54 lines
2.9 KiB
Markdown
54 lines
2.9 KiB
Markdown
---
|
||
title: "Testing Evidence Collector Agent Personality"
|
||
type: source
|
||
tags: []
|
||
date: 2026-04-25
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
## Source File
|
||
- [[Agent/agency-agents/testing/testing-evidence-collector.md]]
|
||
|
||
## Summary（用中文描述）
|
||
- 核心主题：EvidenceQA —— 一个以截图为核心证据的 QA Agent 个性化角色定义
|
||
- 问题域：如何对 AI Agent 生成的前端实现进行严格的质量评估，避免"幻想式报告"（Fantasy Reporting）
|
||
- 方法/机制：通过 Playwright 自动化截图 + 视觉对比 + 强制默认找问题（至少 3-5 个）来实现真实性检验
|
||
- 结论/价值：QA 质量评估必须基于视觉证据，零问题报告是红色警报，必须强制提供截图
|
||
|
||
## Key Claims（用中文描述）
|
||
- EvidenceQA 相信"截图不会撒谎"——视觉证据是唯一可靠的真理
|
||
- 首次实现总是存在至少 3-5 个问题，"零问题"是红色警报
|
||
- 每个声明都需要截图证据支撑，无证据的声明视为"幻想"
|
||
- luxury/premium 等描述词无截图支撑即为违规
|
||
- 质量评级默认 FAILED，除非压倒性证据证明通过
|
||
|
||
## Key Quotes
|
||
> "Screenshots Don't Lie" — Visual evidence is the only truth that matters
|
||
> "Default to Finding Issues" — First implementations ALWAYS have 3-5+ issues minimum
|
||
> "Zero issues found" is a red flag - look harder
|
||
> "Your job is to be the reality check that prevents broken websites from being approved"
|
||
|
||
## Key Concepts
|
||
- [[Visual Evidence]]：QA 评估的唯一可靠依据，通过 Playwright 自动化截图捕获
|
||
- [[Fantasy Reporting]]：指无视觉证据支撑的声称，如"零问题"、"Luxury 级别"等
|
||
- [[Reality Check Commands]]：强制性初始检查命令，包括 Playwright 截图、文件检查、grep 特征搜索
|
||
- [[Specification Compliance]]：将实际截图与原始规范逐字对比，不添加规范外的额外要求
|
||
- [[Accordion Testing Protocol]]：通过 before/after 截图对比验证手风琴组件的展开/折叠功能
|
||
- [[Form Testing Protocol]]：验证表单提交、校验、错误信息展示的完整性
|
||
- [[Mobile Responsive Testing]]：在 desktop/tablet/mobile 三种分辨率下验证布局和导航
|
||
|
||
## Key Entities
|
||
- [[EvidenceQA]]：截图驱动型 QA Agent，以视觉证据为唯一真理，默认发现 3-5+ 问题
|
||
- [[Playwright]]：自动化截图工具（qa-playwright-capture.sh），提供 comprehensive screenshots 和 test-results.json
|
||
|
||
## Connections
|
||
- [[Testing Reality Checker]] ← related_to ← [[Testing Evidence Collector]]
|
||
- [[Testing Test Results Analyzer]] ← related_to ← [[Testing Evidence Collector]]
|
||
- [[Testing Performance Benchmarker]] ← related_to ← [[Testing Evidence Collector]]
|
||
|
||
## Contradictions
|
||
- 与声称"零问题"的报告冲突：
|
||
- 冲突点：首次实现的问题数量
|
||
- 当前观点：默认发现 3-5+ 问题，"零问题"是红色警报
|
||
- 对方观点：声称"零问题"即通过
|
||
```
|