Around the web"}.from-your-site__headline:before{content:"More from Spectrum"}.from-your-site__item,.around-the-web__item{padding:16px 0 24px 0!important;border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf;line-height:normal;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif}.from-your-site__item:last-child,.around-the-web__item:last-child{border-bottom:none}.from-your-site__item a,.around-the-web__item a{margin:0;text-decoration:none}.around-the-web__link:hover,.from-your-site__link:hover{color:#0d0d0d!important;text-decoration-color:var(--terciary-color)}.from-your-site__link:after,.around-the-web__link:after{content:"";border-right:10px solid #ecece9;margin-left:-10px}.article-content__comments-wrapper{border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf}.article-content__comments-wrapper{position:relative}.comment-header{position:absolute;top:0;right:0;padding:13px 0 10px!important}.comment-sort{text-transform:uppercase;color:#404040;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:12px!important;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px}.comment--sort{text-transform:uppercase;color:#404040;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;background:transparent;border:none;vertical-align:baseline;margin:0 0 0 8px;padding:0;border:0;-webkit-appearance:none}.comment-headline:before{content:"Reader responses";text-transform:uppercase;color:#404040;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;visibility:visible}.comment-headline{visibility:hidden}.talk--load_more__replies,.comment--show--replies,.comment--hide--replies{background:#ecece8;border:1px solid #bfbfbf;text-transform:uppercase;padding:6px 8px 4px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px}.talk--messages{font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif}.comment--item-avatar img{width:80px;height:80px}.comment--item-date{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase}.comment-item--publish{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;border:1px solid #bfbfbf;background:#ecece8;color:#404040;padding:3px 12px 0px}.comment-item--publish:hover,.comment--hide--replies:hover,.comment--show--replies:hover{background:#d9d9d9;color:inherit}.feature_wrapper .topbar{margin-bottom:0!important}.feature_post_full .widget__shares.share-panel{margin:0;float:right;padding:0 32px;border:0;display:inline-block;text-align:right}.feature_post_full .widget__shares a,.feature_post_full .widget__shares .share{color:white!important}.feature_post_full .widget__shares a i.fa-twitter,.feature_post_full .widget__shares .share i.fa-twitter{-webkit-mask-image:unset;-webkit-mask-box-image:none;background-color:transparent}.feature_post_full .widget__shares i.fa-twitter:before{content:"";background-size:contain;width:20px;height:20px;display:block;margin:0 auto;position:relative}.feature_post_full.DarkGray,.feature_post_full.Green,.feature_post_full.LightGreen,.feature_post_full.Yellow,.feature_post_full.Red,.feature_post_full.Orange,.feature_post_full.Purple,.feature_post_full.Purple2,.feature_post_full.Pink,.feature_post_full.Blue,.feature_post_full.LightBlue,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2,.feature_post_full.Green .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Red .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Orange .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Blue .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.LightBlue .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Pink .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Purple .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Purple2 .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .time-to-read{color:#ffffff}.feature_post_full .widget:hover .widget__headline a{color:inherit;text-decoration:none}.feature_post_full .all-related-sections{padding:0 32px}.feature_post_full .widget__headline{font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif;color:white;font-size:92px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:-3px;line-height:84px;text-transform:uppercase;padding:0 32px}.feature_post_full .widget__subheadline{font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif;font-size:24px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:-0.25px;line-height:28px;padding:0 32px 248px;border-bottom:1px solid #4096c8;margin-bottom:14px}.feature_post_full .widget .widget__body:first-child{padding:24px 0px 30px 0px;margin-bottom:0}.feature_post_full .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{color:white}.feature_post_full .widget .widget__head{margin-bottom:0}.feature_post_full .widget .widget__body:last-child{background:#ecece8;border-bottom:1px solid #bdbdbd;padding-top:8px;padding-left:16px;padding-right:16px;line-height:18px}.feature_post_full .social-author{padding-left:32px}.feature_post_full .social-author:before,.feature_post_full .social-author__name,.feature_post_full .social-date{color:white}.feature_post_full .social-date{padding-left:8px}.feature_post_full .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full .like-btn.unlike{border-left-color:#4096c8}.feature_post_full .widget .widget__body:first-child,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#1a1a1a}.feature_post_full.DarkGray .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.DarkGray .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border-left-color:#404040;border-bottom-color:#404040;color:#bfbfbf}.feature_post_full .widget__subheadline,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .widget__subheadline{color:#bfbfbf;border-bottom:1px solid #404040}.feature_post_full.DarkGray .social-author:before,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .social-author__name,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .social-date,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .social-date-modified{color:#a6a6a6}.feature_post_full.DarkGray .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .like-btn.unlike{border-left-color:#404040}.feature_post_full.DarkGray .social-date,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .social-date-modified{padding-left:16px}.feature_post_full.DarkGray .time-to-read{border-left:1px solid #404040;color:#a6a6a6}.feature_post_full.Green .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#007d6a}.feature_post_full.Green .widget__subheadline{border-bottom:1px solid #27c3ae;color:#d2f9f3}.feature_post_full.Green .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.Green .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border-left-color:#27c3ae;border-bottom-color:#27c3ae}.feature_post_full.LightGreen .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#27c3ae;color:#0d0d0d}.feature_post_full.LightGreen .widget__headline,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .social-author:before,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .social-author__name,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .social-date,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .social-date-modified,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .time-to-read{color:#0d0d0d}.feature_post_full.LightGreen .widget__subheadline{border-bottom:1px solid #007d6a;color:#004238}.feature_post_full.LightGreen .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.LightGreen .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border-left-color:#007d6a;border-bottom-color:#007d6a;color:#0d0d0d}.feature_post_full.LightGreen .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .social-date,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .social-date-modified{border-left-color:#007d6a}.feature_post_full.LightGreen .widget__shares a,.feature_post_full.LightGreen .widget__shares .share{color:#0d0d0d!important}.feature_post_full.Yellow .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#ffbc00}.feature_post_full.Yellow .widget__headline,.feature_post_full.Yellow .social-author:before,.feature_post_full.Yellow .social-author__name,.feature_post_full.Yellow .social-date__text,.feature_post_full.Yellow .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Yellow .social-date,.feature_post_full.Yellow .social-date-modified{color:#0d0d0d}.feature_post_full.Yellow .widget__subheadline{border-bottom:1px solid #c38500;color:#704d00}.feature_post_full.Yellow .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.Yellow .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border-left-color:#704d00;border-bottom-color:#704d00;color:#0d0d0d}.feature_post_full.Yellow .widget__shares a,.feature_post_full.Yellow .widget__shares .share{color:#0d0d0d!important}.feature_post_full.Red .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#a32700}.feature_post_full.Orange .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:var(--terciary-color)}.feature_post_full.Red .widget__subheadline,.feature_post_full.Orange .widget__subheadline{border-bottom:1px solid #ffaa88;color:#ffded1}.feature_post_full.Red .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.Red .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"],.feature_post_full.Orange .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.Orange .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border-left-color:#ffaa88;border-bottom-color:#ffaa88}.feature_post_full.Red .social-date,.feature_post_full.Orange .social-date{border-left:1px solid #ffaa88}.feature_post_full.Red .social-date-modified,.feature_post_full.Red .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Red .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.Red .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.Orange .social-date-modified,.feature_post_full.Orange .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Orange .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.Orange .like-btn.unlike{border-left-color:#ffaa88}.feature_post_full.Purple .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#362ba6}.feature_post_full.Purple2 .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#414099}.feature_post_full.Purple .widget__subheadline,.feature_post_full.Purple2 .widget__subheadline{border-bottom:1px solid #8d8cd6;color:#d8d6ff}.feature_post_full.Purple .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.Purple .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"],.feature_post_full.Purple2 .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.Purple2 .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border-left-color:#8d8cd6;border-bottom-color:#8d8cd6}.feature_post_full.Pink .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#ca3674}.feature_post_full.Pink .widget__subheadline{border-bottom:1px solid #fa5f9f;color:#ffcce1}.feature_post_full.Pink .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.Pink .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border-left-color:#fa5f9f;border-bottom-color:#fa5f9f}.feature_post_full.Blue .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#005690}.feature_post_full.Blue .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.Blue .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border-left-color:#4096c8;border-bottom-color:#4096c8}.feature_post_full.Blue .widget__subheadline{color:#d0ebfb;border-bottom:1px solid #4096c8}.feature_post_full.Vertical .social-date{border-left:0}.feature_post_full.LightBlue .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#4096c8}.feature_post_full.LightBlue .widget__subheadline{color:#d0ebfb;border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf}.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#101341}.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .widget .widget__body:first-child{background:#313662}.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .widget__subheadline,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .widget__subheadline{border-bottom:1px solid #898ba5;color:#dcdde4}.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"],.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border-left-color:#898ba5;border-bottom-color:#898ba5}.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .social-date,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .social-date{border-left:1px solid #898ba5}.feature_post_full .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]:hover{background:#595959;border:1px solid #595959;box-shadow:0px -4px 0px #595959;color:#bfbfbf}.feature_post_full .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"]:hover{border:1px solid var(--terciary-color);background-color:var(--terciary-color);color:white}.feature_post_full.Orange .all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]:hover,.feature_post_full.Orange .all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"]:hover{background:#ffffff;border:1px solid #ffffff;box-shadow:0px -4px 0px #ffffff;color:#ff4b00}.feature_post_full.Orange .posts-custom .main-author__name:hover,.feature_post_full.Orange .posts-custom .social-author__name:hover,.feature_post_full.Orange .posts-custom .main-author__social-name:hover,.feature_post_full.Orange .posts-custom .social-author__social-name:hover{color:#ffded1}.dark_layout .body-description em{font-family:inherit!important}.dark_layout .photo-caption,.dark_layout .photo-credit{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:14px;letter-spacing:0.1px;display:inline-block;padding-right:10px}.dark_layout .media-caption,.dark_layout .posts-custom .media-caption,.dark_layout .photo-caption{color:#bfbfbf}.dark_layout .media-photo-credit,.dark_layout .photo-credit{color:#737373}.dark_layout .photo-credit a{text-decoration:underline;color:inherit}.dark_layout .show-less,.dark_layout .show-more{color:#f2f2f2}.dark_layout .show-less:hover,.dark_layout .show-more:hover{color:var(--terciary-color)}.dark_layout .body-description{color:#f2f2f2;font-family:"FavoritPro-Regular",sans-serif;font-size:24px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:-0.25px;line-height:36px;margin-bottom:40px}.tags:before{content:"tags"}.widget__shares.share-panel:before,.tags:before,.dark_layout .widget__shares.share-panel:before,.dark_layout .tags:before{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:12px;display:block;padding-bottom:24px;color:#404040;text-align:left}.dark_layout .time-to-read,.dark_layout .widget__shares.share-panel:before,.dark_layout .tags:before{color:#a6a6a6}.tags .tags__item,.dark_layout .tags .tags__item{border:1px solid transparent;display:inline-block;margin:0px;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;white-space:nowrap;letter-spacing:0.0625em;line-height:1;padding:1px 8px 5px 8px}.tags .tags__item{border-left:1px solid #bfbfbf;border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf;color:#404040}.dark_layout .tags .tags__item{border-left:1px solid #404040;border-bottom:1px solid #404040;color:#bfbfbf}.tags__item[href$="/type-upcoming"],.tags__item[href$="/type-podcast"],.tags__item[href$="/type-video"],.tags__item[href$="/type-cover"],.tags__item[href$="/type-whitepaper"],.tags__item[href$="/type-webinar"],.tags__item[href$="/type-sponsored"],.tags__item[href$="/type-feature"],.tags__item[href$="/type-ti"],.tags__item[href$="/type-slideshow"],.tags__item[href$="/type-departments"]{display:none!important}.tags__item:hover{background-color:#d9d9d9;border:1px solid #d9d9d9;box-shadow:0px -4px 0px #d9d9d9}.dark_layout .tags__item:hover{background-color:#404040;border:1px solid #404040;box-shadow:0px -4px 0px #404040}.posts-custom .widget__shares a,.posts-custom .widget__shares .share{color:#ff4c00;background:transparent;font-size:25px}.posts-custom .widget__shares a i.fa-twitter,.posts-custom .widget__shares .share i.fa-twitter{-webkit-mask-image:unset;-webkit-mask-box-image:none;background-color:transparent}.posts-custom .widget__shares i.fa-twitter:before{content:"";background-size:contain;width:20px;height:20px;display:block;margin:0 auto;position:relative}.post-author-list{font-size:0;position:relative}.post-author{display:block;overflow:hidden}.post-author-list:before,.post-author + .post-author:before{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.0625em;line-height:12px;display:block;padding-bottom:16px;color:#404040}.post-author-list:before{content:"About the author"}.post-author:first-child + .post-author:before{content:"s";position:absolute;left:10.6em;top:0}.post-author__avatar{display:none}.post-author + .post-author{margin-top:16px;padding-top:16px;border-top:1px solid #bfbfbf}.post-author__name,.post-author__bio{color:#0d0d0d;font-size:18px;letter-spacing:-0.011111111111111112em;line-height:22px}.post-author__name{font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;float:left;margin-right:5px}.post-author__bio{font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif}.post-author__bio a:first-child{display:none}@media (max-width:767px){.current_post .tags{padding-bottom:36px}.featured_post .widget__headline-text,.featured_post .widget__subheadline-text,.article_post .widget__headline-text,.article_post .widget__subheadline-text,.fullwidth_post .widget__headline,.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:32px;letter-spacing:-0.15px;line-height:32px}.article_post .body{}.post-author{margin-left:-16px;margin-right:-16px;padding-left:16px;padding-right:16px}.post-author-list:before{padding-bottom:24px}.post-partial.article__authors{padding-bottom:32px!important}.rebellt-item{line-height:16px}.rebellt-item p,.rebellt-item blockquote{line-height:28px}.comment-header{right:16px}.feature_post_full .body-description{padding:0}}.widget__shares a,.widget__shares .share{font-size:20px!important;margin:0!important;border:none}.widget__shares a{display:inline-block;padding:5px;line-height:0;width:25px;height:25px;border-radius:50%;font-size:1.5rem;text-align:center;position:relative;vertical-align:middle}.share-copy-link i svg{display:none}.share-copy-link i{content:" ";background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;background-position:center}.widget__shares a .fa-envelope:before,.widget__shares .share .fa-envelope:before{content:"";background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg%20width='22px'%20height='16px'%20viewBox='0%200%2022%2016'%20version='1.1'%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20xmlns:xlink='http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink'%3E%3Ctitle%3EFF38D0EB-1E4A-449A-B5ED-D75AE92C6713%3C/title%3E%3Cg%20id='Podcast-pages'%20stroke='none'%20stroke-width='1'%20fill='none'%20fill-rule='evenodd'%3E%3Cg%20id='1376---Individual-podcast-episode'%20transform='translate(-71.000000,-513.000000)'%20stroke='%23FF4C00'%3E%3Cg%20id='Group-12'%20transform='translate(32.000000,509.000000)'%3E%3Cg%20id='Group-3'%20transform='translate(40.000000,5.000000)'%3E%3Crect%20id='Rectangle'%20x='0'%20y='0'%20width='20'%20height='14'%20rx='2'%3E%3C/rect%3E%3Cpath%20d='M0,2.15810473%20L8.76584115,9.03218556%20C9.49049293,9.60044989%2010.5095071,9.60044989%2011.2341588,9.03218556%20L20,2.15810473%20L20,2.15810473'%20id='Path-6'%3E%3C/path%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/svg%3E");background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding:0 12px;vertical-align:middle}.widget.tag-type-ti .widget__shares a .fa-envelope:before,.widget.tag-type-ti .widget__shares .share .fa-envelope:before{content:"";background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;padding:0 12px;vertical-align:middle}.widget.tag-type-ti .share-copy-link i{content:" ";background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;background-position:center}.widget.tag-type-ti .widget__shares a,.widget.tag-type-ti .widget__shares .share{color:#005690}table{display:block;overflow-x:auto;white-space:nowrap}table th,table td{border-collapse:collapse;padding:8px 16px;background:white;border:1px solid #d9d9d9;color:#0d0d0d;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:16px;letter-spacing:0;line-height:20px;text-align:left}table th{text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px}.article__comments{margin-top:-20px}.listicle-slideshow .media-photo-credit i{font-style:normal!important}.listicle-slideshow{margin:32px 0}.listicle-slideshow .rebellt-item{display:flex;flex-direction:column}.listicle-slideshow h3,.listicle-slideshow h1{margin:0}.listicle-slideshow h3,.listicle-slideshow h1,.listicle-slideshow .rebellt-item-media-container{order:0}.listicle-slideshow [data-role="headline"]:empty{display:none}.listicle-slideshow .media-caption{order:1}.listicle-slideshow .media-photo-credit{order:2;font-size:12px}.listicle-slideshow__thumbnails{display:none}.listicle-slideshow__counter{font-family:"Favorit-Mono";font-size:14px;color:#262626;font-weight:bolder;text-shadow:0 0 #262626;display:flex;letter-spacing:0.1px}.listicle-slideshow__counter:before{content:"["}.listicle-slideshow__counter:after{content:"]"}.listicle-slideshow.listicle-slideshow .image-media.media-caption{text-indent:64px;margin-top:-18px}.listicle-slideshow-switch-page-btn i{visibility:hidden}.listicle-slideshow .listicle-slideshow-switch-page-btn{position:static;text-decoration:none;margin:0;line-height:20px;background-color:#404040;border-radius:50%;width:38px;height:38px;display:inline-flex;justify-content:center;align-items:center}.listicle-slideshow-switch-page-btn:before{content:"";height:21px;width:21px;display:inline-block;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:auto 100%}.rm-non-critical-loaded .listicle-slideshow-pager{display:block}a.listicle-slideshow-switch-page-btn.listicle-slideshow--prev{margin-right:10px}.listicle-slideshow-pager .listicle-slideshow--prev:before{background-position:0 center}.listicle-slideshow-pager .listicle-slideshow--next:before{background-position:100% center}.listicle-slideshow .image-media{display:block!important;margin-top:0;padding:0}.listicle-slideshow .image-media p{margin:0}.ieee-sidebar-small p,.ieee-sidebar-medium p,.ieee-sidebar-large p,.listicle-slideshow p{line-height:inherit!important}.listicle-slideshow .rebellt-item-media-container{}.listicle-slideshow-pager{opacity:1;float:right;margin:16px 0}.listicle-slideshow .rebellt-item-media-container{padding-bottom:16px}.listicle-slideshow h3:empty{display:none}.feature_post_full.Vertical .posts-custom .social-author{display:block;padding:0 16px}.feature_post_full.Vertical .posts-custom .social-date{padding-left:32px;border:0}@media (min-width:768px){.feature_post_full.Vertical .posts-custom .social-author{padding:0 32px}.feature_post_full.Vertical .posts-custom .social-date{padding-left:32px}.container_feature_below .read_also_posts .widget .row .col{margin-bottom:0}.container_feature_below>.article__authors{margin-top:-10px}.container_feature_below .read_also_posts .posts-wrapper:after{margin-bottom:0}.infinite_scroll .posts-custom .social-date,.posts-custom .post-partial .social-date,.social-date-modified{border-left:1px solid #a6a6a6;padding-left:8px}.posts-custom .social-author{display:inline-block;vertical-align:bottom}.dark_layout .social-author.clearfix{vertical-align:text-bottom}.widget__shares.share-panel{border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf}.dark_layout .widget__shares.share-panel{border-bottom:1px solid #404040;padding-bottom:11px}.body-description h2{font-size:36px;letter-spacing:-0.49px;line-height:40px}.body-description h3,.body-description h1[data-role="headline"]{font-size:28px;line-height:32px}.body-description h4{font-size:20px;letter-spacing:0.83px;line-height:28px}.body-description h5{font-size:18px;letter-spacing:0.9px;line-height:18px}}@media (min-width:769px){.dark_layout .tags{margin-left:0}.feature_post_full .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description{margin:72px auto 64px;border:1px solid #bfbfbf;padding:45px 40px;padding:calc(45px - 1em) 40px;max-width:768px;box-sizing:border-box}.feature_post_full.Vertical .col{display:flex;flex-wrap:wrap;justify-content:center}.feature_post_full.Vertical .widget__body:first-child,.feature_post_full.Vertical .widget__head{width:50%}.feature_post_full.Vertical .widget__head .widget__image{height:100%;padding:inherit!important}.rebellt-item.col3:not(.show_columns_on_mobile){padding:4px}.rebellt-item.col2:not(.show_columns_on_mobile){padding:8px}.read_also_posts .widget .rm-col-center{padding-right:22px}.container_feature_below .tags{margin:16px 0 0}.tags .tags__item{max-width:calc(100% - 32px);overflow:hidden;text-overflow:ellipsis}.listicle-slideshow .rebellt-item-media-container{padding-top:0}.listicle-slideshow-pager{position:absolute;opacity:1;top:auto;right:0}.listicle-slideshow .image-media{max-width:85%}}.read_also_posts .widget:not(:last-child){border-bottom:1px solid #bdbdbd}.read_also_posts .social-date{padding-left:0;border-left:none}.social-author__bio{display:none}.current_post_content .rm-col-center{padding:0!important}@media screen and (max-width:1023px){.post-author__name,.post-author__bio{font-size:16px;letter-spacing:-0.00625em;line-height:20px}.listicle-slideshow{position:relative}.listicle-slideshow__thumbnails{}.listicle-slideshow__thumbnail{width:8px;height:8px;background:#bfbfbf;border-radius:50%;margin:0 2px}.listicle-slideshow__thumbnail.active{background:#404040}.listicle-slideshow__thumbnail .image{display:none}i.icons-share.em.fa.fa-envelope{margin-top:9px}.feature_post_full .photo-credit{padding:8px 0}.feature_post_full .widget__headline{font-size:36px;line-height:36px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:-1px;padding:0 16px}.feature_post_full .widget__subheadline{padding:0 16px 64px;font-size:18px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:-0.2px;line-height:20px}.feature_post_full .social-author{padding-left:16px}.feature_post_full .widget .widget__body:first-child{padding:24px 0 16px 0}.feature_post_full .widget__shares.share-panel{text-align:left;padding:0 16px;width:-webkit-fill-available;border-top:1px solid #404040;padding-top:16px;margin:16px 0 0;border-bottom:0}.feature_post_full.Blue .widget__shares.share-panel{border-top:1px solid #4096c8}.feature_post_full.LightBlue .widget__shares.share-panel{border-top:1px solid #bfbfbf}.feature_post_full.Red .widget__shares.share-panel,.feature_post_full.Orange .widget__shares.share-panel{border-top:1px solid #fa8}.feature_post_full.Green .widget__shares.share-panel{border-top:1px solid #27c3ae}.feature_post_full.Pink .widget__shares.share-panel{border-top:1px solid #fa5f9f}.feature_post_full.Purple .widget__shares.share-panel,.feature_post_full.Purple2 .widget__shares.share-panel{border-top:1px solid #8d8cd6}.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .widget__shares.share-panel,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .widget__shares.share-panel{border-top:1px solid #898ba5}.tags .tags__item{line-height:2.3em}.body-description{font-size:18px;line-height:28px;padding:0 16px}.tags{border-top:1px solid #bfbfbf;padding:16px 16px 48px;margin:auto}.article-content__comments-wrapper{padding:0 16px 32px}.feature_post_full .social-date{padding-left:16px}.feature_post_full .all-related-sections,.current_post_content .body-description{padding:0 16px}.media-photo-credit,.photo-credit{padding:0 6px;line-height:18px}.current_post_content .media-photo-credit,.photo-credit{padding:0}.read_also_posts .rm-col-left{padding:0 16px 0 0!important}.read_also_posts .widget .row{margin:0}.infinite_scroll .widget .widget__body:first-child{padding:16px 16px 0!important}.infinite_scroll .widget .widget__body:nth-child(3){display:grid}.infinite_scroll .widget .rm-col-center{padding:0px}.infinite_scroll .tags{margin:0;order:2}.infinite_scroll .photo-credit{padding:6px 16px}.dark_layout .body-description{color:#d9d9d9;margin:0;letter-spacing:0;line-height:24px;font-size:18px;padding-top:24px!important}.dark_layout .current_post .body-description p:first-child{margin-top:0}.dark_layout .tags{border-top:none;padding:0px}.feature_post_full .photo-caption:before{margin-top:-12px}.feature_post_full .tags{margin:0 -16px}table th,table td{font-size:14px;line-height:18px}.article_post-shares-and-tags .tags{display:none!important}.posts-custom .widget__shares{margin-top:0;padding-bottom:10px}}@media (min-width:769px) and (max-width:1023px){.listicle-slideshow__thumbnails{}}@media (min-width:768px) and (max-width:1023px){.widget__shares.share-panel{border-bottom:0;padding:0px}.body-description p:last-child{padding-bottom:28px}.article_post--body-and-tags{margin-bottom:0}.tag_column{margin-bottom:0}.current_post_media .widget{padding:24px 22px!important}.infinite_scroll .widget__head,.current_post_media .widget__head{margin-top:32px}.tags{margin:0;padding-bottom:40px}.current_post_content .tags{padding-bottom:36px}.container_feature_below .tags{margin:16px 0 0}.infinite_scroll .widget{padding:0px!important}.infinite_scroll .widget .widget__image{margin:0 32px}.infinite_scroll .posts-custom .widget__shares{padding:10px 27px;border-top:1px solid #bfbfbf;border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf;margin:0}.dark_layout .infinite_scroll .posts-custom .widget__shares{border-color:#404040}.read_also_posts:before{padding:16px 32px}.read_also_posts .widget .rm-col-center{padding:0 22px 0 0}.feature_post_full .widget__headline{font-size:68px;line-height:64px;letter-spacing:-0.04411764705882353em}.body-description{font-size:20px;line-height:32px;padding:0 32px}.feature_post_full .all-related-sections,.widget .body-description,.feature_post_full .widget__subheadline,.feature_post_full .widget__headline,.tags,.article-content__comments-wrapper{padding-left:32px;padding-right:32px}.feature_post_full .widget__shares.share-panel,.tag_column .widget__shares{padding-left:27px;padding-right:27px}.read_also_posts .widget,.post-partial.article__authors,.infinite_scroll .widget .widget__body:first-child{padding-left:32px!important;padding-right:32px!important}.feature_post_full .posts-custom .social-author{padding-left:32px!important;display:inline-block}.feature_post_full .social-date{padding-left:8px}.featured_columns .widget_column{display:none}.container_feature_below .feature .col{margin-bottom:0}.comment-header{right:32px}.current_post_content .read_also_posts{margin-top:-22px}.feature_post_full .body-description{padding-left:16px;padding-right:16px}.featured_post .widget__headline-text,.featured_post .widget__subheadline-text,.article_post .widget__headline-text,.article_post .widget__subheadline-text,.fullwidth_post .widget__headline,.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline-text{font-size:36px;letter-spacing:-0.2px;line-height:36px}}@media (min-width:1376px){.listicle-slideshow .rebellt-item-media-container{}}@media (min-width:768px) and (max-width:1375px){.listicle-slideshow .rebellt-item-media-container{}}@media (min-width:1024px){.read_also_posts{}.listicle-slideshow-switch-page-btn:before{height:21px;width:21px}.listicle-slideshow .listicle-slideshow-switch-page-btn{width:38px;height:38px}.rebellt-item-media-container .share-tab-img>img{max-height:calc(100vh - 60px);width:auto!important;margin:0 auto}.feature_post_full .photo-caption:before{height:8px}.current_post_content .body-description>p:first-child{margin-top:0}.body-description h2{font-size:42px;letter-spacing:-0.5px;line-height:44px}.body-description h3,.body-description h1[data-role="headline"]{font-size:32px;letter-spacing:-0.5px;line-height:36px}.body-description h4{font-size:24px;letter-spacing:1px;line-height:28px}.body-description h5{font-size:20px;letter-spacing:1px;line-height:18px}.widget__shares.share-panel{margin-bottom:30px;margin-top:30px;padding-bottom:20px}.dark_layout .widget__shares.share-panel{margin:15px 0 30px 0;padding-bottom:14px}.article_post .widget__shares.share-panel:before{content:"share this story"}.dark_layout .article_post .widget__shares.share-panel:before{content:"share this episode"}.infinite_scroll .widget__shares.share-panel{width:calc(100% - 80%);position:sticky;top:80px;margin:35px 0 24px;z-index:1}.infinite_scroll .tags{width:calc(100% - 80%);position:sticky;height:0;top:199px;z-index:0;margin-left:0px}.infinite_scroll .body{margin:-150px 0 0 23.2%}.article_column{border-right:1px solid #bdbdbd}.article_post--body-and-tags .tags{display:none!important}.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description{border-bottom:0;padding-bottom:calc(64px - 1em);margin-bottom:0}.feature_post_full .widget .widget__body:last-child{border-bottom:0;padding-left:32px;padding-right:32px}.feature_post_full.Vertical .widget .widget__body:last-child{width:inherit;margin-bottom:0}.container_feature_below{margin:0 auto 64px;border:solid #bfbfbf;border-width:0 1px 1px;padding:0 56px 29px;max-width:768px;box-sizing:border-box}.container_feature_below .tags{padding-top:16px;border-top:1px solid #bdbdbd;margin-top:0}.body-description a,.body-description a u{text-underline-offset:1px;text-decoration-thickness:1px}}@media (min-width:1376px){.feature_post_full .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description{padding-left:64px;padding-right:64px;margin-top:96px;max-width:992px}.feature_post_full:not(.current_post) .body-description{margin-bottom:96px}.container_feature_below{padding-left:64px;padding-right:64px;max-width:992px;margin-bottom:96px}}.feature_post_full .photo-caption{padding-right:0}.media-caption,.posts-custom .media-caption,.photo-caption{color:#262626;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:14px;letter-spacing:0.1px;display:inline;line-height:18px;padding-right:5px}.photo-credit,.photo-caption p{display:inline}.feature_post_full .photo-credit{padding:8px 0}.feature_post_full .photo-caption{padding-right:0}@media (max-width:767px){.feature_post_full .body-description{padding:0}.feature_post_full.Vertical .posts-custom .social-date{padding-left:16px;border:0}.article_post.infinite_scroll .photo-caption{padding:0 16px}.feature_post_full .social-date-modified{padding-left:16px}}@media (min-width:768px) and (max-width:1023px){.feature_post_full .body-description{padding-left:16px;padding-right:16px}.article_post.infinite_scroll .photo-caption{padding:0 16px}}@media (max-width:1023px){.feature_post_full .photo-caption:before{margin-top:-12px}.feature_post_full .tags{margin:0 -16px}}@media (min-width:1024px){.feature_post_full .photo-caption:before{height:8px}}.feature_post_full.DarkGray .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .social-date-modified,.feature_post_full.DarkGray .social-date{border-left:1px solid #404040}.feature_post_full.Yellow .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.Yellow .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.Yellow .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Yellow .social-date-modified,.feature_post_full.Yellow .social-date{border-left:1px solid #c38500}.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .social-date,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .social-date-modified,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .social-date,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .social-date-modified{border-left:1px solid #898ba5}.feature_post_full.Green .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.Green .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.Green .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Green .social-date,.feature_post_full.Green .social-date-modified{border-left:1px solid #27c3ae}.feature_post_full.LightBlue .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.LightBlue .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.LightBlue .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.LightBlue .social-date,.feature_post_full.LightBlue .social-date-modified{border-left:1px solid #b0d7ed}.feature_post_full.Purple .social-date,.feature_post_full.Purple .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Purple .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.Purple .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.Purple .social-date-modified{border-left:1px solid #8d8cd6}.feature_post_full.Purple2 .social-date,.feature_post_full.Purple2 .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Purple2 .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.Purple2 .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.Purple2 .social-date-modified{border-left:1px solid #8d8cd6}.feature_post_full.Pink .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Pink .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.Pink .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.Pink .social-date,.feature_post_full.Pink .social-date-modified{border-left:1px solid #fa5f9f}.feature_post_full.Blue .time-to-read,.feature_post_full.Blue .like-btn.like,.feature_post_full.Blue .like-btn.unlike,.feature_post_full.Blue .social-date,.feature_post_full.Blue .social-date-modified{border-left-color:#4096c8}p.ieee-sidebar-medium{width:40%;clear:both;max-width:40%;margin-bottom:0;margin-top:0;display:block}@media (max-width:767px){p.ieee-sidebar-medium{width:auto;max-width:100%}}.body-description a,.body-description a u{text-underline-offset:1px;text-decoration-thickness:1px}.ieee-sidebar-small .caption a,.ieee-sidebar-medium .caption a,.ieee-sidebar-large .caption a,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth .caption a{text-decoration:none}.badge_module.rm-float-left img{margin-top:7px}.tag-type-ti .body-description a,.tag-type-ti .body-description a u{text-underline-position:from-font;text-decoration-color:#005690;color:inherit;text-underline-offset:1px;text-decoration-thickness:1px}.feature_post_full .widget__shares i.fa-twitter:before{background:url('")}.feature_post_full.Green .like-btn.like .heart,.feature_post_full.Purple .like-btn.like .heart,.feature_post_full.Purple2 .like-btn.like .heart,.feature_post_full.Red .like-btn.like .heart,.feature_post_full.Orange .like-btn.like .heart,.feature_post_full.Pink .like-btn.like .heart,.feature_post_full.Blue .like-btn.like .heart,.feature_post_full.LightBlue .like-btn.like .heart,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .like-btn.like .heart,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .like-btn.like .heart{background-image:url("")}.listicle-slideshow-pager .listicle-slideshow--next:before{background-image:url("")}@media (min-width:769px){.rebellt-item .fl-scrolly-caption p{font-family:"Favorit-Pro";font-size:2.2rem;line-height:2.6rem}}.ieee-image-small .media-photo-credit p,.ieee-image-xsmall .media-photo-credit p{line-height:inherit}.ieee-sidebar-left h4,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth h4,.ieee-sidebar-left h5,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth h5{margin-bottom:8px}.feature_post_full .ieee-sidebar-large ol li{padding:4px 6px;margin:0 0 0 16px;line-height:inherit!important}.has_voting .vote-down .vote-container:before{content:"No";display:block;font-family:"Favorit-Pro";font-size:16px;padding:16px 8px 4px 8px;color:#0d0d0d}.has_voting .vote-up .vote-container:before{content:"Yes";display:block;font-family:"Favorit-Pro";font-size:16px;padding:16px 8px 4px 8px;color:#0d0d0d}.has_voting .number-container{font-family:"Favorit-Mono";padding:8px}.has_voting .up_down_voting--wrp{margin:0 0 0 8px}.vote-down.disabled.voted .vote-container:before{content:"No";display:block;font-family:"Favorit-Pro";font-size:16px;padding:16px 8px 4px 8px;color:#ffffff}.vote-up.disabled.voted .vote-container:before{content:"Yes";display:block;font-family:"Favorit-Pro";font-size:16px;padding:16px 8px 4px 8px;color:#ffffff}.has_voting .votes{padding:4px 0 0 0}@media (max-width:767px){.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns.col2:nth-of-type(1){margin-bottom:0}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns.col2:nth-of-type(2){margin-top:0}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns.col2:nth-of-type(1) ul{margin-bottom:0}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns.col2:nth-of-type(2) ul{margin-top:0}.rebellt-item{margin:0!important}.rebellt-item.is--mobile,.rebellt-item.is--tablet{margin-bottom:0}.pull-quote p,.ieee-pullquote p,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth p,.ieee-pullquote-left p{margin-top:0!important;line-height:40px}.body-description .rebellt-item em{line-height:inherit;font-family:inherit}}.body-description .rebellt-item em{line-height:inherit;font-family:inherit}.ieee-sidebar-left p em,.ieee-sidebar-medium p em,.ieee-sidebar-small p em,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth p em,.ieee-sidebar-large p em,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns p em,.ieee-sidebar-list-left p em,.ieee-factbox-left p em,.ieee-statbox-left p em,.ieee-number-list-left p em,.ieee-thumbnail-left p em,.ieee-infographic p em,.ieee-summary p em{font-family:"Favorit-Pro"}.body-description .ieee-sidebar-medium em{font-family:unset}.ieee-thumbnail-left>div:first-of-type{float:left;width:100px;padding-right:12px}.ieee-thumbnail-left p:first-of-type{clear:both;padding-top:12px}.post__last-point,.ieee-end-mark{content:"";display:inline-block;width:0.6em;height:0.6em;margin:0 0 0 5px;background-color:#ff4c00}.rebellt-item ol,.rebellt-item ul{line-height:36px}.posts-custom .body .image-media.media-caption p{line-height:18px}pre{font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;background:#ddd;padding:10px;border-radius:4px;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;color:#404040}.rebellt-item.ieee-image-xsmall .image-media.media-caption p,.rebellt-item.ieee-image-small .image-media.media-caption p,.rebellt-item.ieee-image-medium .image-media.media-caption p,.rebellt-item.ieee-image-large .image-media.media-caption p{line-height:18px}.ieee-sidebar-left,.ieee-sidebar-right,.ieee-sidebar-medium,.ieee-sidebar-small,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth,.ieee-sidebar-large,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns,.ieee-sidebar-list-left,.ieee-sidebar-list-right,.ieee-factbox-left,.ieee-factbox-right,.ieee-statbox-left,.ieee-statbox-right,.ieee-number-list-left,.ieee-infographic,.ieee-summary{color:#0d0d0d;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-size:16px;letter-spacing:-0.1px;line-height:20px;background:white;padding:16px 16px 16px}.listicle-slideshow-headline{margin:16px 0!important}.ieee-sidebar-right .media-caption p,.ieee-sidebar-right .media-photo-credit p,.ieee-sidebar-left .media-caption p,.ieee-sidebar-left .media-photo-credit p,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth .media-caption p{display:contents}.ieee-sidebar-right p,.ieee-sidebar-left p,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth p,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns p,.ieee-sidebar-list-left p,.ieee-sidebar-list-right p,.ieee-number-list-left p,.ieee-factbox-left p,.ieee-factbox-right p,.ieee-statbox-left p,.ieee-statbox-right p{line-height:20px}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns p strong,.ieee-sidebar-left p strong,.ieee-sidebar-right p strong,.ieee-sidebar-list-left p strong,.ieee-sidebar-list-right p strong{display:inline-block;padding-top:16px}.ieee-statbox-left,.ieee-statbox-right{padding-bottom:24px}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth h3,.ieee-sidebar-large h3,.ieee-sidebar-medium h3,.ieee-sidebar-small h3,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns h3,.ieee-number-list-left h3,.ieee-statbox-left h3,.ieee-statbox-right h3,.ieee-sidebar-left h3,.ieee-sidebar-right h3,.ieee-sidebar-list-left h3,.ieee-sidebar-list-right h3,.ieee-infographic h3,.ieee-summary h3{font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif;margin:0 0 24px;font-size:32px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:-0.5px;line-height:36px}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns h3,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns p,.ieee-sidebar-left p{margin:8px 0 0}.ieee-factbox-left h3,.ieee-factbox-right h3{color:#0d0d0d;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:48px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:-1.5px;line-height:48px;margin:8px 0 0 0}.ieee-factbox-left p,.ieee-factbox-right p{margin-top:14px}.ieee-statbox-left strong,.ieee-statbox-right strong{color:#404040;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;text-transform:uppercase;font-weight:inherit}.ieee-statbox-left p,.ieee-statbox-right p{margin:8px 0}.ieee-statbox-left p:nth-child(2n + 3):not(:last-child),.ieee-statbox-right p:nth-child(2n + 3):not(:last-child){margin-bottom:24px}.ieee-sidebar-list-left p strong,.ieee-sidebar-list-right p strong{border-top:1px solid #d9d9d9;display:inherit;padding-top:8px}.ieee-sidebar-list-left p{margin:0;padding-top:8px}.ieee-sidebar-list-left h3{margin-bottom:20px}.ieee-sidebar-list-left p:nth-child(odd){margin-bottom:16px}.ieee-number-list-left h4{border-bottom:1px solid #d9d9d9;color:#8c8c8c;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:32px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:0;line-height:36px;margin:0}.ieee-number-list-left{padding-bottom:24px}.ieee-number-list-left p{margin:8px 0}.ieee-number-list-left h4:not(:nth-child(2)){margin:24px 0 0 0}.pull-quote,.ieee-pullquote,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth,.ieee-pullquote-left{color:#ff4c00;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-size:32px;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:-1px;line-height:40px!important;margin-top:32px!important}.pull-quote p,.ieee-pullquote p,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth p,.ieee-pullquote-left p{margin-top:0}.pull-quote:before,.ieee-pullquote:before,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth:before,.ieee-pullquote-left:before{content:"";display:block;width:40px;height:25px;margin-left:-10px;margin-bottom:16px;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:100% auto;background-image:url("")}.ieee-pullquote-left .caption,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth .caption{line-height:16px;color:#737373;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;font-weight:400;text-transform:uppercase;width:66%}.ieee-pullquote-left .caption strong,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth .caption strong{color:#0d0d0d;font-weight:inherit}.widget.tag-type-ti .pull-quote,.widget.tag-type-ti .ieee-pullquote,.widget.tag-type-ti .ieee-pullquote-fullwidth,.widget.tag-type-ti .ieee-pullquote-left{color:#005690}.widget.tag-type-ti .pull-quote:before,.widget.tag-type-ti .ieee-pullquote:before,.widget.tag-type-ti .ieee-pullquote-fullwidth:before,.widget.tag-type-ti .ieee-pullquote-left:before{background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg%20width='62px'%20height='40px'%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20xmlns:xlink='http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink'%3E%3Cg%20id='Page-1'%20stroke='none'%20stroke-width='1'%20fill='none'%20fill-rule='evenodd'%3E%3Cg%20id='1568---Feature-article-pull-quote'%20transform='translate(-144.000000,-286.000000)'%20stroke='%23005690'%20stroke-width='5'%3E%3Cg%20id='Group'%20transform='translate(144.758053,243.000000)'%3E%3Cg%20id='Group-3'%20transform='translate(0.000000,44.977510)'%3E%3Cpolyline%20id='Hed/dek-separator'%20transform='translate(17.522490,17.522490)%20rotate(45.000000)%20translate(-17.522490,-17.522490)'%20points='5.24194695%205.0224901%2029.8030332%205.0224901%2029.8030332%2030.0224901'%3E%3C/polyline%3E%3Cpolyline%20id='Hed/dek-separator-Copy'%20transform='translate(39.567470,18.522490)%20rotate(45.000000)%20translate(-39.567470,-18.522490)'%20points='27.2869272%206.0224901%2051.8480135%206.0224901%2051.8480135%2031.0224901'%3E%3C/polyline%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/svg%3E")}blockquote,.posts-custom blockquote{border-left:2px solid #d9d9d9;border-left-color:#d9d9d9;color:#0d0d0d;font-family:"IvarTextItalic",sans-serif;font-style:italic}.ieee-sidebar-right ol li,.ieee-sidebar-left ol li,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth ol li,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns ol li,.ieee-sidebar-list-left ol li,.ieee-sidebar-list-right ol li,.ieee-number-list-left ol li,.ieee-factbox-left ol li,.ieee-factbox-right ol li,.ieee-statbox-left ol li,.ieee-statbox-right ol li,.ieee-sidebar-right ul li,.ieee-sidebar-left ul li,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth ul li,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns ul li,.ieee-sidebar-list-left ul li,.ieee-sidebar-list-right ul li,.ieee-number-list-left ul li,.ieee-factbox-left ul li,.ieee-factbox-right ul li,.ieee-statbox-left ul li,.ieee-statbox-right ul li{line-height:20px;padding:8px 0}.ieee-sidebar-small .shortcode-media,.ieee-sidebar-medium .shortcode-media,.ieee-sidebar-large .shortcode-media,.ieee-sidebar-small p.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image.rm-float-left,.ieee-sidebar-medium p.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image.rm-float-left,.ieee-sidebar-large p.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image.rm-float-left{width:100%}.ieee-sidebar-large{display:flow-root;margin-bottom:48px}figcaption{color:#262626;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:14px;letter-spacing:0.1px;display:inline!important;line-height:normal}.ee-ul{padding-left:0;margin:0}.ieee-sidebar-large .ee-ul li,.ieee-sidebar-medium .ee-ul li,.ieee-sidebar-small .ee-ul li{list-style:none;padding:8px 0}.ieee-sidebar-large .ee-ul li:not(:last-child),.ieee-sidebar-medium .ee-ul li:not(:last-child),.ieee-sidebar-small .ee-ul li:not(:last-child){border-bottom:1px solid #d9d9d9}ol,ul{padding-left:1em;margin:49px 0 47px}ul li{padding:12px 0}ol li{padding:12px 0 12px 5px}.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul,.feature_post_full :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol,.feature_post_full :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul{padding-left:2em;margin:16px 0 4px}.shortcode-media-brightcove,.shortcode-media-facebook,.shortcode-media-imgur,.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image,.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-proxy-image,.shortcode-media-twitter_embed{display:inline-block}@media (min-width:769px){.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns.rebellt-item.col2{padding:16px;display:table-cell!important}.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image.rm-float-right,.shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image.rm-float-left{width:50%}.ieee-image-small{width:45%;float:left;margin-right:32px;margin-bottom:16px}.ieee-image-xsmall{width:33%;float:left;margin-right:32px;margin-bottom:16px}.ieee-image-medium{width:70%}.ieee-statbox-left,.ieee-statbox-right,.ieee-sidebar-small{width:25%}.ieee-pullquote-left,.ieee-sidebar-left,.ieee-number-list-left,.ieee-statbox-left,.ieee-factbox-left,.ieee-sidebar-list-left,.ieee-sidebar-medium,.ieee-sidebar-small{float:left;margin-right:32px;margin-bottom:5px}.ieee-sidebar-right,.ieee-statbox-right,.ieee-factbox-right,.ieee-sidebar-list-right{float:left;margin-right:32px;margin-bottom:5px}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns.rebellt-item.col2{vertical-align:top;padding:16px 16px 40px}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns[data-basename*="particle"]{padding-top:60px!important}.feature_post_full.Red .social-date,.feature_post_full.Orange .social-date{border-left:1px solid #ffaa88}.feature_post_full.Blue .social-date{border-left:1px solid #4096c8}.feature_post_full.Pink .social-date{border-left:1px solid #fa5f9f}.feature_post_full.Purple .social-date{border-left:1px solid #8d8cd6}.feature_post_full.LightGreen .social-date{border-left-color:#007d6a}.feature_post_full.DarkBlue1 .social-date,.feature_post_full.DarkBlue2 .social-date{border-left:1px solid #898ba5}}@media (min-width:769px) and (max-width:1023px){.ieee-pullquote-left,.ieee-sidebar-medium,.ieee-sidebar-left,.ieee-sidebar-right,.ieee-number-list-left,.ieee-sidebar-list-left,.ieee-sidebar-list-right,.ieee-factbox-left,.ieee-factbox-right{width:30%}}@media (max-width:768px){.ieee-sidebar-right p{margin-top:24px}.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-medium) ol,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-medium) ul,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-small) ol,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-small) ul,.article_post ul:not(around-the-web__list){margin:37px 0 35px}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns.col2{display:block!important}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns[data-basename*="particle"]{padding:1px 16px 32px!important}}@media (min-width:1024px){.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul li,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol li,.feature_post_full :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul li,.feature_post_full :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol li{line-height:36px}blockquote,.posts-custom blockquote{padding:0 16px;margin:32px 0}.ieee-pullquote-left,.ieee-sidebar-medium,.ieee-sidebar-left,.ieee-sidebar-right,.ieee-number-list-left,.ieee-sidebar-list-left,.ieee-sidebar-list-right,.ieee-factbox-left,.ieee-factbox-right{width:40%}}@media (min-width:768px) and (max-width:1023px){blockquote,.posts-custom blockquote{padding:0 16px;margin:40px 0}.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul li,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol li,.feature_post_full :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul li,.feature_post_full :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol li{padding:4px 0;line-height:28px}.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul,.article_post ul:not(around-the-web__list){margin:40px 0}}@media (max-width:767px){.feature_post_full .social-date.social-date{border-left:none}blockquote,.posts-custom blockquote{padding:0 16px;margin:32px 0}.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul li,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol li,.feature_post_full :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul li,.feature_post_full :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol li{padding:4px 4px;line-height:28px}.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul,.article_post ul:not(around-the-web__list){margin:16px 0 4px}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns h3,.ieee-sidebar-left h3{margin:0 0 11px;font-size:24px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:-0.25px;line-height:28px}.pull-quote p,.ieee-pullquote p,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth p,.ieee-pullquote-left p,p.pull-quote{margin-bottom:16px}.ieee-pullquote-left .caption,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth .caption{margin-bottom:32px}.shortcode-media{margin:32px 0 16px}.ieee-sidebar-medium,.ieee-sidebar-large,.pull-quote p,.ieee-pullquote p,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth p,.ieee-pullquote-left p,p.pull-quote,.pull-quote,.ieee-pullquote,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth,.ieee-pullquote-left,.ieee-infographic,.ieee-summary,.rebellt-item{margin:32px 0}.ieee-sidebar-small .shortcode-media,.ieee-sidebar-medium .shortcode-media,.ieee-sidebar-large .shortcode-media,.ieee-sidebar-small .shortcode-media,.ieee-sidebar-medium .shortcode-media,.ieee-sidebar-large .shortcode-media{margin:16px 0}}@media (max-width:768px){.ieee-number-list-left h4{font-size:24px;letter-spacing:-0.25px;line-height:28px}}@media (max-width:768px){.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns.col2{display:block!important;padding-bottom:0px!important}.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns.col2 + .ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns.col2,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns[data-basename*="particle"]{padding:1px 16px 32px!important}}@media (min-width:768px){.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul li,.article_post :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol li,.feature_post_full :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ul li,.feature_post_full :not(.ieee-sidebar-large) ol li{padding:4px 6px}}.article_post .ieee-sidebar-fullwidth ol{list-style-position:inside;padding:0;margin:0}.article_post .ieee-sidebar-fullwidth ol li{line-height:20px;padding:16px 0px}.around-the-web__list{padding:0!important;margin:0!important}@media (max-width:1023px){.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth h3,.ieee-sidebar-large h3,.ieee-sidebar-medium h3,.ieee-sidebar-small h3,.ieee-sidebar-fullwidth-columns h3,.ieee-number-list-left h3,.ieee-statbox-left h3,.ieee-statbox-right h3,.ieee-sidebar-left h3,.ieee-sidebar-right h3,.ieee-sidebar-list-left h3,.ieee-sidebar-list-right h3,.ieee-infographic h3,.ieee-summary h3{font-size:24px;letter-spacing:-0.25px;line-height:28px}}.ieee-infographic{margin-right:0;padding-right:0}.ieee-infographic .share-tab-img.share-buttons.share-trigger{overflow:scroll}.ieee-infographic img{height:50vh;width:auto;max-width:fit-content;padding-right:16px}.ieee-infographic p{line-height:22px}.ieee-infographic p,.ieee-infographic h3{padding-right:16px}@media (min-width:640px){.ieee-infographic{margin-right:0;padding-right:16px}.ieee-infographic .share-tab-img.share-buttons.share-trigger{overflow:hidden}.ieee-infographic img{height:auto;width:100%;max-width:fit-content;padding-right:0}}.comment--item--menu{display:inline-block;margin:14px 0;padding:0 4px 0 8px;border-left:1px solid #bfbfbf}.talk--messages,.talk-linked-comment{font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif}.article__comments .comment-item--publish:focus{outline:5px auto #2684b1;border-radius:0}.comment--item-word-count{margin-left:auto;width:fit-content;pointer-events:none}@media screen and (max-width:767px){.comment--item-text{overflow:inherit;background:transparent;padding:0;border-radius:5px;margin-bottom:0}.comment--item-avatar.comment--item-avatar img{margin-right:17px}.comment--item-message.comment--item-message{margin:32px 0 5px 0}.talk-linked-comment .comment--item,.talk--messages .comment--item{margin:0 -16px;position:relative;padding:16px 16px 0 16px}.comment--item-message.comment--item-message p{margin:40px 0 0}.talk--messages .comment--custom-field-member-badges{overflow:auto;margin-top:-1px}}.article__comments .comment-item--publish{background:var(--terciary-background-color);border:none;padding-top:1px;transition:all 0.3s}.article__comments .comment-item--publish:hover{background:var(--terciary-color)}.article__comments .comment--item-date{font-size:0px;line-height:0}.article__comments .comment--item-date::after{content:attr(data-date);font-size:12px;display:block;line-height:1.2}.talk--load_more-wrp.has_load_more.loaded.rm-preact:not(:empty):after{content:"";background:linear-gradient(180deg,rgba(236,236,233,0) 0%,rgba(236,236,233,0.8) 20%,#ecece9 100%);border:0;display:block;height:200px;margin-top:-263px;position:absolute;width:100%}.talks--load_more:after{content:"\2193";padding-left:8px;font-size:16px}.talks--load_more:before{content:"See all responses";font-size:16px}.talks--load_more.talks--load_more{font-size:0}.article-content__comments-wrapper .talk--messages .material-icons.status-rejected.selected{display:none!important}.talk--load_more-wrp.has_load_more.loaded.rm-preact:not(:empty):after{content:"";background:linear-gradient(180deg,rgba(236,236,233,0) 0%,rgba(236,236,233,0.8) 20%,#ecece9 100%);border:0;display:block;height:200px;margin-top:-263px;position:absolute;width:100%}.talks--load_more:before{content:"See all responses";font-size:16px}.talks--load_more.talks--load_more{font-size:0}.comment--custom-field-member-badges,.comment--custom-field-grade{display:inline;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;padding:2px 4px 0px;width:fit-content;white-space:nowrap;vertical-align:middle}.comment--item-toolbar{background:white!important}.comment--custom-field-grade{visibility:hidden}.comment--custom-field-grade:before{padding:2px 4px 0px;visibility:visible}.comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE GRADUATE STUDENT MEMBER"]{background:#d2f9f3;color:#004238}.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="GSM"]:before{background:#d2f9f3;color:#004238;content:"IEEE GRADUATE STUDENT MEMBER"}.comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE STUDENT MEMBER"]{background:#d7f2c2;color:#114200}.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="StM"]:before{background:#d7f2c2;color:#114200;content:"IEEE STUDENT MEMBER"}.comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE ASSOCIATE MEMBER"]{background:#d0ebfb;color:#002e4d}.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="AM"]:before{background:#d0ebfb;color:#002e4d;content:"IEEE ASSOCIATE MEMBER"}.comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE MEMBER"]{background:#dcdde4;color:#02032c}.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="M"]:before,.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="SA MBR"]:before{background:#dcdde4;color:#02032c;content:"IEEE MEMBER"}.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="LM"]:before{background:#dcdde4;color:#02032c;content:"IEEE LIFE MEMBER"}.comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE SENIOR MEMBER"]{background:#d8d6ff;color:#160f57}.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="SM"]:before{background:#d8d6ff;color:#160f57;content:"IEEE SENIOR MEMBER"}.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="LS"]:before{background:#d8d6ff;color:#160f57;content:"IEEE LIFE SENIOR MEMBER"}.comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE FELLOW"]{background:#ffcce1;color:#6b0f36}.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="F"]:before{background:#ffcce1;color:#6b0f36;content:"IEEE FELLOW"}.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="LF"]:before{background:#ffcce1;color:#6b0f36;content:"IEEE LIFE FELLOW"}.comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="H"]:before{background:#ffcce1;color:#6b0f36;content:"IEEE HONORARY MEMBER"}.comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="STAFF EDITOR"]{background:#ffded1;color:#521400}.comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="CONTRIBUTOR"]{background-color:#fff0cc;color:#704d00}.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE GRADUATE STUDENT MEMBER"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="GSM"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE STUDENT MEMBER"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="StM"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE ASSOCIATE MEMBER"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="AM"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE MEMBER"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="H"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="LM"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="M"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="SA MBR"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE SENIOR MEMBER"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="LS"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="SM"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE FELLOW"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="F"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="LF"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="STAFF EDITOR"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="CONTRIBUTOR"]{color:white}.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE GRADUATE STUDENT MEMBER"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="GSM"]:before{background:#007d6a}.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE STUDENT MEMBER"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="StM"]:before{background:#316e1c}.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE ASSOCIATE MEMBER"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="AM"]:before{background:#005690}.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE MEMBER"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="H"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="LM"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="M"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="SA MBR"]:before{background:#313662}.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE SENIOR MEMBER"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="LS"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="SM"]:before{background:#362ba6}.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="IEEE FELLOW"],.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="F"]:before,.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-grade[data-value="LF"]:before{background:#ca3674}.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="STAFF EDITOR"]{background:#a32700}.dark_layout .comment--custom-field-member-badges[data-value="CONTRIBUTOR"]{background-color:#9e6c00}.talks--load_more{background:transparent!important;border:none!important;color:#0d0d0d!important;text-transform:inherit!important;font-size:16px;font-weight:700!important;letter-spacing:-0.1px;font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif}.dark_layout .talks--load_more{color:#f2f2f2!important}.talks--load_more:after{content:"\2193";padding-left:8px;font-size:16px}.talks--load_more:hover{color:#ff4c00!important}.comment--item-message{margin:16px 0 5px 0}.comment--item-word-count-user{background:white;margin-left:-6px}.comment--item.rejected-comment .comment--item__reply,.comment--item.proposed-comment .comment--item__reply{margin-left:-8px}.input__star_rating,.author-rating,.talk__author__desc,.comment--item-word-count-min,.comment--item--short-bio,.comment--item--action .comment-action-icon,.comment--hide--replies svg,.comment--show--replies svg{display:none}.comment--item--action .admin-controls svg{display:block}a.comment--item__reply:after,a.comment--item__share:after{vertical-align:text-top;color:#404040;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;font-weight:100}a.comment--item__reply:after{content:"REPLY"}a.comment--item__share:after{content:"SHARE"}.comment--item__share{margin-right:0!important}a.comment--item__like:after,a.comment--item__dislike:after{content:"";vertical-align:middle;display:inline-block;width:13px;height:10px;transition:all 0.3s ease;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:100% auto}a.comment--item__like:after{transform:rotate(180deg);position:relative;top:-2px}.comment--item--action>div:not(.admin-controls){display:flex}.comment--item--action div a.comment--item__like{border-left:0;border-right:1px solid #bfbfbf;order:0;margin-left:-8px!important}.comment--item--action div a.comment--item__dislike{order:1}.comment--item--action .comment--item__reply{order:2}.comment--item--action .comment--item__share{order:3}a.comment--item__like:hover:after,a.comment--item__dislike:hover:after{filter:opacity(1)}.comment--item__like.selected,.comment--item__dislike.selected{background:#ff4c007a}a.comment--hide--replies,a.comment--show--replies{font-size:0}a.comment--hide--replies:after,a.comment--show--replies:after,a.comment--show--replies .comment--count{vertical-align:bottom;text-transform:capitalize;color:#0d0d0d;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-size:16px;letter-spacing:-0.1px;line-height:24px}a.comment--show--replies:after{content:"Show Responses";color:#0d0d0d;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-size:16px;letter-spacing:-0.1px;line-height:24px}a.comment--hide--replies:after{content:"Hide Responses";color:#0d0d0d;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-size:16px;letter-spacing:-0.1px;line-height:24px}a.comment--show--replies .comment--count{float:right;padding-left:8px}a.comment--show--replies .comment--count:before{content:"("}a.comment--show--replies .comment--count:after{content:")"}.talk--load_more__replies,.comment--show--replies,.comment--hide--replies{padding:2px 8px 0 8px!important;background:#ecece9!important;border:none!important;z-index:3!important}.dark_layout .talk--load_more__replies,.dark_layout .comment--show--replies,.dark_layout .comment--hide--replies{background:#1a1a1a!important}.dark_layout .comment--hide--replies:after,.dark_layout .comment--show--replies:after,.dark_layout .comment--show--replies .comment--count{color:#f2f2f2}.comment--item-date{margin:7px 0 0 0;color:#404040;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;font-weight:100;right:0!important}.comment--item--action a:hover{color:#ff4c00!important}.talk-linked-comment .comment--item,.talk--messages .comment--item{border-bottom:1px solid #bfbfbf!important}.dark_layout .talk-linked-comment .comment--item,.dark_layout .talk--messages .comment--item{border-bottom:1px solid #404040!important}.comment--item--action a{margin:16px 0!important;height:14px;line-height:16px;padding:0 8px}.comment--item--action a:not(:first-child){border-left:1px solid #bfbfbf}.dark_layout .comment--item--action a:not(:first-child){border-left:1px solid #262626}.comment--item-text-field{font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif}.dark_layout .comment--item-text-field{color:#fff}.dark_layout .comment--item-text-input,.dark_layout .redactor-box,.dark_layout .comment--item-toolbar{background:#404040!important}.dark_layout .comment--item-text-input{border-color:#404040}.dark_layout a.comment--item__reply:after,.dark_layout a.comment--item__share:after,.dark_layout .comment--item-date,.dark_layout .redactor-toolbar>li a,.dark_layout .redactor-editor p,.dark_layout .comment-headline:before,.dark_layout .comment-sort,.dark_layout .comment--sort{color:#a6a6a6!important}.dark_layout .comment--item-username{color:#f2f2f2}.dark_layout .comment--item-message p{color:#d9d9d9}.dark_layout .talk-linked-comment .comment--item,.dark_layout .talk--messages .comment--item{border-bottom:1px solid #262626}.dark_layout .article-content__comments-wrapper{border-bottom:1px solid #404040}.dark_layout .comment--item-word-count-user{background:#404040}.comment--item-text .comment--item-username{text-transform:capitalize;font-size:18px;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:-0.2px;line-height:22px}.comment--item-message p{font-size:18px;letter-spacing:-0.2px;line-height:28px}.comment--item-avatar img{width:75px!important;height:75px!important}@media (max-width:1023px){.comment--item-message p{font-size:16px;line-height:24px;letter-spacing:-0.1px;margin:16px 0 0}.comment--item-avatar img{margin-right:7px}}@media screen and (max-width:768px){.talk--messages .comment--custom-field-member-badges,.talk--messages .comment--custom-field-grade,.comment--item-text .comment--item-username{display:block}.comment--item-date{right:0!important;position:relative!important}.replies.level-two{margin:0px}}.material-icons.status-featured,.material-icons.status-proposed,.material-icons.status-rejected{right:105px!important;top:16px!important}@media (min-width:769px){.rm-float-right{float:right;margin-left:32px}.rm-float-left{float:left;margin-right:32px}.rm-resized-container-10{width:10%}.rm-resized-container-15{width:15%}.rm-resized-container-20{width:20%}.rm-resized-container-25{width:25%}.rm-resized-container-30{width:30%}.rm-resized-container-35{width:35%}.rm-resized-container-40{width:40%}.rm-resized-container-45{width:45%}.rm-resized-container-50{width:50%}.rm-resized-container-55{width:55%}.rm-resized-container-60{width:60%}.rm-resized-container-65{width:65%}.rm-resized-container-70{width:70%}.rm-resized-container-75{width:75%}.rm-resized-container-80{width:80%}.rm-resized-container-85{width:85%}.rm-resized-container-90{width:90%}}.post-author-list .posts-custom .social-author{margin-top:0;position:relative;font-size:18px;width:100%}.post-author-list .posts-custom .social-author:before{content:""}.post-author-list .posts-custom .social-author__name{text-decoration:none;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;float:left;margin-right:5px;text-transform:none;padding-right:0}.post-author-list .social-author__bio{display:list-item;font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif;list-style:none}.post-author-list .posts-custom .social-author__name,.post-author-list .social-author__bio{color:#0D0D0D;font-size:18px;letter-spacing:-0.011111111111111112em;line-height:22px}.post-author-list .social-author__bio p{margin:0;line-height:22px}.post-author-list .posts-custom .social-author__avatar{clear:both;display:block;float:none;height:0;width:0;position:revert}.post-author-list .social-author__bio a:first-child{display:none}.post-author-list:before{margin-bottom:-14px;padding-bottom:0}.post-author-list{padding:16px 0 48px 0;border-top:1px solid #BFBFBF;border-bottom:1px solid #BFBFBF}.container_feature_below .post-author-list{border-top:0;padding-top:6px}.container_feature_below .col{margin-bottom:0}.social-author__bio:not(:last-child){margin-bottom:16px;padding-bottom:16px;border-bottom:1px solid #BFBFBF}.social-author__bio + .social-author__avatar:before{content:"s";position:absolute;left:10.6em;top:2px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.0625em;line-height:12px;display:block;padding-bottom:16px;color:#404040}.post-author-list .social-author__avatar.image .cover-all.image{width:0;height:0}@media screen and (max-width:1023px){.post-author-list .posts-custom .social-author__name,.post-author-list .social-author__bio p,.post-author-list .social-author__bio{font-size:16px;letter-spacing:-0.00625em;line-height:20px}}@media (min-width:768px) and (max-width:1023px){.post-author-list{padding-left:32px;padding-right:32px}}@media (min-width:0) and (max-width:767px){.container_feature_below .post-author-list.post-author-list{padding:28px 16px 52px 16px}.post-author-list.post-author-list{padding:16px 16px 32px 16px}.post-author-list .posts-custom .social-author{margin-top:8px;position:relative}.social-author__bio + .social-author__avatar:before{top:-6px}.post-author-list .social-author__bio{padding-left:16px;padding-right:16px;margin-left:-16px;margin-right:-16px}}#sTop_Bar_0_0_27_0_0_0_0_16 {margin:0;position:relative;z-index:100000;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#sTop_Bar_0_0_27_0_0_0_0_16 {margin-bottom:24px;}}#sTop_Bar_0_0_27_0_0_0_0_16_0 {align-items:center;position:relative;}.toggle-user-dropdown{top:0;font-size:0}.rebelbar__user-info .notification-counter:not(.user-info__dropdown-wrapper .notification-counter){position:relative;top:5px}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1 {margin:0;text-transform:uppercase;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1 {padding-top:6px;}}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0 {display:flex;margin:auto;padding:0 32px;justify-content:space-between;box-sizing:border-box;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0 {padding:0 16px;}}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0 {margin:0;}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0 a {color:#BFBFBF;font-size:12px;text-decoration:none;font-family:'Favorit-Mono',sans-serif;padding:16px 24px 16px 0px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:10px;}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0 a:last-child {border:0;}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0 a:hover {text-decoration:underline;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0 a {padding-bottom:14px;}}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_0_1_1 {display:inline-block;}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_0_1_1_0 {margin:0;}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_0_1_1_0 a {color:#BFBFBF;font-family:'Favorit-Mono',sans-serif;font-size:12px;line-height:10px;text-decoration:none;padding:16px 24px 16px 0px;letter-spacing:0.0625em;}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_0_1_1_0 a:last-child {border:0;}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_0_1_1_0 a:hover {text-decoration:underline;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_0_1_1_0 a {padding:15px 0px 13px 16px;}}#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_1 {display:inline-block;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_1 {display:none;}}.announcement-bar.announcement-bar{margin-bottom:10px}.huge-menu.huge-menu{z-index:100002}.lightbox-popup.lightbox-popup{z-index:100001}#s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0 {display:flex;justify-content:space-between;align-items:center;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0_0 {width:186px;}}.active .topbar__sticky-headline--post ~ .topbar__static-headline,.floating-shares{display:none}.active .floating-shares{font-size:0;display:inline-block;width:25px;height:25px;background-color:transparent;background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg%20width='18px'%20height='20px'%20viewBox='0%200%2018%2020'%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20xmlns:xlink='http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink'%3E%3Cg%20stroke='none'%20stroke-width='1'%20fill='none'%20fill-rule='evenodd'%3E%3Cg%20transform='translate(-207.000000,-1593.000000)'%20stroke='%23FF4C00'%3E%3Cg%20id='Group-4-Copy'%20transform='translate(208.000000,1528.500000)'%3E%3Cg%20id='Group-12-Copy'%20transform='translate(0.000000,64.500000)'%3E%3Cg%20id='Group-2'%20transform='translate(0.000000,1.000000)'%3E%3Cpath%20d='M16,8%20L16,16%20C16,17.1045695%2015.1045695,18%2014,18%20L2,18%20C0.8954305,18%200,17.1045695%200,16%20L0,8%20L0,8'%20id='Path'%3E%3C/path%3E%3Cpolyline%20id='Path'%20transform='translate(8.000000,5.656854)%20rotate(-45.000000)%20translate(-8.000000,-5.656854)'%20points='4%201.65685425%2012%201.65685425%2012%209.65685425'%3E%3C/polyline%3E%3Cline%20x1='8'%20y1='0'%20x2='8'%20y2='12'%20id='Path-4'%3E%3C/line%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/svg%3E")!important;background-position:center!important;background-repeat:no-repeat!important;cursor:pointer}.active .site_logo{display:flex}@media (min-width:768px){.active .site_logo{max-width:60%}}@media (max-width:1023px){.active .site_logo svg,.active .mobile_search_icon{display:none}.active .topbar__sticky-headline.topbar__sticky-headline--post{display:inline;width:calc(100% - 30px);max-width:100%}.active .site_logo{width:calc(100% - 50px)!important}}#s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_0 {text-overflow:ellipsis;}#s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0_1 {display:flex;align-items:center;padding-bottom:6px;}#sElement_Menu_0_0_7_0_0_0_0_1_0 {padding-top:5px;}#sElement_Menu_0_0_7_0_0_0_0_1_0 a {display:table;font-size:18px;line-height:22px;white-space:initial;font-family:'Favorit-Pro', sans-serif;letter-spacing:-0.2px;padding:6px 20px;}.huge-menu{inset:0px;z-index:5000;position:fixed;top:0;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;margin:0 0 -20px;background-color:#1a1a1a;overflow-y:auto}.huge-menu .dark_layout{background:#1a1a1a;border:solid #404040;border-width:0 1px;box-sizing:border-box;margin:0 auto;max-width:1568px;padding-top:0}.huge-menu .top-menu .list__item.active:before,.huge-menu .top-menu .list__item:hover:before{font-size:16pt;transition:all 100ms ease;padding-right:10px}.huge-menu .top-menu--sm-links .list__item.active:before,.huge-menu .top-menu--sm-links .list__item:hover:before{font-size:12pt}.huge-menu .top-menu .list__item:before{content:"\f111";font-family:"FontAwesome";color:#ff4c00;font-size:0pt;vertical-align:top;transition:all 100ms ease}.huge-menu-opened{overflow:hidden}.huge-menu{display:none}.huge-menu-opened .huge-menu,.huge-menu-opened .topbar--sticky{display:block}.huge-menu-opened .topbar--sticky{position:fixed;left:0;right:0;top:0}.hm__close{position:absolute;right:0;top:0;width:28px;height:28px;color:#fff;transition:color 0.3s ease}.hm__close:before,.hm__close:after{position:absolute;left:14px;content:" ";height:29px;border-left:2px solid}.hm__close:before{transform:rotate(45deg)}.hm__close:after{transform:rotate(-45deg)}.huge-menu .module-headline__text{letter-spacing:0.75px;color:#8c8c8c;font-size:12px;font-family:"Favorit-Mono",sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase;line-height:24px;margin-bottom:5px;font-weight:normal}.huge-menu .list{margin:0}.huge-menu .list__item{padding-left:0;padding-right:0}.top-menu--sm-links .list{margin:0;padding-bottom:8px}.top-menu--sm-links .list__item{display:block;padding:2px 0;font:20px/28px "Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif;letter-spacing:-0.0125em}.huge-menu .social-links{margin-left:-16px;margin-right:-16px;display:flex;flex-direction:row;flex-wrap:wrap;justify-content:flex-start}.huge-menu .social-links__link{color:#bfbfbf;font-size:20px;background:transparent;padding:13px 8px 9px;width:auto;height:auto}.huge-menu .social-links__link:hover{color:#ff4c00}.huge-menu .social-links__link>span{position:static}.huge-menu .social-links__link span.fa-twitter{-webkit-mask-image:unset;-webkit-mask-box-image:none;background-color:transparent}.huge-menu .social-links__link span.fa-twitter:before{content:"";background:url('data:image/svg+xml,<svg width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="M15.1563 1.875H17.9141L11.8906 8.75781L18.9766 18.125H13.4297L9.08203 12.4453L4.11328 18.125H1.35156L7.79297 10.7617L1 1.875H6.6875L10.6133 7.06641L15.1563 1.875ZM14.1875 16.4766H15.7148L5.85547 3.4375H4.21484L14.1875 16.4766Z" fill="%23bfbfbf"/></svg>') no-repeat center;background-size:contain;width:20px;height:20px;display:block;margin:0 auto;position:relative}.huge-menu .social-links__link:hover span.fa-twitter:before{background:url('data:image/svg+xml,<svg width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><path d="M15.1563 1.875H17.9141L11.8906 8.75781L18.9766 18.125H13.4297L9.08203 12.4453L4.11328 18.125H1.35156L7.79297 10.7617L1 1.875H6.6875L10.6133 7.06641L15.1563 1.875ZM14.1875 16.4766H15.7148L5.85547 3.4375H4.21484L14.1875 16.4766Z" fill="%23ff4c00"/></svg>') no-repeat center}.huge-menu .social-links__link.share-instagram{font-size:18px;padding-left:4px}.huge-menu .fa-tumblr:before{font-family:"FontAwesome",sans-serif;content:"\f09e"}.huge-menu .fa-tiktok::before,.huge-menu .fa-threads::before{width:20px;height:20px;content:"";display:inline-flex;background-image:url('data:image/svg+xml,<svg width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 448 512" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" fill="none"><path d="M448 209.9a210.1 210.1 0 0 1 -122.8-39.3V349.4A162.6 162.6 0 1 1 185 188.3V278.2a74.6 74.6 0 1 0 52.2 71.2V0l88 0a121.2 121.2 0 0 0 1.9 22.2h0A122.2 122.2 0 0 0 381 102.4a121.4 121.4 0 0 0 67 20.1z" fill-rule="nonzero" fill="%23bfbfbf"/></svg>');background-size:contain;background-repeat:no-repeat}.huge-menu .social-links__link:hover .fa-tiktok::before{background-image:url('data:image/svg+xml,<svg width="20" height="20" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewBox="0 0 448 512" fill="none"><path d="M448 209.9a210.1 210.1 0 0 1 -122.8-39.3V349.4A162.6 162.6 0 1 1 185 188.3V278.2a74.6 74.6 0 1 0 52.2 71.2V0l88 0a121.2 121.2 0 0 0 1.9 22.2h0A122.2 122.2 0 0 0 381 102.4a121.4 121.4 0 0 0 67 20.1z" fill-rule="nonzero" fill="%23ff4c00"/></svg>')}.huge-menu .fa-threads::before{background-image:url('data:image/svg+xml, <svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 448 512" fill="none"><path d="M331.5 235.7c2.2 .9 4.2 1.9 6.3 2.8c29.2 14.1 50.6 35.2 61.8 61.4c15.7 36.5 17.2 95.8-30.3 143.2c-36.2 36.2-80.3 52.5-142.6 53h-.3c-70.2-.5-124.1-24.1-160.4-70.2c-32.3-41-48.9-98.1-49.5-169.6V256v-.2C17 184.3 33.6 127.2 65.9 86.2C102.2 40.1 156.2 16.5 226.4 16h.3c70.3 .5 124.9 24 162.3 69.9c18.4 22.7 32 50 40.6 81.7l-40.4 10.8c-7.1-25.8-17.8-47.8-32.2-65.4c-29.2-35.8-73-54.2-130.5-54.6c-57 .5-100.1 18.8-128.2 54.4C72.1 146.1 58.5 194.3 58 256c.5 61.7 14.1 109.9 40.3 143.3c28 35.6 71.2 53.9 128.2 54.4c51.4-.4 85.4-12.6 113.7-40.9c32.3-32.2 31.7-71.8 21.4-95.9c-6.1-14.2-17.1-26-31.9-34.9c-3.7 26.9-11.8 48.3-24.7 64.8c-17.1 21.8-41.4 33.6-72.7 35.3c-23.6 1.3-46.3-4.4-63.9-16c-20.8-13.8-33-34.8-34.3-59.3c-2.5-48.3 35.7-83 95.2-86.4c21.1-1.2 40.9-.3 59.2 2.8c-2.4-14.8-7.3-26.6-14.6-35.2c-10-11.7-25.6-17.7-46.2-17.8H227c-16.6 0-39 4.6-53.3 26.3l-34.4-23.6c19.2-29.1 50.3-45.1 87.8-45.1h.8c62.6 .4 99.9 39.5 103.7 107.7l-.2 .2zm-156 68.8c1.3 25.1 28.4 36.8 54.6 35.3c25.6-1.4 54.6-11.4 59.5-73.2c-13.2-2.9-27.8-4.4-43.4-4.4c-4.8 0-9.6 .1-14.4 .4c-42.9 2.4-57.2 23.2-56.2 41.8l-.1 .1z" fill-rule="nonzero" fill="%23bfbfbf" /></svg>')}.huge-menu .social-links__link:hover .fa-threads::before{background-image:url('data:image/svg+xml,<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="20" height="20" viewBox="0 0 448 512" fill="none"><path d="M331.5 235.7c2.2 .9 4.2 1.9 6.3 2.8c29.2 14.1 50.6 35.2 61.8 61.4c15.7 36.5 17.2 95.8-30.3 143.2c-36.2 36.2-80.3 52.5-142.6 53h-.3c-70.2-.5-124.1-24.1-160.4-70.2c-32.3-41-48.9-98.1-49.5-169.6V256v-.2C17 184.3 33.6 127.2 65.9 86.2C102.2 40.1 156.2 16.5 226.4 16h.3c70.3 .5 124.9 24 162.3 69.9c18.4 22.7 32 50 40.6 81.7l-40.4 10.8c-7.1-25.8-17.8-47.8-32.2-65.4c-29.2-35.8-73-54.2-130.5-54.6c-57 .5-100.1 18.8-128.2 54.4C72.1 146.1 58.5 194.3 58 256c.5 61.7 14.1 109.9 40.3 143.3c28 35.6 71.2 53.9 128.2 54.4c51.4-.4 85.4-12.6 113.7-40.9c32.3-32.2 31.7-71.8 21.4-95.9c-6.1-14.2-17.1-26-31.9-34.9c-3.7 26.9-11.8 48.3-24.7 64.8c-17.1 21.8-41.4 33.6-72.7 35.3c-23.6 1.3-46.3-4.4-63.9-16c-20.8-13.8-33-34.8-34.3-59.3c-2.5-48.3 35.7-83 95.2-86.4c21.1-1.2 40.9-.3 59.2 2.8c-2.4-14.8-7.3-26.6-14.6-35.2c-10-11.7-25.6-17.7-46.2-17.8H227c-16.6 0-39 4.6-53.3 26.3l-34.4-23.6c19.2-29.1 50.3-45.1 87.8-45.1h.8c62.6 .4 99.9 39.5 103.7 107.7l-.2 .2zm-156 68.8c1.3 25.1 28.4 36.8 54.6 35.3c25.6-1.4 54.6-11.4 59.5-73.2c-13.2-2.9-27.8-4.4-43.4-4.4c-4.8 0-9.6 .1-14.4 .4c-42.9 2.4-57.2 23.2-56.2 41.8l-.1 .1z" fill-rule="nonzero" fill="%23ff4c00"/></svg>')}@media (min-width:768px){.sticky-active .topbar--sticky{display:block}}@media (max-width:768px){svg.site_logo_menu{width:199px;height:28px}.top-menu--big-links .module-headline__text{margin-top:10px;margin-bottom:0}.top-menu--big-links .list{margin-bottom:60px}}@media (min-width:1024px){.huge-menu .site_logo_menu{width:341px;height:auto}.Top_hugeMenu{padding:37px 32px 10px!important}.Top_hugeMenu .text-element{position:relative;top:-5px}.Top_hugeMenu .rebelbar__menu-toggle{right:-6px}.top-menu--sm-links .list{margin:0;padding-bottom:28px}.top-menu--sm-links .module-headline__text{margin-bottom:8px}.huge-menu .module-headline__text{margin-bottom:8px}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_0 {margin:0;padding:16px 16px 12px 16px;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_0 {border-bottom:1px solid #404040;}}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_0 {border-bottom:1px solid #404040;padding:13px 9px 7px 15px;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_0_0_1 {font-family:'Favorit-Mono', sans-serif;font-size:12px;font-weight:normal;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:20px;padding-left:16px;display:none;vertical-align:bottom;color: #D9D9D9;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_0_0_1 {display:inline-block;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_1 {padding:16px;margin:0;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_1 {padding:16px 32px;}}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_1 {border-bottom:1px solid #404040;margin-bottom:0;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_1_1 {padding-top:10px;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_1_1 {padding-top:0;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_1_1 a {display:block;font-size:32px;line-height:36px;font-family:'Favorit-Pro-Light', sans-serif;letter-spacing:-0.015625em;padding:8px 0;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_1_1 a {font-size:28px;letter-spacing:-0.008928571428571428em;line-height:32px;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2 {padding:0;margin:0;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2 {border-left:1px solid #404040;border-right:1px solid #404040;margin-right:-1px;width:24.5%;padding-bottom:35px;}}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2 {border-right:1px solid #404040;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_0 {border-bottom:1px solid #404040;padding:16px;margin:0;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_0_1 {padding-bottom:22px;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_1 {padding:16px;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_1 {border-bottom:1px solid #404040;margin-bottom:0;}}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_1_1 {padding-bottom:12px;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_2 {padding:16px;margin:0;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_2 {display:none;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3 {padding:0;border-left:1px solid #404040;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3 {width:25.5%;}}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3 {margin-bottom:0;padding-bottom:20px;border-left:0;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_0 {border-bottom:1px solid #404040;padding:16px;margin:0;display:none;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_0 {display:block;}}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_0_1 {padding-bottom:13px;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_1 {padding:16px;border-bottom:1px solid #404040;margin:0;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_1 {border:none;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_2 {border-bottom:1px solid #404040;padding:16px 16px 35px;margin:0;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_2 {display:none;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_3 {padding:16px 32px 16px 16px;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_3 {display:none;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_3_1 {color:#D9D9D9;font-family:'Favorit-Mono', sans-serif;font-size:14px;font-weight:300;letter-spacing:0;line-height:20px;padding:5px 0 30px;}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_3_2 {display:inline-block;}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_4 {padding:0;border-top:1px solid #404040;display:none;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_4 {display:block;}}#s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_5 {padding:0;border-top:1px solid #404040;}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0 {margin:0;position:relative;z-index:10;padding:16px 0;}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0 {margin:auto;padding:22px 35px 12px;justify-content:space-between;box-sizing:border-box;color:#BFBFBF;font-family:'Favorit-Mono',sans-serif;font-size:12px;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0 {padding:18px 17px;}}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0.row-wrapper {padding:0px 0px 20px 0px;}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0 {font-size:12px;}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_0 {margin:0;}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_0_0 {margin:0;}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_0_0 a {color:#8C8C8C;font-size:12px;text-decoration:none;font-family:'Favorit-Mono',sans-serif;text-transform:uppercase;letter-spacing:0.064em;}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_0_0 a:last-child {border:0;}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_0_0 a:hover {text-decoration:underline;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_0_0 a {border:none;display:block;padding:7px 0px;font-size:11px;letter-spacing:0.12em;}}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_1 {line-height:1.5em;margin-bottom:6px;margin-top:21px;}@media (min-width: 1024px) {#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_1 {line-height:1.5em;margin:0px 0 20px 0px;max-width:1240px;}}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_1 {margin-top:21px;line-height:1.5em;margin-bottom:6px;}}#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_1 {float:right;max-width:111px;position:absolute;right:35px;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_1 {margin:5px 15px 0 0;max-width:111px;right:3px;}}#s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0 {background-color:#1A1A1A;max-width:630px;}#s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0_2 {padding:10px 20px;display:none;}#s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0_2_0 a {color:white;font-family:'Favorit-Mono',sans-serif;font-size:12px;line-height:12px;text-decoration:none;padding:10px;border-radius:5px;}#s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0_2_0 a:last-child {border:0;}#s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0_3 {padding:10px 20px;display:none;}#s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0_3_0 a {color:white;font-family:'Favorit-Mono',sans-serif;font-size:12px;line-height:12px;text-decoration:none;padding:10px;border-radius:5px;}#s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0_3_0 a:last-child {border:0;}.gated-popup{position:fixed;top:0;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;z-index:10000;background:rgba(20,20,20,0.9);align-items:center;justify-content:center;display:none;margin:0px!important;padding:20px}.gated-popup a{text-decoration:underline;text-decoration-color:#ff4c00;text-underline-position:under;color:inherit}.gated-popup a:hover{color:#ff4c00}.popup-gated-h2{color:#bfbfbf;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-weight:300;font-size:18px;letter-spacing:-0.2px;line-height:22px}.popup-heading-h2{font-size:32px;font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif;letter-spacing:-0.5px;line-height:36px;color:#f2f2f2;margin:0;max-width:500px}.for_pdf .popup_links.for_pdf,.for_save .popup_links.for_save,.for_ebooks .popup_links.for_ebooks,.for_pdf_issues .popup_links.for_pdf_issues,.for_nxtbook .popup_links.for_nxtbook,.for_follow_topics .popup_links.for_follow_topics,.for_comments .popup_links.for_comments,.for_member_content .popup_links.for_member_content,.for_pdf .popup-heading-h2.for_pdf,.for_save .popup-heading-h2.for_save,.for_ebooks .popup-heading-h2.for_ebooks,.for_pdf_issues .popup-heading-h2.for_pdf_issues,.for_nxtbook .popup-heading-h2.for_nxtbook,.for_follow_topics .popup-heading-h2.for_follow_topics,.for_comments .popup-heading-h2.for_comments,.for_member_content .popup-heading-h2.for_member_content,.for_pdf .popup-gated-h2.for_pdf,.for_save .popup-gated-h2.for_save,.for_ebooks .popup-gated-h2.for_ebooks,.for_pdf_issues .popup-gated-h2.for_pdf_issues,.for_nxtbook .popup-gated-h2.for_nxtbook,.for_follow_topics .popup-gated-h2.for_follow_topics,.for_comments .popup-gated-h2.for_comments,.for_member_content .popup-gated-h2.for_member_content{display:block!important}.gated-popup__contents{position:relative;overflow:hidden;padding:20px 25px 40px;max-width:480px;width:100%;box-sizing:border-box}.gated-popup__close{position:absolute;color:#000;font-size:23px;border-radius:50%;width:40px;line-height:40px;text-align:center;right:10px;top:13px;background:transparent;border:none;height:54px}.gated-popup__close:focus{outline:5px auto #2684b1}.gated-popup--shown{display:block;display:-webkit-box;display:-moz-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:-webkit-flex;display:flex}#s__Session_Popup_0_0_36_0_0_0_0 {background-color:#1A1A1A;max-width:736px;}#s__Session_Popup_0_0_36_0_0_0_0_2_0 {margin:32px 0 0;}#s__Session_Popup_0_0_36_0_0_0_0_2_0 a {color:white;font-family:'Favorit-Mono',sans-serif;font-size:12px;line-height:16px;text-decoration:none;padding:8px 12px;border-radius:5px;letter-spacing:0.0625em;}#s__Session_Popup_0_0_36_0_0_0_0_2_0 a:last-child {border:0;padding:7px 11px;}.lightbox-popup{position:fixed;top:0;left:0;right:0;bottom:0;z-index:10000;background:rgba(20,20,20,0.9);align-items:center;justify-content:center;display:none;margin:0px!important;padding:16px}.lightbox-popup a{text-decoration:underline;text-decoration-color:#ff4c00;text-underline-offset:2px;text-decoration-thickness:1px;color:inherit}.lightbox-popup a:hover{color:#ff4c00}.popup-ligtbox-h2{color:#bfbfbf;font-family:"Favorit-Pro",sans-serif;font-weight:300;font-size:18px;letter-spacing:-0.011111111111111112em;line-height:22px}.popup-heading-h2{font-size:24px;font-family:"Favorit-Pro-Light",sans-serif;letter-spacing:-0.010416666666666666em;line-height:28px;color:#f2f2f2;margin:0;max-width:260px;margin-right:24px}.lightbox-popup__contents{position:relative;overflow:hidden;padding:24px 24px 32px;max-width:480px;width:100%;box-sizing:border-box}.lightbox-popup__close{position:absolute;color:#000;font-size:23px;border-radius:50%;width:40px;height:40px;line-height:40px;text-align:center;right:0;top:19px}.lightbox-popup--shown{display:block;display:-webkit-box;display:-moz-box;display:-ms-flexbox;display:-webkit-flex;display:flex}.popup_links .list .list__item:nth-child(2){margin-left:16px}@media (max-width:768px){.popup-heading-h2{max-width:250px}.icon-close:before,.icon-close:after{height:24px;left:auto}a.js--close-lightbox.lightbox-popup__close.icon-close.hide-text{padding-right:12px}}@media (min-width:1024px){.popup-heading-h2{font-size:32px;letter-spacing:-0.015625em;line-height:36px;max-width:500px}.lightbox-popup__close{right:10px}.lightbox-popup__contents{padding-bottom:48px}}.feature_post_full .row{overflow:unset}.rblad-ieee_infinite_new{border-bottom:1px solid silver;padding-bottom:30px;position:relative;background-color:#ecece8;z-index:10000}@media (min-width:1024px){.rblad-ieee_infinite_new:after{content:"";display:block;background-color:#ecece9;height:30px;width:100%;position:absolute;bottom:-31px}}.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description .ieee-editors-note:first-letter {font-size:inherit}.body-description>p:first-child strong,.body-description .widget__brief:first-child strong{text-transform:uppercase;font-family:"Favorit-Pro"}.body-description .drop-caps strong:first-child{text-transform:uppercase;font-family:"Favorit-Pro"}.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description:first-letter ,.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description .drop-caps:first-letter {float:left;font-family:"Favorit-Pro";font-weight:400;margin-bottom:0}@media (min-width:1024px){.Vertical.feature_post_full .widget__subheadline{padding-bottom:560px}.Vertical.feature_post_full .widget .widget__body:last-child{padding-left:32px;padding-right:32px;width:inherit}.feature_post_full.current_post .tags{margin:auto;padding:0 40px 29px;max-width:768px;border-left:1px solid #bfbfbf;border-right:1px solid #bfbfbf;box-sizing:border-box}.feature_post_full.current_post .tags:before{padding-top:16px;border-top:1px solid #bdbdbd}.feature_post_full.current_post .tags:after{content:"";padding-bottom:48px;border-bottom:1px solid #bdbdbd;display:block}.container_feature_below{padding-bottom:32px;margin-bottom:64px}.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description{margin-top:65px;padding-left:56px;padding-right:56px}.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description:first-letter ,.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description .drop-caps:first-letter {font-size:120px;margin:46px 21px 20px 0}.feature_post_full .widget__subheadline{margin-bottom:16px}.feature_post_full .widget .widget__body:first-child{padding-bottom:22px}}@media (min-width:1376px){.feature_post_full.current_post .tags{padding:0 56px;max-width:992px}.container_feature_below{padding-left:56px;padding-right:56px}}@media (min-width:768px){.container_feature_below{padding-top:10px}.container_feature_below .tags{padding-top:24px}}@media (max-width:767px){.body.expanded .widget__show-more{padding:0;margin-bottom:-14px}.container_feature_below{overflow:hidden}.comment--item-message.comment--item-message,.comment--item-message.comment--item-message p:first-child{margin-top:0!important}.comment--item-message.comment--item-message p{margin:15px 0 0!important}.comment--custom-field-grade{visibility:hidden;position:relative!important;top:-40px}.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description:first-letter ,.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description .drop-caps:first-letter {font-size:96px;margin:36px 21px 0 0;font-weight:900}.body-description .widget__brief:first-child strong{font-size:16px;line-height:28px}.container_feature_below .article_post .row{margin:0}.container_feature_below .article_post .row .rm-col-center{padding:0;margin:auto}.container_feature_below .article_post .tags{padding:20px 16px 40px}.tags .tags__item{line-height:normal;margin-bottom:4px}}@media (max-width:727px){#top_leaderboard{height:100px}.top-leader-container{height:128px}}@media (min-width:728px){#top_leaderboard{height:90px}}.top-leader-container{width:calc(100% - 64px)}@media (min-width:769px){.feature_post_full .widget__head .rm-lazyloadable-image{max-width:none;height:100%;object-fit:cover}}@media (min-width:768px) and (max-width:1023px){.comment--item-avatar img{width:64px!important;height:64px!important}.container_feature_below .tags{margin-top:36px;padding-top:24px;padding-bottom:39px}.comment-header{right:32px}.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description:first-letter ,.feature_post_full.current_post .widget .widget__body:last-child .body-description .drop-caps:first-letter {font-size:108px;margin:46px 21px 0 0}.sm-mt-1>*:empty{margin-top:0}.feature_post_full .widget .body{margin-top:0}}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0 .custom-field-FullwidthCardColor {display:none;}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0 .custom-field-FullwidthCardPosition {display:none;}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0 .custom-field-FeaturePostColor {display:none;}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0 .custom-field-FeaturePostImgPosition {display:none;}
@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0 {margin-bottom:10px;}}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_0 {width:100%;}
#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_1_1_0 {width:100%;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_1_1_0 {margin-bottom:20px;}}
#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_0:before {color:#404040;content:"READ ALSO";font-family:'Favorit-Mono',sans-serif;font-size:12px;letter-spacing:0.75px;line-height:16px;display:inline-block;margin-bottom:16px;}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_0 {border-bottom: 1px solid #bdbdbd;;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_0:before {padding:16px;}}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_0 .widget {margin:0px;padding:16px 0;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_0 .widget {padding:16px;}}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_0 .widget .widget__headline-text {font-family:'Favorit-Pro', sans-serif;font-size:24px;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:-0.25px;line-height:26px;}
#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_1 {border-bottom:1px solid #bdbdbd;;}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_1 .widget {margin:0px;padding:16px 0;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_1 .widget {padding:16px;}}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_1 .widget .widget__headline-text {font-family:'Favorit-Pro', sans-serif;font-size:24px;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:-0.25px;line-height:26px;}
#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_2 .widget {margin:0px;padding:16px 0;}@media (min-width: 0) and (max-width: 767px) {#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_2 .widget {padding:16px;}}#sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_2 .widget .widget__headline-text {font-family:'Favorit-Pro', sans-serif;font-size:24px;font-weight:bold;letter-spacing:-0.25px;line-height:26px;}.lightbox_icon{cursor:pointer;position:relative}.lightbox_icon:before{right:0;top:0;content:"";z-index:3;position:absolute;padding:30px;margin:14px;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg%20width%3D%2260%22%20height%3D%2260%22%20viewBox%3D%220%200%20256%20256%22%20xmlns%3D%22http://www.w3.org/2000/svg%22%3E%3Ccircle%20cx%3D%22128%22%20cy%3D%22128%22%20r%3D%22128%22%20fill%3D%22black%22%20fill-opacity%3D%220.4%22/%3E%3Cg%20transform%3D%22translate(51.2%2C51.2)%20scale(0.6)%22%3E%3Cpath%20fill%3D%22white%22%20d%3D%22M10.3%2C30.3c-0.2%2C0.1-0.3%2C15-0.3%2C33v32.7h4.6h4.6l0-1.5c0-0.8%2C0-13.5%2C0.1-28.2l0.1-26.7l28.2-0.1L76%2C39.3v-4.6V30H43.3C25.3%2C30%2C10.5%2C30.1%2C10.3%2C30.3zM180.5%2C34.6v4.6h28.1h28.1v28.3v28.3h4.6h4.6V63V30h-32.8h-32.8L180.5%2C34.6L180.5%2C34.6zM10.1%2C192.9l0.1%2C32.9l32.9%2C0.1L76%2C226v-4.6v-4.6l-28.2-0.1l-28.2-0.1l-0.1-25.1c0-13.8-0.1-26.5-0.1-28.2l0-3.1h-4.6H10L10.1%2C192.9zM236.7%2C188.4v28.3h-28.1h-28.1v4.6v4.6h32.8H246v-33v-33h-4.6h-4.6L236.7%2C188.4L236.7%2C188.4z%22/%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/svg%3E")}.rm-float-left.lightbox_icon::before{top:-14px}.custom-field-lightbox-img-shortcode-ids,.lightbox.lightbox_icon:before{display:none}.fixed_scrolling{overflow:hidden}.lightbox-layout{position:fixed;right:0;bottom:0;top:0;left:0;display:none;margin:0px!important;z-index:300;background:rgba(20,20,20)}.lightbox .share-tab-img{display:block}.lightbox{top:50%;left:50%;transform:translate(-50%,-50%);position:fixed;z-index:10000;margin:auto;cursor:initial;width:auto!important}.lightbox img{margin:auto;padding-bottom:0;max-width:100vw!important;max-height:100vh!important;width:auto!important;height:auto!important;box-sizing:border-box}.lightbox__close{position:absolute;color:#fff;font-size:23px;border-radius:50%;width:40px;height:40px;line-height:40px;text-align:center;right:10px;top:13px;cursor:pointer}.lightbox--shown{display:block}.lightbox--shown h3,.lightbox--shown ul,.lightbox--shown p,.lightbox--shown blockquote{display:none}.lightbox--shown .media-caption p,.lightbox--shown .media-photo-credit p{display:table-cell}.lightbox--shown .image-media.media-caption{padding-right:10px;white-space:nowrap;max-width:450px;overflow:hidden;text-overflow:ellipsis;display:inline-block}.lightbox--shown .image-media.media-caption,.lightbox--shown .image-media.media-photo-credit{text-align:left;color:#BFBFBF;font-size:14px;line-height:16px;vertical-align:top}.lightbox--shown .image-media.media-caption a,.lightbox--shown .image-media.media-photo-credit a{vertical-align:top}.lightbox--shown .image-media.media-photo-credit{color:#737373;font-size:12px}@media print{.topbar,.huge-menu,.gdpr-cookie,.gated-popup,.rblad-ieee_welcome_interstitial,.rblad-ieee_infinite_leaderboard,.rblad-ieee_infinite_new,.rblad-ieee_in_content,.rblad-ieee_mobile_sticky,.top-leader-container,.container_feature_below,.around-the-web,.time-to-read,.like-button,.widget__shares,.user-prefs,.trending_stories_carousel,.trending-stories__headline-wrapper,.tags,.after_main_article_content,.trending_stories_row,.widget_column,.tag_column,.article__comments,.read_also_posts,.post-author-list,.lightbox_icon:before,.footer{display:none!important}html,body,.main,.all-content-wrapper{background:#FFF!important}body{position:absolute!important;top:0!important;left:0!important}.main{max-width:100%!important;width:100%!important;display:block!important;background-color:#FFF!important;position:relative;left:0;top:0}.all-content-wrapper{background-color:#FFF!important;border:none!important;position:relative!important;left:0!important;top:120px!important}.all-content-wrapper:before{width:100%!important;border-bottom:1px solid black!important;height:100px!important;display:block;position:absolute;left:0;top:-120px!important;-webkit-print-color-adjust:exact;print-color-adjust:exact;z-index:999;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:contain;content:"";background-image:url(https://assets.rbl.ms/32925844/origin.png)}.widget__head,.widget__body:first-child,.widget__body:last-child{width:100%!important;background:#FFF!important}.widget__headline,.widget__subheadline{color:#000!important;text-transform:none!important;padding-bottom:0!important;border-bottom:none!important;padding:0!important}.all-related-sections,.social-author,.social-date{padding:0!important}.all-related-sections a[href*="/topic/"],.all-related-sections a[href*="/type/"]{border:none!important;color:#000!important;padding:0 16px 0 0!important;margin-right:0!important}.social-author:before,.social-author__name,.social-date{color:#000!important}.photo-credit{color:#000!important}.body-description{max-width:100%!important;width:100%!important}*{color:#000!important;border:none!important;box-shadow:none!important;text-shadow:none!important}*:after,*:before{color:#000!important;border:none!important}.rebellt-item{display:block;clear:both;width:100%;height:auto}.article_column{width:100%!important;border:none!important}.featured_columns{border:none!important;margin:0!important;padding:0!important}.posts-custom .posts-wrapper .widget{padding:0!important}.current_post_content{width:100%!important;padding:0!important}.row-wrapper,.rm-col-center{margin:0!important;padding:0!important}@page{size:8.5in 11in;margin:2cm;margin-bottom:30mm!important}.embed-media,.widget__body{break-inside:avoid;break-after:always;width:600px!important;height:auto}body,.posts-wrapper,.row,.row.px10{background:#FFF!important}img{break-inside:avoid!important;display:block!important;max-width:100%!important}.body-description a,.body-description a u{text-decoration-color:#8f8f8f!important;text-underline-offset:1px!important;text-decoration-thickness:1px!important}.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline-text:before,.featured_post .widget__subheadline-text:before,.article_post .widget__subheadline-text:before,.story_teaser .widget__subheadline-text:before{-webkit-print-color-adjust:exact;print-color-adjust:exact}h2,h3,h4,h5,h6{break-after:avoid}ul,ol,img,table{break-inside:avoid}.body-description>p:first-child:first-line ,.body-description div:not(.content-container) p:first-child:first-line {font-weight:800!important;text-transform:uppercase!important;font-family:"Favorit-Pro"!important}.body-description>p:first-child:first-letter ,.body-description div:not(.content-container) p:first-child:first-letter {font-size:120px!important;float:left!important;font-family:"Favorit-Pro"!important;font-weight:400!important;margin:42px 16px 16px 0!important}.post__last-point,.ieee-end-mark{background-color:#343434}.body-description,.widget__body,.ieee-sidebar-large,.ieee-sidebar-medium,.ieee-sidebar-small{margin:0!important;padding:0!important}.rm-resized-container-25 img{width:600px!important;height:auto;float:none;clear:both;display:block!important}.rm-float-left{float:none!important;clear:both}.pull-quote:before,.ieee-pullquote:before,.ieee-pullquote-fullwidth:before,.ieee-pullquote-left:before{filter:brightness(0%);-webkit-print-color-adjust:exact;print-color-adjust:exact}}.comment--item-toolbar{padding:10px;}.comment--item-text-field .ProseMirror:focus{outline:none;}.comment--item-text-field .ProseMirror-menubar{background:transparent;border:0px;bottom:-37px !important;box-shadow:none;display:inline-block;min-height:22px;left:7px !important;padding:0px !important;position:absolute !important;right:auto;top:auto !important;visibility:visible !important;width:auto !important;}.comment--item-text-field .ProseMirror-icon.ProseMirror-menu-active{outline:0;background-color:#ccc;color:#444;}.comment--item-text-field .ProseMirror-menuitem div:hover{background-color:#1f78d8;color:#fff;outline:0;}.comment--item-word-count{color:#666;font-size:0.9em;text-align:right;padding-bottom:8px;}.comment-headline{font-size:21px;margin:20px 0;font-family:"Helvetica Neue","Montserrat","Helvetica","sans-serif";font-weight:400;display:block;}.sub-headline{margin:4px 0 21px;font-size:14px;color:#666;display:block;}.comment-sort{font-size:13px;}.comment-sort select{margin-left:4px;}.comment-header{display:flex;justify-content:space-between;padding:10px 0 10px;}.comment--login--feedback{border-radius:4px;color:#333;font-size:13px;line-height:16px;margin:10px auto 10px;max-width:210px;padding:10px;text-align:center;}.comment--login--feedback.errors{background:#fbd3d3;}.comment--login--success{background-color:#dff2bf;color:#4f8a10;}.talk-comments-wrp .edit-mode .site-avatar:before{content:"Optimum size is 100x100px";font-size:13px;width:196px;display:block;text-align:left;margin:0 0 0 -26px;color:#696969;}.avatar-list{list-style:none;margin:0;padding:0;}.avatar-list li{display:inline-block;margin:0 2px;}.avatar-list .avatar-list--item-image{position:relative;z-index:3;}.avatar-list li img{width:38px;height:38px;border-radius:50%;border:2px solid transparent;box-shadow:1px 1px 1px #ccc;cursor:pointer;}.talk-linked-comment .comment--item,.talk--messages .comment--item{border-bottom:1px solid #e5e6e6;margin:0;position:relative;padding:10px 0 0 10px;}.talk-linked-comment{border:1px dashed #8dabea;position:relative;margin:0;background:transparent;}.reply-items .comment--item{border:none;padding:0;}.comment--item .comment--item--short-bio,.comment--item .talk_review,.comment--item .author-rating{font-size:12px;color:#848282;padding:3px 0;}.comment--item .material-icons{font-size:12px;vertical-align:middle;direction:rtl;overflow:hidden;}.comment-item .author-rating .wrapper__post_rating--disabled{color:#777;}.comment--item .author-rating .material-icons{color:#ffc000;}.author-rating{cursor:pointer;}.reply-items .comment--item{padding:inherit;}.comment--item{-webkit-animation:fadeInFromNone 0.3s ease-in-out;-moz-animation:fadeInFromNone 0.3s ease-in-out;-o-animation:fadeInFromNone 0.3s ease-in-out;animation:fadeInFromNone 0.3s ease-in-out;}@keyframes fadeInFromNone{0%{display:none;opacity:0;}100%{display:block;opacity:1;}}.comment--item-avatar{float:left;}.comment--item-avatar img{width:38px;height:38px;border-radius:50%;margin:0 10px 0 0;}.comment--item-avatar img[src='https://www.rebelmouse.com/res/avatars/default']{content:url(https://assets.rbl.ms/18273603/2000x.png);}.comment--item-avatar.editable img:hover{opacity:0.2;}.comment--item-avatar.editable .avatar_edit_text{display:none;}.comment--item-avatar.editable img:hover .avatar_edit_text{display:block;}.comment--item-text{overflow:hidden;background:transparent;padding:7px 9px 10px;border-radius:5px;margin-bottom:0;}.material-icons.status-featured,.material-icons.status-proposed,.material-icons.status-rejected{display:none;position:absolute;right:10px;top:10px;font-size:20px;vertical-align:middle;}.featured-comment .status-featured.selected{display:block;}.proposed-comment .status-proposed.selected{display:block;}.rejected-comment .status-rejected.selected{display:block;}.status-rejected,.status-rejected:hover{color:#b15252;}.status-proposed,.status-proposed:hover{color:#adaba9;}.status-featured,.status-featured:hover{color:#f8bb1d;}.talk--messages__featured .featured-comment{background-color:#fefcf2;}.talk__author__add{margin:10px 0 0 0;}.talk__author__add .input__star_rating{margin:-6px 0 8px 0;}.comment--item-text-input{background:#ffffff;border:2px solid #eeeeee;border-radius:4px;padding:13px 0 0;font-size:20px;overflow:hidden;margin:0 0 10px;}.comment--item-text-field{min-height:44px;padding:0 10px;font-size:15px;color:#333;}.comment--item-text-field:focus{outline:none;box-shadow:none;}.comment--item-text-field.message:before{content:"Add comment...";color:#999;}.comment--item-text-field.reply:before{content:"Reply";color:#999;}.comment--item-text-field.reply:focus:before,.comment--item-text-field.message:focus:before{content:none;}.comment--item-toolbar{background:#f1f1f1;text-align:right;padding:5px;}.comment-item--publish{background:#1c2a50;display:inline-block;line-height:26px;color:#fff;padding:0 15px;border-radius:4px;text-decoration:none;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;}.comment-item--publish:hover{background:#3984b9;color:#fff;}.comment--item-username{text-transform:uppercase;padding-right:10px;font-weight:500;font-size:13px;}.comment--item-date{color:#999;font-size:12px;white-space:nowrap;position:absolute;right:45px;margin:3px 0 0 0;}.comment--item-text .follow-wrapper{display:inline-block;vertical-align:middle;}.comment--item--action{padding-bottom:0;display:flex;justify-content:space-between;}.comment--item--action a{font-size:12px;color:#999;text-transform:uppercase;text-decoration:none;margin-right:10px;display:inline-block;}.comment--item--action .admin-controls a{margin-right:0;margin-left:5px;}.comment--item--action .selected{color:#4667be;}.action__featured.selected,.action__approved.selected{color:#479ad2;}.action__rejected.selected{color:#ff3f7f;}.comment--item--action .comment--item__share{margin-right:15px;}.comment--item--action .comment--item__tooltip_share-wrp{position:absolute;top:auto;left:106px;margin:-33px 0 0 16px;background-color:#fff;border-radius:4px;box-shadow:inset 0 0 0 1px #d4d6d7,0 2px 2px 0 rgba(0,0,0,0.1);padding:10px;z-index:1000;}.comment--item--action .comment--item__tooltip_share-wrp:focus{outline:none;}.comment--item--action .comment--item__tooltip_share{padding:0;}.comment--item--action .comment--item__tooltip_share a{margin:0;padding:0 5px;}.comment--item--action .comment--item__tooltip_share .share-tw,.comment--item--action .comment--item__tooltip_share .share-fb{background:#fff;}.comment--item__copyed-link{color:#999;font-size:12px;}.comment--item--action a:hover{color:#1c2a50;}.comment--item--action .material-icons{font-size:17px;vertical-align:middle;}.comment--item--action .comment-action-icon{fill:currentColor;font-size:17px;vertical-align:middle;}.comment--item--action .comment--item--menu svg{fill:#999;}.comment--item--action .comment-action-icon:hover{fill:#1c2a50;}.action__featured.selected .comment--item--action,.action__approved.selected .comment--item--action{fill:#479ad2;}.status-featured.selected svg{fill:#f8bb1d;}.status-rejected.selected svg,.action__rejected.selected .comment--item--action{fill:#ff3f7f;}.comment--item-message{padding:0;border-radius:4px;font-size:14px;margin:5px 0;line-height:20px;}.comment--item-message p{margin:0;}.comment--hide--replies{display:block;text-transform:capitalize;margin:0;}.level-two{margin-left:40px;margin-top:20px;}.comment--item-reply-to{color:#999;font-size:12px;padding:0 10px;}.comment--item-reply-to .material-icons{vertical-align:middle;font-size:17px;}.comment--login,.comment--signup,.comment--reset,.comment--otp{text-align:center;border:2px solid #eeeeee;background:#fff;border-radius:4px;max-width:50%;margin:0 auto 20px;padding:30px;position:relative;}.comment--login--close{position:absolute;right:10px;top:10px;color:#ccc;cursor:pointer;}.comment--login-headline{font-size:25px;padding:0 0 15px;}.comment--done-button,.comment--signup-button,.comment--login-button,.comment--reset-button{background:#1c2a50;display:block;line-height:36px;color:#fff;padding:0 15px;border-radius:4px;text-decoration:none;text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;width:200px;margin:0 auto;}.comment--done-button:disabled{opacity:0.5;}.comment--login-field{width:196px;padding:0 15px;border-radius:4px;border:2px solid #eeeeee;display:block;line-height:30px;margin:0 auto 10px;font-size:14px;}.comment--login-field.required{background:#ffe4e1;}.comment--login-headline-subheadline{margin:10px 0 15px;position:relative;}.comment--signup .avatar-list,.comment--login .avatar-list{margin:0 0 15px;}.comment--signup .avatar-list .active img,.comment--login .avatar-list .active img{border:2px solid #1c2a50;}.comment--signup .avatar-list .avatar-list--item:hover img,.comment--login .avatar-list .avatar-list--item:hover img{border:2px solid #1c2a50;}.comment--item-text-field{position:relative;}.avatar-list--item-info{position:relative;background:#ffffff;border:4px solid #f7f7f7;min-width:150px;text-align:center;padding:10px;}.avatar-list--item-info:after,.avatar-list--item-info:before{bottom:100%;left:50%;border:solid transparent;content:" ";height:0;width:0;position:absolute;pointer-events:none;}.avatar-list--item-info:after{border-color:rgba(255,255,255,0);border-bottom-color:#ffffff;border-width:12px;margin-left:-12px;}.avatar-list--item-info:before{border-color:rgba(247,247,247,0);border-bottom-color:#f7f7f7;border-width:18px;margin-left:-18px;}.avatar-list--item-drop-down{position:absolute;left:-67px;top:55px;display:none;}.avatar-list--item:hover .avatar-list--item-drop-down{display:block;}.avatar-list--username{text-transform:uppercase;font-size:12px;font-weight:bold;margin:8px 0 2px 0;}.avatar-list--role{font-size:14px;}.avatar-list--rating .material-icons{font-size:16px;margin:10px 0 0 0;color:#edb823;}.comment-text-wrapper .redactor-toolbar{bottom:-52px !important;left:7px !important;top:auto !important;visibility:visible !important;width:auto !important;display:inline-block;right:auto;background:transparent;box-shadow:none;}.comment-text-wrapper .redactor-box{margin:0;padding:0 0 0 10px;}.comment-text-wrapper .redactor-box .redactor-placeholder:after{top:0;}.comment--show--replies{text-transform:capitalize;display:block;margin-bottom:0;}.comment--hide--replies i.material-icons,.comment--show--replies i.material-icons{font-size:16px;vertical-align:middle;}.talk--load_more__replies,.comment--show--replies,.comment--hide--replies{text-align:center;position:relative;background:#fff;z-index:999;display:inline-block;border:1px solid #e5e6e6;border-radius:4px;padding:0 11px 0 4px;line-height:22px;font-size:11px;color:#666;cursor:pointer;}.replies{position:relative;text-align:center;}.reply-items{text-align:left;padding:10px 0;}.replies.level-two{margin-top:-10px;margin-bottom:-11px;padding-left:0;}.comment--login--message{font-size:12px;padding:8px 0 0;}.comment--login--message a{color:#0a7cc4;text-decoration:underline;}.comment--login--message a:hover{text-decoration:none;}.comment--login--message.requirements{color:#ed143d;}.flip-horizontal{-moz-transform:scaleX(-1);-webkit-transform:scaleX(-1);-o-transform:scaleX(-1);transform:scaleX(-1);-ms-filter:fliph;filter:fliph;}.flip-vertical{-moz-transform:scaleY(-1);-webkit-transform:scaleY(-1);-o-transform:scaleY(-1);transform:scaleY(-1);-ms-filter:flipv;filter:flipv;}.comment--item--menu{display:inline-block;padding:0 0 0 12px;}.comment--item--menu .material-icons{font-size:17px;color:#666;cursor:pointer;}.comment--item--menu--drop-down{position:absolute;background:#fff;top:auto;bottom:25px;z-index:99;width:auto;right:1px;padding:9px 18px;box-shadow:0 1px 5px #ccc;line-height:23px;color:#666;text-transform:capitalize;font-size:12px;display:none;}.comment--item--action .comment--item--menu--drop-down a{text-transform:none;white-space:nowrap;margin:0;}.comment--item--menu:hover .comment--item--menu--drop-down{display:block;}.comment--signup .community-site-logo{width:90px;height:90px;border-radius:50%;background-size:cover;background-position:center;margin:0 auto 5px;}.comment--signup .site-avatar-edit{min-height:150px;}.comment--signup .site-avatar .input-data{display:none;}.community-site-logo .hover-menu.edit{background:url("/static/img/sprites/icons-buttons.png?3") -125px -214px;width:72px;height:72px;border-radius:50%;font-size:0;vertical-align:top;}.comment--login-headline-subheadline .fake-input{display:block;width:80px;height:140px;overflow:hidden;z-index:99;left:0 !important;opacity:0;position:absolute;margin:0 auto !important;right:0;top:-115px !important;}.comment--item-avatar .comment--login-headline-subheadline .fake-input{width:60px;height:60px;top:-60px !important;}.comment--login-headline-subheadline .fake-input input,.comment--login-headline-subheadline .fake-input input::-webkit-file-upload-button{cursor:pointer;}.comment--signup .fake-input input{display:none;}.talk-comments-wrp .community-site-logo .edit-mode .image-by-url{-moz-border-radius:0;-webkit-border-radius:0;border-radius:0;-webkit-box-shadow:none;-moz-box-shadow:none;box-shadow:none;padding:17px 15px 17px;vertical-align:top;font:18px "PT Sans",Tahoma,sans-serif;width:250px;}.community-site-logo .edit-mode .site-avatar{max-width:600px;max-height:none;margin:0 auto;}.community-site-logo .edit-mode .avatar-form{display:inline-block;}.talk-comments-wrp .community-site-logo .edit-mode .or{color:#a8a8a8;padding:0 11px;text-transform:uppercase;}.talk-comments-wrp .community-site-logo .edit-mode .buttons{padding:83px;}.talk-comments-wrp .community-site-logo .edit-mode .add-image-by-src{padding:18px 21px 17px;}.talk-comments-wrp .community-site-logo .edit-mode .add-image-by-src .upload-arrow{margin:4px 0 3px;display:block;height:12px;width:12px;background-image:url("/static/img/roar/icons.png?31");background-position:-382px -135px;background-size:458px 225px;}.talk-comments-wrp .community-site-logo .edit-mode .ch-cover-upload,.talk-comments-wrp .community-site-logo .edit-mode .buttons .btn{width:175px;margin:0 5px;background:#5d97ce;color:#fff;padding:5px 10px;border-radius:3px;font-size:12px;text-transform:uppercase;}.talk-comments-wrp .community-site-logo .edit-mode label{margin:20px 0 35px;font-size:24px;}.community-native-js-wrp .disabled,.community-native-wrp .disabled{opacity:0.6;}.comment--item--action a.disabled{opacity:0.5;cursor:progress;}.talk--load_more-wrp{text-align:center;}.talks--load_more{background:#8db7e0;border:1px solid #8db7e0;border-radius:3px;color:white;cursor:pointer;font-size:13px;font-weight:500;padding:0;text-transform:uppercase;line-height:35px;position:relative;z-index:1;margin:30px 0 0 0;text-align:center;}.talks--load_more:hover{background:#5e99d4;}.community-site-logo.logo-preview .circle-loader{margin:0 auto;height:85px;width:85px;}.community-native-wrp .circle-loader-box{background:rgba(255,255,255,0.9);z-index:7;min-height:200px;display:flex;justify-content:center;align-items:center;margin-top:-60px;}.community-native-wrp .circle-loader{border:2px solid rgba(0,0,0,0.2);border-left-color:#479ad2;animation-name:loader-spin;animation-duration:1s;animation-iteration-count:infinite;animation-timing-function:linear;position:relative;display:block;vertical-align:top;margin:0;}.community-native-wrp .circle-loader,.community-native-wrp .circle-loader:after{border-radius:50%;width:40px;height:40px;}.community-native-wrp .comment--item-avatar.editable .circle-loader,.community-native-wrp .comment--item-avatar.editable .circle-loader:after{margin-top:-40px;width:38px;height:38px;margin-left:-2px;}@keyframes loader-spin{0%{transform:rotate(0deg);}100%{transform:rotate(360deg);}}@keyframes checkmark{0%{height:0;width:0;opacity:1;}20%{height:0;width:2em;opacity:1;}40%{height:4em;width:2em;opacity:1;}100%{height:4em;width:2em;opacity:1;}}@media only screen and (max-width:768px){.replies.level-two{margin-top:0;margin-bottom:0;padding-left:0;}.comment--login,.comment--signup{max-width:100%;}}.comment_placeholder-wrp{background:#f1f1f1;width:100%;height:94px;}.animated-background{animation-duration:1s;animation-fill-mode:forwards;animation-iteration-count:infinite;animation-name:placeHolderShimmer;animation-timing-function:linear;background:#f6f7f8;background:linear-gradient(to right,#eeeeee 8%,#dddddd 18%,#eeeeee 33%);background-size:800px 104px;height:94px;position:relative;border-radius:4px;padding-top:1px;}.placeholder__textarea_top{background:white;height:15px;margin:2px 2px 0 2px;}.placeholder__textarea_botmiddle_left{background:white;height:20px;margin:0 2px;width:10px;display:inline-block;}.placeholder__textarea_botmiddle_right{background:white;height:20px;margin:-28px 2px 0 117px;}.placeholder__textarea_bottom{background:white;height:15px;margin:0 2px 2px 2px;}.placeholder__button_b{background:#dadada;height:26px;width:20px;border-radius:4px;margin-top:6px;margin-bottom:8px;margin-left:19px;display:inline-block;}.placeholder__button_i{background:#dadada;height:26px;width:20px;border-radius:4px;margin-top:6px;margin-bottom:8px;margin-left:19px;display:inline-block;}.placeholder__button_publish{background:#1c2a50;height:26px;margin:0 2px 2px 2px;opacity:0.5;width:83px;border-radius:4px;margin-top:6px;float:right;margin-right:5px;margin-bottom:8px;}@keyframes placeHolderShimmer{0%{background-position:-468px 0;}100%{background-position:468px 0;}}.talk--messages .follow-button,.comment--item .comment--user-follow{color:#479ad2;font-size:14px;text-align:center;width:auto;border-radius:0;background:none;transition:unset;text-indent:unset;font-weight:bold;margin:0;height:17px;position:static;border:0;cursor:pointer;}.talk--messages .follow-button:hover{background:none;opacity:0.6;}.talk__review{font-weight:900;padding:8px 0;}.talk__review .wrapper__post_rating{cursor:default;}.input__post_rating_total{font-weight:900;padding:0 12px;}.input__post_rating_count{font-weight:400;}.wrapper__post_rating{cursor:pointer;}.wrapper__post_rating--disabled{cursor:default;}.input__post_rating_item svg,.input__post_rating_item--active svg{vertical-align:middle;fill:#ffc000;width:18px;height:18px;}.wrapper__post_rating--disabled i svg{fill:#777;}.input__post_rating_item .icon__star_empty,.input__post_rating_item--active .icon__star_full{display:inline;}.input__post_rating_item--active .icon__star_empty,.input__post_rating_item .icon__star_full{display:none;}.talk__author__add .talk__avatar .comment--item-avatar .fake-input{width:40px;}.comment--item-text .wrapper__post_rating--disabled i svg{height:12px;width:12px;}
</style><style class="rm-i-styles rm-component-css">
</style><script class="rm-i-script">
window.REBELMOUSE_LOW_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function() {
if(window.REBELMOUSE_BOOTSTRAP_DATA.engine.enableRunnerCss){
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.loadExternalStylesheet("/static/css-build/roar/runner/social-ux-non-critical.css?v=rmxassets9f85b614d0482c26a5f33e04e87319ff", function(){
document.body.classList.add("rm-non-critical-loaded");
});
}
});
</script><script class="rm-i-script">
var __RUNNER_PUBLIC__ = {
root: '#runner-root',
events: {
PAGE_VIEW: 'page_view.url_change.listicle_switch_page',
URL_CHANGE_PAGE_VIEW: 'page_view.url_change',
LISTICLE_CHANGE_PAGE_VIEW: 'page_view.listicle_switch_page'
}
}
</script><script class="rm-i-script">
window.__rebelmouseJsBaseUrl = "/static/js-build/";
window.__rebelmousePrimaryColor = "#FF4C00";
</script><link rel="apple-touch-icon" href="https://assets.rebelmouse.io/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjU5NjY0OS9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTg0ODgxODUwNn0.1LlzHtxZSVXyzapxWjeSrRIRu5qo3CeB8FaWpd2tl_o/img.png?width=192&height=192" sizes="192x192"/><link rel="icon" type="image/png" href="https://assets.rebelmouse.io/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjU5NjY0OS9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTg0ODgxODUwNn0.1LlzHtxZSVXyzapxWjeSrRIRu5qo3CeB8FaWpd2tl_o/img.png?width=48&height=48" sizes="48x48"/><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="socialux" data-abtest-value="1"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_socialux" data-abtest-value="1"></script><meta property="article:published_time" content="2019-04-18T19:49:00+00:00"/><meta property="article:modified_time" content="2024-02-03T22:03:05+00:00"/><meta property="article:author" content="https://www.facebook.com/48576411181"/><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="itms"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="itms"></script><meta name="fediverse:creator" content="@ieeespectrum@mastodon.social"/><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="gated" data-abtest-value="fix"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_gated" data-abtest-value="fix"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="IEEE" data-abtest-value="2572"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_IEEE" data-abtest-value="2572"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="IEEE" data-abtest-value="2579"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_IEEE" data-abtest-value="2579"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="ieee" data-abtest-value="2490v2"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_ieee" data-abtest-value="2490v2"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="1"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="1"></script><link data-rh="true" rel="alternate" type="application/json+oembed" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/r/kappa/api/v2/reader/oembed_json?url=https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer" title="How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Developer"/><script>
window.postid = "2650278376";
window.category = ["aerospace","feature"];
window.tags = ["aviation","software","airbus","boeing","737-max"];
window.custom_tags = ["aviation", "software", "airbus", "boeing", "fly-by-wire", "737 max", "~rmsc:rebelmouse-image:25588398", "~rmsc:rebelmouse-image:25588399", "~rmsc:rebelmouse-image:25588396", "Technology \u0026 Computing", "Automotive", "Business and Finance", "Travel", "News and Politics", "Personal Finance", "Education", "Computing", "Business", "Economy", "Industries", "Auto Technology", "Budget Cars", "Luxury Cars", "Aviation Industry", "Technology Industry", "Manufacturing Industry", "Business Administration", "Large Business", "Sales", "Logistics"]
console.log('tags - ', window.custom_tags)
</script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="FA" data-abtest-value="709"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_FA" data-abtest-value="709"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v" data-abtest-value="cwvfix"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_v" data-abtest-value="cwvfix"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="IEEE" data-abtest-value="2452"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_IEEE" data-abtest-value="2452"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="IEEE" data-abtest-value="2"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_IEEE" data-abtest-value="2"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="IEEE" data-abtest-value="2453"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_IEEE" data-abtest-value="2453"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="xsmall"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="xsmall"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="job"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="job"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="anbar" data-abtest-value="off"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_anbar" data-abtest-value="off"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="anbar" data-abtest-value="on"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_anbar" data-abtest-value="on"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="footerfixes"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="footerfixes"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="ppid" data-abtest-value="link"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_ppid" data-abtest-value="link"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="IEEE" data-abtest-value="7"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_IEEE" data-abtest-value="7"></script><meta name="google-site-verification" content="TL2pz9TZSlPds24a3mqZClMC79zWmgOKFwO4aYRjdXk"/><meta name="facebook-domain-verification" content="bgsalp9vtqx07wdoczkh2jq79qvonr"/><meta property="fb:pages" content="48576411181"/><meta name="google-site-verification" content="L-skWDKE3KKfxCj4MKcOwZUVoZ1L_MkSRLAsNxx-JIw"/><meta name="google-site-verification" content="CTQnzy87CzDH0ZMNer4KvBtvb7X0tiJoehjRFhqPCis"/><meta name="google-site-verification" content="TL2pz9TZSlPds24a3mqZClMC79zWmgOKFwO4aYRjdXk"/><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="noad"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="noad"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="4"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="4"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="also"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="also"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="3"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="3"></script><style class="rm-i-styles" id="custom-post-styles-2650278376">
</style><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v" data-abtest-value="share"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_v" data-abtest-value="share"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="postidall"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="postidall"></script><meta name="parsely-post-id" content="2650278376"/><meta name="parsely-title" content="How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Developer"/><meta name="parsely-link" content="https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer"/><meta name="parsely-section" content="Aerospace"/><meta name="parsely-tags" content="aviation,software,airbus,boeing,737-max,SpectrumType.Feature"/><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="fullscreenicon"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="fullscreenicon"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="test" data-abtest-value="blank"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_test" data-abtest-value="blank"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="smartlinks" data-abtest-value="1"></script><script type="application/json" data-abtest-name="v_smartlinks" data-abtest-value="1"></script><script class="rm-i-script">
(function() {
var cookie = 'rebelmouse_abtests=';
cookie += "v1:165477109-A:1,B:2";
cookie += '; Max-Age=604800';
document.cookie = cookie + '; Path=/; SameSite=None; Secure';
})();
</script><!--[if IE]>
<script type="text/javascript" src="/static/js-build/libs/html5shiv/html5shiv.js"></script>
<![endif]--></head><body class="logged-out-user section-aerospace"><div id="fb-root"></div><div id="runner-root"></div><div id="curtain" class="curtain"></div><nav class="menu-global"><div class="main-menu-wrapper"><div class="menu-global__search-form hide-tablet-and-desktop"><form action="/search/"><button type="submit" class="menu-global__submit fa fa-search" value="" aria-label="Submit"></button><input name="q" class="menu-global__text-input" type="text" placeholder="Search..." aria-label="Search"/></form></div><div class="divider hide-tablet-and-desktop"></div><div class="divider"></div><ul id="main-menu" class="main-menu"></ul></div></nav><div class="all-content-wrapper"><div class="main v-sep"><div class="feature_wrapper" id="sPost_0_0_16_0_0_0_0_1_4_0"><div class="menu-overlay js-toggle" data-target="body" data-share-status-id="menu-toggle" data-toggle-class="menu-opened"></div><!-- User Code --><link rel="preload" as="&#115;tyle" onload="this.rel=&#39;stylesheet&#39;" href="https://htlbid.com/v3/spectrum.ieee.org/rblbid.css"/><!-- End User Code --><!-- User Code --><script>
window.PARSELY = window.PARSELY || {};
function isPublished(post){
return [0,1,2].includes(post.status)
}
window.PARSELY.autotrack = false;
window.PARSELY.onload = function () {
if(Object.keys(window.REBELMOUSE_BOOTSTRAP_DATA.post).length > 0 && !isPublished(window.REBELMOUSE_BOOTSTRAP_DATA.post)){
return;
}
var event = {
url: location.href,
urlref: document.referrer,
js: 1
};
window.PARSELY.updateDefaults({
data: {
level: localStorage.getItem("userMembershipStatus") || "anonymous"
}
});
window.PARSELY.beacon.trackPageView(event);
};
</script><!-- End User Code --><!-- User Code --><!-- Google Tag Manager (noscript) --><noscript><iframe src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-5WJB5X2" height="0" width="0" style="display:none;visibility:hidden"></iframe></noscript><!-- End Google Tag Manager (noscript) --><!-- End User Code --><span class="viewport-css-anchor"></span><!-- User Code --><svg width="0" height="0" viewbox="0 0 20 20" fill="none" style="position: absolute"><mask id="xLogoMask" style="mask-type: alpha" maskunits="userSpaceOnUse" x="1" y="1" width="18" height="18"><path d="M15.1563 1.875H17.9141L11.8906 8.75781L18.9766 18.125H13.4297L9.08203 12.4453L4.11328 18.125H1.35156L7.79297 10.7617L1 1.875H6.6875L10.6133 7.06641L15.1563 1.875ZM14.1875 16.4766H15.7148L5.85547 3.4375H4.21484L14.1875 16.4766Z" fill="black"></path></mask></svg><!-- End User Code --><span class="viewport-css-anchor"></span><span class="viewport-css-anchor"></span><div class="topbar topbar--static" id="sTop_Bar_0_0_27_0_0_0_0_16"><div class="" id="sTop_Bar_0_0_27_0_0_0_0_16_0"><div class="dark_top_bar" id="sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1"><div class="" id="sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0"><div class="top_menu_links" id="sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_0"><div class="list" id="sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0"><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/" target="_blank">IEEE.org</a><a class="list__item" href="https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/Xplore/home.jsp" target="_blank">IEEE Xplore</a><a class="list__item" href="https://standards.ieee.org/" target="_blank">IEEE Standards</a><a class="list__item" href="https://jobs.ieee.org/" target="_blank">IEEE Job Site</a><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/sitemap.html" target="_blank">More Sites</a></div></div><div class="" id="sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1"><div class="access_links" id="sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_0_1_1"><div class="list" id="sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_0_1_1_0"><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/profile/public/createwebaccount/showCreateAccount.html?ShowMGAMarkeatbilityOptIn=true&sourceCode=spectrum&signinurl=https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/saml/main/login&url=https://spectrum.ieee.org/&autoSignin=Y&car=IEEE-Spectrum" target="_self">Sign In</a><a class="list__item" href="/join" target="_blank">Join IEEE</a></div></div><div class="" id="sElement_Bar_0_0_6_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_1"><!-- User Code --><svg width="70px" height="21px" viewbox="0 0 70 21" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><defs><polygon id="path-1" points="0 0 21.3639449 0 21.3639449 21 0 21"></polygon></defs><g id="Symbols" stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd"><g id="Light-/-IEEE-Bar-/-Signed-out-/-1376" transform="translate(-1274.000000, -14.000000)"><g id="Group-13" transform="translate(1274.000000, 14.000000)"><polygon id="Fill-1" fill="#FEFEFE" points="23.4111174 18.6889405 27.8363724 18.6889405 27.8363724 2.77905063 23.4111174 2.77905063"></polygon><polygon id="Fill-2" fill="#FEFEFE" points="29.7536549 18.6881005 29.7536549 2.77821061 41.9217005 2.77821061 41.9217005 5.8624668 34.17891 5.8624668 34.17891 9.14692664 41.3017712 9.14692664 41.3017712 12.2311828 34.17891 12.2311828 34.17891 15.6024442 41.9217005 15.6024442 41.9217005 18.6881005"></polygon><polygon id="Fill-3" fill="#FEFEFE" points="43.7923126 18.6881005 43.7923126 2.77821061 55.9603583 2.77821061 55.9603583 5.8624668 48.2175677 5.8624668 48.2175677 9.14692664 55.3418347 9.14692664 55.3418347 12.2311828 48.2175677 12.2311828 48.2175677 15.6024442 55.9603583 15.6024442 55.9603583 18.6881005"></polygon><polygon id="Fill-4" fill="#FEFEFE" points="57.8305486 2.77793061 57.8305486 18.6878205 70 18.6878205 70 15.6021642 62.2558037 15.6021642 62.2558037 12.2323028 69.3800707 12.2323028 69.3800707 9.14664663 62.2558037 9.14664663 62.2558037 5.8621868 70 5.8621868 70 2.77793061"></polygon><g id="Group-12"><g id="Group-7"><mask id="mask-2" fill="white"><use xlink:href="#path-1"></use></mask><g id="Clip-6"></g><path d="M20.9520644,9.85449953 L20.8930235,9.84469935 C19.0838421,8.61967703 17.3983653,7.23365178 15.8098843,5.66142314 L14.0555265,3.83578988 C13.3442244,3.05037557 12.6540084,2.18095973 11.9961242,1.35074461 L11.1976665,0.22232405 C11.099265,0.164923005 10.976966,0.0669212192 10.8687244,0.0375206836 C10.6339666,-0.0646811784 10.3795285,0.0571210406 10.1883485,0.202723693 L8.74184673,2.07875787 C6.42378906,4.93900998 3.67838782,7.60885862 0.684171419,9.65429588 C0.448007872,9.84049927 0.0951682866,10.0211026 0.0220700458,10.3235081 C-0.0566511366,10.596513 0.0853281388,10.8219172 0.256827858,10.9913202 C2.65360672,12.6363502 4.94776689,14.5907858 6.98748895,16.8168264 C7.35016869,17.1962333 7.64396739,17.5728401 7.99680697,17.9284466 C8.59424452,18.719461 9.29570648,19.5160755 9.84534902,20.364491 C10.0168487,20.5450943 10.0463692,20.8390996 10.3148646,20.9259012 C10.525725,20.9987026 10.785786,21.0477034 10.9868062,20.9259012 L11.1878263,20.7256976 C13.6675436,17.2256338 16.8149851,14.0825766 20.3293236,11.5429303 C20.6821632,11.2321246 21.3541047,11.1145225 21.3639449,10.5335119 C21.3386417,10.264707 21.182605,10.0015022 20.9520644,9.85449953 M18.5496626,10.7911166 C18.1476223,11.7879348 17.3337015,12.5831492 16.6238051,13.4525651 C15.0845249,15.1017951 13.4623062,16.6992242 11.6432846,17.9718474 C11.2763877,18.2322522 10.7815688,18.4702565 10.3401679,18.2658528 C9.00190778,17.56724 7.87450799,16.4248192 6.7035304,15.3860003 C5.34559001,14.1301774 3.98202667,12.6713508 2.95302836,11.142523 C2.80120893,10.9283191 2.75763114,10.6651143 2.76184834,10.3823091 C2.89398747,9.85449953 3.2566672,9.42049162 3.60107238,8.97668354 C4.81562776,7.43385543 6.30570729,5.96942875 7.80984416,4.63240439 C7.84498755,4.59740376 7.90824564,4.5232024 7.96306932,4.48960179 C8.60970761,3.93379167 9.25212869,3.44098269 9.92828741,2.95657386 C10.6339666,2.41056392 11.5209856,2.86417218 12.114206,3.36678134 C12.7369467,3.83998996 13.383585,4.37759975 13.9529079,4.9236097 L14.0555265,4.98241077 C15.6285445,6.43703727 17.0891035,8.05406673 18.2910073,9.76209785 C18.4864045,10.0603033 18.6579042,10.3963094 18.5496626,10.7911166" id="Fill-5" fill="#FEFEFE" mask="url(#mask-2)"></path></g><path d="M17.8685838,9.92786087 C16.3152462,7.68782006 14.2755241,5.70538394 12.1135031,3.97215236 C11.5554261,3.58154525 10.9087879,2.8983328 10.1876456,3.3869417 C7.9483091,4.92836978 5.79050526,7.01860786 4.05582778,9.15084671 C3.70298819,9.66885615 3.08587035,10.1616651 3.3656117,10.8504777 C3.56663186,11.3586869 4.01646719,11.7240936 4.30604868,12.1735018 C6.00698851,14.2091389 8.01719014,16.1089735 10.1145474,17.6364013 C11.0367098,18.221612 11.6931882,17.2751947 12.4087075,16.8397868 C13.8734838,15.6875658 15.2314242,14.2875403 16.5162664,12.9253155 L16.5162664,12.8917149 C17.0307655,12.2715036 17.5747851,11.6610924 17.9768254,10.9918802 C18.1525424,10.6642743 18.0653868,10.2162661 17.8685838,9.92786087 L17.8685838,9.92786087 Z M10.4477066,5.41697869 L10.6431039,4.79256731 L10.6684071,4.79256731 C11.0704474,5.9391882 11.4865451,7.08300904 11.9181059,8.21422965 L11.0549843,8.22962993 L11.0367098,8.33183179 L11.163226,11.4020877 L11.163226,11.4510886 C10.844124,11.5042896 10.4533296,11.4902893 10.1384449,11.4608888 L10.1145474,11.4258882 L10.2565266,8.26323054 L10.2565266,8.23943011 C10.0161459,8.21422965 9.71250703,8.23943011 9.46790907,8.21422965 L10.4477066,5.41697869 Z M9.93742469,15.6203646 C10.0217688,14.491944 10.0358262,13.4531251 10.0948671,12.3289046 C10.4912844,12.3695053 10.8356896,12.3541051 11.1969636,12.3401048 L11.2222668,12.4913076 L11.3642461,15.6301648 C10.8891076,15.698766 10.3844486,15.6595653 9.93742469,15.6203646 L9.93742469,15.6203646 Z M13.5501647,11.7058933 C11.492168,12.3443049 8.90420917,12.3149044 6.95304844,11.4608888 C6.60020885,11.2900857 6.15459073,11.0268809 6.03650896,10.6166734 C5.94794763,9.86485972 6.75624548,9.44905214 7.30588802,9.17604717 C7.62920717,9.03464459 7.95814925,8.87924176 8.31520604,8.8596414 C8.64836533,9.10324584 8.99698771,9.29924941 9.33998715,9.51765339 C8.67366857,9.69405661 7.87380512,9.84525936 7.56594907,10.5718726 C7.61936702,11.1248827 8.24632501,11.2998859 8.68350872,11.4370884 C10.2565266,11.8514959 11.9574665,11.7968949 13.4672263,11.250885 C13.7511848,11.0842819 14.2024259,10.8840783 14.1630653,10.4752708 C14.1138646,10.0356628 13.6092056,9.84105928 13.256366,9.70245676 C13.0412885,9.73185729 12.8346454,9.78085819 12.6336252,9.84525936 C12.5253836,9.54285385 12.432605,9.23484824 12.3046831,8.94224291 C12.9724074,9.1172461 13.638726,9.29924941 14.3289421,9.41965161 L14.3289421,9.43505189 C14.1869628,9.44905214 14.0309262,9.49805304 13.8931641,9.551254 L13.8931641,9.57645446 C14.2853643,9.77105801 14.8293839,10.0944639 14.8336011,10.6068732 C14.7422283,11.2270845 14.0604466,11.5098897 13.5501647,11.7058933 L13.5501647,11.7058933 Z" id="Fill-8" fill="#FEFEFE"></path><path d="M14.1946944,19.3564726 L14.1946944,19.1646691 L14.3141819,19.1646691 C14.3788457,19.1646691 14.467407,19.1716693 14.467407,19.2528707 C14.467407,19.3410724 14.4224235,19.3564726 14.3465138,19.3564726 L14.1946944,19.3564726 Z M14.1946944,19.4922751 L14.2748213,19.4922751 L14.4603783,19.8268812 L14.6613985,19.8268812 L14.4575669,19.4782749 C14.562997,19.4698747 14.6501526,19.4166737 14.6501526,19.2710711 C14.6501526,19.0890678 14.5278536,19.0302667 14.3226163,19.0302667 L14.0231946,19.0302667 L14.0231946,19.8268812 L14.1946944,19.8268812 L14.1946944,19.4922751 Z M15.0620331,19.429274 C15.0620331,18.9630655 14.7105992,18.6900605 14.3183991,18.6900605 C13.9233874,18.6900605 13.5719536,18.9630655 13.5719536,19.429274 C13.5719536,19.8954825 13.9233874,20.1670874 14.3183991,20.1670874 C14.7105992,20.1670874 15.0620331,19.8954825 15.0620331,19.429274 L15.0620331,19.429274 Z M14.8483613,19.429274 C14.8483613,19.7694802 14.6051691,19.9976843 14.3183991,19.9976843 L14.3183991,19.9962843 C14.0231946,19.9976843 13.7856254,19.7694802 13.7856254,19.429274 C13.7856254,19.0890678 14.0231946,18.8622636 14.3183991,18.8622636 C14.6051691,18.8622636 14.8483613,19.0890678 14.8483613,19.429274 L14.8483613,19.429274 Z" id="Fill-10" fill="#FEFEFE"></path></g></g></g></g></svg><!-- End User Code --></div></div></div></div><div class="topbar-sticky announcement-show" id="sTop_Bar_0_0_27_0_0_0_0_16_0_2"><div id="sTop_Bar_0_0_27_0_0_0_0_16_0_2_0_0_0" class="js-hidden-panel" data-offset="0"></div><div class="rebelbar-wrapper_static announcement-show" id="sTop_Bar_0_0_27_0_0_0_0_16_0_2_1"><div class="" id="s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0"><div class="site_logo" id="s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0_0"><!-- User Code --><a href="/" title="Return to homepage"><svg width="214px" height="30px" viewbox="0 0 214 30" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g id="Symbols" stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd"><g id="Light-/-Sticky-Site-Header-/-1376" transform="translate(-33.000000, -17.000000)" fill="#0D0D0D" fill-rule="nonzero"><g id="IEEE-Spectrum-Logo" transform="translate(32.000000, 15.000000)"><g id="IEEESpectrum-LogoFinal-Black" transform="translate(1.454545, 2.909091)"><path d="M67.5731087,15.3769418 C67.7375958,17.1915012 68.9067885,18.8411007 71.9786975,18.8411007 C74.7749795,18.8411007 75.8285865,17.851341 75.8285865,16.3310345 C75.8285865,14.882062 74.9750314,14.1553466 73.3301597,13.923511 L68.5600317,13.3974225 C64.6123396,12.9515848 62.3361928,10.6911877 62.3361928,6.96398467 C62.3361928,2.83552769 65.4481122,6.3357346e-15 71.7475264,6.3357346e-15 C78.4915004,6.3357346e-15 81.1899792,3.23232323 81.4833887,7.133403 L75.7485657,7.133403 C75.5173945,5.38126088 74.2014972,4.22654127 71.7475264,4.22654127 C69.5247267,4.22654127 68.191047,5.11821665 68.191047,6.57164751 C68.191047,7.6907001 68.8489957,8.51549983 70.5294322,8.71612679 L74.7082955,9.16196447 C79.5095427,9.60780216 81.6834407,11.8994079 81.6834407,15.8495298 C81.6834407,20.1741553 78.984962,23.0765587 71.8764488,23.0765587 C64.6701324,23.0765587 62.1717056,19.3136886 61.9405344,15.390317 L67.5731087,15.3769418 Z" id="Path"></path><path d="M101.439684,14.266806 C101.439684,18.8544758 99.3013506,23.0141414 93.8821651,23.0141414 C91.0858831,23.0141414 89.2098403,21.9575061 88.102886,20.1741553 L88.102886,29.0909091 L82.456975,29.0909091 L82.456975,6.00543365 L88.1162228,6.00543365 L88.1162228,8.23462208 C89.2320682,6.48693835 91.1081111,5.46597005 93.8955019,5.46597005 C99.3013506,5.47934518 101.439684,9.53646813 101.439684,14.266806 Z M95.7804359,14.266806 C95.7804359,11.1994427 94.7935129,9.91097179 91.997231,9.91097179 C89.1031459,9.91097179 88.1162228,11.3287356 88.1162228,14.266806 C88.1162228,17.2048763 89.1031459,18.6226402 91.997231,18.6226402 C94.7935129,18.6092651 95.7804359,17.3207941 95.7804359,14.266806 Z" id="Shape"></path><path d="M114.367486,17.5214211 L119.862247,17.5214211 C119.302102,20.3569488 117.065965,23.0319749 111.077743,23.0319749 C104.364888,23.0319749 101.995384,18.7430164 101.995384,14.2222222 C101.995384,9.43838384 104.760546,5.47934518 111.077743,5.47934518 C117.790598,5.47934518 119.928931,9.73263671 119.928931,14.3203065 C119.934228,14.7845667 119.900021,15.2484337 119.826682,15.7068617 L107.490144,15.7068617 C107.819119,18.3462208 109.103897,19.2378962 111.211111,19.2378962 C112.887102,19.2378962 113.905144,18.5111808 114.367486,17.5214211 Z M107.556828,12.4076628 L114.563093,12.4076628 C114.367486,10.3256008 113.349444,9.20654824 111.144427,9.20654824 C109.103897,9.20654824 107.921368,10.031348 107.556828,12.4076628 Z" id="Shape"></path><path d="M129.811498,5.47934518 C135.764156,5.47934518 138.662686,8.84096134 138.791609,12.9649599 L133.247946,12.9649599 C133.083459,11.0211076 132.096536,9.89759666 129.895965,9.89759666 C127.52646,9.89759666 126.174998,10.954232 126.174998,14.2534309 C126.174998,17.5526297 127.459776,18.6092651 129.793716,18.6092651 C132.127655,18.6092651 133.119024,17.3207941 133.31463,15.4884013 L138.876075,15.4884013 C138.742707,19.4162313 136.013109,23.0141966 129.895965,23.0141966 C123.085307,23.0319749 120.520196,18.7251829 120.520196,14.266806 C120.520196,9.80842912 123.018623,5.47934518 129.811498,5.47934518 Z" id="Path"></path><path d="M141.77016,16.0011146 L141.77016,10.2542668 L138.876075,10.2542668 L138.876075,7.62382445 L142.228057,6.13472658 L144.566442,2.01072797 L147.429408,2.01072797 L147.429408,6.02326715 L151.901681,6.02326715 L151.901681,10.2542668 L147.429408,10.2542668 L147.429408,18.0163009 L151.3771,18.0163009 L151.3771,22.5014281 L148.380766,22.5014281 C143.348348,22.5014281 141.77016,20.2588645 141.77016,16.0011146 Z" id="Path"></path><path d="M164.304903,5.74238941 L164.304903,11.2529432 L162.299938,11.2529432 C159.565894,11.2529432 158.414484,12.5904563 158.414484,15.9030303 L158.414484,22.5014281 L152.755236,22.5014281 L152.755236,6.00543365 L158.263333,6.00543365 L158.263333,9.36259143 C158.921282,7.0174852 160.272744,5.73347266 162.935658,5.73347266 L164.304903,5.74238941 Z" id="Path"></path><path d="M182.989757,6.00543365 L182.989757,22.5014281 L177.330509,22.5014281 L177.330509,19.5009404 C176.281347,21.6454197 174.405304,23.0319749 171.511219,23.0319749 C167.198988,23.0319749 165.256261,20.3569488 165.256261,16.0367816 L165.256261,6.00543365 L170.915509,6.00543365 L170.915509,15.0470219 C170.915509,17.2762104 171.804629,18.4443051 173.81404,18.4443051 C176.014611,18.4443051 177.330509,16.9239986 177.330509,13.758551 L177.330509,6.00543365 L182.989757,6.00543365 Z" id="Path"></path><path d="M213.090909,12.4834552 L213.090909,22.5148032 L207.431661,22.5148032 L207.431661,13.3305468 C207.431661,11.2172762 206.613671,10.0625566 204.737628,10.0625566 C202.514828,10.0625566 201.479004,11.5159875 201.479004,14.7483107 L201.479004,22.5014281 L195.917559,22.5014281 L195.917559,13.3305468 C195.917559,11.2172762 195.095123,10.0625566 193.223526,10.0625566 C191.000726,10.0625566 189.964902,11.5159875 189.964902,14.7483107 L189.964902,22.5014281 L184.305654,22.5014281 L184.305654,6.00543365 L189.964902,6.00543365 L189.964902,8.8097527 C190.982944,6.76335772 192.725619,5.47934518 195.557466,5.47934518 C198.389312,5.47934518 200.163106,6.81685824 200.985542,9.13967259 C202.003585,6.91048415 203.812943,5.47934518 206.809277,5.47934518 C211.117063,5.47934518 213.090909,8.14991292 213.090909,12.4834552 Z" id="Path"></path><polygon id="Path" points="11.9408796 7.10219436 11.9408796 3.0450714 0 3.0450714 0 7.10219436 3.14303867 7.10219436 3.14303867 18.4086381 0 18.4086381 0 22.4702194 11.9408796 22.4702194 11.9408796 18.4086381 8.80228652 18.4086381 8.80228652 7.10219436"></polygon><polygon id="Path" points="18.8537864 18.4086381 18.8537864 14.467433 26.0378748 14.467433 26.0378748 10.6956461 18.8537864 10.6956461 18.8537864 7.10219436 26.9136579 7.10219436 26.9136579 3.0450714 18.8537864 3.0450714 13.1945386 3.0450714 13.1945386 22.4613027 13.1945386 22.4702194 27.0025699 22.4702194 27.0025699 18.4086381"></polygon><polygon id="Path" points="33.6487408 18.4086381 33.6487408 14.467433 40.8372748 14.467433 40.8372748 10.6956461 33.6487408 10.6956461 33.6487408 7.10219436 41.7086122 7.10219436 41.7086122 3.0450714 33.6487408 3.0450714 27.9939385 3.0450714 27.9939385 22.4613027 27.9939385 22.4702194 41.7975242 22.4702194 41.7975242 18.4086381"></polygon><polygon id="Path" points="48.4481407 18.4086381 48.4481407 14.467433 55.6322291 14.467433 55.6322291 10.6956461 48.4481407 10.6956461 48.4481407 7.10219436 56.5080121 7.10219436 56.5080121 3.0450714 48.4481407 3.0450714 42.7888928 3.0450714 42.7888928 22.4613027 42.7888928 22.4702194 56.5924785 22.4702194 56.5924785 18.4086381"></polygon></g></g></g></g></svg></a><!-- End User Code --><div class="topbar__sticky-headline topbar__sticky-headline--post" id="s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0_0_1_0_1"><div class="text-element" id="s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0_0_1_0_1_0">How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Developer</div></div><!-- User Code --><span class="floating-shares hide-desktop">Share</span><!-- End User Code --><!-- User Code --><script>
function createElementChangeListener(selector, callback, oneTime) {
const initializedNodes = new Set([]);
let reported = false;
document.querySelectorAll(selector).forEach((node) => {
if (oneTime && reported) {
return;
}
reported = true;
callback(node);
initializedNodes.add(node);
});
const mutationObserver = new MutationObserver(() => {
const nodes = document.querySelectorAll(selector);
nodes.forEach((node) => {
if (oneTime && reported) {
return;
}
if (!initializedNodes.has(node)) {
reported = true;
callback(node);
initializedNodes.add(node);
if (oneTime) {
mutationObserver.disconnect();
}
}
});
});
if (!oneTime || !reported) {
mutationObserver.observe(document.body, {
childList: true,
subtree: true,
});
}
return mutationObserver;
}
</script><!-- End User Code --><div class="topbar__static-headline" id="s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0_0_2"><div class="text-element" id="s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0_0_2_0">FOR THE TECHNOLOGY INSIDER</div></div></div><div class="" id="s__TopBar_Second_Bar_0_0_37_0_0_0_1"><div class="search-form"><form action="/search/"><label for="q" class="hide-text">Search: </label><input placeholder="Type to search" type="text" name="q" id="q" class="search-form__text-input"/><button aria-label="Search" type="submit" class="search-form__submit" value="Search"><svg width="18px" height="19px" viewbox="0 0 18 19" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g id="Page-1" stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd"><g id="1376---Sample-Front-Page" transform="translate(-826.000000, -102.000000)" stroke="#0D0D0D" stroke-width="1.5"><g id="Light-/-Nav" transform="translate(816.857864, 96.000000)"><g id="Search-Icon" transform="translate(7.307612, 5.000000)"><path d="M11.631728,14.6819805 C15.2215789,14.6819805 18.131728,11.7718314 18.131728,8.18198052 C18.131728,4.59212964 15.2215789,1.68198052 11.631728,1.68198052 C8.04187711,1.68198052 5.13172798,4.59212964 5.13172798,8.18198052 C5.13172798,11.7718314 8.04187711,14.6819805 11.631728,14.6819805 Z M11.631728,14.5814755 L11.631728,21.5814755" id="Combined-Shape" transform="translate(11.631728, 11.631728) rotate(-45.000000) translate(-11.631728, -11.631728) "></path></g></g></g></g></svg></button></form></div><div class="main-menu-el" id="sElement_Menu_0_0_7_0_0_0"><div class="menu-item" id="sElement_Menu_0_0_7_0_0_0_0"><!-- User Code --><button class="menu-item__title">Explore by topic</button><!-- End User Code --><div class="menu-dropdown" id="sElement_Menu_0_0_7_0_0_0_0_1"><div class="list" id="sElement_Menu_0_0_7_0_0_0_0_1_0"><a class="list__item" href="/topic/aerospace/" target="_self">Aerospace</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/artificial-intelligence/" target="_self">AI</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/biomedical/" target="_self">Biomedical</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/climate-tech/" target="_self">Climate Tech</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/computing/" target="_self">Computing</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/consumer-electronics/" target="_self">Consumer Electronics</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/energy/" target="_self">Energy</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/tech-history/" target="_self">History of Technology</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/robotics/" target="_self">Robotics</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/semiconductors/" target="_self">Semiconductors</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/telecommunications/" target="_self">Telecommunications</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/transportation/" target="_self">Transportation</a></div></div></div></div><!-- User Code --><button data-share-status-id="huge-menu-toggle" data-toggle-class="huge-menu-opened" class="rebelbar__menu-toggle js-toggle hambg-btn" data-target="body" aria-label="Open menu" aria-expanded="false" aria-controls="huge-menu" type="button"><svg width="32px" height="18px" viewbox="0 0 32 18" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g id="Page-1" stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd"><g id="992---Search---Open-filters---selected" transform="translate(-928.000000, -75.000000)"><g id="Light-/-Collapsed-Site-Header" transform="translate(0.000000, 56.000000)"><g id="Light-/-Nav" transform="translate(432.857864, 12.000000)"><g id="Group" transform="translate(495.142136, 7.000000)"><rect id="Rectangle" x="0" y="0" width="32" height="2"></rect><rect id="Rectangle-Copy" x="0" y="8" width="32" height="2"></rect><rect id="Rectangle-Copy-2" x="0" y="16" width="32" height="2"></rect></g></g></g></g></g></svg></button><!-- End User Code --></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="huge-menu" id="sTop_Bar_0_0_27_0_0_0_0_17"><div id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1" class="dark_layout row-wrapper clearfix content sm-cp-2 md-cp-4"><div class="row px20"><div id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_0" class="Top_hugeMenu col sm-mb-2 md-mb-4 s12 m12 l12"><div class="" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_0_0"><!-- User Code --><a href="/" class="hide-text" aria-label="IEEE Spectrum">
IEEE Spectrum
<svg width="214px" height="30px" class="site_logo_menu" viewbox="0 0 214 30" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><g id="Symbols" stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd"><g id="Light-/-Sticky-Site-Header-/-1376" transform="translate(-33.000000, -17.000000)" fill="#F2F2F2" fill-rule="nonzero"><g id="IEEE-Spectrum-Logo" transform="translate(32.000000, 15.000000)"><g id="IEEESpectrum-LogoFinal-Black" transform="translate(1.454545, 2.909091)"><path d="M67.5731087,15.3769418 C67.7375958,17.1915012 68.9067885,18.8411007 71.9786975,18.8411007 C74.7749795,18.8411007 75.8285865,17.851341 75.8285865,16.3310345 C75.8285865,14.882062 74.9750314,14.1553466 73.3301597,13.923511 L68.5600317,13.3974225 C64.6123396,12.9515848 62.3361928,10.6911877 62.3361928,6.96398467 C62.3361928,2.83552769 65.4481122,6.3357346e-15 71.7475264,6.3357346e-15 C78.4915004,6.3357346e-15 81.1899792,3.23232323 81.4833887,7.133403 L75.7485657,7.133403 C75.5173945,5.38126088 74.2014972,4.22654127 71.7475264,4.22654127 C69.5247267,4.22654127 68.191047,5.11821665 68.191047,6.57164751 C68.191047,7.6907001 68.8489957,8.51549983 70.5294322,8.71612679 L74.7082955,9.16196447 C79.5095427,9.60780216 81.6834407,11.8994079 81.6834407,15.8495298 C81.6834407,20.1741553 78.984962,23.0765587 71.8764488,23.0765587 C64.6701324,23.0765587 62.1717056,19.3136886 61.9405344,15.390317 L67.5731087,15.3769418 Z" id="Path"></path><path d="M101.439684,14.266806 C101.439684,18.8544758 99.3013506,23.0141414 93.8821651,23.0141414 C91.0858831,23.0141414 89.2098403,21.9575061 88.102886,20.1741553 L88.102886,29.0909091 L82.456975,29.0909091 L82.456975,6.00543365 L88.1162228,6.00543365 L88.1162228,8.23462208 C89.2320682,6.48693835 91.1081111,5.46597005 93.8955019,5.46597005 C99.3013506,5.47934518 101.439684,9.53646813 101.439684,14.266806 Z M95.7804359,14.266806 C95.7804359,11.1994427 94.7935129,9.91097179 91.997231,9.91097179 C89.1031459,9.91097179 88.1162228,11.3287356 88.1162228,14.266806 C88.1162228,17.2048763 89.1031459,18.6226402 91.997231,18.6226402 C94.7935129,18.6092651 95.7804359,17.3207941 95.7804359,14.266806 Z" id="Shape"></path><path d="M114.367486,17.5214211 L119.862247,17.5214211 C119.302102,20.3569488 117.065965,23.0319749 111.077743,23.0319749 C104.364888,23.0319749 101.995384,18.7430164 101.995384,14.2222222 C101.995384,9.43838384 104.760546,5.47934518 111.077743,5.47934518 C117.790598,5.47934518 119.928931,9.73263671 119.928931,14.3203065 C119.934228,14.7845667 119.900021,15.2484337 119.826682,15.7068617 L107.490144,15.7068617 C107.819119,18.3462208 109.103897,19.2378962 111.211111,19.2378962 C112.887102,19.2378962 113.905144,18.5111808 114.367486,17.5214211 Z M107.556828,12.4076628 L114.563093,12.4076628 C114.367486,10.3256008 113.349444,9.20654824 111.144427,9.20654824 C109.103897,9.20654824 107.921368,10.031348 107.556828,12.4076628 Z" id="Shape"></path><path d="M129.811498,5.47934518 C135.764156,5.47934518 138.662686,8.84096134 138.791609,12.9649599 L133.247946,12.9649599 C133.083459,11.0211076 132.096536,9.89759666 129.895965,9.89759666 C127.52646,9.89759666 126.174998,10.954232 126.174998,14.2534309 C126.174998,17.5526297 127.459776,18.6092651 129.793716,18.6092651 C132.127655,18.6092651 133.119024,17.3207941 133.31463,15.4884013 L138.876075,15.4884013 C138.742707,19.4162313 136.013109,23.0141966 129.895965,23.0141966 C123.085307,23.0319749 120.520196,18.7251829 120.520196,14.266806 C120.520196,9.80842912 123.018623,5.47934518 129.811498,5.47934518 Z" id="Path"></path><path d="M141.77016,16.0011146 L141.77016,10.2542668 L138.876075,10.2542668 L138.876075,7.62382445 L142.228057,6.13472658 L144.566442,2.01072797 L147.429408,2.01072797 L147.429408,6.02326715 L151.901681,6.02326715 L151.901681,10.2542668 L147.429408,10.2542668 L147.429408,18.0163009 L151.3771,18.0163009 L151.3771,22.5014281 L148.380766,22.5014281 C143.348348,22.5014281 141.77016,20.2588645 141.77016,16.0011146 Z" id="Path"></path><path d="M164.304903,5.74238941 L164.304903,11.2529432 L162.299938,11.2529432 C159.565894,11.2529432 158.414484,12.5904563 158.414484,15.9030303 L158.414484,22.5014281 L152.755236,22.5014281 L152.755236,6.00543365 L158.263333,6.00543365 L158.263333,9.36259143 C158.921282,7.0174852 160.272744,5.73347266 162.935658,5.73347266 L164.304903,5.74238941 Z" id="Path"></path><path d="M182.989757,6.00543365 L182.989757,22.5014281 L177.330509,22.5014281 L177.330509,19.5009404 C176.281347,21.6454197 174.405304,23.0319749 171.511219,23.0319749 C167.198988,23.0319749 165.256261,20.3569488 165.256261,16.0367816 L165.256261,6.00543365 L170.915509,6.00543365 L170.915509,15.0470219 C170.915509,17.2762104 171.804629,18.4443051 173.81404,18.4443051 C176.014611,18.4443051 177.330509,16.9239986 177.330509,13.758551 L177.330509,6.00543365 L182.989757,6.00543365 Z" id="Path"></path><path d="M213.090909,12.4834552 L213.090909,22.5148032 L207.431661,22.5148032 L207.431661,13.3305468 C207.431661,11.2172762 206.613671,10.0625566 204.737628,10.0625566 C202.514828,10.0625566 201.479004,11.5159875 201.479004,14.7483107 L201.479004,22.5014281 L195.917559,22.5014281 L195.917559,13.3305468 C195.917559,11.2172762 195.095123,10.0625566 193.223526,10.0625566 C191.000726,10.0625566 189.964902,11.5159875 189.964902,14.7483107 L189.964902,22.5014281 L184.305654,22.5014281 L184.305654,6.00543365 L189.964902,6.00543365 L189.964902,8.8097527 C190.982944,6.76335772 192.725619,5.47934518 195.557466,5.47934518 C198.389312,5.47934518 200.163106,6.81685824 200.985542,9.13967259 C202.003585,6.91048415 203.812943,5.47934518 206.809277,5.47934518 C211.117063,5.47934518 213.090909,8.14991292 213.090909,12.4834552 Z" id="Path"></path><polygon id="Path" points="11.9408796 7.10219436 11.9408796 3.0450714 0 3.0450714 0 7.10219436 3.14303867 7.10219436 3.14303867 18.4086381 0 18.4086381 0 22.4702194 11.9408796 22.4702194 11.9408796 18.4086381 8.80228652 18.4086381 8.80228652 7.10219436"></polygon><polygon id="Path" points="18.8537864 18.4086381 18.8537864 14.467433 26.0378748 14.467433 26.0378748 10.6956461 18.8537864 10.6956461 18.8537864 7.10219436 26.9136579 7.10219436 26.9136579 3.0450714 18.8537864 3.0450714 13.1945386 3.0450714 13.1945386 22.4613027 13.1945386 22.4702194 27.0025699 22.4702194 27.0025699 18.4086381"></polygon><polygon id="Path" points="33.6487408 18.4086381 33.6487408 14.467433 40.8372748 14.467433 40.8372748 10.6956461 33.6487408 10.6956461 33.6487408 7.10219436 41.7086122 7.10219436 41.7086122 3.0450714 33.6487408 3.0450714 27.9939385 3.0450714 27.9939385 22.4613027 27.9939385 22.4702194 41.7975242 22.4702194 41.7975242 18.4086381"></polygon><polygon id="Path" points="48.4481407 18.4086381 48.4481407 14.467433 55.6322291 14.467433 55.6322291 10.6956461 48.4481407 10.6956461 48.4481407 7.10219436 56.5080121 7.10219436 56.5080121 3.0450714 48.4481407 3.0450714 42.7888928 3.0450714 42.7888928 22.4613027 42.7888928 22.4702194 56.5924785 22.4702194 56.5924785 18.4086381"></polygon></g></g></g></g></svg></a><!-- End User Code --><div class="text-element" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_0_0_1">FOR THE TECHNOLOGY INSIDER</div><!-- User Code --><button data-share-status-id="huge-menu-toggle" data-toggle-class="huge-menu-opened" class="rebelbar__menu-toggle js-toggle hm__close js--active" data-target="body" data-loaded="true" aria-label="close button" aria-expanded="true" aria-controls="huge-menu" type="button"></button><!-- End User Code --></div></div><div id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_1" class="top-menu top-menu--big-links col sm-mb-2 md-mb-4 s12 m12 l6"><!-- User Code --><h3 class="module-headline__text">Topics</h3><!-- End User Code --><div class="list" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_1_1"><a class="list__item" href="/topic/aerospace/" target="_self" aria-label="Aerospace">Aerospace</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/artificial-intelligence/" target="_self" aria-label="AI">AI</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/biomedical/" target="_self" aria-label="Biomedical">Biomedical</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/climate-tech/" target="_self" aria-label="Climate Tech">Climate Tech</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/computing/" target="_self" aria-label="Computing">Computing</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/consumer-electronics/" target="_self" aria-label="Consumer Electronics">Consumer Electronics</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/energy/" target="_self" aria-label="Energy">Energy</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/tech-history/" target="_self" aria-label="History of Technology">History of Technology</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/robotics/" target="_self" aria-label="Robotics">Robotics</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/semiconductors/" target="_self" aria-label="Semiconductors">Semiconductors</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/telecommunications/" target="_self" aria-label="Telecommunications">Telecommunications</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/transportation/" target="_self" aria-label="Transportation">Transportation</a></div></div><div id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2" class="top-menu top-menu--sm-links col sm-mb-2 md-mb-4 s6 m12 l3"><div class="" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_0"><!-- User Code --><h3 class="module-headline__text">Sections</h3><!-- End User Code --><div class="list" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_0_1"><a class="list__item" href="/type/feature/" target="_self" aria-label="Features">Features</a><a class="list__item" href="/type/news/" target="_self" aria-label="News">News</a><a class="list__item" href="/type/opinion/" target="_self" aria-label="Opinion">Opinion</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/careers/" target="_self" aria-label="Careers">Careers</a><a class="list__item" href="/topic/diy/" target="_self" aria-label="DIY">DIY</a><a class="list__item" href="/engineering-resources/" target="_self" aria-label="Engineering Resources">Engineering Resources</a></div></div><div class="" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_1"><!-- User Code --><h3 class="module-headline__text">More</h3><!-- End User Code --><div class="list" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_1_1"><a class="list__item" href="/newsletters/" target="_self" rel="Newsletters">Newsletters</a><a class="list__item" href="/special-reports/" target="_self" rel="Special Reports">Special Reports</a><a class="list__item" href="/collections/" target="_self" rel="Collections">Collections</a><a class="list__item" href="/type/explainer/" target="_self" rel="Explainers">Explainers</a><a class="list__item" href="/top-programming-languages" target="_self" aria-label="Top Programming Languages">Top Programming Languages</a><a class="list__item" href="https://robotsguide.com" target="_blank" aria-label="Robots Guide ">Robots Guide ↗</a><a class="list__item" href="https://jobs.ieee.org/" target="_blank" aria-label="IEEE Job Site">IEEE Job Site ↗</a></div></div><div class="" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_2"><!-- User Code --><h3 class="module-headline__text">For IEEE Members</h3><!-- End User Code --><div class="list" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_2_2_1"><a class="list__item" href="/magazine/current-issue" target="_self" aria-label="Current Issue">Current Issue</a><a class="list__item" href="/magazine/" target="_self" aria-label="Magazine Archive">Magazine Archive</a><a class="list__item" href="/the-institute/" target="_self" aria-label="The Institute">The Institute</a><a class="list__item" href="/the-institute/ti-archive/" target="_self" aria-label="The Institute Archive">The Institute Archive</a></div></div></div><div id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3" class="top-menu top-menu--sm-links col sm-mb-2 md-mb-4 s6 m12 l3"><div class="" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_0"><!-- User Code --><h3 class="module-headline__text">For IEEE Members</h3><!-- End User Code --><div class="list" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_0_1"><a class="list__item" href="/magazine/current-issue" target="_self">Current Issue</a><a class="list__item" href="/magazine/" target="_self">Magazine Archive</a><a class="list__item" href="/the-institute/" target="_self">The Institute</a><a class="list__item" href="/the-institute/ti-archive/" target="_self">The Institute Archive</a></div></div><div class="" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_1"><!-- User Code --><h3 class="module-headline__text">IEEE Spectrum</h3><!-- End User Code --><div class="list" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_1_1"><a class="list__item" href="/about" target="_self" aria-label="About Us">About Us</a><a class="list__item" href="/contact" target="_self" aria-label="Contact Us">Contact Us</a><a class="list__item" href="https://www.parsintl.com/publications/ieee-media/" target="_blank" aria-label="Reprints & Permissions">Reprints &amp; Permissions ↗</a><a class="list__item" href="https://advertise.ieee.org/ " target="_blank" aria-label="Advertising">Advertising ↗</a></div></div><div class="" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_2"><!-- User Code --><h3 class="module-headline__text">Follow IEEE Spectrum</h3><!-- End User Code --><div class="sm-mb-2" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_2_1"><div class="social-links"><a class="social-links__link share-twitter" href="https://twitter.com/ieeespectrum" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Open twitter"><span aria-hidden="true" class="fa fa-twitter"></span></a><a class="social-links__link share-facebook" href="https://www.facebook.com/IEEE.Spectrum" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Open facebook"><span aria-hidden="true" class="fa fa-facebook"></span></a><a class="social-links__link share-instagram" href="https://www.instagram.com/ieeespectrum/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Open instagram"><span aria-hidden="true" class="fa fa-instagram"></span></a><a class="social-links__link share-threads" href="https://www.threads.net/@ieeespectrum " target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Open threads"><span aria-hidden="true" class="fa fa-threads"></span></a><a class="social-links__link share-linkedin" href="https://www.linkedin.com/company/ieee-spectrum/" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Open linkedin"><span aria-hidden="true" class="fa fa-linkedin"></span></a><a class="social-links__link share-youtube" href="https://www.youtube.com/c/ieeespectrum" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Open youtube"><span aria-hidden="true" class="fa fa-youtube"></span></a><a class="social-links__link share-tiktok" href="https://www.tiktok.com/@ieeespectrum " target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Open tiktok"><span aria-hidden="true" class="fa fa-tiktok"></span></a><a class="social-links__link share-tumblr" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/customfeeds/feed/all-topics/rss" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Open tumblr"><span aria-hidden="true" class="fa fa-tumblr"></span></a></div></div></div><div class="" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_3"><!-- User Code --><h3 class="module-headline__text">Support IEEE Spectrum</h3><!-- End User Code --><div class="text-element" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_3_1"><em>IEEE Spectrum</em> is the flagship publication of the IEEE — the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences. Our articles, videos, and infographics inform our readers about developments in technology, engineering, and science.</div><div class="text-element" id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_3_3_2"><a class="color-inherit" href="https://ieee.dragonforms.com/spectrum_subscribe?utm_source=ieee-spectrum&utm_medium=nav&utm_content=hugemenu" target="_blank" rel="orange_button" aria-label="Subscribe">Subscribe</a></div></div></div><div id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_4" class=" col sm-mb-2 md-mb-4 s12 m12 l12"></div><div id="s__Huge_Menu_Links_0_0_32_0_0_1_5" class=" col sm-mb-2 md-mb-4 s12 m12 l12"><div class="footer containerHidden" id="sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0"><div class="" id="sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0"><div id="sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0" class=" row-wrapper clearfix content sm-cp-2 md-cp-4"><div class="row "><div id="sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0" class=" col sm-mb-2 md-mb-4 s12 m10 l10"><div class="bottom_menu_links" id="sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_0"><div class="list" id="sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_0_0"><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/about/" target="_blank">About IEEE</a><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/about/contact.html" target="_blank">Contact &amp; Support</a><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/accessibility-statement.html" target="_blank">Accessibility</a><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/about/corporate/governance/p9-26.html" target="_blank">Nondiscrimination Policy</a><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/about/help/site-terms-conditions.html" target="_blank">Terms</a><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/security-privacy.html" target="_blank">IEEE Privacy Policy</a><a class="list__item" href="#" target="_self" rel="cookie-preferences">Cookie Preferences</a><a class="list__item" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/st/ppid-info" target="_self">Ad Privacy Options</a></div></div><div class="ftr-copy" id="sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_0_1">© Copyright 2026 IEEE — All rights reserved. A public charity, IEEE is the world&#39;s largest technical professional organization dedicated to advancing technology for the benefit of humanity.</div></div><div id="sFooter_0_0_8_0_0_0_0_0_1" class=" col sm-mb-2 md-mb-4 s12 m2 l2"><!-- User Code --><svg viewbox="0 0 70 21" version="1.1" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><defs><polygon id="path-1" points="0 0 21.3639449 0 21.3639449 21 0 21"></polygon></defs><g id="Symbols" stroke="none" stroke-width="1" fill="none" fill-rule="evenodd"><g id="Light-/-IEEE-Bar-/-Signed-out-/-1376" transform="translate(-1274.000000, -14.000000)"><g id="Group-13" transform="translate(1274.000000, 14.000000)"><polygon id="Fill-1" fill="#FEFEFE" points="23.4111174 18.6889405 27.8363724 18.6889405 27.8363724 2.77905063 23.4111174 2.77905063"></polygon><polygon id="Fill-2" fill="#FEFEFE" points="29.7536549 18.6881005 29.7536549 2.77821061 41.9217005 2.77821061 41.9217005 5.8624668 34.17891 5.8624668 34.17891 9.14692664 41.3017712 9.14692664 41.3017712 12.2311828 34.17891 12.2311828 34.17891 15.6024442 41.9217005 15.6024442 41.9217005 18.6881005"></polygon><polygon id="Fill-3" fill="#FEFEFE" points="43.7923126 18.6881005 43.7923126 2.77821061 55.9603583 2.77821061 55.9603583 5.8624668 48.2175677 5.8624668 48.2175677 9.14692664 55.3418347 9.14692664 55.3418347 12.2311828 48.2175677 12.2311828 48.2175677 15.6024442 55.9603583 15.6024442 55.9603583 18.6881005"></polygon><polygon id="Fill-4" fill="#FEFEFE" points="57.8305486 2.77793061 57.8305486 18.6878205 70 18.6878205 70 15.6021642 62.2558037 15.6021642 62.2558037 12.2323028 69.3800707 12.2323028 69.3800707 9.14664663 62.2558037 9.14664663 62.2558037 5.8621868 70 5.8621868 70 2.77793061"></polygon><g id="Group-12"><g id="Group-7"><mask id="mask-2" fill="white"><use xlink:href="#path-1"></use></mask><g id="Clip-6"></g><path d="M20.9520644,9.85449953 L20.8930235,9.84469935 C19.0838421,8.61967703 17.3983653,7.23365178 15.8098843,5.66142314 L14.0555265,3.83578988 C13.3442244,3.05037557 12.6540084,2.18095973 11.9961242,1.35074461 L11.1976665,0.22232405 C11.099265,0.164923005 10.976966,0.0669212192 10.8687244,0.0375206836 C10.6339666,-0.0646811784 10.3795285,0.0571210406 10.1883485,0.202723693 L8.74184673,2.07875787 C6.42378906,4.93900998 3.67838782,7.60885862 0.684171419,9.65429588 C0.448007872,9.84049927 0.0951682866,10.0211026 0.0220700458,10.3235081 C-0.0566511366,10.596513 0.0853281388,10.8219172 0.256827858,10.9913202 C2.65360672,12.6363502 4.94776689,14.5907858 6.98748895,16.8168264 C7.35016869,17.1962333 7.64396739,17.5728401 7.99680697,17.9284466 C8.59424452,18.719461 9.29570648,19.5160755 9.84534902,20.364491 C10.0168487,20.5450943 10.0463692,20.8390996 10.3148646,20.9259012 C10.525725,20.9987026 10.785786,21.0477034 10.9868062,20.9259012 L11.1878263,20.7256976 C13.6675436,17.2256338 16.8149851,14.0825766 20.3293236,11.5429303 C20.6821632,11.2321246 21.3541047,11.1145225 21.3639449,10.5335119 C21.3386417,10.264707 21.182605,10.0015022 20.9520644,9.85449953 M18.5496626,10.7911166 C18.1476223,11.7879348 17.3337015,12.5831492 16.6238051,13.4525651 C15.0845249,15.1017951 13.4623062,16.6992242 11.6432846,17.9718474 C11.2763877,18.2322522 10.7815688,18.4702565 10.3401679,18.2658528 C9.00190778,17.56724 7.87450799,16.4248192 6.7035304,15.3860003 C5.34559001,14.1301774 3.98202667,12.6713508 2.95302836,11.142523 C2.80120893,10.9283191 2.75763114,10.6651143 2.76184834,10.3823091 C2.89398747,9.85449953 3.2566672,9.42049162 3.60107238,8.97668354 C4.81562776,7.43385543 6.30570729,5.96942875 7.80984416,4.63240439 C7.84498755,4.59740376 7.90824564,4.5232024 7.96306932,4.48960179 C8.60970761,3.93379167 9.25212869,3.44098269 9.92828741,2.95657386 C10.6339666,2.41056392 11.5209856,2.86417218 12.114206,3.36678134 C12.7369467,3.83998996 13.383585,4.37759975 13.9529079,4.9236097 L14.0555265,4.98241077 C15.6285445,6.43703727 17.0891035,8.05406673 18.2910073,9.76209785 C18.4864045,10.0603033 18.6579042,10.3963094 18.5496626,10.7911166" id="Fill-5" fill="#FEFEFE" mask="url(#mask-2)"></path></g><path d="M17.8685838,9.92786087 C16.3152462,7.68782006 14.2755241,5.70538394 12.1135031,3.97215236 C11.5554261,3.58154525 10.9087879,2.8983328 10.1876456,3.3869417 C7.9483091,4.92836978 5.79050526,7.01860786 4.05582778,9.15084671 C3.70298819,9.66885615 3.08587035,10.1616651 3.3656117,10.8504777 C3.56663186,11.3586869 4.01646719,11.7240936 4.30604868,12.1735018 C6.00698851,14.2091389 8.01719014,16.1089735 10.1145474,17.6364013 C11.0367098,18.221612 11.6931882,17.2751947 12.4087075,16.8397868 C13.8734838,15.6875658 15.2314242,14.2875403 16.5162664,12.9253155 L16.5162664,12.8917149 C17.0307655,12.2715036 17.5747851,11.6610924 17.9768254,10.9918802 C18.1525424,10.6642743 18.0653868,10.2162661 17.8685838,9.92786087 L17.8685838,9.92786087 Z M10.4477066,5.41697869 L10.6431039,4.79256731 L10.6684071,4.79256731 C11.0704474,5.9391882 11.4865451,7.08300904 11.9181059,8.21422965 L11.0549843,8.22962993 L11.0367098,8.33183179 L11.163226,11.4020877 L11.163226,11.4510886 C10.844124,11.5042896 10.4533296,11.4902893 10.1384449,11.4608888 L10.1145474,11.4258882 L10.2565266,8.26323054 L10.2565266,8.23943011 C10.0161459,8.21422965 9.71250703,8.23943011 9.46790907,8.21422965 L10.4477066,5.41697869 Z M9.93742469,15.6203646 C10.0217688,14.491944 10.0358262,13.4531251 10.0948671,12.3289046 C10.4912844,12.3695053 10.8356896,12.3541051 11.1969636,12.3401048 L11.2222668,12.4913076 L11.3642461,15.6301648 C10.8891076,15.698766 10.3844486,15.6595653 9.93742469,15.6203646 L9.93742469,15.6203646 Z M13.5501647,11.7058933 C11.492168,12.3443049 8.90420917,12.3149044 6.95304844,11.4608888 C6.60020885,11.2900857 6.15459073,11.0268809 6.03650896,10.6166734 C5.94794763,9.86485972 6.75624548,9.44905214 7.30588802,9.17604717 C7.62920717,9.03464459 7.95814925,8.87924176 8.31520604,8.8596414 C8.64836533,9.10324584 8.99698771,9.29924941 9.33998715,9.51765339 C8.67366857,9.69405661 7.87380512,9.84525936 7.56594907,10.5718726 C7.61936702,11.1248827 8.24632501,11.2998859 8.68350872,11.4370884 C10.2565266,11.8514959 11.9574665,11.7968949 13.4672263,11.250885 C13.7511848,11.0842819 14.2024259,10.8840783 14.1630653,10.4752708 C14.1138646,10.0356628 13.6092056,9.84105928 13.256366,9.70245676 C13.0412885,9.73185729 12.8346454,9.78085819 12.6336252,9.84525936 C12.5253836,9.54285385 12.432605,9.23484824 12.3046831,8.94224291 C12.9724074,9.1172461 13.638726,9.29924941 14.3289421,9.41965161 L14.3289421,9.43505189 C14.1869628,9.44905214 14.0309262,9.49805304 13.8931641,9.551254 L13.8931641,9.57645446 C14.2853643,9.77105801 14.8293839,10.0944639 14.8336011,10.6068732 C14.7422283,11.2270845 14.0604466,11.5098897 13.5501647,11.7058933 L13.5501647,11.7058933 Z" id="Fill-8" fill="#FEFEFE"></path><path d="M14.1946944,19.3564726 L14.1946944,19.1646691 L14.3141819,19.1646691 C14.3788457,19.1646691 14.467407,19.1716693 14.467407,19.2528707 C14.467407,19.3410724 14.4224235,19.3564726 14.3465138,19.3564726 L14.1946944,19.3564726 Z M14.1946944,19.4922751 L14.2748213,19.4922751 L14.4603783,19.8268812 L14.6613985,19.8268812 L14.4575669,19.4782749 C14.562997,19.4698747 14.6501526,19.4166737 14.6501526,19.2710711 C14.6501526,19.0890678 14.5278536,19.0302667 14.3226163,19.0302667 L14.0231946,19.0302667 L14.0231946,19.8268812 L14.1946944,19.8268812 L14.1946944,19.4922751 Z M15.0620331,19.429274 C15.0620331,18.9630655 14.7105992,18.6900605 14.3183991,18.6900605 C13.9233874,18.6900605 13.5719536,18.9630655 13.5719536,19.429274 C13.5719536,19.8954825 13.9233874,20.1670874 14.3183991,20.1670874 C14.7105992,20.1670874 15.0620331,19.8954825 15.0620331,19.429274 L15.0620331,19.429274 Z M14.8483613,19.429274 C14.8483613,19.7694802 14.6051691,19.9976843 14.3183991,19.9976843 L14.3183991,19.9962843 C14.0231946,19.9976843 13.7856254,19.7694802 13.7856254,19.429274 C13.7856254,19.0890678 14.0231946,18.8622636 14.3183991,18.8622636 C14.6051691,18.8622636 14.8483613,19.0890678 14.8483613,19.429274 L14.8483613,19.429274 Z" id="Fill-10" fill="#FEFEFE"></path></g></g></g></g></svg><!-- End User Code --></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="gated-popup" id="s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0"><div class="gated-popup__contents" id="s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0"><!-- User Code --><button aria-label="close button" type="button" class="js--close-gated gated-popup__close icon-close"></button><!-- End User Code --><!-- User Code --><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 popup-heading-h2 for_pdf" style="display:none">
Enjoy more free content and benefits by creating an account
</h2><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 popup-heading-h2 for_save" style="display:none">
Saving articles to read later requires an IEEE Spectrum account
</h2><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 popup-heading-h2 for_member_content" style="display:none">
The Institute content is only available for members
</h2><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 popup-heading-h2 for_pdf_issues" style="display:none">
Downloading full PDF issues is exclusive for IEEE Members
</h2><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 popup-heading-h2 for_ebooks" style="display:none">
Downloading this e-book is exclusive for IEEE Members
</h2><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 popup-heading-h2 for_nxtbook" style="display:none">
Access to
<i>Spectrum</i>
&#39;s Digital Edition is exclusive for IEEE Members
</h2><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 popup-heading-h2 for_follow_topics" style="display:none">
Following topics is a feature exclusive for IEEE Members
</h2><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 popup-heading-h2 for_comments" style="display:none">
Adding your response to an article requires an IEEE Spectrum account
</h2><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 for_pdf for_save for_comments" style="display:none">
Create an account to access more content and features on
<i>IEEE Spectrum</i>
, including the ability to save articles to read later, download Spectrum Collections, and participate in
conversations with readers and editors. For more exclusive content and features, consider
<a class="ieee_link" href="/join">Joining IEEE</a>
.
</h2><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 for_pdf_issues for_nxtbook for_follow_topics for_member_content" style="display:none">
Join the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences and get access to
all of Spectrum’s articles, archives, PDF downloads, and other benefits.
<a href="/join">Learn more about IEEE →</a></h2><h2 class="popup-gated-h2 for_ebooks" style="display:none">
Join the world’s largest professional organization devoted to engineering and applied sciences and get access to
this e-book plus all of
<em>IEEE Spectrum’s</em>
articles, archives, PDF downloads, and other benefits.
<a href="/join">Learn more about IEEE →</a></h2><!-- End User Code --><div class="popup_links for_pdf for_save for_comments create_account" id="s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0_2"><div class="list" id="s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0_2_0"><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/profile/public/createwebaccount/showCreateAccount.html?ShowMGAMarkeatbilityOptIn=true&sourceCode=spectrum&signinurl=https%3A%2F%2Fspectrum.ieee.org%2Fcore%2Fsaml%2Fmain%2Flogin%3Fnext_url%3Dhttps%3A%2F%2Fspectrum.ieee.org%2Fcore%2Fintegrations%2Fieee%2Fchanges%0A&url=https://spectrum.ieee.org/&autoSignin=Y&car=IEEE-Spectrum" target="_self">CREATE AN ACCOUNT</a><a class="list__item" href="/core/saml/main/login?next_url=https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/integrations/ieee/changes" target="_self">SIGN IN</a></div></div><div class="popup_links for_pdf_issues for_nxtbook for_follow_topics for_member_content for_ebooks" id="s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0_3"><div class="list" id="s__Gated_Popup_0_0_31_0_0_0_0_3_0"><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/membership-application/public/join.html?promo=JOINLITE&style=SPECTRUM&joinlite=TRUE" target="_self">JOIN IEEE</a><a class="list__item" href="/core/saml/main/login?next_url=https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/integrations/ieee/changes" target="_self">SIGN IN</a></div></div></div></div><!-- User Code --><script>
var popupGatedElement=document.querySelector('.gated-popup'),
closeGated,
gatedCloseBtn = '.js--close-gated',
gatedShownClass = 'gated-popup--shown';
closeGated = function () {
popupGatedElement.classList.remove(gatedShownClass);
popupGatedElement.classList.remove('for_save');
popupGatedElement.classList.remove('for_pdf');
popupGatedElement.classList.remove('for_ebooks');
popupGatedElement.classList.remove('for_pdf_issues');
popupGatedElement.classList.remove('for_nxtbook');
popupGatedElement.classList.remove('for_follow_topics');
popupGatedElement.classList.remove('for_comments');
popupGatedElement.classList.remove('for_member_content');
};
function openGatedPopup(type){
document.querySelectorAll(".popup_links.create_account .list__item")[0].href =
"https://www.ieee.org/profile/public/createwebaccount/showCreateAccount.html?ShowMGAMarkeatbilityOptIn=true&sourceCode=spectrum&signinurl=" + encodeURIComponent(window.location.origin + "/core/saml/main/login?next_url=" + window.location.origin + "/core/integrations/ieee/changes?redirect=" + window.location.href) + "&url=" + encodeURIComponent(window.location.origin + "/core/saml/main/login?next_url=" + window.location.origin + "/core/integrations/ieee/changes?redirect=" + window.location.href) + "&autoSignin=Y&car=IEEE-Spectrum";
// update popups for_member_content
document.querySelectorAll(".popup_links.for_member_content .list__item")[1].href = "https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/saml/main/login?next_url=" + encodeURIComponent("https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/integrations/ieee/changes?redirect=" + window.location.href);
// update popups for_pdf for_save for_comments
document.querySelectorAll(".popup_links.for_save .list__item")[1].href = "https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/saml/main/login?next_url=" + encodeURIComponent("https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/integrations/ieee/changes?redirect=" + window.location.href);
popupGatedElement.classList.add(type);
popupGatedElement.classList.add(gatedShownClass);
}
document.querySelector(gatedCloseBtn).onclick= closeGated;
</script><!-- End User Code --><div class="lightbox-popup" id="s__Session_Popup_0_0_36_0_0_0"><div class="lightbox-popup__contents" id="s__Session_Popup_0_0_36_0_0_0_0"><!-- User Code --><a href="javascript:;" class="js--close-lightbox lightbox-popup__close icon-close hide-text">Close</a><!-- End User Code --><!-- User Code --><h2 class="popup-ligtbox-h2 popup-heading-h2">Access Thousands of Articles — Completely Free</h2><h2 class="popup-ligtbox-h2">
Create an account and get exclusive content and features:
<strong>Save articles, download collections,</strong>
and
<strong>post comments</strong>
— all free! For full access and benefits,
<a class="ieee_link" target="_blank" href="https://ieee.dragonforms.com/spectrum_subscribe">
subscribe
</a>
to <em>Spectrum</em>.
</h2><!-- End User Code --><div class="popup_links signin_button" id="s__Session_Popup_0_0_36_0_0_0_0_2"><div class="list" id="s__Session_Popup_0_0_36_0_0_0_0_2_0"><a class="list__item" href="https://www.ieee.org/profile/public/createwebaccount/showCreateAccount.html?ShowMGAMarkeatbilityOptIn=true&sourceCode=spectrum3c&signinurl=https%3A%2F%2Fspectrum.ieee.org%2Fcore%2Fsaml%2Fmain%2Flogin%3Fnext_url%3Dhttps%3A%2F%2Fspectrum.ieee.org%2Fcore%2Fintegrations%2Fieee%2Fchanges%0A&url=https://spectrum.ieee.org/&autoSignin=Y&car=IEEE-Spectrum" target="_self">CREATE AN ACCOUNT</a><a class="list__item" href="/core/saml/main/login?next_url=https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/integrations/ieee/changes" target="_self">SIGN IN</a></div></div></div></div><!-- User Code --><script>
function addPopSave(){
var save_post_links = document.querySelectorAll(".like-btn:not(.proc)");
for (i = 0; i < save_post_links.length; i++) {
// save_post_links[i].removeAttribute("href");
save_post_links[i].addEventListener("click", function(event){
openGatedPopup('for_save');
});
save_post_links[i].classList.add('proc');
}
}
</script><!-- End User Code --><!-- User Code --><div class="rblad-ieee_welcome_interstitial"></div><!-- End User Code --><div class="" id="sSS_Feature_Post_0_0_20_0_0_0_0_1"><div class="" id="sSS_Feature_Post_0_0_20_0_0_0_0_1_0"><div class="non_member_follow" id="sSS_Feature_Post_0_0_20_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_1_0"><div class="mb-2 feature_post_full current_post updated_post" id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0"><div class="posts-custom posts-custom-section section-holder clearfix" data-block="None" data-format="posts-custom" data-source="current_post" data-source-type="current_post" data-source-unique="true" data-section-id="" data-is-reordable="false" data-using-stickers="false" data-has-more="false" data-attr-format="posts-custom" data-attr-posts_id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_0_1_0_0_0" data-attr-layout_quality="1" data-attr-header_template="jinja/post/custom-css.html" data-attr-node_id="/root/blocks/block[open_current_feature_post]/abtests/abtest[1]/rm_tabs/rm_wrapper[1]/choose/otherwise/choose/when[post.roar_specific_data.is_updated_post]/posts-" data-attr-use_tag_image_for_lead_media="true" data-attr-source_url="current_post" data-attr-all_element_order="all_sections,headline,subheadline,author,date,date_modified,time_to_read,like_button,custom_field_pdf_version,post_shares,custom_field_FeaturePostImgPosition,photo_caption,photo_credit,custom_field_FeaturePostColor,body,tags,custom_field_lightbox_img_shortcode_ids,custom_field_TimeofRead,custom_field_FullwidthCardColor,custom_field_FullwidthCardPosition,badges_sponsored,section,snark_line,community_name,primary_tag,follow_button,community_comments,badges,page_views,collection_button,main_author,source_link,custom_field_ContentType,custom_field_CustomFieldTestEG,custom_field_Issue,product_prices,product_vendor,product_buy_link,site_field_Twitter,site_field_Facebook,site_field_Instagram,site_field_LinkedIn,custom_field_Editor,custom_field_PodcastVideoTime,custom_field_PodcastEpisode,custom_field_due_date,custom_field_access,custom_field_publication_date,site_field_member_badges,words_count,site_field_first_name,site_field_last_name,site_field_grade,custom_field_fullwidthbackgroundposition,custom_field_disable_comments,custom_field_copy_editor,custom_field_is_updated_post,custom_field_youtube_video" data-attr-limit="1" data-attr-layout_headline="top" data-attr-layout_subheadline="top" data-attr-layout_date="top" data-attr-data-rm-advanced="true" data-attr-element_classes="feature_post_full current_post updated_post" data-attr-layout_all_date_format="%d %b %Y" data-attr-layout_all_date_full_format="false" data-attr-layout_all_image_crop="original" data-attr-data-rm-device-crops="true" data-attr-layout_mobile_image_crop="original" data-attr-layout_like_button="top" data-attr-layout_all_sections="top" data-attr-layout_author="top" data-attr-layout_post_shares="top" data-attr-all_share_buttons="Email,CopyLink,Separator,Slack,Twitter,Facebook,Linkedin,GooglePlus,Whatsapp,Reddit,Tumblr,Flipboard,SMS,Pinterest" data-attr-layout_tumblr="inactive" data-attr-layout_googleplus="inactive" data-attr-layout_pinterest="inactive" data-attr-layout_whatsapp="inactive" data-attr-layout_reddit="inactive" data-attr-layout_flipboard="inactive" data-attr-layout_sms="inactive" data-attr-layout_slack="inactive" data-attr-layout_separator="inactive" data-attr-layout_facebook="active" data-attr-layout_twitter="active" data-attr-layout_linkedin="active" data-attr-layout_copylink="active" data-attr-layout_photo_caption="bottom" data-attr-layout_photo_credit="bottom" data-attr-layout_custom_field_featurepostcolor="bottom" data-attr-layout_body="bottom" data-attr-layout_custom_field_featurepostimgposition="top" data-attr-show_full_post_body="true" data-attr-layout_time_to_read="top" data-attr-layout_all_headline_tag="h1" data-attr-layout_all_subheadline_tag="h2" data-attr-show_around_the_web="true" data-attr-layout_tags="bottom" data-attr-layout_custom_field_lightbox_img_shortcode_ids="bottom" data-attr-layout_custom_field_pdf_version="top" data-attr-layout_date_modified="top" data-attr-filters="" data-attr-section_url="" data-attr-source="" data-attr-is_current_post="true"><div class="posts-wrapper clearfix"><div class="widget post-partial tag-aviation tag-software tag-airbus tag-boeing tag-737-max post-section--topic/aerospace" data-category="Aerospace"><article elid="2650278376" data-frozen-sections="[]" class="clearfix page-article sm-mb-1 quality-HD post-2650278376" data-category="Aerospace"><div class="row px10"><div class="rm-col-center col sm-mb-1" style="width:100.0%;"><div class="widget__body clearfix sm-mt-1"><div class="all-related-sections"><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/topic/aerospace/">Aerospace</a><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/type/feature/">Feature</a></div><h1 class="widget__headline h1"><span class="widget__headline-text " data-type="text">
How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Developer
</span></h1><div class="widget__subheadline"><h2 class="widget__subheadline-text h2" data-type="text">Design shortcuts meant to make a new plane seem like an old, familiar one are to blame</h2></div><div class="social-author clearfix"><div class="social-author__avatar image"><div class="cover-all image" style="background-image: url(&quot;https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjY0NTkxNC9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTYyODI0MzE3M30.NwS_cVTzuyCiLxaAml2FFbcCzSQcEEQvx8aDC_ELg_M/image.png?width=980&quot;)"></div></div><a class="social-author__name" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/u/gregory-travis" data-type="text">Gregory Travis</a></div><div class="social-date"><span class="social-date__text">18 Apr 2019</span></div><div class="social-date-modified"><span class="social-date-modified__text">03 Feb 2024</span></div><div class="time-to-read">20 min read</div><div class="like-button" data-post-likes="19"></div><div class="widget__shares share-panel"><!-- EMAIL --><a href="mailto:?subject=How%20the%20Boeing%20737%20Max%20Disaster%20Looks%20to%20a%20Software%20Developer&body=https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer" target="_blank" data-track-share="Email" class="share share-popup share-email" rel="noopener noreferrer" aria-label="Share via Email"><i aria-hidden="true" class="icons-share em fa fa-envelope"></i></a><!-- COPY LINK --><button href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer" data-clipboard-text="https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer" class="share share-copy-link" title="Copy this link to clipboard"><i class="icons-share" style="width: 60%"><svg aria-hidden="true" data-prefix="far" data-icon="copy" class="svg-inline--fa fa-copy fa-w-14" role="img" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" viewbox="0 0 448 512"><path fill="currentColor" d="M433.941 65.941l-51.882-51.882A48 48 0 0 0 348.118 0H176c-26.51 0-48 21.49-48 48v48H48c-26.51 0-48 21.49-48 48v320c0 26.51 21.49 48 48 48h224c26.51 0 48-21.49 48-48v-48h80c26.51 0 48-21.49 48-48V99.882a48 48 0 0 0-14.059-33.941zM266 464H54a6 6 0 0 1-6-6V150a6 6 0 0 1 6-6h74v224c0 26.51 21.49 48 48 48h96v42a6 6 0 0 1-6 6zm128-96H182a6 6 0 0 1-6-6V54a6 6 0 0 1 6-6h106v88c0 13.255 10.745 24 24 24h88v202a6 6 0 0 1-6 6zm6-256h-64V48h9.632c1.591 0 3.117.632 4.243 1.757l48.368 48.368a6 6 0 0 1 1.757 4.243V112z"></path></svg></i></button><!-- TWITTER --><button data-href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?url=https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer&text=How%20the%20Boeing%20737%20Max%20Disaster%20Looks%20to%20a%20Software%20Developer&" target="_blank" data-track-share="Twitter" class="share share-popup share-tw" "="&quot;" aria-label=" Share on Twitter"><i aria-hidden="true" class="icons-share tw fa fa-twitter"></i></button><!-- FACEBOOK --><button data-href="https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fspectrum.ieee.org%2Fhow-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer%3Fxrs%3DRebelMouse_fb%26ts%3D1706997785" data-track-share="Facebook" class="share share-popup share-fb" aria-label="Share on Facebook"><i aria-hidden="true" class="icons-share fb fa fa-facebook"></i></button><!-- LINKEDIN --><button data-href="https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=false&url=https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer&" class="share share-popup share-linkedin" data-track-share="Linkedin" aria-label="Share on Linkedin"><i aria-hidden="true" class="icons-share fa fa-linkedin"></i></button></div></div><div class="widget__head"><picture><source srcset="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&width=3600&height=2700 3x, https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&width=2400&height=1800 2x, https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&width=1200&height=900 1x"/><img fetchpriority="high" role="img" alt="Photo of the crash site showing engine." aria-label="Photo of the crash site showing engine." src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/photo-of-the-crash-site-showing-engine.jpg?id=25588396&width=1200&height=900" style="object-fit: cover;" class="rm-lazyloadable-image rm-hero-media" width="1240" height="930"/></picture></div><div class="widget__body clearfix sm-mt-1"><div class="photo-caption"><p>This is part of the wreckage of Ethiopian Airlines Flight ET302, a Boeing 737 Max airliner that crashed on 11 March in Bishoftu, Ethiopia, killing all 157 passengers and crew.</p></div><div class="photo-credit">
Photo: Jemal Countess/Getty Images
</div><span class="js-scroll-trigger" data-target="body" data-triggers="render-rebelbar" data-toggle-class="with-floating-shares"></span><div id="utm_campaign"></div><div class="body js-expandable clearfix js-listicle-body css-listicle-body-2650278376" data-headline="How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Developer"><div class="body-description"><p><strong>UPDATE: 3 Feb. 2024: </strong>In the wake of a near-disastrous cabin blowout in an <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaska_Airlines_Flight_1282" target="_blank">Alaska Airlines 737 Max 9 on 5 Jan.</a>—which has propelled the embattled redesign of the once iconic 737 back into the headlines—Boeing, the plane’s designer, has been shaken anew. As the <em>Financial Times</em> <a href="https://www.ft.com/content/542a310f-bac3-499d-8b23-0ce054f33bdc" target="_blank">reported</a> on 31 Jan., the company’s chief executive Dave Calhoun wrote in a note to employees that outsourcing in the 737 Max design (discussed below) probably went “too far.” </p><p>“We caused the problem, and we understand that,” Calhoun said. “Whatever conclusions are reached, <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/boeing">Boeing</a> is accountable for what happened. ... We simply must be better.” Which perhaps explains why the company even <a href="https://www.npr.org/2024/01/31/1228164802/boeing-earnings-737-max-9-analysts-quality-safety" target="_blank">declined to report their financial outlook</a> for the remainder of 2024. </p><p>In response to the company’s near-crisis state, <em>The Los Angeles Times </em><a href="https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2024-01-30/boeing-max-9-flying-again-after-door-panel-blowout" target="_blank">reported</a> on 30 Jan. that a former Boeing manager has publicly stated his aversion to ever flying on the redesigned 737. “I would absolutely not fly a Max airplance,” former Boeing senior manager Ed Pierson told the paper. “I’ve worked in the factory where they were built, and I saw the pressure employees were under to rush the planes out the door. I tried to get them to shut down before the first crash.”</p><p>As Gregory Travis chronicles below from a 2019 perspective, a latter-day crisis of faith about the “Max” appears to be building even more in size and stature. On 1 Feb., Reuters reported that demand for older 737 jetliners has <a href="https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/boeing-737-max-crisis-adds-high-demand-older-planes-2024-02-01/" target="_blank">skyrocketed</a> since 2024’s near-disaster. As Travis describes it, the original, classic craft with “smallish engines and relatively simple systems” is, even in its advanced age, proving very tough to top. —<em>IEEE Spectrum</em> </p><p><div class="rblad-ieee_in_content"></div></p><p><em><strong></strong>Original article from 18 Apr. 2019 follows: </em><br/></p><p><em>The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not represent positions of </em>IEEE Spectrum<em> or the IEEE.</em></p><p><strong>I have been a pilot</strong> for 30 years, a software developer for more than 40. I have written extensively about both aviation and <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/software-engineering">software engineering</a>. Now it’s time for me to write about both together.
</p><p>
The Boeing 737 Max has
<a href="https://www.cnn.com/2019/04/09/business/boeing-737-max-deliveries/index.html">been in the news</a> because of two crashes, practically back to back and involving brand new airplanes. In an industry that relies more than anything on the appearance of total control, total safety, these two crashes pose as close to an existential risk as you can get. Though airliner passenger death rates have fallen over the decades, that achievement is no reason for complacency.
</p><p>
The 737 first appeared in 1967, when I was 3 years old. Back then it was a smallish aircraft with smallish engines and relatively simple systems. Airlines (
<a href="https://www.economist.com/gulliver/2012/06/18/the-secrets-of-southwests-continued-success">especially Southwest</a>) loved it because of its simplicity, reliability, and flexibility. Not to mention the fact that it could be flown by a two-person cockpit crew—as opposed to the three or four of previous airliners—which made it a significant cost saver. Over the years, market and technological forces pushed the 737 into ever-larger versions with increasing electronic and mechanical complexity. This is not, by any means, unique to the 737. Airliners constitute enormous capital investments both for the industries that make them and the customers who buy them, and they all go through a similar growth process.
</p><p>
Most of those market and technical forces are on the side of economics, not safety. They work as allies to relentlessly drive down what the industry calls “
<a href="https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/casm.asp">seat-mile costs</a>“—the cost of flying a seat from one point to another.
</p><p>
Much had to do with the engines themselves. The principle of
<a href="https://www.grc.nasa.gov/www/k-12/airplane/carnot.html">Carnot efficiency</a> dictates that the larger and hotter you can make any heat engine, the more efficient it becomes. That’s as true for <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/jet-engines">jet engines</a> as it is for chainsaw engines.
</p><p>
It’s as simple as that. The most effective way to make an engine use less fuel
per unit of power produced is to make it larger. That’s why the
<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lycoming_O-360">Lycoming O-360 engine</a> in my <a href="https://cessna.txtav.com/">Cessna</a> has pistons the size of dinner plates. That’s why
marine <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/diesel">diesel</a> engines stand three stories tall. And that’s why Boeing wanted to put the huge CFM International LEAP engine in its latest version of the 737.
</p><p>
There was just one little problem: The original 737 had (by today’s standards) tiny little engines, which easily cleared the ground beneath the wings. As the 737 grew and was fitted with bigger engines, the clearance between the engines and the ground started to get a little…um, tight.
</p><p><div class="rblad-ieee_in_content"></div></p><div class="ieee-sidebar-large"><p class="shortcode-media shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image"><img alt="Illustration showing the Boeing 737 airliner." class="rm-shortcode rm-lazyloadable-image" data-rm-shortcode-id="a00eb72c4639d1c94a020e6c7a90ad33" data-rm-shortcode-name="rebelmouse-image" data-runner-src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/illustration-showing-the-boeing-737-airliner.jpg?id=25588398&width=980" height="351" id="c48f5" lazy-loadable="true" src="data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg%20xmlns=&#39;http://www.w3.org/2000/svg&#39;%20viewBox=&#39;0%200%201240%20351&#39;%3E%3C/svg%3E" width="1240"/><small class="image-media media-caption" placeholder="Add Photo Caption...">By substituting a larger engine, Boeing changed the intrinsic aerodynamic nature of the 737 airliner.</small><small class="image-media media-photo-credit" placeholder="Add Photo Credit...">Norebbo.com</small></p></div><p>
Various hacks (as we would call them in the software industry) were developed. One of the most noticeable to the public was changing the shape of the engine intakes from circular to oval, the better to clear the ground.
</p><p>
With the 737 Max, the situation became critical. The engines on the original 737 had a fan diameter (that of the intake blades on the engine) of just 100 centimeters (40 inches); those planned for the 737 Max have 176 cm. That’s a centerline difference of well over 30 cm (a foot), and you couldn’t “ovalize” the intake enough to hang the new engines beneath the wing without scraping the ground.
</p><p>
The solution was to extend the engine up and well in front of the wing. However, doing so also meant that the centerline of the engine’s thrust changed. Now, when the pilots applied power to the engine, the aircraft would have a significant propensity to “pitch up,” or raise its nose.
</p><p>
The angle of attack is the angle between the wings and the airflow over the wings. Think of sticking your hand out of a car window on the highway. If your hand is level, you have a low angle of attack; if your hand is pitched up, you have a high angle of attack. When the angle of attack is great enough, the wing enters what’s called an aerodynamic stall. You can feel the same thing with your hand out the window: As you rotate your hand, your arm wants to move up like a wing more and more until you stall your hand, at which point your arm wants to flop down on the car door.
</p><p>
This propensity to pitch up with power application thereby increased the risk that the airplane could stall when the pilots “punched it” (as my son likes to say). It’s particularly likely to happen if the airplane is flying slowly.
</p><p>
Worse still, because the engine nacelles were so far in front of the wing and so large, a power increase will cause them to actually produce lift, particularly at high angles of attack. So the nacelles make a bad problem worse.
</p><p>
I’ll say it again: In the 737 Max, the engine nacelles themselves can, at high angles of attack, work as a wing and produce lift. And the lift they produce is well ahead of the wing’s center of lift, meaning the nacelles will cause the 737 Max at a high angle of attack to go to a
<em>higher </em>angle of attack. This is aerodynamic malpractice of the worst kind.
</p><p>
Pitch changes with power changes are common in aircraft. Even my little Cessna pitches up a bit when power is applied. Pilots train for this problem and are used to it. Nevertheless, there are limits to what safety regulators will allow and to what pilots will put up with.
</p><p>
Pitch changes with increasing angle of attack, however, are quite another thing. An airplane approaching an aerodynamic stall cannot, under any circumstances, have a tendency to go further into the stall. This is called “dynamic instability,” and the only airplanes that exhibit that characteristic—fighter jets—are also fitted with ejection seats.
</p><p>
Everyone in the aviation community wants an airplane that flies as simply and as naturally as possible. That means that conditions should not change markedly, there should be no significant roll, no significant pitch change, no nothing when the pilot is adding power, lowering the flaps, or extending the landing gear.
</p><p>
The airframe, the hardware, should get it right the first time and not need a lot of added bells and whistles to fly predictably. This has been
<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KISS_principle">an aviation canon</a> from the day the Wright brothers first flew at Kitty Hawk.
</p><p>
Apparently the 737 Max pitched up a bit too much for comfort on power application as well as at already-high angles of attack. It violated that most ancient of aviation canons and probably violated the certification criteria of the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration. But instead of going back to the drawing board and getting the airframe hardware right (more on that below), Boeing relied on something called the “Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System,” or MCAS.
</p><p>
Boeing’s solution to its hardware problem was software.
</p><p>
I will leave a discussion of the corporatization of the aviation lexicon for another article, but let’s just say another term might be the “Cheap way to prevent a stall when the pilots punch it,” or CWTPASWTPPI, system. Hmm. Perhaps MCAS is better, after all.
</p><p>
MCAS is certainly much less expensive than extensively modifying the airframe to accommodate the larger engines. Such an airframe modification would have meant things like longer landing gear (which might not then fit in the fuselage when retracted), more
<a href="https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/26759/how-does-the-dihedral-angle-work">wing dihedral</a> (upward bend), and so forth. All of those hardware changes would be horribly expensive.
</p><div class="ieee-pullquote">
“Everything about the design and manufacture of the Max was done to preserve the myth that ‘it’s just a 737.’ Recertifying it as a new aircraft would have taken years and millions of dollars. In fact, the pilot licensed to fly the 737 in 1967 is still licensed to fly all subsequent versions of the 737.”
</div><p>
What’s worse, those changes could be extensive enough to require not only that the <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/faa">FAA</a> recertify the 737 but that Boeing build an entirely new aircraft. Now we’re talking
<em>real </em>money, both for the manufacturer as well as the manufacturer’s customers.
</p><p>
That’s because
<em>the </em>major selling point of the 737 Max is that it is just a 737, and any pilot who has flown other 737s can fly a 737 Max without expensive training, without recertification, without another type of rating. Airlines—Southwest is a prominent example—tend to go for one “standard” airplane. They want to have one airplane that all their pilots can fly because that makes both pilots and airplanes fungible, maximizing flexibility and minimizing costs.
</p><p>
It all comes down to money, and in this case, MCAS was the way for both Boeing and its customers to keep the money flowing in the right direction. The necessity to insist that the 737 Max was no different in flying characteristics, no different in systems, from any other 737 was the key to the 737 Max’s fleet fungibility. That’s probably also the reason why the documentation about the MCAS system was kept on the down-low.
</p><p>
Put in a change with too much visibility, particularly a change to the aircraft’s operating handbook or to pilot training, and someone—probably a pilot—would have piped up and said, “Hey. This doesn’t look like a 737 anymore.” And then the money would flow the wrong way.
</p><p><strong>As I explained, </strong>you can do your own angle-of-attack experiments just by putting your hand out a car door window and rotating it. It turns out that sophisticated aircraft have what is essentially the mechanical equivalent of a hand out the window: <a href="https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/2317/how-does-an-alpha-aoa-vane-work">the angle-of-attack sensor</a>.
</p><p>
You may have noticed this sensor when boarding a plane. There are usually two of them, one on either side of the plane, and usually just below the pilot’s windows. Don’t confuse them with the
<a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pitot_tube">pitot</a> tubes (we’ll get to those later). The angle-of-attack sensors look like wind vanes, whereas the pitot tubes look like, well, tubes.
</p><p>
Angle-of-attack sensors look like wind vanes because that’s exactly what they are. They are mechanical hands designed to rotate in response to changes in that angle of attack.
</p><p>
The pitot tubes measure how much the air is “pressing” against the airplane, whereas the angle-of-attack sensors measure what direction that air is coming from. Because they measure air pressure, the pitot tubes are used to determine the aircraft’s speed through the air. The angle-of-attack sensors measure the aircraft’s direction relative to that air.
</p><p>
There are two sets of angle-of-attack sensors and two sets of pitot tubes, one set on either side of the fuselage. Normal usage is to have the set on the pilot’s side feed the instruments on the pilot’s side and the set on the copilot’s side feed the instruments on the copilot’s side. That gives a state of natural redundancy in instrumentation that can be easily cross-checked by either pilot. If the copilot thinks his airspeed indicator is acting up, he can look over to the pilot’s airspeed indicator and see if it agrees. If not, both pilot and copilot engage in a bit of triage to determine which instrument is profane and which is sacred.
</p><p>
Long ago there was a joke that in the future planes would fly themselves, and the only thing in the cockpit would be a pilot and a dog. The pilot’s job was to make the passengers comfortable that someone was up front. The dog’s job was to bite the pilot if he tried to touch anything.
</p><p>
On the 737, Boeing not only included the requisite redundancy in instrumentation and sensors, it also included redundant flight computers—one on the pilot’s side, the other on the copilot’s side. The flight computers do a lot of things, but their main job is to fly the plane when commanded to do so and to make sure the human pilots don’t do anything wrong when they’re flying it. The latter is called “envelope protection.”
</p><p>
Let’s just call it what it is: the bitey dog.
</p><p>
Let’s review what the MCAS does: It pushes the nose of the plane down when the system thinks the plane might exceed its angle-of-attack limits; it does so to avoid an aerodynamic stall. Boeing put MCAS into the 737 Max because the larger engines and their placement make a stall more likely in a 737 Max than in previous 737 models.
</p><p>
When MCAS senses that the angle of attack is too high, it commands the aircraft’s trim system (the system that makes the plane go up or down) to lower the nose. It also does something else: Indirectly, via something Boeing calls the “Elevator Feel Computer,” it pushes the pilot’s control columns (the things the pilots pull or push on to raise or lower the aircraft’s nose) downward.
</p><p>
In the 737 Max, like most modern airliners and most modern cars, everything is monitored by computer, if not directly controlled by computer. In many cases, there are no actual mechanical connections (cables, push tubes, hydraulic lines) between the pilot’s controls and the things on the wings, rudder, and so forth that actually make the plane move. And, even where there are mechanical connections, it’s up to the computer to determine if the pilots are engaged in good decision making (that’s the bitey dog again).
</p><p>
But it’s also important that the pilots get physical feedback about what is going on. In the old days, when cables connected the pilot’s controls to the flying surfaces, you had to pull up, hard, if the airplane was trimmed to descend. You had to push, hard, if the airplane was trimmed to ascend. With computer oversight there is a loss of natural sense in the controls. In the 737 Max, there is no real “natural feel.”
</p><p>
True, the 737 does employ redundant hydraulic systems, and those systems do link the pilot’s movement of the controls to the action of the ailerons and other parts of the airplane. But those hydraulic systems are powerful, and they do not give the pilot direct feedback from the aerodynamic forces that are acting on the ailerons. There is only an artificial feel, a feeling that the computer wants the pilots to feel. And sometimes, it doesn’t feel so great.
</p><p>
When the flight computer trims the airplane to descend, because the MCAS system thinks it’s about to stall, a set of motors and jacks push the pilot’s control columns forward. It turns out that the Elevator Feel Computer can put a
<em>lot</em> of force into that column—indeed, so much force that a human pilot can quickly become exhausted trying to pull the column back, trying to tell the computer that this really, really should not be happening.
</p><div class="ieee-sidebar-large"><p class="shortcode-media shortcode-media-rebelmouse-image"><img alt="Illustration showing the Boeing 737 anti-stall system." class="rm-shortcode rm-lazyloadable-image" data-rm-shortcode-id="a4bdee922b23be7208a6853009b1eb26" data-rm-shortcode-name="rebelmouse-image" data-runner-src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/illustration-showing-the-boeing-737-anti-stall-system.jpg?id=25588399&width=980" height="522" id="e3a57" lazy-loadable="true" src="data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg%20xmlns=&#39;http://www.w3.org/2000/svg&#39;%20viewBox=&#39;0%200%201240%20522&#39;%3E%3C/svg%3E" width="1240"/><small class="image-media media-caption" placeholder="Add Photo Caption...">The antistall system depended crucially on sensors that are installed on each side of the airliner—but the system consulted only the sensor on one side.</small><small class="image-media media-photo-credit" placeholder="Add Photo Credit...">Norebbo.com</small></p></div><p>
Indeed, not letting the pilot regain control by pulling back on the column was an explicit design decision. Because if the pilots could pull up the nose when MCAS said it should go down, why have MCAS at all?
</p><p>
MCAS is implemented in the flight management computer, even at times when the <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/autopilot">autopilot</a> is turned off, when the pilots think they are flying the plane. In a fight between the flight management computer and human pilots over who is in charge, the computer will bite humans until they give up and (literally) die.
</p><p>
Finally, there’s the need to keep the very existence of the MCAS system on the hush-hush lest someone say, “Hey, this isn’t your father’s 737,” and bank accounts start to suffer.
</p><p>
The flight management computer is a computer. What that means is that it’s not full of aluminum bits, cables, fuel lines, or all the other accoutrements of aviation. It’s full of lines of code. And that’s where things get dangerous.
</p><p><strong>Those lines of code</strong> were no doubt created by people at the direction of managers. Neither such coders nor their managers are as in touch with the particular culture and mores of the aviation world as much as the people who are down on the factory floor, riveting wings on, designing control yokes, and fitting landing gears. Those people have decades of institutional memory about what has worked in the past and what has not worked. Software people do not.
</p><p>
In the 737 Max, only one of the flight management computers is active at a time—either the pilot’s computer or the copilot’s computer. And the active computer takes inputs
<em>only</em> from the sensors on its own side of the aircraft.
</p><p>
When the two computers disagree, the solution for the humans in the cockpit is 
to look across the control panel to see
 what the other instruments are saying and then sort it out. In the Boeing system, the flight
 management computer does not “look 
across” at the other instruments. It 
believes only the instruments on its side. It doesn’t go old-school. It’s modern. It’s software.
</p><p>
This means that if a particular angle-of-attack sensor goes haywire—which happens all the time in a machine that alternates from one extreme environment to another, vibrating and shaking all the way—the flight management computer just believes it.
</p><p>
It gets even worse. There are several other instruments that can be used to determine things like angle of attack, either directly or indirectly, such as the pitot tubes, the artificial horizons, etc. All of these things would be cross-checked by a human pilot to quickly diagnose a faulty angle-of-attack sensor.
</p><p>
In a pinch, a human pilot could just look out the windshield to confirm visually and directly that, no, the aircraft is not pitched up dangerously. That’s the ultimate check and should go directly to the pilot’s ultimate sovereignty. Unfortunately, the current implementation of MCAS denies that sovereignty. It denies the pilots the ability to respond to what’s before their own eyes.
</p><p>
Like someone with narcissistic personality disorder, MCAS gaslights the pilots. And it turns out badly for everyone. “Raise the nose, HAL.” “I’m sorry, Dave, I’m afraid I can’t do that.”
</p><p>
In the MCAS system, the flight management computer is blind to any other evidence that it is wrong, including what the pilot sees with his own eyes and what he does when he desperately tries to pull back on the robotic control columns that are biting him, and his passengers, to death.
</p><p>
In the old days, the FAA had armies of aviation engineers in its employ. Those FAA employees worked side by side with the airplane manufacturers to determine that an airplane was safe and could be certified as airworthy.
</p><p>
As airplanes became more complex and the gulf between what the FAA could pay and what an aircraft manufacturer could pay grew larger, more and more of those engineers migrated from the public to the private sector. Soon the FAA had no in-house ability to determine if a particular airplane’s design and manufacture were safe. So the FAA said to the airplane manufacturers, “Why don’t you just have your people tell us if your designs are safe?”
</p><p>
The airplane manufacturers said, “Sounds good to us.” The FAA said, “And say hi to Joe, we miss him.”
</p><p>
Thus was born the concept of the “Designated Engineering Representative,” or DER. DERs are people in the employ of the airplane manufacturers, the engine manufacturers, and the software developers who certify to the FAA that it’s all good.
</p><p>
Now this is not quite as sinister a conflict of interest as it sounds. It is in nobody’s interest that airplanes crash. The industry absolutely relies on the public trust, and every crash is an existential threat to the industry. No manufacturer is going to employ DERs that just pencil-whip the paperwork. On the other hand, though, after a long day and after the assurance of some software folks, they might just take their word that things will be okay.
</p><p>
It is astounding that no one who wrote the MCAS software for the 737 Max seems even to have raised the possibility of using multiple inputs, including the opposite angle-of-attack sensor, in the computer’s determination of an impending stall. As a lifetime member of the <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/software-development">software development</a> fraternity, I don’t know what toxic combination of inexperience, hubris, or lack of cultural understanding led to this mistake.
</p><p>
But I do know that it’s indicative of a much deeper problem. The people who wrote the code for the original MCAS system were obviously terribly far out of their league and did not know it. How can they implement a software fix, much less give us any comfort that the rest of the flight management software is reliable?
</p><p><strong>So Boeing produced</strong> a dynamically unstable airframe, the 737 Max. That is big strike No. 1. Boeing then tried to mask the 737’s dynamic instability with a software system. Big strike No. 2. Finally, the software relied on systems known for their propensity to fail (angle-of-attack indicators) and did not appear to include even rudimentary provisions to cross-check the outputs of the angle-of-attack sensor against other sensors, or even the other angle-of-attack sensor. Big strike No. 3.
</p><p>
None of the above should have passed muster. None of the above should have passed the “OK” pencil of the most junior engineering staff, much less a DER.
</p><p>
That’s not a big strike. That’s a political, social, economic, and technical sin.
</p><p>
It just so happens that, during the timeframe between the first 737 Max crash and the most recent 737 crash, I’d had the occasion to upgrade and install a brand-new digital autopilot in my own aircraft. I own a 1979 Cessna 172, the most common aircraft in history, at least by production numbers. Its original certification also predates that of the 737’s by about a decade (1955 versus 1967).
</p><p>
My new autopilot consists of several very modern components, including redundant flight computers (dual Garmin G5s) and a sophisticated communication “bus” (a Controller Area Network bus) that lets all the various components talk to one another, irrespective of where they are located in my plane. A CAN bus derives from automotive “drive by wire” technology but is otherwise very similar in purpose and form to the various ARINC buses that connect the components in the 737 Max.
</p><p>
My autopilot also includes electric pitch trim. That means it can make the same types of configuration changes to my 172 that the flight computers and MCAS system make to the 737 Max. During the installation, after the first 737 Max crash, I remember remarking to a friend that it was not lost on me that I was potentially adding a hazard similar to the one that brought down the Lion Air crash.
</p><p>
Finally, my new autopilot also implements “envelope protection,” the envelope being the graph of the performance limitations of an aircraft. If my Cessna is
<em>not</em> being flown by the autopilot, the system nonetheless constantly monitors the airplane to make sure that I am not about to stall it, roll it inverted, or a whole host of other things. Yes, it has its own “bitey dog” mode.
</p><p>
As you can see, the similarities between my US $20,000 autopilot and the multimillion-dollar autopilot in every 737 are direct, tangible, and relevant. What, then, are the differences?
</p><p>
For starters, the installation of my autopilot required paperwork in the form of a “Supplemental Type Certificate,” or STC. It means that the autopilot manufacturer and the FAA both agreed that my 1979 Cessna 172 with its (Garmin) autopilot was so significantly different from what the airplane was when it rolled off the assembly line that it was
<em>no longer the same Cessna 172. </em>It was a different aircraft altogether.
</p><p>
In addition to now carrying a new (supplemental) aircraft-type certificate (and certification), my 172 required a very large amount of new paperwork to be carried in the plane, in the form of revisions and addenda to the aircraft operating manual. As you can guess, most of those addenda revolved around the autopilot system.
</p><p>
Of particular note in that documentation, which must be studied and understood by anyone who flies the plane, are various explanations of the autopilot system, including its command of the trim control system and its envelope protections.
</p><p>
There are instructions on how to detect when the system malfunctions
<em>and how to disable the system, immediately. </em>Disabling the system means pulling the autopilot circuit breaker; instructions on how to do that are strewn throughout the documentation, repeatedly. Every pilot who flies my plane becomes intimately aware that it is <em>not </em>the same as any other 172.
</p><p>
This is a big difference between what pilots who want to fly my plane are told and what pilots stepping into a 737 Max are (or were) told.
</p><p>
Another difference is between the autopilots in my system and that in the 737 Max. All of the CAN bus–interconnected components constantly do the kind of instrument cross-check that human pilots do and that, apparently, the MCAS system in the 737 Max does not. For example, the autopilot itself has a self-contained attitude platform that checks the attitude information coming from the G5 flight computers. If there is a disagreement, the system simply goes off-line and alerts the pilot that she is now flying manually. It doesn’t point the airplane’s nose at the ground, thinking it’s about to stall.
</p><p>
Perhaps the biggest difference is in the amount of physical force it takes for the pilot to override the computers in the two planes. In my 172, there are still cables linking the controls to the flying surfaces. The computer has to press on the same things that I have to press on—and its strength is nowhere near as great as mine. So even if, say, the computer thought that my plane was about to stall when it wasn’t, I can easily overcome the computer.
</p><p>
In my Cessna, humans still win a battle of the wills every time. That used to be a design philosophy of every Boeing aircraft, as well, and one they used against their archrival Airbus, which had a different philosophy. But it seems that with the 737 Max, Boeing has changed philosophies about human/machine interaction as quietly as they’ve changed their aircraft operating manuals.
</p><p>
The 737 Max saga teaches us not only about the limits of technology and the risks of complexity, it teaches us about our real priorities. Today, safety doesn’t come first—money comes first, and safety’s only utility in that regard is in helping to keep the money coming. The problem is getting worse because our devices are increasingly dominated by something that’s all too easy to manipulate: software.
</p><p>
Hardware defects, whether they are engines placed in the wrong place on a plane or
<a href="/tech-history/heroic-failures/the-space-shuttle-a-case-of-subjective-engineering">O-rings</a> that turn brittle when cold, are notoriously hard to fix. And by hard, I mean expensive. Software defects, on the other hand, are easy and cheap to fix. All you need to do is post an update and push out a patch. What’s more, we’ve trained consumers to consider this normal, whether it’s an update to my desktop <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/operating-systems">operating systems</a> or the patches that get posted automatically to my <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/tesla">Tesla</a> while I sleep.
</p><p>
Back in the 1990s, I wrote an article comparing the relative complexity of the Pentium <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/processors">processors</a> of that era, expressed as the number of transistors on the chip, to the complexity of the Windows <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/operating-system">operating system</a>, expressed as the number of lines of code. I found that the complexity of the Pentium processors and the contemporaneous Windows operating system was roughly equal.
</p><p>
That was the time when early Pentiums were affected by what was known as the
FDIV bug. It affected only a tiny fraction of Pentium users. Windows was also affected by similar defects, also affecting only fractions of its users.
</p><p>
But the effects on the companies were quite different. Where Windows addressed its small defects with periodic software updates, in 1994 <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/intel">Intel</a> recalled the (slightly) defective processors. It cost the company $475 million—more than $800 million in today’s money.
</p><p>
I believe the relative ease—not to mention the lack of tangible cost—of software updates has created a cultural laziness within the software engineering community. Moreover, because more and more of the hardware that we create is monitored and controlled by software, that cultural laziness is now creeping into hardware engineering—like building airliners. Less thought is now given to getting a design correct and simple up front because it’s so easy to fix what you didn’t get right later.
</p><p>
Every time a <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/software-update">software update</a> gets pushed to my Tesla, to the Garmin flight computers in my Cessna, to my Nest thermostat, and to the TVs in my house, I’m reminded that none of those things were complete when they left the factory—because their builders realized they didn’t have to be complete. The job could be done at any time in the future with a software update.
</p><div class="ieee-pullquote">
“I’m a software developer turned network engineer and have written airliner avionics software in the past. It was interesting how many hoops we had to jump through to get an add-on board for the computer certified, while software certifications were nil (other than “cannot run on Windows,” “must be written in C++”). This was, admittedly, nearly 10 years ago, and I hope that things have changed since.”
</div><p><strong>Boeing is in the process</strong> of rolling out a set of software updates to the 737 Max <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/flight-control">flight control</a> system, including MCAS. I don’t know, but I suspect that those updates will center on two things:
</p><ol class="ee-ol"><li>Having the software “cross-check” system indicators, just as a human pilot would. Meaning, if one angle-of-attack indicator says the plane’s about to stall, but the other one says it’s not so, at least hold off judgment about pushing the nose down into the dirt and maybe let a pilot or two know you’re getting conflicting signals. 
</li><li>Backing off on the “shoot first, ask questions later” design philosophy—meaning, looking at multiple inputs. 
</li></ol><p>
For the life of me, I do not know why those two basic aviation design considerations, bedrocks of a mind-set that has served the industry so well until now, were not part of the original MCAS design. And, when they were not, I do not know or understand what part of the DER process failed to catch the fundamental design defect.
</p><p>
But I suspect that it all has to do with the same thing that brought us from Boeing’s initial desire to put larger engines on the 737 and to avoid having to internalize the cost of those larger engines—in other words, to do what every child is taught is impossible: get a free lunch.
</p><p>
The emphasis on simplicity comes from the work of
<a href="/energy/policy/shrink-the-targets">Charles Perrow</a>, a sociologist at <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/yale">Yale</a> University whose 1984 book, <em>Normal Accidents: Living With High-Risk Technologies</em>, tells it all in the very title. Perrow argues that system failure is a normal outcome in any system that is very complex and whose components are “tightly bound”—meaning that the behavior of one component immediately controls the behavior of another. Though such failures may seem to stem from one or another faulty part or practice, they must be seen as inherent in the system itself. They are “normal” failures.
</p><p>
Nowhere is this problem more acutely felt than in systems designed to augment or improve safety. Every increment, every increase in complexity, ultimately leads to decreasing rates of return and, finally, to negative returns. Trying to patch and then repatch such a system in an attempt to make it safer can end up making it less safe.
</p><p>
This is the root of the old engineering axiom “Keep it simple, stupid” (KISS) and its aviation-specific counterpart: “
<a href="https://www.classicdriver.com/en/article/genius-colin-chapman-simplify-then-add-lightness%E2%80%9D">Simplify, then add lightness.”</a></p><p>
The original FAA Eisenhower-era certification requirement was a testament to simplicity: Planes should not exhibit significant pitch changes with changes in engine power. That requirement was written when there was a direct connection between the controls in the pilot’s hands and the flying surfaces on the airplane. Because of that, the requirement—when written—rightly imposed a discipline of simplicity on the design of the airframe itself. Now software stands between man and machine, and no one seems to know exactly what is going on. Things have become too complex to understand.
</p><p>
I cannot get the parallels between the 737 Max and the <a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/space-shuttle">space shuttle</a> Challenger out of my head. The Challenger accident, another textbook case study in normal failure, came about not because people didn’t follow the rules but because they did. In the Challenger case, the rules said that they had to have prelaunch conferences to ascertain flight readiness. It didn’t say that a significant input to those conferences couldn’t be the political considerations of delaying a launch. The inputs were weighed, the process was followed, and a majority consensus was to launch. And seven people died.
</p><p>
In the 737 Max case, the rules were also followed. The rules said you couldn’t have a large pitch-up on power change and that an employee of the manufacturer, a DER, could sign off on whatever you came up with to prevent a pitch change on power change. The rules didn’t say that the DER couldn’t take the business considerations into the decision-making process. And 346 people are dead.
</p><p>
It is likely that MCAS, originally added in the spirit of increasing safety, has now killed more people than it could have ever saved. It doesn’t need to be “fixed” with more complexity, more software. It needs to be removed altogether.
</p><p>
An
<a href="https://drive.google.com/file/d/1249KS8xtIDKb5SxgpeFI6AD-PSC6nFA5/view">earlier version</a> of this article was cited in <a href="https://www.eetimes.com/document.asp?doc_id=1334482"><em>EE Times</em></a>.
</p><p><em>Editor’s note: This story was updated on 21 April to clarify that the MCAS pushes the airliner’s nose by means of the “Elevator Feel Computer.”</em></p><div class="around-the-web"><div class="from-your-site__headline">From Your Site Articles</div><ul class="around-the-web__list"><li class="from-your-site__item"><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/memory-safe-programming-languages" class="from-your-site__link" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">The Move to Memory-Safe Programming - IEEE Spectrum ›</a></li><li class="from-your-site__item"><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-top-programming-languages-2023" class="from-your-site__link" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">The Top Programming Languages 2023 - IEEE Spectrum ›</a></li></ul></div></div></div><span class="" data-elid="2650278376" data-post-url="https://spectrum.ieee.org/how-the-boeing-737-max-disaster-looks-to-a-software-developer" data-authors="Gregory Travis" data-headline="How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Developer" data-page-title="How the Boeing 737 Max Disaster Looks to a Software Developer - IEEE Spectrum"></span><div class="tags"><a class="tags__item" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/aviation">aviation</a><a class="tags__item" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/software">software</a><a class="tags__item" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/airbus">airbus</a><a class="tags__item" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/boeing">boeing</a><a class="tags__item" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tag/737-max">737 max</a></div></div></div></div><script type="application/json" id="post-context-2650278376" class="post-context post-context-2650278376">
{"customDimensions": {"5":"Gregory Travis","11":2650278376,"7":"aviation, software, airbus, boeing, 737-max","10":"aviation","6":"aerospace","8":"04/18/2019"}, "post": {"id": 2650278376, "providerId": 20, "sections": [0, 497728257, 497728258, 544169516, 544169517, 2289600833, 2289599519, 2289605931, 2289600218, 2289615276], "authors": [21081394], "tags": ["aviation", "software", "airbus", "boeing", "737-max"], "streams": [], "split_testing": {}} }
</script></article></div></div></div></div><div class="container_feature_below" id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1"><div class="" id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_0"><div class="mb-2 post-author-list" id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_0_0"><div class="posts-custom posts-custom-section section-holder clearfix" data-block="None" data-format="posts-custom" data-source="current_post" data-source-type="current_post" data-source-unique="true" data-section-id="" data-is-reordable="false" data-using-stickers="false" data-has-more="false" data-attr-format="posts-custom" data-attr-posts_id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_0_0" data-attr-layout_quality="1" data-attr-node_id="/root/blocks/block[open_current_feature_post]/abtests/abtest[1]/rm_tabs/rm_wrapper[1]/element_wrapper/element_wrapper/current_post-" data-attr-layout_all_headline_tag="h1" data-attr-layout_all_subheadline_tag="h2" data-attr-all_element_order="author,headline,subheadline,section,community_name,date,date_modified,badges,badges_sponsored,photo_credit,photo_caption,body,snark_line,page_views,post_shares,follow_button,community_comments,like_button,source_link,collection_button,tags,primary_tag,main_author,all_sections,product_prices,product_vendor,product_buy_link,words_count,time_to_read,site_field_first_name,site_field_last_name,site_field_Instagram,site_field_member_badges,site_field_Twitter,site_field_LinkedIn,site_field_grade,site_field_Facebook,custom_field_due_date,custom_field_FeaturePostImgPosition,custom_field_pdf_version,custom_field_copy_editor,custom_field_FullwidthCardColor,custom_field_disable_comments,custom_field_PodcastVideoTime,custom_field_fullwidthbackgroundposition,custom_field_lightbox_img_shortcode_ids,custom_field_access,custom_field_Editor,custom_field_PodcastEpisode,custom_field_publication_date,custom_field_TimeofRead,custom_field_FeaturePostColor,custom_field_FullwidthCardPosition,custom_field_is_updated_post,custom_field_youtube_video" data-attr-layout_author="top" data-attr-layout_remove_image="true" data-attr-show_authors_bio="true" data-attr-element_classes="post-author-list" data-attr-data-rm-advanced="true" data-attr-data-rm-ecomerce="true" data-attr-filters="" data-attr-section_url="" data-attr-source="" data-attr-is_current_post="true"><div class="posts-wrapper clearfix"><div class="widget post-partial tag-aviation tag-software tag-airbus tag-boeing tag-737-max post-section--topic/aerospace" data-category="Aerospace"><article elid="2650278376" data-frozen-sections="[]" class="clearfix page-article sm-mb-1 quality-HD post-2650278376" data-category="Aerospace"><div class="row px10"><div class="rm-col-center col sm-mb-1" style="width:100.0%;"><div class="widget__body clearfix sm-mt-1"><div class="social-author clearfix"><div class="social-author__avatar image"><div class="cover-all image" style="background-image: url(&quot;https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjY0NTkxNC9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTYyODI0MzE3M30.NwS_cVTzuyCiLxaAml2FFbcCzSQcEEQvx8aDC_ELg_M/image.png?width=980&quot;)"></div></div><a class="social-author__name" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/u/gregory-travis" data-type="text">Gregory Travis</a><div class="social-author__bio"><p><a href="https://www.linkedin.com/in/gregorytravis" target="_blank">Gregory Travis</a> is a writer, a software executive, a pilot, and an aircraft owner. In 1977, at the age of 13, he wrote Note, one of the first social media platforms, and he has logged more than 2,000 hours of flying time, ranging from gliders to a Boeing 757 (as a full-motion simulator).
</p></div></div></div><div class="widget__head"></div></div></div><script type="application/json" id="post-context-2650278376" class="post-context post-context-2650278376">
{"customDimensions": {"5":"Gregory Travis","11":2650278376,"7":"aviation, software, airbus, boeing, 737-max","10":"aviation","6":"aerospace","8":"04/18/2019"}, "post": {"id": 2650278376, "providerId": 20, "sections": [0, 497728257, 497728258, 544169516, 544169517, 2289600833, 2289599519, 2289605931, 2289600218, 2289615276], "authors": [21081394], "tags": ["aviation", "software", "airbus", "boeing", "737-max"], "streams": [], "split_testing": {}} }
</script></article></div></div></div></div><span class="viewport-css-anchor"></span></div><div class="" id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_1_1_0"><div class="post-partial article__comments"><div class="article-content__comments-wrapper"><div id="comments-widget"><div class="talk-comments-wrp community-native-wrp " data-talk_id="post:2650278376:comments" data-limit="3" data-order="best" data-is_amp="" data-count_top_level="8" data-count_featured="0" data-show_rating="False" data-expand_replies="" data-all_element_order="avatar,title,date,site_field_member_badges,site_field_grade,message,update_author_rating,update_avatar,follow,bio,review" data-words-per-message="{&quot;min&quot;: 1, &quot;max&quot;: 250}" data-inactive_layout_attributes="update_avatar,follow,bio,review" data-active_layout_attributes="site_field_member_badges,site_field_grade"><div class="editmode-section-title"></div><span class="hidden new-comments-notification" aria-label="New coments notification"></span><div class="comment-headline">The Conversation (8)</div><div class="add-comment"><div class="comment_placeholder-wrp"><div class="animated-background"><div class="placeholder__textarea_top"></div><div class="placeholder__textarea_botmiddle_left"></div><div class="placeholder__textarea_botmiddle_right"></div><div class="placeholder__textarea_bottom"></div><div class="placeholder__button_b"></div><div class="placeholder__button_i"></div><div class="placeholder__button_publish"></div></div><div class="comment-login-wrp"></div></div></div><div class="comment-header"></div><div class="talk--messages"><div class="talk--messages__featured"></div><div class="talk--messages__top_level"><div id="comment-65a2dab4b6890e0595ae006a" class="comment--item approved-comment" data-talk_id="post:2650278376:comments" data-message_id="65a2dab4b6890e0595ae006a" data-parents=""><div class="comment--item-avatar"><img src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy81MTA3OTcwNi9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTg0MzgyNDcxOH0.y7fFxZL0qGP0OqCqYyVxwaG75lRA834fRz3M24uX9xc/image.png?width=210" title="Greg Frank" alt="Greg Frank" loading="lazy" width="38" height="38"/></div><div class="comment--item-text"><span class="comment--item-username">Greg Frank</span><span class="comment--item-date" title="January 13 2024, 18:47:16">13 Jan, 2024</span><div class="comment--custom-field-grade" data-value="INDV">
INDV
</div><div class="comment--item-message"><p>This is a great article bringing together insight and understanding from multiple areas of expertise. I am surprised to see so few comments nearly 5 years later as this aircraft remains in the news. Your comment about <em>&quot;<strong>I don&#39;t know what toxic combination of inexperience, hubris, or lack of cultural understanding led to this mistake.&quot;</strong> </em>really hits home for me as a software engineer. Some companies attempt fully open and blameless incident reviews. Too bad the aerospace industry has nothing to gain form that openness and probably a lot to lose from a legal perspective. Without hearing from someone on the inside testifying or leaking we will never know the explanation for this entirely preventable negative outcome.There is a non-zero chance the cause relates to a culture prioritizing authoritative hierarchy over engineering truth. That is often paired with a bureaucratic compartmentalization of work intentionally severing lines of communication between teams. Either or both of these create an environment suppressing understanding of risk and blocking mitigation attempts.</p><p></p><p>About complexity and <strong>KISS</strong>, shifting from one sensor to multiple sensors grows complexity. The chance software can actually untangle multiple conflicting sensor readings to find the &quot;real&quot; one is low. The only safe choice is to give up and disengage at any sign of sensor problems. At that point, the total system reliability is reduced to the odds of any single input sensor failing. That design path may be the correct choice but it has consequences to be considered and documented.</p></div><div class="comment--item--action"><div><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="reply" class="comment--item__reply disabled" data-message_id="65a2dab4b6890e0595ae006a" aria-label="reply"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M10 9V5l-7 7 7 7v-4.1c5 0 8.5 1.6 11 5.1-1-5-4-10-11-11z"></path><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="share" class="comment--item__share disabled" data-message_id="65a2dab4b6890e0595ae006a" aria-label="share"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path><path d="M18 16.08c-.76 0-1.44.3-1.96.77L8.91 12.7c.05-.23.09-.46.09-.7s-.04-.47-.09-.7l7.05-4.11c.54.5 1.25.81 2.04.81 1.66 0 3-1.34 3-3s-1.34-3-3-3-3 1.34-3 3c0 .24.04.47.09.7L8.04 9.81C7.5 9.31 6.79 9 6 9c-1.66 0-3 1.34-3 3s1.34 3 3 3c.79 0 1.5-.31 2.04-.81l7.12 4.16c-.05.21-.08.43-.08.65 0 1.61 1.31 2.92 2.92 2.92 1.61 0 2.92-1.31 2.92-2.92s-1.31-2.92-2.92-2.92z"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="like" class="comment--item__like disabled" data-action="like" data-message_id="65a2dab4b6890e0595ae006a" aria-label="like"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path fill="none" d="M0 0h24v24H0V0z"></path><path d="M1 21h4V9H1v12zm22-11c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2h-6.31l.95-4.57.03-.32c0-.41-.17-.79-.44-1.06L14.17 1 7.59 7.59C7.22 7.95 7 8.45 7 9v10c0 1.1.9 2 2 2h9c.83 0 1.54-.5 1.84-1.22l3.02-7.05c.09-.23.14-.47.14-.73v-2z"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="unlike" class="comment--item__dislike disabled" data-action="dislike" data-message_id="65a2dab4b6890e0595ae006a" aria-label="unlike"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path fill="none" d="M0 0h24v24H0z"></path><path d="M15 3H6c-.83 0-1.54.5-1.84 1.22l-3.02 7.05c-.09.23-.14.47-.14.73v2c0 1.1.9 2 2 2h6.31l-.95 4.57-.03.32c0 .41.17.79.44 1.06L9.83 23l6.59-6.59c.36-.36.58-.86.58-1.41V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm4 0v12h4V3h-4z"></path></svg></a></div></div><div class="comment-login-wrp"></div></div><div class="replies level-two hidden"><a href="javascript: void(0);" class="comment--show--replies " data-message_id="65a2dab4b6890e0595ae006a" aria-label="show replies"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="16" height="16" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M16.59 8.59L12 13.17 7.41 8.59 6 10l6 6 6-6z"></path><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path></svg><span class="comment--count">0</span>
Replies
</a><a href="javascript: void(0);" class="comment--hide--replies hidden" data-message_id="65a2dab4b6890e0595ae006a" aria-label="hide replies"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="16" height="16" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M12 8l-6 6 1.41 1.41L12 10.83l4.59 4.58L18 14z"></path><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path></svg>
Hide replies
</a><div class="reply-items hidden"></div><div class="talk--load_more__replies hidden" data-message_id="65a2dab4b6890e0595ae006a">Show More Replies</div></div></div><div id="comment-6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9" class="comment--item approved-comment" data-talk_id="post:2650278376:comments" data-message_id="6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9" data-parents=""><div class="comment--item-avatar"><img src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjY0NTkxNC9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTYyODI0MzE3M30.NwS_cVTzuyCiLxaAml2FFbcCzSQcEEQvx8aDC_ELg_M/image.png?width=980" title="Kevin Brown" alt="Kevin Brown" loading="lazy" width="38" height="38"/></div><div class="comment--item-text"><span class="comment--item-username">Kevin Brown</span><span class="comment--item-date" title="September 07 2022, 16:48:15">07 Sep, 2022</span><div class="comment--custom-field-grade" data-value="INDV">
INDV
</div><div class="comment--item-message"><p>Really good article. I came here because I remembered the detail about MCAS only looking at one AoA sensors and not both, and I was convinced that someone at Boeing had to have been aware of that. But the way you write it, nope. Anyway, great article. This just came out:</p><p></p><p>https://www.washingtonpost.com/transportation/2022/09/07/faa-boeing-oversight/</p><p></p></div><div class="comment--item--action"><div><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="reply" class="comment--item__reply disabled" data-message_id="6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9" aria-label="reply"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M10 9V5l-7 7 7 7v-4.1c5 0 8.5 1.6 11 5.1-1-5-4-10-11-11z"></path><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="share" class="comment--item__share disabled" data-message_id="6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9" aria-label="share"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path><path d="M18 16.08c-.76 0-1.44.3-1.96.77L8.91 12.7c.05-.23.09-.46.09-.7s-.04-.47-.09-.7l7.05-4.11c.54.5 1.25.81 2.04.81 1.66 0 3-1.34 3-3s-1.34-3-3-3-3 1.34-3 3c0 .24.04.47.09.7L8.04 9.81C7.5 9.31 6.79 9 6 9c-1.66 0-3 1.34-3 3s1.34 3 3 3c.79 0 1.5-.31 2.04-.81l7.12 4.16c-.05.21-.08.43-.08.65 0 1.61 1.31 2.92 2.92 2.92 1.61 0 2.92-1.31 2.92-2.92s-1.31-2.92-2.92-2.92z"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="like" class="comment--item__like disabled" data-action="like" data-message_id="6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9" aria-label="like"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path fill="none" d="M0 0h24v24H0V0z"></path><path d="M1 21h4V9H1v12zm22-11c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2h-6.31l.95-4.57.03-.32c0-.41-.17-.79-.44-1.06L14.17 1 7.59 7.59C7.22 7.95 7 8.45 7 9v10c0 1.1.9 2 2 2h9c.83 0 1.54-.5 1.84-1.22l3.02-7.05c.09-.23.14-.47.14-.73v-2z"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="unlike" class="comment--item__dislike disabled" data-action="dislike" data-message_id="6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9" aria-label="unlike"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path fill="none" d="M0 0h24v24H0z"></path><path d="M15 3H6c-.83 0-1.54.5-1.84 1.22l-3.02 7.05c-.09.23-.14.47-.14.73v2c0 1.1.9 2 2 2h6.31l-.95 4.57-.03.32c0 .41.17.79.44 1.06L9.83 23l6.59-6.59c.36-.36.58-.86.58-1.41V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm4 0v12h4V3h-4z"></path></svg></a></div></div><div class="comment-login-wrp"></div></div><div class="replies level-two "><a href="javascript: void(0);" class="comment--show--replies " data-message_id="6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9" aria-label="show replies"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="16" height="16" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M16.59 8.59L12 13.17 7.41 8.59 6 10l6 6 6-6z"></path><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path></svg><span class="comment--count">1</span>
Reply
</a><a href="javascript: void(0);" class="comment--hide--replies hidden" data-message_id="6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9" aria-label="hide replies"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="16" height="16" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M12 8l-6 6 1.41 1.41L12 10.83l4.59 4.58L18 14z"></path><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path></svg>
Hide replies
</a><div class="reply-items hidden"><div id="comment-6680be99a45e79b3f8c13606" class="comment--item approved-comment" data-talk_id="post:2650278376:comments" data-message_id="6680be99a45e79b3f8c13606" data-parents="6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9"><div class="comment--item-avatar"><img src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjY0NTkxNC9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTYyODI0MzE3M30.NwS_cVTzuyCiLxaAml2FFbcCzSQcEEQvx8aDC_ELg_M/image.png?width=980" title="Graham Stevenson" alt="Graham Stevenson" loading="lazy" width="38" height="38"/></div><div class="comment--item-text"><span class="comment--item-username">Graham Stevenson</span><span class="comment--item-date" title="June 30 2024, 02:10:33">30 Jun, 2024</span><div class="comment--custom-field-grade" data-value="INDV">
INDV
</div><div class="comment--item-message"><p>The original software did have the functionality to compare both of the AoA sensors and illuminate an &#39;AoA disagree&#39; annunciator on the panel but this was an extra cost option which few airlines chose (if any).</p><p></p><p>At which point any sensible person may well have a &#39;facepalm&#39; moment.</p></div><div class="comment--item--action"><div><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="reply" class="comment--item__reply disabled" data-message_id="6680be99a45e79b3f8c13606" aria-label="reply"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M10 9V5l-7 7 7 7v-4.1c5 0 8.5 1.6 11 5.1-1-5-4-10-11-11z"></path><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="share" class="comment--item__share disabled" data-message_id="6680be99a45e79b3f8c13606" aria-label="share"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path><path d="M18 16.08c-.76 0-1.44.3-1.96.77L8.91 12.7c.05-.23.09-.46.09-.7s-.04-.47-.09-.7l7.05-4.11c.54.5 1.25.81 2.04.81 1.66 0 3-1.34 3-3s-1.34-3-3-3-3 1.34-3 3c0 .24.04.47.09.7L8.04 9.81C7.5 9.31 6.79 9 6 9c-1.66 0-3 1.34-3 3s1.34 3 3 3c.79 0 1.5-.31 2.04-.81l7.12 4.16c-.05.21-.08.43-.08.65 0 1.61 1.31 2.92 2.92 2.92 1.61 0 2.92-1.31 2.92-2.92s-1.31-2.92-2.92-2.92z"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="like" class="comment--item__like disabled" data-action="like" data-message_id="6680be99a45e79b3f8c13606" aria-label="like"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path fill="none" d="M0 0h24v24H0V0z"></path><path d="M1 21h4V9H1v12zm22-11c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2h-6.31l.95-4.57.03-.32c0-.41-.17-.79-.44-1.06L14.17 1 7.59 7.59C7.22 7.95 7 8.45 7 9v10c0 1.1.9 2 2 2h9c.83 0 1.54-.5 1.84-1.22l3.02-7.05c.09-.23.14-.47.14-.73v-2z"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="unlike" class="comment--item__dislike disabled" data-action="dislike" data-message_id="6680be99a45e79b3f8c13606" aria-label="unlike"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path fill="none" d="M0 0h24v24H0z"></path><path d="M15 3H6c-.83 0-1.54.5-1.84 1.22l-3.02 7.05c-.09.23-.14.47-.14.73v2c0 1.1.9 2 2 2h6.31l-.95 4.57-.03.32c0 .41.17.79.44 1.06L9.83 23l6.59-6.59c.36-.36.58-.86.58-1.41V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm4 0v12h4V3h-4z"></path></svg></a></div></div><div class="comment-login-wrp"></div></div></div></div><div class="talk--load_more__replies hidden" data-message_id="6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9">Show More Replies</div></div></div><div id="comment-6830fe13fba9017eb2784adb" class="comment--item approved-comment" data-talk_id="post:2650278376:comments" data-message_id="6830fe13fba9017eb2784adb" data-parents=""><div class="comment--item-avatar"><img src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjY0NTkxNC9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTYyODI0MzE3M30.NwS_cVTzuyCiLxaAml2FFbcCzSQcEEQvx8aDC_ELg_M/image.png?width=980" title="Brian Huston" alt="Brian Huston" loading="lazy" width="38" height="38"/></div><div class="comment--item-text"><span class="comment--item-username">Brian Huston</span><span class="comment--item-date" title="May 23 2025, 23:00:35">23 May, 2025</span><div class="comment--custom-field-grade" data-value="INDV">
INDV
</div><div class="comment--item-message"><p>Nice article. I know it is written from the point of view of a Program developer, but I think it misses a key point. Software is too often regarded as its own separate industry when more often than not it is just a part of a complete system. Frequently this leads to software being tested only for success on its own and not being tested or evaluated for failure as part of a complete system. As automated manufacturing matures thanks to computers and software using CNC, CAD, CAM, 3D printing, and AI… the days of stating “I’m only a software developer” or “I’m only a electrical or mechanical engineer” are going to fade away. Performance is coming back into the mix in the form of product and manufacturing engineers that can bridge the gap between hardware and software in overall design. Competition for final products that work without excuses is on the rise. </p></div><div class="comment--item--action"><div><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="reply" class="comment--item__reply disabled" data-message_id="6830fe13fba9017eb2784adb" aria-label="reply"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M10 9V5l-7 7 7 7v-4.1c5 0 8.5 1.6 11 5.1-1-5-4-10-11-11z"></path><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="share" class="comment--item__share disabled" data-message_id="6830fe13fba9017eb2784adb" aria-label="share"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path><path d="M18 16.08c-.76 0-1.44.3-1.96.77L8.91 12.7c.05-.23.09-.46.09-.7s-.04-.47-.09-.7l7.05-4.11c.54.5 1.25.81 2.04.81 1.66 0 3-1.34 3-3s-1.34-3-3-3-3 1.34-3 3c0 .24.04.47.09.7L8.04 9.81C7.5 9.31 6.79 9 6 9c-1.66 0-3 1.34-3 3s1.34 3 3 3c.79 0 1.5-.31 2.04-.81l7.12 4.16c-.05.21-.08.43-.08.65 0 1.61 1.31 2.92 2.92 2.92 1.61 0 2.92-1.31 2.92-2.92s-1.31-2.92-2.92-2.92z"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="like" class="comment--item__like disabled" data-action="like" data-message_id="6830fe13fba9017eb2784adb" aria-label="like"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path fill="none" d="M0 0h24v24H0V0z"></path><path d="M1 21h4V9H1v12zm22-11c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2h-6.31l.95-4.57.03-.32c0-.41-.17-.79-.44-1.06L14.17 1 7.59 7.59C7.22 7.95 7 8.45 7 9v10c0 1.1.9 2 2 2h9c.83 0 1.54-.5 1.84-1.22l3.02-7.05c.09-.23.14-.47.14-.73v-2z"></path></svg></a><a href="javascript: void(0);" title="unlike" class="comment--item__dislike disabled" data-action="dislike" data-message_id="6830fe13fba9017eb2784adb" aria-label="unlike"><svg class="comment-action-icon" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="17" height="17" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path fill="none" d="M0 0h24v24H0z"></path><path d="M15 3H6c-.83 0-1.54.5-1.84 1.22l-3.02 7.05c-.09.23-.14.47-.14.73v2c0 1.1.9 2 2 2h6.31l-.95 4.57-.03.32c0 .41.17.79.44 1.06L9.83 23l6.59-6.59c.36-.36.58-.86.58-1.41V5c0-1.1-.9-2-2-2zm4 0v12h4V3h-4z"></path></svg></a></div></div><div class="comment-login-wrp"></div></div><div class="replies level-two hidden"><a href="javascript: void(0);" class="comment--show--replies " data-message_id="6830fe13fba9017eb2784adb" aria-label="show replies"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="16" height="16" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M16.59 8.59L12 13.17 7.41 8.59 6 10l6 6 6-6z"></path><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path></svg><span class="comment--count">0</span>
Replies
</a><a href="javascript: void(0);" class="comment--hide--replies hidden" data-message_id="6830fe13fba9017eb2784adb" aria-label="hide replies"><svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" width="16" height="16" viewbox="0 0 24 24" aria-hidden="true"><path d="M12 8l-6 6 1.41 1.41L12 10.83l4.59 4.58L18 14z"></path><path d="M0 0h24v24H0z" fill="none"></path></svg>
Hide replies
</a><div class="reply-items hidden"></div><div class="talk--load_more__replies hidden" data-message_id="6830fe13fba9017eb2784adb">Show More Replies</div></div></div></div></div><script type="rm-preact-state">{"authors": {"24736047": {"id": 26679772, "path": "u/graham_stevenson", "title": "Graham Stevenson", "image": "https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjY0NTkxNC9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTYyODI0MzE3M30.NwS_cVTzuyCiLxaAml2FFbcCzSQcEEQvx8aDC_ELg_M/image.png?width=980", "about": "", "rating": 0, "owner_id": 24736047, "site_specific_data": {"Facebook": null, "last_name": "Stevenson", "mini_bio": null, "job_title": null, "alumni_of": null, "affiliation": null, "member_badges": null, "Twitter": null, "works_for": null, "Instagram": null, "LinkedIn": null, "grade": "INDV", "member_of": null, "first_name": "Graham"}}, "24526449": {"id": 26462003, "path": "u/greg-frank", "title": "Greg Frank", "image": "https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy81MTA3OTcwNi9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTg0MzgyNDcxOH0.y7fFxZL0qGP0OqCqYyVxwaG75lRA834fRz3M24uX9xc/image.png?width=210", "about": "", "rating": 0, "owner_id": 24526449, "site_specific_data": {"Facebook": null, "last_name": "Frank", "mini_bio": null, "job_title": null, "alumni_of": null, "affiliation": null, "member_badges": null, "Twitter": null, "works_for": null, "Instagram": null, "LinkedIn": null, "grade": "INDV", "member_of": null, "first_name": "Greg"}}, "23652480": {"id": 25333607, "path": "u/kevin-brown-a", "title": "Kevin Brown", "image": "https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjY0NTkxNC9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTYyODI0MzE3M30.NwS_cVTzuyCiLxaAml2FFbcCzSQcEEQvx8aDC_ELg_M/image.png?width=980", "about": "", "rating": 0, "owner_id": 23652480, "site_specific_data": {"Facebook": null, "last_name": "Brown", "mini_bio": null, "job_title": null, "alumni_of": null, "affiliation": null, "member_badges": null, "Twitter": null, "works_for": null, "Instagram": null, "LinkedIn": null, "grade": "INDV", "member_of": null, "first_name": "Kevin"}}, "25267095": {"id": 27219726, "path": "u/brian_huston", "title": "Brian Huston", "image": "https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJpbWFnZSI6Imh0dHBzOi8vYXNzZXRzLnJibC5tcy8yNjY0NTkxNC9vcmlnaW4ucG5nIiwiZXhwaXJlc19hdCI6MTYyODI0MzE3M30.NwS_cVTzuyCiLxaAml2FFbcCzSQcEEQvx8aDC_ELg_M/image.png?width=980", "about": "", "rating": 0, "owner_id": 25267095, "site_specific_data": {"Facebook": null, "last_name": "Huston", "mini_bio": null, "job_title": null, "alumni_of": null, "affiliation": null, "member_badges": null, "Twitter": null, "works_for": null, "Instagram": null, "LinkedIn": null, "grade": "INDV", "member_of": null, "first_name": "Brian"}}}, "forcedComments": [], "topLevelComments": [{"id": "65a2dab4b6890e0595ae006a", "html": "\u003cp\u003eThis is a great article bringing together insight and understanding from multiple areas of expertise. I am surprised to see so few comments nearly 5 years later as this aircraft remains in the news. Your comment about \u003cem\u003e\"\u003cstrong\u003eI don't know what toxic combination of inexperience, hubris, or lack of cultural understanding led to this mistake.\"\u003c/strong\u003e \u003c/em\u003ereally hits home for me as a software engineer. Some companies attempt fully open and blameless incident reviews. Too bad the aerospace industry has nothing to gain form that openness and probably a lot to lose from a legal perspective. Without hearing from someone on the inside testifying or leaking we will never know the explanation for this entirely preventable negative outcome.There is a non-zero chance the cause relates to a culture prioritizing authoritative hierarchy over engineering truth. That is often paired with a bureaucratic compartmentalization of work intentionally severing lines of communication between teams. Either or both of these create an environment suppressing understanding of risk and blocking mitigation attempts.\u003c/p\u003e\u003cp\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\u003cp\u003eAbout complexity and \u003cstrong\u003eKISS\u003c/strong\u003e, shifting from one sensor to multiple sensors grows complexity. The chance software can actually untangle multiple conflicting sensor readings to find the \"real\" one is low. The only safe choice is to give up and disengage at any sign of sensor problems. At that point, the total system reliability is reduced to the odds of any single input sensor failing. That design path may be the correct choice but it has consequences to be considered and documented.\u003c/p\u003e", "data": null, "payload": {"review_score": 5}, "status": "approved", "rating": 10, "author_id": 24526449, "created_ts": 1705171636, "updated_ts": 1705171636, "parents": "", "counts": {"replies": {"total": 0, "direct": 0, "public": {"total": 0, "direct": 0, "total_eq_1": false}}, "reports": 0}}, {"id": "6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9", "html": "\u003cp\u003eReally good article. I came here because I remembered the detail about MCAS only looking at one AoA sensors and not both, and I was convinced that someone at Boeing had to have been aware of that. But the way you write it, nope. Anyway, great article. This just came out:\u003c/p\u003e\u003cp\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\u003cp\u003ehttps://www.washingtonpost.com/transportation/2022/09/07/faa-boeing-oversight/\u003c/p\u003e\u003cp\u003e\u003c/p\u003e", "data": null, "payload": {"review_score": 5}, "status": "approved", "rating": 10, "author_id": 23652480, "created_ts": 1662569295, "updated_ts": 1662569295, "parents": "", "counts": {"replies": {"total": 1, "direct": 1, "public": {"total": 1, "direct": 1, "total_eq_1": true}}, "reports": 0}}, {"id": "6830fe13fba9017eb2784adb", "html": "\u003cp\u003eNice article. I know it is written from the point of view of a Program developer, but I think it misses a key point. Software is too often regarded as its own separate industry when more often than not it is just a part of a complete system. Frequently this leads to software being tested only for success on its own and not being tested or evaluated for failure as part of a complete system. As automated manufacturing matures thanks to computers and software using CNC, CAD, CAM, 3D printing, and AI\u2026 the days of stating \u201cI\u2019m only a software developer\u201d or \u201cI\u2019m only a electrical or mechanical engineer\u201d are going to fade away. Performance is coming back into the mix in the form of product and manufacturing engineers that can bridge the gap between hardware and software in overall design. Competition for final products that work without excuses is on the rise. \u003c/p\u003e", "data": null, "payload": {"review_score": 5}, "status": "approved", "rating": 0, "author_id": 25267095, "created_ts": 1748041235, "updated_ts": 1748041235, "parents": "", "counts": {"replies": {"total": 0, "direct": 0, "public": {"total": 0, "direct": 0, "total_eq_1": false}}, "reports": 0}}], "featuredComments": [], "replies": [{"id": "6680be99a45e79b3f8c13606", "html": "\u003cp\u003eThe original software did have the functionality to compare both of the AoA sensors and illuminate an 'AoA disagree' annunciator on the panel but this was an extra cost option which few airlines chose (if any).\u003c/p\u003e\u003cp\u003e\u003c/p\u003e\u003cp\u003eAt which point any sensible person may well have a 'facepalm' moment.\u003c/p\u003e", "data": null, "payload": {}, "status": "approved", "rating": 0, "author_id": 24736047, "created_ts": 1719713433, "updated_ts": 1719713433, "parents": "6318cb4f7a5dcda28cf99db9", "counts": {"replies": {"total": 0, "direct": 0, "public": {"total": 0, "direct": 0, "total_eq_1": false}}, "reports": 0}}]}
</script><div class="talk--load_more-wrp has_load_more"></div></div></div></div></div><!-- User Code --><script>
var clickeableItems = [
".talk-comments-wrp .add-comment",
".talk-comments-wrp .comment-item--publish",
".talk-comments-wrp .comment--item__reply",
".talk-comments-wrp .comment--item__like",
".talk-comments-wrp .comment--item__dislike",
".talk-comments-wrp .replies"];
var allowed = ".comment--show--replies, .comment--hide--replies, .talk--load_more__replies";
var talkItems = document.querySelectorAll(clickeableItems.join(",")) || [];
talkItems.forEach(function(item) {
item.addEventListener("click", function(event){
if (event.target.closest(allowed)) {
return;
}
event.preventDefault();
event.stopPropagation();
openGatedPopup('for_comments');
}, true);
});
</script><!-- End User Code --></div><div class="mb-2 read_also_posts" id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_0"><div class="posts-custom posts-custom-section section-holder clearfix" data-block="section_5" data-format="posts-custom" data-source="read-also-posts-one" data-source-type="page" data-source-unique="true" data-section-id="" data-is-reordable="false" data-using-stickers="false" data-has-more="true" data-attr-cache_ttl_in_seconds="43200" data-attr-format="posts-custom" data-attr-posts_id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_0" data-attr-source_unique="true" data-attr-without_current="true" data-attr-layout_quality="1" data-attr-node_id="/root/blocks/block[open_current_feature_post]/abtests/abtest[1]/rm_tabs/rm_wrapper[1]/element_wrapper/choose[2]/otherwise/posts[1]-" data-attr-use_tag_image_for_lead_media="true" data-attr-source="filtered" data-attr-from_regular_sections_of_current_post="true" data-attr-from_regular_sections_other_than="webinar,whitepaper,sponsored,podcast,video,tests,issue-cover-posts,paper,exclude-from-site-pages,topic/the-institute" data-attr-all_element_order="all_sections,headline,date,time_to_read,like_button,custom_field_TimeofRead,section,primary_tag,author,badges,badges_sponsored,photo_credit,community_name,subheadline,snark_line,page_views,photo_caption,follow_button,community_comments,body,collection_button,tags,source_link,main_author,post_shares,custom_field_contact-person-phone,custom_field_event-performer,custom_field_event-street-address,custom_field_job-type,custom_field_event-postal-code,custom_field_contact-person-title,custom_field_event-start,custom_field_company_name,custom_field_event-end,custom_field_hiring-organization,custom_field_event-price,custom_field_job-tags,custom_field_event-city,custom_field_contact_email,custom_field_posted-on-date,custom_field_job-title,custom_field_job-location,custom_field_event-region,custom_field_event-currency,custom_field_base-salary,custom_field_event-country,custom_field_contact_person,custom_field_expire-date,date_modified,custom_field_ContentType,custom_field_CustomFieldTestEG,custom_field_Issue,custom_field_FullwidthCardColor,custom_field_FullwidthCardPosition,product_prices,product_vendor,product_buy_link,site_field_Twitter,site_field_Facebook,site_field_Instagram,site_field_LinkedIn,custom_field_PodcastVideoTime,custom_field_Editor,custom_field_PodcastEpisode,custom_field_FeaturePostColor,custom_field_due_date,custom_field_FeaturePostImgPosition,custom_field_access,site_field_member_badges,custom_field_publication_date,words_count,site_field_first_name,site_field_last_name,site_field_grade,custom_field_pdf_version,custom_field_fullwidthbackgroundposition,custom_field_copy_editor,custom_field_lightbox_img_shortcode_ids,custom_field_disable_comments,custom_field_is_updated_post,custom_field_youtube_video" data-attr-limit="1" data-attr-layout_headline="right" data-attr-data-rm-device-crops="true" data-attr-layout_desktop_image_crop="3x2" data-attr-layout_image_column_width="28" data-attr-data-rm-advanced="true" data-attr-element_classes="read_also_posts" data-attr-layout_date="right" data-attr-layout_all_date_format="%d %b %Y" data-attr-layout_all_date_full_format="false" data-attr-layout_all_image_crop="3x2" data-attr-layout_like_button="right" data-attr-layout_all_sections="right" data-attr-layout_time_to_read="right" data-attr-source_id="read-also-posts-one" data-attr-source_site="parent_site"><div class="posts-wrapper clearfix"><div class="widget tag-robotics tag-manipulation tag-tactile-sensing post-section--topic/robotics" elid="2677734602"><article elid="2677734602" data-frozen-sections="[]" class="clearfix page-article sm-mb-1 quality-HD post-2677734602"><div class="row px10"><div class="rm-col-center col sm-mb-1" style="width:28.0%;"><div class="widget__head"><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tactile-data-robots" aria-label="Robots Are Learning to Feel"><img role="img" type="lazy-image" alt="Robots Are Learning to Feel" aria-label="Robots Are Learning to Feel" src="data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg xmlns=&#39;http://www.w3.org/2000/svg&#39; viewBox=&#39;0 0 1200 800&#39;%3E%3C/svg%3E" data-runner-src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/image.jpg?id=67745231&width=1200&height=800&quality=100&coordinates=119%2C0%2C119%2C0" style="object-fit: cover;" class="rm-lazyloadable-image" width="1200" height="800"/></a></div></div><div class="rm-col-right col" style="width:72.0%;"><div class="widget__body clearfix sm-mt-1"><div class="all-related-sections"><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/topic/robotics/">Robotics</a><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/type/news/">News</a></div><h2 class="widget__headline h2"><a class="widget__headline-text " href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/tactile-data-robots" aria-label="Robots Are Learning to Feel" data-type="text">
Robots Are Learning to Feel
</a></h2><div class="social-date"><span class="social-date__text">23h</span></div><div class="time-to-read">5 min read</div><div class="like-button" data-post-likes="2"></div></div></div></div><script type="application/json" id="post-context-2677734602" class="post-context post-context-2677734602">
{"customDimensions": {"5":"Edd Gent","11":2677734602,"7":"robotics, manipulation, tactile-sensing","10":"tactile-sensing","6":"robotics","8":"09/10/2026"}, "post": {"id": 2677734602, "providerId": 20, "sections": [539266128, 497728257, 544169523, 2267926519, 550122300, 550122302, 2289599169, 2289606013, 2289613275], "authors": [21081576], "tags": ["robotics", "manipulation", "tactile-sensing"], "streams": [], "split_testing": {}} }
</script></article></div></div></div></div><div class="mb-2 read_also_posts" id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_1"><div class="posts-custom posts-custom-section section-holder clearfix" data-block="section_6" data-format="posts-custom" data-source="read-also-posts-two" data-source-type="page" data-source-unique="true" data-section-id="" data-is-reordable="false" data-using-stickers="false" data-has-more="true" data-attr-cache_ttl_in_seconds="43200" data-attr-format="posts-custom" data-attr-posts_id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_1" data-attr-source_unique="true" data-attr-without_current="true" data-attr-layout_quality="1" data-attr-node_id="/root/blocks/block[open_current_feature_post]/abtests/abtest[1]/rm_tabs/rm_wrapper[1]/element_wrapper/choose[2]/otherwise/posts[2]-" data-attr-use_tag_image_for_lead_media="true" data-attr-source="filtered" data-attr-from_regular_sections="sponsored" data-attr-from_regular_sections_other_than="webinar,whitepaper,podcast,video,tests,issue-cover-posts,paper,exclude-from-site-pages,topic/the-institute" data-attr-all_element_order="all_sections,headline,date,time_to_read,like_button,custom_field_TimeofRead,section,primary_tag,author,badges,badges_sponsored,photo_credit,community_name,subheadline,snark_line,page_views,photo_caption,follow_button,community_comments,body,collection_button,tags,source_link,main_author,post_shares,custom_field_contact-person-phone,custom_field_event-performer,custom_field_event-street-address,custom_field_job-type,custom_field_event-postal-code,custom_field_contact-person-title,custom_field_event-start,custom_field_company_name,custom_field_event-end,custom_field_hiring-organization,custom_field_event-price,custom_field_job-tags,custom_field_event-city,custom_field_contact_email,custom_field_posted-on-date,custom_field_job-title,custom_field_job-location,custom_field_event-region,custom_field_event-currency,custom_field_base-salary,custom_field_event-country,custom_field_contact_person,custom_field_expire-date,date_modified,custom_field_ContentType,custom_field_CustomFieldTestEG,custom_field_Issue,custom_field_FullwidthCardColor,custom_field_FullwidthCardPosition,product_prices,product_vendor,product_buy_link,site_field_Twitter,site_field_Facebook,site_field_Instagram,site_field_LinkedIn,custom_field_PodcastVideoTime,custom_field_Editor,custom_field_PodcastEpisode,custom_field_FeaturePostColor,custom_field_due_date,custom_field_FeaturePostImgPosition,custom_field_access,site_field_member_badges,custom_field_publication_date,words_count,site_field_first_name,site_field_last_name,site_field_grade,custom_field_pdf_version,custom_field_fullwidthbackgroundposition,custom_field_copy_editor,custom_field_lightbox_img_shortcode_ids,custom_field_disable_comments,custom_field_is_updated_post,custom_field_youtube_video" data-attr-limit="1" data-attr-layout_headline="right" data-attr-data-rm-device-crops="true" data-attr-layout_desktop_image_crop="3x2" data-attr-layout_image_column_width="28" data-attr-data-rm-advanced="true" data-attr-element_classes="read_also_posts" data-attr-layout_date="right" data-attr-layout_all_date_format="%d %b %Y" data-attr-layout_all_date_full_format="false" data-attr-layout_all_image_crop="3x2" data-attr-layout_like_button="right" data-attr-layout_all_sections="right" data-attr-layout_time_to_read="right" data-attr-source_id="read-also-posts-two" data-attr-source_site="parent_site"><div class="posts-wrapper clearfix"><div class="widget tag-articulated-robots tag-robot-uptime tag-automation tag-robot-arms tag-manufacturing tag-factory-robots tag-cables tag-industrial-robots post-section--topic/robotics" elid="2677715209"><article elid="2677715209" data-frozen-sections="[]" class="clearfix image-article sm-mb-1 quality-HD post-2677715209"><div class="row px10"><div class="rm-col-center col sm-mb-1" style="width:28.0%;"><div class="widget__head"><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/industrial-robot-cable-carrier-protection" aria-label="Protecting Dynamic Industrial Robot Cable Carriers"><img role="img" type="lazy-image" alt="Industrial robotic arm with cable management system and flexible energy chains" aria-label="Industrial robotic arm with cable management system and flexible energy chains" src="data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg xmlns=&#39;http://www.w3.org/2000/svg&#39; viewBox=&#39;0 0 1200 800&#39;%3E%3C/svg%3E" data-runner-src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/industrial-robotic-arm-with-cable-management-system-and-flexible-energy-chains.jpg?id=67633840&width=1200&height=800&quality=100&coordinates=0%2C0%2C0%2C0" style="object-fit: cover;" class="rm-lazyloadable-image" width="1200" height="800"/></a></div></div><div class="rm-col-right col" style="width:72.0%;"><div class="widget__body clearfix sm-mt-1"><div class="all-related-sections"><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/topic/robotics/">Robotics</a><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/type/sponsored/">Sponsored Article</a></div><h2 class="widget__headline h2"><a class="widget__headline-text custom-post-headline" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/industrial-robot-cable-carrier-protection" aria-label="Protecting Dynamic Industrial Robot Cable Carriers" data-type="text">
Protecting Dynamic Industrial Robot Cable Carriers
</a></h2><div class="social-date"><span class="social-date__text">03 Sep 2026</span></div><div class="time-to-read">3 min read</div><div class="like-button" data-post-likes="3"></div></div></div></div><script type="application/json" id="post-context-2677715209" class="post-context post-context-2677715209">
{"customDimensions": {"5":"Tsubaki Kabelschlepp","11":2677715209,"7":"articulated-robots, robot-uptime, automation, robot-arms, manufacturing, factory-robots, cables, industrial-robots","10":"industrial-robots","6":"robotics","8":"09/03/2026"}, "post": {"id": 2677715209, "providerId": 0, "sections": [0, 497728257, 539266128, 544169516, 544169535, 2298170381, 2298170383, 2289604032, 2289603946, 2289600859, 2289600599, 2289603960, 2289599162], "authors": [27540619], "tags": ["articulated-robots", "robot-uptime", "automation", "robot-arms", "manufacturing", "factory-robots", "cables", "industrial-robots"], "streams": [], "split_testing": {}} }
</script></article></div></div></div></div><div class="mb-2 read_also_posts" id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_2"><div class="posts-custom posts-custom-section section-holder clearfix" data-block="section_7" data-format="posts-custom" data-source="read-also-posts-three" data-source-type="page" data-source-unique="true" data-section-id="" data-is-reordable="false" data-using-stickers="false" data-has-more="true" data-attr-cache_ttl_in_seconds="300" data-attr-format="posts-custom" data-attr-posts_id="sOpen_Current_Feature_Post_0_0_12_0_0_0_0_1_2_1_2" data-attr-source_unique="true" data-attr-without_current="true" data-attr-layout_quality="1" data-attr-node_id="/root/blocks/block[open_current_feature_post]/abtests/abtest[1]/rm_tabs/rm_wrapper[1]/element_wrapper/choose[2]/otherwise/posts[3]-" data-attr-use_tag_image_for_lead_media="true" data-attr-source="filtered" data-attr-order="page-views" data-attr-order_period="12h" data-attr-from_regular_sections_of_current_post="true" data-attr-from_regular_sections_other_than="webinar,whitepaper,sponsored,podcast,video,tests,issue-cover-posts,paper,exclude-from-site-pages,topic/the-institute" data-attr-all_element_order="all_sections,headline,date,time_to_read,like_button,custom_field_TimeofRead,section,primary_tag,author,badges,badges_sponsored,photo_credit,community_name,subheadline,snark_line,page_views,photo_caption,follow_button,community_comments,body,collection_button,tags,source_link,main_author,post_shares,custom_field_contact-person-phone,custom_field_event-performer,custom_field_event-street-address,custom_field_job-type,custom_field_event-postal-code,custom_field_contact-person-title,custom_field_event-start,custom_field_company_name,custom_field_event-end,custom_field_hiring-organization,custom_field_event-price,custom_field_job-tags,custom_field_event-city,custom_field_contact_email,custom_field_posted-on-date,custom_field_job-title,custom_field_job-location,custom_field_event-region,custom_field_event-currency,custom_field_base-salary,custom_field_event-country,custom_field_contact_person,custom_field_expire-date,date_modified,custom_field_ContentType,custom_field_CustomFieldTestEG,custom_field_Issue,custom_field_FullwidthCardColor,custom_field_FullwidthCardPosition,product_prices,product_vendor,product_buy_link,site_field_Twitter,site_field_Facebook,site_field_Instagram,site_field_LinkedIn,custom_field_PodcastVideoTime,custom_field_Editor,custom_field_PodcastEpisode,custom_field_FeaturePostColor,custom_field_due_date,custom_field_FeaturePostImgPosition,custom_field_access,site_field_member_badges,custom_field_publication_date,words_count,site_field_first_name,site_field_last_name,site_field_grade,custom_field_pdf_version,custom_field_fullwidthbackgroundposition,custom_field_copy_editor,custom_field_lightbox_img_shortcode_ids,custom_field_disable_comments,custom_field_is_updated_post,custom_field_youtube_video" data-attr-limit="1" data-attr-layout_headline="right" data-attr-data-rm-device-crops="true" data-attr-layout_desktop_image_crop="3x2" data-attr-layout_image_column_width="28" data-attr-data-rm-advanced="true" data-attr-element_classes="read_also_posts" data-attr-layout_date="right" data-attr-layout_all_date_format="%d %b %Y" data-attr-layout_all_date_full_format="false" data-attr-layout_all_image_crop="3x2" data-attr-layout_like_button="right" data-attr-layout_all_sections="right" data-attr-layout_time_to_read="right" data-attr-source_id="read-also-posts-three" data-attr-source_site="parent_site"><div class="posts-wrapper clearfix"><div class="widget tag-self-driving-cars tag-self-driving tag-rivian tag-robotaxis tag-level-4-autonomy tag-rivian-r2 post-section--topic/transportation" elid="2677805237"><article elid="2677805237" data-frozen-sections="[]" class="clearfix image-article sm-mb-1 quality-HD post-2677805237"><div class="row px10"><div class="rm-col-center col sm-mb-1" style="width:28.0%;"><div class="widget__head"><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/rivian-self-driving" aria-label="Rivian’s Gambit for Full Autonomy"><img role="img" type="lazy-image" alt="Two men in dark blue shirts watch SUVs being put together on an assembly line." aria-label="Two men in dark blue shirts watch SUVs being put together on an assembly line." src="data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg xmlns=&#39;http://www.w3.org/2000/svg&#39; viewBox=&#39;0 0 1200 800&#39;%3E%3C/svg%3E" data-runner-src="https://spectrum.ieee.org/media-library/two-men-in-dark-blue-shirts-watch-suvs-being-put-together-on-an-assembly-line.jpg?id=67724197&width=1200&height=800&quality=100&coordinates=62%2C0%2C63%2C0" style="object-fit: cover;" class="rm-lazyloadable-image" width="1200" height="800"/></a></div></div><div class="rm-col-right col" style="width:72.0%;"><div class="widget__body clearfix sm-mt-1"><div class="all-related-sections"><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/topic/transportation/">Transportation</a><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/magazine/">Magazine</a><a href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/type/feature/">Feature</a></div><h2 class="widget__headline h2"><a class="widget__headline-text custom-post-headline" href="https://spectrum.ieee.org/rivian-self-driving" aria-label="Rivian’s Gambit for Full Autonomy" data-type="text">
Rivian’s Gambit for Full Autonomy
</a></h2><div class="social-date"><span class="social-date__text">08 Sep 2026</span></div><div class="time-to-read">13 min read</div><div class="like-button" data-post-likes="1"></div></div></div></div><script type="application/json" id="post-context-2677805237" class="post-context post-context-2677805237">
{"customDimensions": {"5":"Lawrence Ulrich","11":2677805237,"7":"self-driving-cars, self-driving, rivian, robotaxis, level-4-autonomy, rivian-r2","10":"self-driving","6":"transportation","8":"09/08/2026"}, "post": {"id": 2677805237, "providerId": 0, "sections": [0, 497728257, 539626628, 544169516, 544169517, 2286739568, 539622579, 2267926519, 2286715740, 2289600262, 2289600366, 2289615929, 2289612076, 2289612162, 2298492614], "authors": [21075905], "tags": ["self-driving-cars", "self-driving", "rivian", "robotaxis", "level-4-autonomy", "rivian-r2"], "streams": [], "split_testing": {}} }
</script></article></div></div></div></div></div></div></div><div class="wrapper-lazy-loading infinite-scroll-wrapper next-page-wrapper" style="display: block !important;" data-skl-id="/root/blocks/block[ss_feature_post]/abtests/abtest[1]/rm_tabs/rm_wrapper[1]/element_wrapper/lazyload-" data-has-more="true" data-more-posts-exists="true" data-posts-sources="multi_filtered_parent_site_filtered_parent_site,trending_posts_id,post_sponsor_webinar_whitepaper,post_most_sections,post_sponsored" data-ignore-page-number="false"></div></div><!-- User Code --><script>
function feature_post_full_style(){
var feature_post_full = document.querySelectorAll(".feature_post_full:not(.proc)");
for (i = 0; i < feature_post_full.length; i++) {
var style_post_color = feature_post_full[i].querySelector(".custom-field-FeaturePostColor");
var style_post_position = feature_post_full[i].querySelector(".custom-field-FeaturePostImgPosition");
if(style_post_color){
feature_post_full[i].classList.add(style_post_color.innerText.trim());
}else{
feature_post_full[i].classList.add('DarkGray');
}
if(style_post_position){
feature_post_full[i].classList.add(style_post_position.innerText.trim());
}
feature_post_full[i].classList.add('proc');
}
}
</script><!-- End User Code --></div><div class="lightbox-layout" id="s__Lightbox_Functionality_0_0_33_0_0_1_1_1"><!-- User Code --><div class="lightbox__close hm__close"></div><!-- End User Code --></div></div></div><script class="rm-i-script" defer="defer" src="https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtag/js?id=G-DPQFLXZCWN"></script><script class="rm-i-script">
(function (i, s, o, g, r, a, m) {
i["GoogleAnalyticsObject"] = r;
(i[r] = i[r] || function () { (i[r].q = i[r].q || []).push(arguments);}),(i[r].l = 1 * new Date());
})(window, document, "script", "/", "ga");
ga('create', '', 'auto', {'name': 'b'});
window.dataLayer = window.dataLayer || [];
window.gtag = function(){dataLayer.push(arguments);}
gtag('js', new Date());
var utmCampaignData = null;// ADD REFERRER AS SOURCE IF SOURCE IS NOT PRESENT OR IF ISN'T URL UTM
if(utmCampaignData && (utmCampaignData.dataSource != "url" || !utmCampaignData['campaignSource'])) {
var referrerAnchor = document.createElement('a');
referrerAnchor.setAttribute('href', document.referrer);
if(referrerAnchor.href && referrerAnchor.host) {
var splitHost = referrerAnchor.host.split(".");
var nakedDomain = splitHost.length < 3 ? splitHost[0] : splitHost[1];
if (nakedDomain) {
nakedDomain = nakedDomain[0].toUpperCase() + nakedDomain.substring(1);
utmCampaignData['campaignSource'] = nakedDomain;
}
}
}
var configParams = { transport: 'beacon', send_page_view: false };
// DEFAULTS
if (utmCampaignData) {
configParams.campaignName = utmCampaignData.campaignName;
configParams.campaignSource = utmCampaignData.campaignSource;
configParams.campaignMedium = utmCampaignData.campaignMedium;
configParams.campaignContent = utmCampaignData.campaignContent;
if (utmCampaignData.campaignKeyword) {
configParams.campaignKeyword = utmCampaignData.campaignKeyword;
}
}
gtag('config', 'G-DPQFLXZCWN', configParams);
window._ga_cd_params = window._ga_cd_params || {};
window._ga_cd_params["dimension9"] = 'socialux,1';window._ga_cd_params["dimension5"] = "Gregory Travis";
window._ga_cd_params["dimension11"] = '2650278376';
window._ga_cd_params["dimension7"] = "aviation, software, airbus, boeing, 737-max";
window._ga_cd_params["dimension10"] = 'aviation';
window._ga_cd_params["dimension6"] = 'aerospace';
window._ga_cd_params["dimension8"] = '04/18/2019';
if(window._ga_cd_params && Object.keys(window._ga_cd_params).length){
gtag('event', 'page_view', window._ga_cd_params);
}else{
gtag('event', 'page_view');
}
</script><script class="lazy-style" type="css">
.menu-item__title:after{background-image:url("")}.dark_layout .menu-item__title:after{background-image:url("")}#mobile_search_icon.fa-search:before{content:url(https://assets.rbl.ms/26018263/origin.png)}.like-btn.like .heart{background-image:url("")}.dark_layout .widget__subheadline-text:before,.podcast_collection .widget__subheadline-text:before{background-image:url("")}.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline-text:before{background-image:url("")}.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .widget__subheadline-text:before,.fullwidth_post.FillLight .widget__subheadline-text:before{background-image:url("")}.fullwidth_post.FillDark .widget__subheadline-text:before{background-image:url("")}.fullwidth_post .widget__subheadline:before{content:"";background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg%20width='7px'%20height='13px'%20viewBox='0%200%207%2013'%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20xmlns:xlink='http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink'%3E%3Cg%20id='Typography'%20stroke='none'%20stroke-width='1'%20fill='none'%20fill-rule='evenodd'%3E%3Cg%20transform='translate(-1152.000000,-384.000000)'%3E%3Crect%20x='0'%20y='0'%20width='1376'%20height='1600'%3E%3C/rect%3E%3Cg%20transform='translate(1146.136039,384.000000)'%20stroke='%23A6A6A6'%20stroke-width='1.5'%3E%3Cpolyline%20transform='translate(6.363961,6.500000)%20rotate(45.000000)%20translate(-6.363961,-6.500000)'%20points='1.86396103%202%2010.863961%202%2010.863961%2011'%3E%3C/polyline%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/svg%3E")}.fullwidth_post .like-btn.like .heart{background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg%20width='12px'%20height='14px'%20viewBox='0%200%2012%2014'%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20xmlns:xlink='http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink'%3E%3Cg%20stroke='none'%20stroke-width='1'%20fill='none'%20fill-rule='evenodd'%3E%3Cg%20transform='translate(-444.000000,-335.000000)'%20stroke='%23A6A6A6'%3E%3Cg%20transform='translate(208.000000,332.000000)'%3E%3Cg%20transform='translate(237.000000,4.000000)'%3E%3Cpath%20d='M1,0%20L9,0%20C9.55228475,-1.01453063e-16%2010,0.44771525%2010,1%20L10,12%20L10,12%20L5,9%20L0,12%20L0,1%20C-6.76353751e-17,0.44771525%200.44771525,1.01453063e-16%201,0%20Z'%3E%3C/path%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/svg%3E%0A")}.fullwidth_post.TextDarkFillTransparent .like-btn.like .heart,.fullwidth_post.FillLight .like-btn.like .heart{background-image:url("data:image/svg+xml,%3Csvg%20width='12px'%20height='14px'%20viewBox='0%200%2012%2014'%20xmlns='http://www.w3.org/2000/svg'%20xmlns:xlink='http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink'%3E%3Cg%20stroke='none'%20stroke-width='1'%20fill='none'%20fill-rule='evenodd'%3E%3Cg%20transform='translate(-444.000000,-335.000000)'%20stroke='%23404040'%3E%3Cg%20transform='translate(208.000000,332.000000)'%3E%3Cg%20transform='translate(237.000000,4.000000)'%3E%3Cpath%20d='M1,0%20L9,0%20C9.55228475,-1.01453063e-16%2010,0.44771525%2010,1%20L10,12%20L10,12%20L5,9%20L0,12%20L0,1%20C-6.76353751e-17,0.44771525%200.44771525,1.01453063e-16%201,0%20Z'%3E%3C/path%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/g%3E%3C/svg%3E%0A")}.section-podcast .story_teaser .tag-fixing-the-future .widget__head>a,.section-podcasts .story_teaser .tag-fixing-the-future .widget__head>a,.widget.tag-fixing-the-future .widget__head>a{background-image:url(https://assets.rbl.ms/26705823/origin.jpg)}.section-podcast .story_teaser .tag-chatbot-podcast .widget__head>a,.section-podcasts .story_teaser .tag-chatbot-podcast .widget__head>a,.widget.tag-chatbot-podcast .widget__head>a{background-image:url(https://assets.rbl.ms/46469974/origin.jpg)}#notification .success{color:white!important;font-family:"Favorit-Mono"!important;font-size:12px!important;background:#ff4c00!important;text-transform:uppercase!important}.fa-twitter{-webkit-mask-box-image:url(#xLogoMask);-webkit-mask-image:url(#xLogoMask);-webkit-mask-repeat:space;-webkit-mask-position:20px;-webkit-mask-origin:content-box;-webkit-mask-size:24px;background-color:currentColor}a.comment--item__like:after,a.comment--item__dislike:after{background-image:url("")}.post-author-list .social-author__bio a:first-child{display:inline}.post-author-list .posts-custom .social-author{width:100%}.post-author-list .flourish-embed,.post-author-list .rm-shortcode{display:none}
</script><script class="rm-i-script" id="parsely-cfg" src="//cdn.parsely.com/keys/spectrum.ieee.org/p.js"></script><script class="rm-i-script" id="user-javascript-medium-normal">
window.REBELMOUSE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function loadFonts(){
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.loadFontFace('IvarText', 'https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/IvarCompleteWeb/IvarText-Regular.woff2', {selector: '',
weight: '400',
style: 'normal'
});
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.loadFontFace('IvarTextItalic', 'https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/IvarCompleteWeb/IvarText-Italic.woff2', {selector: '',
weight: '400',
style: 'italic'
});
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.loadFontFace('IvarText', 'https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/IvarCompleteWeb/IvarText-Bold.woff2', {selector: '',
weight: '700',
style: 'normal'
});});
window.REBELMOUSE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.loadExternalScript("https://htlbid.com/v3/spectrum.ieee.org/rblbid.js", function() {
rblbid.addHook("beforePbjsAuction", (hbConfig, auctionInfo) => {
window.auction = {};
var d = {
key: "adxbid",
val: function (e) {
var realPrice = e.pbHg;
if (e.pbHg == 0.0 || e.pbHg == 0.01) {
window.auction[e.adUnitCode] = {"price": realPrice, "adxbid":"0.01" , "targeting":auctionInfo.bidderSettings.standard.adserverTargeting};
return 0.01;
}
e.pbHg = parseFloat((e.pbHg - 0.01).toFixed(2));
if (e.pbHg >= 0.01 && e.pbHg < 1.02) {
window.auction[e.adUnitCode] = {"price": realPrice, "adxbid":e.pbHg.toFixed(2) , "targeting":auctionInfo.bidderSettings.standard.adserverTargeting};
return e.pbHg.toFixed(2);
} else if (e.pbHg >= 1.02 && e.pbHg < 2.0) {
var temp = e.pbHg.toString();
if (/\d+(\.\d+)?/.test(temp)) {
var lastNum = parseInt(temp[temp.length - 1]);
if (lastNum % 2 == 1) {
e.pbHg = parseFloat(e.pbHg.toFixed(2)) - 0.01;
}
}
window.auction[e.adUnitCode] = {"price": realPrice, "adxbid":e.pbHg.toFixed(2) , "targeting":auctionInfo.bidderSettings.standard.adserverTargeting};
return e.pbHg.toFixed(2);
} else if (e.pbHg >= 2 && e.pbHg < 5) {
window.auction[e.adUnitCode] = {"price":realPrice, "adxbid":e.pbHg.toFixed(1) + 0 , "targeting":auctionInfo.bidderSettings.standard.adserverTargeting};
return e.pbHg.toFixed(1) + 0;
} else if (e.pbHg >= 5 && e.pbHg < 10) {
function roundDown(number) {
var decimalPart = number % 1;
if (decimalPart < 0.5) {
window.auction[e.adUnitCode] = {"price": realPrice, "adxbid":number - decimalPart , "targeting":auctionInfo.bidderSettings.standard.adserverTargeting};
return number - decimalPart}
else {
window.auction[e.adUnitCode] = {"price":realPrice, "adxbid":number - decimalPart + 0.5 , "targeting":auctionInfo.bidderSettings.standard.adserverTargeting};
return number - decimalPart + 0.5};
}
window.auction[e.adUnitCode] = {"price":realPrice, "adxbid":roundDown(e.pbHg).toFixed(1) + 0 , "targeting":auctionInfo.bidderSettings.standard.adserverTargeting};
return roundDown(e.pbHg).toFixed(1) + 0;
} else {
window.auction[e.adUnitCode] = {"price":realPrice, "adxbid":10.00 , "targeting":auctionInfo.bidderSettings.standard.adserverTargeting};
return (e.pbHg = "10.00");
}
},
};
auctionInfo.bidderSettings.standard.adserverTargeting.push(d);
let adUnits = auctionInfo.adUnits.map(item=>{return item.code});
let slotRendered = function (event) {
var slot = event.slot;
auctionInfo.adUnits.filter((adUnit) => {
if (adUnit.code == slot.getSlotElementId()) {
console.group(
"Moravac: ",
slot.getSlotElementId(),
"finished rendering."
);
console.log("Is empty:", event.isEmpty);
console.log("Prebid price?: ", window.auction[slot.getSlotElementId()]?.price || 0);
console.log("AdxBid price?: ", window.auction[slot.getSlotElementId()]?.adxbid)
if(event.isEmpty && window.auction[slot.getSlotElementId()]?.price){
//console.log("HB price is set but ad is empty");
//console.log("Reloading ad without AdXBID");
//slot.setTargeting('adxbid', '0.01');
//console.log("set: ", slot.getTargetingKeys())
//console.log("Refresh unit")
//googletag.pubads().refresh([slot], {changeCorrelator: true})
//console.log("Refreshed")
}
adUnits = adUnits.filter(function(item) {
return item !== slot.getSlotElementId()
})
console.groupEnd();
}
});
if (adUnits.length == 0){
googletag.pubads().removeEventListener("slotRenderEnded", slotRendered);
console.group(
"Moravac: ",
);
console.log("Listener removed for this auction")
console.groupEnd();
}
};
googletag.cmd.push(function () {
googletag.pubads().addEventListener("slotRenderEnded", slotRendered);
});
return auctionInfo;
});
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB
.createElementChangeListener('.rm-shortcode[href*=".pdf"]', function(pdfLink){
pdfLink.href = 'javascript:void(0);';
pdfLink.classList.add('pdf-link-nonmember');
pdfLink.addEventListener('click', function(){
openGatedPopup('for_pdf_issues');
});
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
//var ssoValidatorUrl = 'https://oamssoqae.ieee.org/ieeevendorsso/rest/auth/validatePFToken?_=' + (+ new Date());
var ssoValidatorUrl = 'https://securesso.ieee.org/ieeevendorsso/rest/auth/validatePFToken?_=' + (+ new Date());
function getCookie(name) {
const value = `; ${document.cookie}`;
const parts = value.split(`; ${name}=`);
if (parts.length === 2) return parts.pop().split(';').shift();
}
fetch(ssoValidatorUrl, {
method: 'GET',
mode: 'cors',
credentials: 'include',
}).then(function (response) {
// The API call was successful!
if (response.ok) {
response.json().then(function(result) {
if (typeof result == 'object' && result.cookieValid && getCookie('user_logged_in') !== "1") { //SSO
console.log('we should be logged in, redirect to SSO iDP');
//window.location.href = 'https://spectrumtest.ieee.org/core/saml/main/login?next_url=' + window.location.href;
window.location.href = "https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/saml/main/login?next_url=" + encodeURIComponent("https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/integrations/ieee/changes?redirect=" + window.location.href);
} else if (typeof result == 'object' && !result.cookieValid) { //SLO
console.log('we should be logged out, remove cookie and do not show user');
//document.cookie = "sessionid= ; expires = Thu, 01 Jan 1970 00:00:00 GMT";
}
});
} else {
return Promise.reject(response);
}
}).then(function (data) {
// This is the JSON from our response
console.log(data);
}).catch(function (err) {
// There was an error
console.warn('Something went wrong.', err);
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.like-btn.like', function (likeBtn) {
likeBtn.removeAttribute('data-og-href');
likeBtn.href = 'javascript:;';
likeBtn.setAttribute('aria-label', 'Save post');
likeBtn.querySelector('i').setAttribute('aria-hidden', 'true');
});
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.rebellt-item.parallax', function (parallax) {
parallax.setAttribute('aria-label', 'Parallax Image');
});
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.site_logo', function (header) {
header.setAttribute('aria-label', 'header');
header.nextSibling.setAttribute('aria-label', 'nav');
});
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener(
'#sSS_Default_Post_0_0_22_0_0_1, #s__TopHome_Options_0_0_29_0_0_0, #sSection_default_0_0_28_0_0_4',
function (main) {
main.setAttribute('aria-label', 'main');
},
);
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('iframe', function (iframe) {
if (iframe.src.includes('youtube')) {
iframe.setAttribute('title', 'youtube video');
} else if (iframe.src.includes('newsoveraudio')) {
iframe.setAttribute('title', 'audio player');
}
});
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.widget', function (widget) {
let widgetShowMore = widget.querySelector('.widget__show-more');
if (widgetShowMore) {
let button = document.createElement('button');
button.classList.add('show-more');
button.classList.add('js-expand');
button.innerHTML = 'Keep Reading ↓';
// button.innerHTML = "Expand Full Article";
// button.setAttribute('aria-label', 'Expand Full Article');
button.addEventListener('click', (e) => {
e.stopPropagation();
widget.querySelector('.body').classList.add('expanded');
});
widgetShowMore.replaceChildren(button);
}
});
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.ProseMirror-icon[title="Toggle emphasis"], .ProseMirror-icon[title="Toggle strong style"]', function (icon) {
console.log(icon)
icon.setAttribute("role", "button");
icon.setAttribute("tabindex", "0");
icon.setAttribute("aria-label", `${icon.getAttribute('title')} formatting`);
icon.setAttribute("aria-pressed", "false");
icon.addEventListener("click", () => {
const isPressed = icon.getAttribute("aria-pressed") === "true";
icon.setAttribute("aria-pressed", String(!isPressed));
});
icon.addEventListener("keydown", (e) => {
if (e.key === "Enter" || e.key === " ") {
e.preventDefault(); // Prevent page scroll on Space
icon.click(); // Trigger the click handler
}
});
});
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.comment--item-word-count', function (wordCountDiv) {
// const minCount = wordCountDiv.querySelector('.comment--item-word-count-min').textContent;
const userCount = wordCountDiv.querySelector('.comment--item-word-count-user').textContent;
const maxCount = wordCountDiv.querySelector('.comment--item-word-count-max').textContent;
wordCountDiv.setAttribute('tabindex', '0');
wordCountDiv.setAttribute('role', 'status');
wordCountDiv.setAttribute('aria-live', 'polite');
wordCountDiv.setAttribute('aria-label', `Word count: ${userCount} of ${maxCount} words used`);
const observer = new MutationObserver(() => {
// const updatedMin = wordCountDiv.querySelector('.comment--item-word-count-min').textContent;
const updatedUser = wordCountDiv.querySelector('.comment--item-word-count-user').textContent;
const updatedMax = wordCountDiv.querySelector('.comment--item-word-count-max').textContent;
wordCountDiv.setAttribute('aria-label', `Word count: ${updatedUser} of ${updatedMax} words used`);
});
observer.observe(wordCountDiv, {
childList: true,
subtree: true,
characterData: true
});
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
feature_post_full_style();
});
window.REBELMOUSE_LOW_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
let scnt=1;
let options = { // threshhold for intersection observer, so it triggers before or after element in viewport dependinng upon value
rootMargin: '0px 0px 400px 0px'
}
function handleIntersection(entries) {
entries.map((entry) => {
if (entry.isIntersecting) {
if(!entry.target.classList.contains('sidebar_sticky_parent')){
processAd(entry.target) //your call back here with the element that is intersected or in viewport
}
else {
sidebar_ad_repeat(entry.target)
}
observer.unobserve(entry.target); // if you want to run it only once unobserve it
}
});
}
window.IcreateElementChangeListener=function(selector, callback) { // look for elements that are injected later in the page.
const initializedNodes = new Set([]);
document.querySelectorAll(selector).forEach((node) => {
callback(node);
initializedNodes.add(node);
});
const mutationObserver = new MutationObserver(() => {
const nodes = document.querySelectorAll(selector);
nodes.forEach((node) => {
if (!initializedNodes.has(node)) {
callback(node);
initializedNodes.add(node);
}
});
});
mutationObserver.observe(document.body, {
childList: true,
subtree: true,
});
}
const observer = new IntersectionObserver(handleIntersection,options);
IcreateElementChangeListener(".sidebar_sticky_parent",function(item){ //looks for item in the dom even if they are lazy laoded
observer.observe(item); // observe item
})
function sidebar_ad_repeat(sidebar_div){
let ad_id="ieee_sidebar_"+scnt;
rblbid.cmd.push(function() {
sidebar_div.querySelector(".sidebar_repeat_ad").id=ad_id;
sidebar_div.style.height="1800px";
scnt++;
sidebar_div.insertAdjacentHTML('afterend','<div class="sidebar_sticky_parent"><div class="stick_in_parent"><div class="sidebar_repeat_ad rblad-ieee_sidebar"></div></div></div>')
});
}
});</script><script class="rm-i-script" id="user-javascript-active" type="text">
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
(function addSummaryAnchorItmTags() {
'use strict';
const DELAY_MS = 2500;
const ITM_SOURCE = 'summaries';
const ITM_MEDIUM = 'ieee-spectrum';
const SUMMARY_SELECTOR = '.body-description .ieee-summary';
const SUMMARY_LINK_SELECTOR = 'li a[href*="#"]';
function normalizeForItm(value) {
return String(value || '')
.trim()
.replace(/^#/, '')
.toLowerCase()
.replace(/[^a-z0-9]+/g, '-')
.replace(/^-+|-+$/g, '');
}
function normalizePathname(pathname) {
return String(pathname || '').replace(/\/+$/, '') || '/';
}
function getArticleSlug(pathname) {
const pathParts = pathname
.split('/')
.filter(Boolean);
return normalizeForItm(pathParts[pathParts.length - 1] || '');
}
function isPlainLeftClick(event) {
return (
event.button === 0 &&
!event.metaKey &&
!event.ctrlKey &&
!event.shiftKey &&
!event.altKey
);
}
function isSamePageHashLink(anchor, currentUrl) {
const rawHref = anchor.getAttribute('href');
if (!rawHref || !rawHref.includes('#')) {
return false;
}
try {
const linkUrl = new URL(rawHref, currentUrl.href);
return (
linkUrl.origin === currentUrl.origin &&
normalizePathname(linkUrl.pathname) === normalizePathname(currentUrl.pathname) &&
Boolean(linkUrl.hash)
);
} catch (error) {
return false;
}
}
function buildTrackedHref(anchor, articleSlug, currentUrl) {
const rawHref = anchor.getAttribute('href');
const linkUrl = new URL(rawHref, currentUrl.href);
const hashtag = normalizeForItm(linkUrl.hash);
if (!hashtag) {
return null;
}
const outputUrl = new URL(currentUrl.href);
outputUrl.hash = linkUrl.hash;
outputUrl.searchParams.set('itm_source', ITM_SOURCE);
outputUrl.searchParams.set('itm_medium', ITM_MEDIUM);
outputUrl.searchParams.set('itm_campaign', `summary-${articleSlug}`);
outputUrl.searchParams.set('itm_content', `summary-${hashtag}`);
return `${outputUrl.pathname}${outputUrl.search}${outputUrl.hash}`;
}
function scrollToHash(hash) {
if (!hash) {
return;
}
let id = hash.slice(1);
try {
id = decodeURIComponent(id);
} catch (error) {
return;
}
const target =
document.getElementById(id) ||
document.getElementsByName(id)[0];
if (target) {
target.scrollIntoView();
}
}
function handleSummaryClick(event) {
if (!isPlainLeftClick(event)) {
return;
}
const clickedElement = event.target instanceof Element
? event.target
: event.target && event.target.parentElement;
if (!clickedElement) {
return;
}
const anchor = clickedElement.closest('a[data-summary-itm-tagged="1"]');
if (!anchor || anchor.target && anchor.target !== '_self') {
return;
}
event.preventDefault();
const trackedUrl = new URL(anchor.href);
window.history.pushState(
{},
'',
`${trackedUrl.pathname}${trackedUrl.search}${trackedUrl.hash}`
);
scrollToHash(trackedUrl.hash);
}
window.setTimeout(function runSummaryItmTagging() {
/*
Cheapest possible gate.
If the article has no summary box, stop here.
*/
const summary = document.querySelector(SUMMARY_SELECTOR);
if (!summary) {
return;
}
/*
Scoped only inside the summary box.
If there are no hash links, stop before URL parsing.
*/
const links = summary.querySelectorAll(SUMMARY_LINK_SELECTOR);
if (!links.length) {
return;
}
const currentUrl = new URL(window.location.href);
/*
Do not add tracking params on draft pages.
Example: /ai-radio-chip-design?draft=1
*/
if (currentUrl.searchParams.get('draft') === '1') {
return;
}
const articleSlug = getArticleSlug(currentUrl.pathname);
if (!articleSlug) {
return;
}
let taggedLinkCount = 0;
links.forEach(function tagLink(anchor) {
if (anchor.dataset.summaryItmTagged === '1') {
return;
}
if (!isSamePageHashLink(anchor, currentUrl)) {
return;
}
const trackedHref = buildTrackedHref(anchor, articleSlug, currentUrl);
if (!trackedHref) {
return;
}
anchor.setAttribute('href', trackedHref);
anchor.dataset.summaryItmTagged = '1';
taggedLinkCount += 1;
});
/*
Add only one click listener to the summary box, not one listener per link.
Skip it entirely if no links were tagged.
*/
if (taggedLinkCount > 0 && summary.dataset.summaryItmClickBound !== '1') {
summary.addEventListener('click', handleSummaryClick);
summary.dataset.summaryItmClickBound = '1';
}
}, DELAY_MS);
})();
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.loadExternalScript("//static.rebelboost.com/tracking/v1.min.js", function() {
rebelboost.init({
origin: 'spectrum.ieee.org',
gdpr: 'permissive',
consent: 'osano',
});
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB?.context?.eventBus?.subscribe('url:change', () => {
rebelboost.pageView();
});
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
localStorage.setItem("userMembershipStatus", 'anonymous');
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
(function(w,d,s,l,i){w[l]=w[l]||[];w[l].push({'gtm.start':
new Date().getTime(),event:'gtm.js'});var f=d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0],
j=d.createElement(s),dl=l!='dataLayer'?'&l='+l:'';j.async=true;j.src=
'https://www.googletagmanager.com/gtm.js?id='+i+dl;f.parentNode.insertBefore(j,f);
})(window,document,'script','dataLayer','GTM-5WJB5X2');
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.loadExternalScript("//app-ab24.marketo.com/js/forms2/js/forms2.min.js", function() {
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.loadExternalScript("https://s3.amazonaws.com/ieee-mkto-cross-domain/enterprise-page-code.js", function() {
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
let favoritProBook = new FontFace("Favorit-Pro-Book", "url(https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/ABCFavoritProFullWeb/ABCFavoritPro-Book.woff2)", {
style: 'normal'
});
favoritProBook.load().then(function() {
document.fonts.add(favoritProBook);
});
let telegrafFont = new FontFace("Telegraf", "url(https://partners.rebelmouse.com/IEEE/Telegraf/Telegraf-UltraBold-800.otf)", {
style: 'normal'
});
telegrafFont.load().then(function() {
document.fonts.add(telegrafFont);
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener("span.comment--item-date", function(dateElement){
setTimeout(function(){
const datestring = dateElement.innerHTML.split(',');
dateElement.setAttribute('data-date', datestring[0] + datestring[1]);
}, 3000);
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
document.querySelector(".access_links .list__item").href = "https://www.ieee.org/profile/public/createwebaccount/showCreateAccount.html?ShowMGAMarkeatbilityOptIn=true&sourceCode=spectrum&signinurl=" + encodeURIComponent(window.location.origin + "/core/saml/main/login?next_url=" + window.location.origin + "/core/integrations/ieee/changes?redirect=" + window.location.href) + "&url=" + encodeURIComponent(window.location.origin + "/core/saml/main/login?next_url=" + window.location.origin + "/core/integrations/ieee/changes?redirect=" + window.location.href) + "&autoSignin=Y&car=IEEE-Spectrum";
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
const cookieButton = document.querySelectorAll('a[rel="cookie-preferences"]');
for (let i = 0; i < cookieButton.length; i++) {
cookieButton[i].addEventListener('click', function(event) {
event.preventDefault();
Osano.cm.showDrawer('osano-cm-dom-info-dialog-open')
});
}
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
function otherPopupsNotOpen() {
if (document.querySelector('.gated-popup--shown') == null && document.querySelector('.stop-scrolling') == null) return true;
else return false;
}
function showLightBox() {
return document.querySelector('.lightbox-popup').classList.add('lightbox-popup--shown');
}
function trackClicks() {
const titleLinks = Array.from(document.querySelectorAll('a'));
const handler = function() {
if (sessionStorage.getItem("sessionPopupClicks")) sessionStorage.setItem("sessionPopupClicks", parseInt(sessionStorage.getItem("sessionPopupClicks")) + 1);
}
titleLinks.map(item => item.addEventListener('click', handler));
}
function countClicks() {
if (sessionStorage.getItem("sessionPopupClicks")) {
if (parseInt(sessionStorage.getItem("sessionPopupClicks")) == 3) {
if (otherPopupsNotOpen()) {
showLightBox();
updateSigninButtons();
}
else sessionStorage.setItem("sessionPopupClicks", parseInt(sessionStorage.getItem("sessionPopupClicks")) - 1);
}
}
else {
sessionStorage.setItem("sessionPopupClicks", 0);
}
trackClicks();
}
setTimeout(countClicks, 1000);
var popupLightBoxElement=document.querySelector('.lightbox-popup'),
closeLightbox,
lightboxCloseBtn = '.js--close-lightbox',
lightboxShownClass = 'lightbox-popup--shown';
closeLightbox = function () {
popupLightBoxElement.parentNode.removeChild(popupLightBoxElement);
};
document.querySelector(lightboxCloseBtn).onclick = closeLightbox;
function setCookie() {
var now = new Date();
now.setTime(now.getTime() + 72 * 3600 * 1000);
var expires = "pop_expires="+now;
document.cookie = expires + ";path=/";
}
function checkCookie() {
var today = new Date();
var cookieset = document.cookie.split(';');
var value_expires = "";
cookieset.forEach((e) => {
if(e.includes("pop_expires")) {
value_expires = e;
}
})
var time_expire = new Date(value_expires.split("=")[1]);
if(today <= time_expire){
return false;
}else{
return true;
}
}
var checkPage = true;
if(window.location.href.indexOf("the-great-ai-reckoning") > -1) {
//console.log("AI Special Report");
checkPage = false;
}
function updateSigninButtons() {
document.querySelectorAll(".popup_links.signin_button .list__item")[0].href = "https://www.ieee.org/profile/public/createwebaccount/showCreateAccount.html?ShowMGAMarkeatbilityOptIn=true&sourceCode=spectrum&signinurl=" + encodeURIComponent(window.location.origin + "/core/saml/main/login?next_url=" + window.location.origin + "/core/integrations/ieee/changes?redirect=" + window.location.href) + "&url=" + encodeURIComponent(window.location.origin + "/core/saml/main/login?next_url=" + window.location.origin + "/core/integrations/ieee/changes?redirect=" + window.location.href) + "&autoSignin=Y&car=IEEE-Spectrum";
document.querySelectorAll(".popup_links.signin_button .list__item")[1].href = "https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/saml/main/login?next_url=" + encodeURIComponent("https://spectrum.ieee.org/core/integrations/ieee/changes?redirect=" + window.location.href);
}
function checkPopup() {
var checkClickCount = true;
if (sessionStorage.getItem("sessionPopupClicks")) {
if (parseInt(sessionStorage.getItem("sessionPopupClicks")) > 2) checkClickCount = false;
}
if (checkCookie() && checkPage && otherPopupsNotOpen() && checkClickCount) {
popupLightBoxElement.classList.add(lightboxShownClass);
setCookie();
sessionStorage.setItem("sessionPopupClicks", 4);
updateSigninButtons();
}
}
setTimeout(checkPopup, 15000);
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.widget', (el) => {
addPopSave();
});
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener(
'.talk-comments-wrp .add-comment, .talk-comments-wrp .comment-item--publish',
function (comment) {
console.log(comment);
comment.setAttribute('tabindex', '0');
comment.addEventListener('keypress', (e) => {
e.preventDefault();
e.stopPropagation();
comment.click();
document.querySelector(".gated-popup").setAttribute('tabindex', '-1');
document.querySelector(".gated-popup").focus();
});
},
);
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
function menuClick() {
document.getElementsByClassName('huge-menu')[0].style.display = 'block';
document.getElementsByClassName('hambg-btn')[0].classList.add('js--active');
document.body.classList.add("huge-menu-opened");
document.body.classList.remove("menu-opened");
}
function close(){
document.getElementsByClassName('huge-menu')[0].style.display = 'none';
document.getElementsByClassName('hambg-btn')[0].classList.remove('js--active');
document.body.classList.remove("huge-menu-opened");
document.body.classList.remove("menu-opened");
}
function addMenuClickListener() {
var rebelMenu_first = document.getElementsByClassName('rebelbar__menu-toggle')[0];
var rebelMenu_second = document.getElementsByClassName('rebelbar__menu-toggle')[1];
var menuClose = document.getElementsByClassName('hm__close')[0];
rebelMenu_first.addEventListener('click', menuClick);
rebelMenu_second.addEventListener('click', menuClick);
menuClose.addEventListener('click', close);
}
addMenuClickListener();
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
function changeDateFormat(widget){
var dates_toChange=widget.querySelectorAll('.widget .social-date__text:not(.processed),.widget .social-date-modified__text:not(.processed)');
if(dates_toChange){
dates_toChange.forEach(function(date) {
if(!date.innerHTML.trim()==""){
date.classList.add('processed')
var date_string=date.innerHTML.toString();
var slpit_dateText=date_string.split(" ");
if(slpit_dateText.length==1){
let plural=true;
if(slpit_dateText[0].length==2){
if(slpit_dateText[0].charAt(0)=="1"){
plural=false;
}
}
let modifier=plural ? 'hours ago':'hour ago';
if(slpit_dateText[0].substr(-1)=='m'){
modifier=plural ? 'minutes ago':'minute ago';
}
if(slpit_dateText[0].substr(-1)=='s'){
modifier=plural ? 'seconds ago':'second ago';
}
var new_dateText=slpit_dateText[0].slice(0,-1);
date.innerHTML= new_dateText+" "+ modifier;
date.classList.add("modified");
}
}
});
}
}
_createElementChangeListener= function (selector, callback) {
const initializedNodes = new Set([]);
document.querySelectorAll(selector).forEach((node) => {
callback(node);
initializedNodes.add(node);
});
const mutationObserver = new MutationObserver(() => {
const nodes = document.querySelectorAll(selector);
nodes.forEach((node) => {
if (!initializedNodes.has(node)) {
callback(node);
initializedNodes.add(node);
}
});
});
mutationObserver.observe(document.body, {
childList: true,
subtree: true,
});
}
_createElementChangeListener(".widget",changeDateFormat);
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
document.querySelectorAll(".social-author__bio").forEach(function (item) {
if(item.querySelector("a")){
item.querySelector("a").remove();
}
var text = item.innerHTML;
var dotSpace = text.indexOf(". ") === -1 ? text.length : text.indexOf(". ");
var dotEnd = text.indexOf(". <") === -1 ? text.length : text.indexOf(".<");
var dotBr = text.indexOf(".\n") === -1 ? text.length : text.indexOf(".\n");
var firstDot = Math.min(dotSpace, dotEnd, dotBr);
var newtext = text.substring(0, firstDot+1);
item.innerHTML = newtext;
});
let authorsList = document.querySelectorAll(".container_feature_below .post-author-list .social-author__name");
let authorsListBios = document.querySelectorAll(".container_feature_below .post-author-list .social-author__bio p");
for (let i = 0; i < authorsList.length; i++) {
authorsListBios[i].innerHTML += ' <a href="'+ authorsList[i].href + '">See&nbsp;full&nbsp;bio&nbsp;&#8594;</a>';
}
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
LightBoxLayout = document.querySelector('.lightbox-layout');
function closeLightbox() {
const LightBoxElement = document.querySelector('.lightbox');
if (LightBoxElement) {
LightBoxElement.classList.remove('lightbox--shown');
LightBoxElement.classList.remove('lightbox');
}
if (LightBoxLayout) {
LightBoxLayout.classList.remove('lightbox--shown');
}
document.body.classList.remove("fixed_scrolling");
}
function attachLightboxClick(theImage) {
theImage.addEventListener("click", function(event) {
//console.log("Image clicked:", this);
this.classList.add('lightbox--shown');
this.classList.add('lightbox');
LightBoxLayout.classList.add('lightbox--shown');
document.body.classList.add("fixed_scrolling");
// Escape key closes lightbox (once)
document.addEventListener("keyup", function onEscapeOnce(event) {
if (event.key === "Escape") {
closeLightbox();
document.removeEventListener("keyup", onEscapeOnce);
}
});
});
}
function checkLightboxForPost(item){
let theIds = item.querySelector(".custom-field-lightbox-img-shortcode-ids");
let lightboxImages = JSON.parse(theIds.innerText);
let postLightbox = lightboxImages["imageShortcodeIds"];
for (var i = 0; i < postLightbox.length; i++) {
let theImgs = item.querySelectorAll("img"), getImg, theImage;
for (var y = 0; y < theImgs.length; y++) {
if (theImgs[y].getAttribute('data-runner-src') != null) {
getImg = theImgs[y].getAttribute('data-runner-src');
} else {
getImg = theImgs[y].src;
}
if (getImg.indexOf(postLightbox[i]) != -1) {
if (theImgs[y].parentElement.classList.contains("share-tab-img")) {
theImage = theImgs[y].parentElement.parentElement;
} else {
theImage = theImgs[y].parentElement;
}
theImage.classList.add("lightbox_icon");
theImage.classList.add("lightbox_" + i);
attachLightboxClick(theImage);
}
}
}
}
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener(".widget", (el) => {
let theIds = el.querySelector(".custom-field-lightbox-img-shortcode-ids");
if (theIds) {
let lightboxImages = JSON.parse(theIds.innerText);
let postLightbox = lightboxImages["imageShortcodeIds"];
let foundAll = postLightbox.length;
for (var i = 0; i < postLightbox.length; i++) {
let theImgs = el.querySelectorAll("img"), getImg, theImage;
for (var y = 0; y < theImgs.length; y++) {
if (theImgs[y].getAttribute('data-runner-src') != null) {
getImg = theImgs[y].getAttribute('data-runner-src');
} else {
getImg = theImgs[y].src;
}
if (getImg.indexOf(postLightbox[i]) != -1) {
if (theImgs[y].parentElement.classList.contains("share-tab-img")) {
theImage = theImgs[y].parentElement.parentElement;
} else {
theImage = theImgs[y].parentElement;
}
foundAll = foundAll - 1;
theImage.classList.add("lightbox_icon");
theImage.classList.add("lightbox_"+i);
attachLightboxClick(theImage);
}
}
}
if (foundAll !== 0) {
const showMoreBtn = el.querySelector(".widget__show-more");
if (showMoreBtn) {
showMoreBtn.addEventListener("click", function(event) {
const parent = this.parentElement?.parentElement?.parentElement;
if (parent) {
checkLightboxForPost(parent);
} else {
//console.warn("Parent element for checkLightboxForPost not found.");
}
});
} else {
//console.warn(".widget__show-more button not found in element:", el);
}
}
}
});
const closeBtn = document.querySelector('.lightbox__close');
if (closeBtn) {
closeBtn.onclick = closeLightbox;
} else {
console.warn("No .lightbox__close button found in DOM");
}
});
window.REBELMOUSE_ACTIVE_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
if (!window.location.href.startsWith('https://spectrum.ieee.org/ai-robots')) {
setTimeout(() => {
// Add target blank to all body links except links inside .ieee-summary,
// and remove IEEE Spectrum homepage link everywhere
const links = document.querySelectorAll('.body-description a');
links.forEach((link) => {
const href = link.getAttribute('href');
// Remove IEEE Spectrum homepage link, inside or outside .ieee-summary
if (href === 'https://spectrum.ieee.org/' && link.textContent.trim() === 'IEEE Spectrum') {
const fragment = document.createDocumentFragment();
while (link.firstChild) {
fragment.appendChild(link.firstChild);
}
if (link.parentNode) {
link.parentNode.replaceChild(fragment, link);
}
return;
}
// Do not add target="_blank" to links inside .ieee-summary
if (link.closest('.ieee-summary')) return;
// Add target="_blank" to non-hash links
if (href && !href.startsWith('#') && (!link.hasAttribute('target') || link.getAttribute('target') === '_self')) {
link.setAttribute('target', '_blank');
link.setAttribute('rel', 'noopener noreferrer');
}
});
// Add ITM tag to inbody releated links
document
.querySelectorAll('p.ieee-inbody-related a[href]')
.forEach((link) => {
try {
const rawHref = link.getAttribute('href');
if (!rawHref) return;
const url = new URL(rawHref, window.location.origin);
const slug = url.pathname
.replace(/^\/+|\/+$/g, '')
.replace(/\//g, '-');
if (!url.searchParams.has('itm_source')) {
url.searchParams.set('itm_source', 'ieee-spectrum');
}
if (!url.searchParams.has('itm_medium')) {
url.searchParams.set('itm_medium', 'inbody_related');
}
if (!url.searchParams.has('itm_campaign') && slug) {
url.searchParams.set('itm_campaign', `inbody_related-${slug}`);
}
link.href = url.toString();
} catch (e) {
console.warn(
'Invalid URL found in related link:',
link.getAttribute('href')
);
}
});
// Add see transcript button
const toggleButton = document.getElementById('ieee-transcript-toggle');
const transcript = document.getElementById('ieee-transcript-content');
if (!toggleButton || !transcript) {
return;
}
toggleButton.addEventListener('click', function () {
const isHidden = transcript.style.display === 'none';
transcript.style.display = isHidden ? 'block' : 'none';
transcript.hidden = !isHidden;
toggleButton.setAttribute('aria-expanded', isHidden ? 'true' : 'false');
});
}, 3000);
}
});</script><script class="rm-i-script" id="user-javascript-components" type="text"></script><script class="rm-i-script" id="user-javascript-lowest" type="text">
window.REBELMOUSE_LOWEST_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
window.REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.loadExternalScript("https://openfpcdn.io/fingerprintjs/v4/iife.min.js", function() {
if (!localStorage.getItem('ppid')) {
var fpPromise = FingerprintJS.load()
fpPromise
.then(fp => fp.get())
.then(result => {
window.ppid=result.visitorId
localStorage.setItem('ppid', result.visitorId);
})
} else {
window.ppid = localStorage.getItem('ppid')
}
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_LOWEST_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
(function () {
let prevFocus = null;
let observer = null;
function enhanceOverlay() {
const overlay = document.getElementById('overlay_DFP');
if (!overlay) return;
if (!prevFocus) prevFocus = document.activeElement;
overlay.setAttribute('role', 'dialog');
overlay.setAttribute('aria-modal', 'true');
overlay.setAttribute('aria-label', 'advertisement pop-up');
overlay.tabIndex = -1;
const bg = document.getElementById('overlay_DFP_bg');
if (bg) { bg.setAttribute('aria-hidden', 'true'); bg.tabIndex = -1; }
const closeText = document.getElementById('close_text');
if (closeText) {
closeText.setAttribute('role', 'button');
closeText.setAttribute('aria-label', 'close pop-up');
closeText.tabIndex = 0;
closeText.addEventListener('click', closeAd);
closeText.addEventListener('keydown', (e) => {
if (e.key === 'Enter') { e.preventDefault(); closeAd(); }
if (e.key === 'Escape') closeAd();
});
}
const closeBtn = document.getElementById('close_DFP_btn');
if (closeBtn) {
closeBtn.setAttribute('role', 'button');
closeBtn.setAttribute('aria-label', 'close pop-up');
closeBtn.tabIndex = 0;
closeBtn.addEventListener('click', closeAd);
closeBtn.addEventListener('keydown', (e) => {
if (e.key === 'Enter') { e.preventDefault(); closeAd(); }
if (e.key === 'Escape') closeAd();
});
}
const adLink = overlay.querySelector('#interContent_DFP a');
if (adLink) adLink.setAttribute('aria-label', 'open advertisement');
const adImg = overlay.querySelector('#interContent_DFP img');
if (adImg) {
adImg.setAttribute('role', 'img');
adImg.setAttribute('aria-label', 'pop-up');
}
overlay.addEventListener('keydown', (e) => {
if (e.key === 'Escape') closeAd();
});
setTimeout(() => {
if (closeText) closeText.focus();
else if (closeBtn) closeBtn.focus();
else if (adLink) adLink.focus();
else overlay.focus();
}, 0);
const getFocusables = () =>
overlay.querySelectorAll('a, button, [role="button"], [tabindex]:not([tabindex="-1"])');
overlay.addEventListener('keydown', (e) => {
if (e.key !== 'Tab') return;
const items = Array.from(getFocusables()).filter(el => el.offsetParent !== null);
if (!items.length) return;
const first = items[0], last = items[items.length - 1];
if (e.shiftKey && document.activeElement === first) { e.preventDefault(); last.focus(); }
else if (!e.shiftKey && document.activeElement === last) { e.preventDefault(); first.focus(); }
});
function closeAd() {
if (overlay && overlay.parentNode) overlay.parentNode.removeChild(overlay);
if (bg && bg.parentNode) bg.parentNode.removeChild(bg);
// ✅ Just remove the scroll lock class
document.body.classList.remove('stop-scrolling');
if (observer) { observer.disconnect(); observer = null; }
if (prevFocus && typeof prevFocus.focus === 'function') {
try { prevFocus.focus(); } catch (e) {}
} else {
document.body.setAttribute('tabindex','-1');
document.body.focus();
document.body.removeAttribute('tabindex');
}
}
}
if (document.readyState === 'loading') {
document.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', enhanceOverlay);
} else {
enhanceOverlay();
}
observer = new MutationObserver(() => {
if (document.getElementById('overlay_DFP')) enhanceOverlay();
});
observer.observe(document.documentElement, { childList: true, subtree: true });
})();
});
window.REBELMOUSE_LOWEST_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
window.RM_AD_LOADER.push({
options: {
threshold: 500,
},
staticSelectors: [],
dynamicSelectors: [],
dependencies: ["https://htlbid.com/v3/spectrum.ieee.org/rblbid.js"],
onDependanciesLoaded: function () {
window.rblbid = window.rblbid || {};
rblbid.cmd = rblbid.cmd || [];
window.custom_tags = "aviation, software, airbus, boeing, fly-by-wire, 737 max, ~rmsc:rebelmouse-image:25588398, ~rmsc:rebelmouse-image:25588399, ~rmsc:rebelmouse-image:25588396, Technology &amp; Computing, Automotive, Business and Finance, Travel, News and Politics, Personal Finance, Education, Computing, Business, Economy, Industries, Auto Technology, Budget Cars, Luxury Cars, Aviation Industry, Technology Industry, Manufacturing Industry, Business Administration, Large Business, Sales, Logistics"
if(!window.custom_tags){
window.custom_tags = window.tags;
}
window.postid = "2650278376";
rblbid.cmd.push(function() {
rblbid.layout('universal');
rblbid.setTargeting("is_testing","no");
rblbid.setTargeting("is_home", "no");
rblbid.setTargeting("ieee_page_type", "postpage");
rblbid.setTargeting("ieee_post_id", window.postid);
rblbid.setTargeting("ieee_category", window.category);
rblbid.setTargeting("ieee_tags", window.tags );
rblbid.pubads().setPublisherProvidedId(window.ppid)
console.log("this thing is running")
rblbid.setTargeting("ieee_taxonomy", ["Aerospace and Defense", "Computing and Software", "Transportation", "Tech Industry", "Industry and Manufacturing", "Research \u0026 Development", "Aviation Industry", "Software and Applications", "Software Development", "Software Engineering", "Ethical Implications of Technology", "Governance and Society", "History of Technology", "Physical Science and Engineering", "Simulation and Testing", "Manufacturing Industry", "Engineering History", "Technology Regulations"]);
rblbid.setTargeting("aud", "Interest432, Interest37, Interest62, Interest464, Interest307, Interest319, Interest35, Interest435, Interest63, Interest89, Interest99, Interest40, Interest41, Interest48, Interest127, Interest124, Interest113, Interest72, Interest66, Interest69, Interest67")
});
function injectGooglePCDTag(segmentID, yourID) {
const script = document.createElement('script');
script.async = true;
script.id = 'google-pcd-tag';
script.src = `https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/pcd.js`;
script.setAttribute('data-audience-pixel', `dc_iu=/22278042776/DFPAudiencePixel;dc_seg=${segmentID};ppid=${yourID}`);
document.head.appendChild(script);
}
let taxs = ["Aerospace and Defense", "Computing and Software", "Transportation", "Tech Industry", "Industry and Manufacturing", "Research \u0026 Development", "Aviation Industry", "Software and Applications", "Software Development", "Software Engineering", "Ethical Implications of Technology", "Governance and Society", "History of Technology", "Physical Science and Engineering", "Simulation and Testing", "Manufacturing Industry", "Engineering History", "Technology Regulations"];
taxs = encodeURIComponent(taxs.join(','));
fetch("/r/kappa/api/v2/reader/taxpixelids?tax="+taxs+"&asdasd=asdsa").then(result=>result.json()).then(res => {
res.forEach(pixaud=>{
if(pixaud!==null){
injectGooglePCDTag(pixaud, window.ppid);
}
})
})
},
onInit: function() {
},
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_LOWEST_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
let floatingShares = document.querySelector('.floating-shares');
floatingShares.onclick = function() {
if (navigator.share) {
navigator.share({
url: window.location.href
}).then(() => {
console.log('Thanks for sharing!');
}).catch(console.error);
} else {
alert("sharing "+ window.location.href);
}
}
});
window.REBELMOUSE_LOWEST_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
let topbarHeadline = document.querySelector('.topbar__sticky-headline--post .text-element');
let windowHeight = window.innerHeight/2;
if(!!window.IntersectionObserver){
let headlineObserver = new IntersectionObserver((entries) => {
entries.forEach(entry => {
if(entry.isIntersecting){
var currentHeadline = entry.target.querySelector('.widget__headline-text');
if(currentHeadline) {
topbarHeadline.textContent = currentHeadline.textContent;
}
}
});
}, {rootMargin: "0px 0px -" + windowHeight + "px 0px"});
createElementChangeListener(".infinite_scroll .widget", (el) => {
headlineObserver.observe(el)
});
createElementChangeListener(".article_column .widget", (el) => {
headlineObserver.observe(el)
});
createElementChangeListener(".feature_post_full .widget", (el) => {
headlineObserver.observe(el)
});
}
});
window.REBELMOUSE_LOWEST_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
function toggleMenu(menuToggle) {
const isExpanded = menuToggle.getAttribute('aria-expanded') === 'true';
menuToggle.setAttribute('aria-expanded', !isExpanded);
// menuToggle.setAttribute('aria-label', isExpanded ? 'Open menu' : 'Close menu');
}
// Topics Dropdown
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.menu-item__title', function (menuItem) {
menuItem.addEventListener('keypress', (e) => {
// if (e.key === 'Enter' || e.key === ' ') {
// e.preventDefault();
menuItem.classList.toggle('keyboard-hover');
// menuItem.click();
// }
});
});
//Hamburger Menu
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.hambg-btn', function (hambgBtn) {
let menuItem = document.querySelector('.menu-item__title');
hambgBtn.addEventListener('keypress', () => {
menuItem.classList.remove('keyboard-hover');
toggleMenu(hambgBtn);
hambgBtn.click();
});
});
//close icon in Huge Menu Links
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.huge-menu .hm__close', function (hmClose) {
let hugeMenu = document.querySelector('.huge-menu');
hmClose.addEventListener('keypress', (e) => {
if (e.key === 'Enter') {
console.log('is this running');
hugeMenu.style.display = 'none';
}
});
});
//stop displaying Huge Menu when focusout
REBELMOUSE_STDLIB.createElementChangeListener('.huge-menu .footer .list .list__item:last-of-type', function (lastItem) {
let hugeMenu = document.querySelector('.huge-menu');
lastItem.addEventListener('focusout', () => {
hugeMenu.style.display = 'none';
});
});
});
window.REBELMOUSE_LOWEST_TASKS_QUEUE.push(function(){
function createIdleScrollListener(callback) {
let ticking = false;
return function onScrollIdle() {
if (ticking) {
return;
}
ticking = true;
requestAnimationFrame(function A() {
callback();
ticking = false;
});
};
}
var stickyEl = document.querySelector('.topbar-sticky');
var startPosition = stickyEl.offsetTop;
var darkTopbarHeight = document.querySelector('.topbar .dark_top_bar').offsetHeight;
var currentPosition;
stickyEl.style.height = stickyEl.offsetHeight + 'px';
document.addEventListener("scroll", createIdleScrollListener(function B() {
currentPosition = stickyEl.getBoundingClientRect().top + darkTopbarHeight;
if( currentPosition < startPosition ) {
if( !stickyEl.classList.contains('active') ) {
stickyEl.classList.add('active');
}
} else {
if( stickyEl.classList.contains('active') ) {
stickyEl.classList.remove('active');
}
}
}));
});</script></body></html>